Ranking Big Show's WrestleMania Matches - From Worst To Best

Ranking the best of The Big Show on the Grand Stage.

WWE.com Over the course of his 17 years in World Wrestling Entertainment, Big Show has worked with every legendary competitor that has come through the door and delivered several unforgettable matches and moments that have helped establish him as one of the greatest giants of all-time, but one cannot help but look at his track record at WrestleMania and be disappointed by what they see. The World's Largest Athlete has rarely been put in the position to steal the show and, despite being one of the staples of The Showcase of the Immortals, has only a handful of memories and contests from the event worth looking back fondly on. Sure, he has been at the center of some of the most hyped bouts on the card but he has also lived the life of an also-ran, a guy thrown into meaningless tag matches to satisfy the desire of management to get him onto the show and justify his salary. Still, Big Show is the only Superstar to ever challenge for the United States, Intercontinental, Tag Team, World Heavyweight and WWE Championships on the grand stage, a staggering feat unlikely to ever be matched. Now, one year after winning the Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal and solidifying his place in history alongside the man once referred to as his father in WCW, Big Show prepares to make it two-in-a-row. Can he again etch his name in the annals of WrestleMania and, perhaps, deliver a performance that ranks higher on this list than lower? Only time will tell. Until then, relive the WrestleMania resume of WWE's greatest big man with this look at his matches, ranked from worst to best according to overall quality and historical significance.

15. Sumo Match: Big Show Vs. Akebono - WrestleMania 21

WWE.com
The abomination that was the Sumo match between Big Show and Akebono in 2005 at WrestleMania 21 belonged nowhere near the biggest show of the year. It was a flawed concept designed to put the world renowned, "celebrity" sumo wrestler in the spotlight. The only problem? No one cared. See, pro wrestling fans appreciate pro wrestling, not sumo. So the 15 minutes of television time that was used up for the entrances, ceremonial stuff and the match itself were wasted on an audience who did not want to see it. Worse yet is the haunting image of Big Show in a mawashi that still has never escaped this writer's deepest, darkest nightmares. The entire ordeal was a major misstep on an otherwise outstanding card. Considering Big Show was in the midst of one of his strongest pushes to that point, it is even more disappointing that he was wasted on such a meaningless "match."

14. Eight-Man Tag Team Match: Big Show, Kane, Santino Marella & Kofi Kingston Vs. The Corre - WrestleMania 27

WWE.com
Speaking of meaningless matches that did no one involved any favors... The Corre was a misguided attempt to take the most essential members of Nexus and rebrand them in hopes of reigniting their momentum. Featuring Nexus founders Wade Barrett, Justin Gabriel and Heath Slater, as well as the massive Ezekiel Jackson, the group failed to catch fire and arrived at WrestleMania 27 for a match that had no real heat or anticipation surrounding it. Big Show would be part of the opposition, teaming with Kane, Santino Marella and Kofi Kingston in a hodge podge mix of guys without anything more interesting to do. With so little effort going into the bout from a creative standpoint, and so little interest on the part of the fans, the right decision was made to keep it short. Too short to be anything even remotely worthwhile. After just 1:35 of ring time, Big Show blasted Slater with the KO Punch and pinned him to secure the win for his team. The outcome essentially killed The Corre dead while giving the babyfaces a victory, even if they would have just as well have been left off the card altogether.

13. Undisputed Tag Team Championship Match: ShowMiz Vs. R-Truth & John Morrison - WrestleMania 26

WWE.com
Big Show has a history of being short-changed on time at WrestleMania. One year before getting just over a minute-and-a-half in Atlanta, him and tag team partner The Miz defended the Undisputed WWE Tag Team Championships against the makeshift team of R-Truth and John Morrison. Total run-time of the "epic" title encounter? Three minutes, 28 seconds. With some solid tag team work from ShowMIz, and a cool knockout spot from the giant to Morrison that led to the finish, the match was a fun sprint if anything. Thus, despite being a title match criminally cut short for the sake of saving time, it ranks higher than the two that preceded it on this list.

