Ranking All 31 WWE Royal Rumble Winners
20. Hacksaw Jim Duggan – 1988
WrestleMania
title shot:
N/A
Hacksaw Jim Duggan never won any titles during his tenure in WWF/E, yet he remains one of the company’s most popular stars. Probably his biggest claim to fame (other than carrying a 2x4 to the ring) is winning the inaugural Royal Rumble match in 1988.
The Rumble back then was a brand-new concept, consisting of 20 men. The event itself was televised rather than put on PPV, and the Rumble match consisted mainly of midcarders rather than the main eventer-populated match it is today.
Despite this and the fact that there was no title shot awarded, nothing should take away from Duggan’s signature WWF/E accomplishment. He deserves kudos for his place in history.
19. ‘Stone Cold’ Steve Austin – 1997
WrestleMania
title shot:
Stripped due to controversial ending of Rumble
It’s hard to rank a Rumble victory in which the winner never cashes in his title shot this high, but when you consider that it was a major stepping stone in the ascension of “Stone Cold” Steve Austin to the top of the WWF, you have to give it special consideration.
Austin pulled his best Eddie Guerrero impersonation and cheated to win the ’97 Rumble, getting eliminated while the refs were tied up, then sneaking back in and winning. He would not get his title shot because of the controversial ending, instead being stuck in a four-way match at IYH 13, which he lost.
Instead, Austin faced Bret Hart (the man who “eliminated” him and then who he eliminated) in a no DQ submission match at WrestleMania XIII, which would help launch Stone Cold into the stratosphere.
18. The Rock – 2000
WrestleMania
title shot:
Lost to Triple H at WrestleMania 2000
Poor Rocky. The Great One couldn’t catch a break in early 2000. First he won the Rumble, then replays showed he actually was eliminated before Big Show. Then they tried unsuccessfully to name a top contender, so he got stuck in a triple threat for the WWF Championship.
Then the McMahons got involved, and each member of the family had a backed wrestler in the Mania main event, with Linda adding the recently retired Mick Foley for a four-way elimination match. It ultimately wound down to the two original combatants, but Rock would lose and Triple H would become the first heel to walk out of WrestleMania with the world title. That would change over time, especially with multiple world titles, but it was a pretty big deal in 2000.
But don’t feel too bad for Rock. Things turned out
OK for him.
17. Yokozuna – 1993
WrestleMania
title shot: Defeated
Bret Hart at WrestleMania IX; Immediately lost title to Hulk Hogan
Until last year, this was the worst Rumble winner who actually won the title at Mania. Yoko eliminated seven wrestlers en route to winning the first Rumble match that carried a WrestleMania title shot. He then went on to beat Bret Hart in the Mania main event. That alone warrants a high placement on the list.
Then it all went to hell. Hulk Hogan came out to help his “friend” Hart, who had been blinded by salt. Mr. Fuji challenged Hogan to a title match right then and there. An errant throw of salt and an atomic leg drop later, the Hulkster was leaving WrestleMania with the world title. Yokozuna’s reign lasted all of about three minutes.
Yoko would eventually get his title back and send Hogan packing out of WWF, but that ridiculous ending severely tarnished his standing as a Rumble winner.
16. John Cena – 2008
WrestleMania
title shot:
Used it at No Way Out unsuccessfully; Lost triple threat title match at
WrestleMania XXIV
John Cena’s surprise return at the 2008 Royal Rumble is still one of the all-time best moments in Rumble history. When Cena can get Madison Square Garden to cheer him without pandering, you know it’s an awesome moment.
Unfortunately, Cena couldn’t wait until WrestleMania XXIV for his title shot and challenged WWE Champion Randy Orton at No Way Out. Orton got himself disqualified to keep the title, but Cena was inserted into a triple threat title match at Mania along with Triple H. In the end, Orton took out Triple H and pinned a prone Cena to retain.
Cena would go on to capture four world titles in 2008-09 alone, so it’s safe to say he recovered from this setback. But his Rumble return alone was a huge success.
15. Edge – 2010
WrestleMania
title shot:
Lost to Chris Jericho at WrestleMania XXVI
Another Royal Rumble surprise return that ended in victory but not success at WrestleMania, Edge made it back from an Achilles tendon injury and shocked the crowd. Like Cena, his return and subsequent Rumble win was a huge moment.
Unlike Cena, Edge actually got to use his Rumble title shot at WrestleMania, although Chris Jericho managed to pull out the win. It was an odd decision to have Edge return, win the Rumble and lose at Mania, but five days later, Jack Swagger would cash in his Money in the Bank briefcase to win the World Heavyweight Championship from Jericho.