12. Paul "Big Show" Wight Vs. Mankind - WrestleMania 15

WWE.com
Big Show was barely a month into his WWE stint when he took to the squared circle for a battle with Mankind. The match, to determine who would referee the main event between "Stone Cold" Steve Austin and The Rock, was one of the highest profile ones on the entire card. It was also one of the night's greatest disappointments, thanks in large part to the fact that the Superstars were put in front of the Philadelphia crowd to have a traditional wrestling match more than the brawl they would deliver in much more effective fashion a month later at Backlash. A slow match that ended with a cop-out of a disqualification finish, it was more of an emphasis for Big Show knocking out Vince McMahon and becoming a babyface than anything resembling a quality wrestling match.

11. World Tag Team Championship Match: Big Show & Kane Vs. Carlito & Chris Masters - WrestleMania 22

The opening contest of WrestleMania 22 saw Big Show and Kane, then world tag team champions, defending againt the young tandem of Carlito and Chris Masters. Considering the fact that The World's Largest Athlete and The Big Red Monster had dominated the tag division since the previous October, most expected the upstart team of youngsters to unseat them and take the titles. The champions completely outclassed the challengers, though, with neither Kane nor Big Show ever really in any damage. Late-match miscommunication from the heels led to a chokeslam to Carlito and a successful title defense by the veteran big men. Big Show's match at the twenty-second incarnation of the event was a lethargic one that never really kicked out of first gear. Like so many of his other tag team bouts on the grand stage, it was shortchanged in regards to time and, worst of all, he was nursing injuries that would ultimately see him take more than a year off from the mat wars.

10. Handicap Match: Big Show & A-Train Vs. The Undertaker - WrestleMania XIX

WWE.com
The original plans for WrestleMania XIX called for Big Show and A-Train to battle The Undertaker and tag team partner, Nathan Jones. The problem? Jones sucked, something that was only brought to the attention of Vince McMahon hours before the show when an angle was developed to write him off the show.
With such a major last-minute change and a contest that never looked particularly pretty on paper to begin with, it was understandable that the match failed to inspire like it did. Big Show and his monstrous partner became the latest victims in Undertaker's legendary Streak, but names among some of the most iconic stars to ever lace a pair of boots.

9. Andre The Giant Memorial Battle Royal - WrestleMania 31

WWE.com
The second-annual Andre The Giant Memorial Battle Royal may have appeared on the Kickoff Show but Big Show treated it as if it was the main event of the night, hellbent on making up for the previous year's loss to Cesaro in the monumental contest. He did just that, rolling through the competition and into the history books courtesy of his win in Santa Clara. The match came down to the giant and Damien Mizdow, who was in the midst of his greatest push to date. Fans in Levi's Stadium loved the stunt double and wanted nothing more than to see him leave victoriously, especially after getting revenge on Miz for months of mistreatment. But, unfortunately for him, he ran into a Superstar that the battle royal was seemingly made for, a giant with a bad attitude in Big Show. The giant withstood a spirited flurry from the former Intellectual Savior and sent him over the top rope for the win. And, whether fans liked it or not, there was something so right about the photo ops that came out of the victor's side-by-side pose with the Andre trophy. Not particularly a great match for the most part, the closing moments with the Mizdow story and Show's triumph make it one of the more entertaining of Big Show's most recent 'Mania matches.

8. Intercontinental Championship Match: Big Show Vs. Cody Rhodes - WrestleMania 28

WWE.com
For weeks leading into WrestleMania 28, intercontinental champion Cody Rhodes pointed out to the WWE Universe just how underwhelming Big Show's resume at the Showcase of the Immortals actually was. He produced videos poking fun of the giant for his many embarrassing losses and the fact that, to that point, he had not enjoyed a real WrestleMania moment. Fueled by enhancing his legacy and shutting up the second-generation Superstar at the same time, The World's Largest Athlete entered Miami for a date with destiny. There, in front of a red hot Miami crowd, Big Show defeated Rhodes to capture the Intercontinental Championship. It was the first time he held the title, completing the elusive Triple Crown and etching his name in the history books as one of the most decorated stars to ever lace a pair of boots. Better yet? He looked motivated doing it, determined to prove to everyone that his string of disappointing showings at WrestleMania would not plague him for the remainder of his career. While the match was far from perfect, it was competitive and much longer than the one-minute sprint he had been subjected to a year earlier.

7. United States Championship Match: Big Show Vs. John Cena - WrestleMania 20

WWE.com
The opening match of WrestleMania 20 pitted United States champion Big Show against John Cena. The giant had embarked on one of the worst reigns with US title ever, and his motivation appeared to be at a low. He was also hurting, something we would find out after the big event as he stepped away from the ring for a few months to get some surgery and heal up. No matter how bad things may have been for him, though, he still showed up to Madison Square Garden to do the favor for Cena. Big Show dominated the action in a classic "big man vs. plucky underdog" match, using his size and strength to subdue Cena. And in the end, it would take a shot from an illegal pair of brass knuckles and a second F-U (Attitude Adjustment, for you young folks) to put an end to Show's dominance. The match marked the last time fans would see Big Show compete in a traditional singles match until WrestleMania 24. More on that one in a bit.

6. Big Show, Randy Orton & Sheamus Vs. The Shield - WrestleMania 29

WWE.com
The Six-Man Tag Team match from WrestleMania 29, pitting Big Show, Sheamus and Randy Orton against The Shield was a shining example of the "tag team partners who dislike each other" formula that became such an integral part of WWE programming during the Attitude Era. For weeks, Big Show, Randy Orton and Sheamus found themselves at odds with one another, only to become targets of Roman Reigns, Dean Ambrose and Seth Rollins at the same time. With one common enemy, the trio banded together to do battle with The Hounds of Justice. And despite having their opponents right where they wanted them, the trio let their egos get the best of them, none bigger or worse than that of the giant Big Show. He left both opponents lying following an energetic opener, leaving to the locker room following another WrestleMania defeat. The match may have been tons of fun and given The Shield their first major win on the grand stage, but it did have one major flaw: it was the emphasis for a hideously boring handicap match pitting Orton and Sheamus against The World's Largest Athlete the following night on Raw.

5. Andre The Giant Memorial Battle Royal - WrestleMania 30

WWE.com
The entire premise of the inaugural Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal centered around Big Show establishing his legacy as the greatest giant in wrestling history and doing so by winning the match named after his greatest competition to that title. He was built up solidly in the weeks leading into the match, almost to the point that everyone knew he would not win because it would be way too obvious. But if not him, which Superstar would be strong enough to toss him over the top rope and to the arena floor? Could it be Sheamus? Maybe former world champions Dolph Ziggler or Alberto Del Rio would be elusive enough to let Show make a mistake and stumble over on his own? Fans got their answer as Cesaro entered unannounced and scored his greatest win to that point, lifting Big Show over his head and bodyslamming him over the top rope for the win. It was shades of Hulk Hogan slamming Andre in one of the most memorable moments in event history, some 27 years earlier, and completely fit the theme of the match. More importantly, it created a buzz about the Swiss Superstar that, even for one night, helped establish him as a singles star unlike any other push had to that point.

4. Fatal 4-Way Elimination Match For The WWE Championship: Big Show Vs. The Rock Vs. Mick Foley Vs. Triple H - WrestleMania 2000

WWE.com
Big Show was one of three challengers chasing Triple H and the WWE Championship in the main event of WrestleMania 2000. A man who felt as though he was unjustly chastised by The Rock, then screwed out of a Royal Rumble victory by an inattentive referee. With no other option, he adopted a meaner and nastier attitude than ever before and aligned himself with the arrogant and rambunctious Shane McMahon ahead of the big Fatal 4-Way match that headlined that year's event. Unfortunately, the heavyweight competitor's stint in the match was relatively short-lived compared to that of Mick Foley and the aforementioned Triple H and Rock. Obviously the biggest threat to either of those three Superstars leaving with the title, he found himself on the receiving end of the finishing maneuvers of all three of his opponents, finally succumbing to the Rock Bottom. Though his exit was hast, his contributions to the match provided it with just one of the many stories that would intertwine to create a main event underrated by modern historians.