Edge would finally capture the WHC before 2010 was done, but four months later, Edge’s career would end and he would retire as champion.
14. Triple H – 2002
WrestleMania
title shot:
Defeated Chris Jericho at WrestleMania X8
So how did Triple H’s triumphant return from a career-threatening injury and subsequent Royal Rumble and WrestleMania victories rank this low? Hunter’s return was poisoned by silly booking decisions and poor planning at Mania.
At the time, the Undisputed World Champion was Chris Jericho. Instead of the feud centering on Jericho being involved in the match that put Helmsley on the shelf months earlier and Triple H wanting both revenge and the title, Jericho would be partnered with Stephanie McMahon, who was feuding with Triple H (her then-storyline estranged husband). To top it off, the match was the main event, when Rock versus Hollywood Hogan clearly should have closed Mania (that’s twice that a Triple H match went last when it shouldn’t have), and it showed with the crowd.
Triple H’s return at the Royal Rumble was a great moment for fans, but everything else that unfolded fell flat. He even lost the title a month after WrestleMania so the Hogan nostalgia act could be milked again. Yes, Triple H won at Mania, but everything that happened after his Rumble victory was a debacle.
13. John Cena – 2013
WrestleMania
title shot:
Defeated the Rock at WrestleMania XXIX
Well, someone had to end part-timer Rock’s title reign, and you knew John Cena had to get redemption for his WrestleMania XXVIII loss, so this felt pretty ordained from the moment Rock announced he would wrestle for the WWE Championship at the 2013 Royal Rumble. So when Cena entered the Rumble at #19, it was pretty obvious he was going the distance.
Cena/Rock I was a pretty awesome match. Seeing the Rock in his first one-on-one match in ages was epic, and he and Cena delivered. The rematch lacked the intrigue and suspense the first one did – the idea that WWE would put its biggest title on a part-time wrestler for months on end was just ludicrous (remember those days?), so it was fairly transparent that Cena would win.
Still, the match itself was pretty decent, WrestleMania XXIX set a company record for highest-grossing live event and Cena would hold the title for four months before dropping it cleanly to Daniel Bryan in a spectacular match. Overall, not too bad for Cena’s second Rumble win.
12. Rey Mysterio – 2006
WrestleMania
title shot: Lost
title shot to Randy Orton at No Way Out; Added to title match and defeated
Orton and Kurt Angle at WrestleMania XXII
For Rey Mysterio, his run in early 2006 was a career milestone. Drawing #2 in the Rumble, Rey went the distance, lasting 62 minutes and setting a longevity record for the Rumble. He eliminated six wrestlers (the most of any superstar), including Rob Van Dam, Triple H and Randy Orton. He would go on to win his first world title at WrestleMania XXII, capping an improbable run for the littlest big man in WWE.
If Mysterio had gone on to WrestleMania XXII and the match unfolded the same, this would be a top 10 entry. But Rey was goaded into putting his title shot on the line by Orton, who snatched it away at No Way Out. He then had to be added to the Mania match artificially and won in a contest that went less than 10 minutes. It was just a deflating ride post-Rumble for Mysterio.
11. Chris Benoit – 2004
WrestleMania
title shot:
Defeated Triple H and Shawn Michaels at WrestleMania XX
If not for the events of June 2007, wrestling fans and WWE itself probably would hold the Chris Benoit title chase angle in 2004 in high regard. Looking back on it as a fan, it was one of WWE’s finest moments in storytelling.
By 2004, even casual fans had become aware of what the most devoted fans had known for years: that Benoit was one of the best in-ring performers in wrestling. Benoit had been involved in top-level feuds since coming over to WWE in 2000, but he never could break through.
At the 2004 Royal Rumble, Benoit was given the #1 entry as punishment, but then went on to become only the second person to go the distance from that spot and win. The Rabid Wolverine would then reveal a loophole in the title opportunity and jump from Smackdown to challenge Triple H for the World Heavyweight Championship. (That loophole created an air of drama after the Rumble for the next decade as fans waited to see who the Rumble winner chose to face.)
Benoit would overcome both Triple H and Shawn
Michaels at WrestleMania XX to win the world title in what arguably is the
greatest main event in Mania history (which has been all-but erased). It was a
huge moment for Benoit and – as Eddie Guerrero also was leaving WrestleMania as
the WWE Champion – for fans who thought that the smaller, underappreciated
performers would never get a big push.