3. Triple Threat Match For the WWE Hardcore Championship: Big Show Vs. Kane Vs. Raven - WrestleMania 17

big show kane wrestlemania 17.jpg
Speaking of underrated matches featuring Big Show... Big Show and Kane again have their paths cross on this list, this time in a Triple Threat match for Raven's WWE Hardcore Championship. To suggest the hardcore title is anything more than a garbage belt, one designed to inspire car crash-like matches full of weaponry and death-defying spots, would be a mistake. It was what it was and at WrestleMania 17, the three Superstars involved in the gigantic bout delivered one of the best matches in the history of that particular championship. Raven bumped around the ring and the backstage area, even enduring being thrown through a glass window. Big Show was destructive, dishing out pain to both of his opponents, but also taking it as well. At one point, he was even slammed through a wall backstage by his Big Red Monster opponent. The match was wild, chaotic and violent, just as fans had come to expect from the hardcore division. It was the clever use of spots and placement of them throughout the bout (including one involving golf carts) that helped elevate it past the normal fare and delivered Big Show's WrestleMania resume its second straight above-average match.

2. Triple Threat Match For The World Heavyweight Championship Match: Big Show Vs. Edge Vs. John Cena - WrestleMania 25

big show john cena edge.jpg
The worst thing to happen to the Triple Threat match for the World Heavyweight Championship match between Big Show, Edge and John Cena at WrestleMania 25 was the five-star classic between Undertaker and Shawn Michaels that immediately preceded it. Fans were so burnt out following the emotional roller coaster that match took them on that the three combatants in the world title bout were greeted with silence. Unfortunately for them, that silence has led some to suggest that the match was underwhelming or, in the most drastic of cases, plain bad. It was the furthest thing from it. The match was actually damn good, with Big Show running over both Cena and Edge. His ongoing relationship with Vickie Guerrero even played a role as the giant was clearly the centerpiece of the match. Though he did not win the title, suffering an Attitude Adjustment from Cena, then being pinned after Edge was slammed on top of him by the franchise star, the match represented the second straight year that Big Show appeared motivated and was involved in one of the evening's highest-profile matches.

1. The Biggest Vs. The Best: Big Show Vs. Floyd "Money" Mayweather - WrestleMania 24

WWE.com
The Undertaker may have battled Edge to close out WrestleMania 24 but make no mistake about it: the real main event of the show was Big Show vs. Floyd Mayweather in a match dubbed "The Biggest vs. The Best." Hyped like a real sporting contest, and featuring input from several boxing insiders in the weeks leading to the match, the show was built around the monumental clash between The World's Largest Athlete and the best boxer on the planet. Big Show was fantastic, carrying the action and wearing down Mayweather throughout the match. The boxing champion was equally as good, playing his role to perfection and generating a ton of heat for his arrogant and cocky demeanor. People wanted to see him squashed like a bug and at times, they got it. Unfortunately, a pair of brass knuckles came into play as Mayweather used them to negate the size of his opponent and beat him. It was a nice callback to WrestleMania, where John Cena had to resort to the same weapon to fell the giant. Too often over the eight years that have followed the event, Mayweather has been credited for the success of the match. In reality, it was Big Show's veteran expertise and experience that helped the match become the satisfying conclusion to all the hype and publicity that it ultimately was.

Contributor
Contributor

Erik Beaston is a freelance pro wrestling writer who likes long walks in the park, dandelions and has not quite figured out that this introduction is not for Match.com. He resides in Parts Unknown, where he hosts weekly cookouts with Kane, The Ultimate Warrior, Papa Shango and The Boogeyman. Be jealous.