Ranking Every Goldberg Match In WWE Since His 2016 Return
What were the best, and the worst matches of Goldberg's return to WWE?
Ever since his debut, Bill Goldberg has been one of the most polarizing figures in all of professional wrestling.
Starting in 1997, Goldberg went on a historic win streak that saw him run rough shot through the entire WCW roster. Following the demise of World Championship Wrestling and a brief run in the WWE, Goldberg left wrestling in 2004, seemingly never to be seen again.
That all changed in 2016, as Goldberg began teasing a return to wrestling across various media platforms. After trading insults with Paul Heyman and his client, Goldberg’s return was set for Survivor Series 2016 against Brock Lesnar. The match was par for the course for the former WCW Heavyweight Champion, as he defeated the nearly unstoppable Beast Incarnate in 86 seconds.
Since that night in November 2016, Goldberg's second stint in WWE has included two Universal Championship wins, and an induction into the WWE Hall of Fame. All this while only wrestling 12 matches culminating this past Saturday against Roman Reigns in Saudi Arabia. If rumors are to be believed, this might have been the final bout of Goldberg's career as his deal is reportedly over. Some of his matches have been great, some just okay, and others have been some of the worst in WWE history.
Here they are, ranked...
12. Vs. Undertaker: Super Showdown 2019
When WWE purchased WCW in 2001, it created an endless list of possible dream matches at Vince McMahon's fingertips. One matchup surely close to the top of wishlists would have been Goldberg vs. The Undertaker. Unfortunately, this match would not take place until 18 years after the close of Ted Turner's company.
Since this was clearly long after both Goldberg and The Phenom's in-ring peak meant wrestling fans were not expecting much coming into Super Showdown 2019. However, even the most modest of expectations were not met as this was one of the worst matches in WWE history.
Goldberg was concussed early on, possibly even before the match as some reports suggested. This led to several botched moves including a brutal Jackhammer that could have seriously hurt The Deadman. Undertaker was not even able to execute a Tombstone Piledriver due to Goldberg’s condition and the finish had to be changed to a chokeslam.
It's a true shame that the one and only encounter between these two wrestling icons is also the worst match of Goldberg’s time in WWE.
11. Vs. Kevin Owens: Fastlane 2017
Goldberg has spent almost the entirety of his career winning matches in quick order. That trademark style was what got him over with the crowd during his legendary winning streak in WCW.
Winning in 22 seconds over Universal Champion Kevin Owens, however, is quite different, and not for the better. The Prizefighter had been on the run of his career following his first world championship win in WWE and had just had one of the best segments in Raw history in The Festival of Friendship. Only his second singles match back in WWE, this bout was the first of many times Goldberg would be chosen to go over the current stars of Raw and SmackDown.
A distraction by Chris Jericho, a Spear, a Jackhammer and Goldberg had successfully buried the second ever Universal Champion. It was clear WWE wanted Goldberg vs. Brock Lesnar for WrestleMania, but burying Kevin Owens in this fashion was the wrong way to do it.
10. Vs. The Fiend: Super Showdown 2020
When Bray Wyatt returned to WWE television in 2019, The Fiend was one of the most entertaining and fresh gimmicks fans had seen in recent memory. This new character was another example of the skill that Wyatt brought to every opportunity given to him throughout his time in wrestling.
Once The Fiend returned to the ring, the leader of the Firefly Fun House was built up as an unstoppable monster, destroying every wrestler put in his way en route to winning the Universal Championship. While the reaction was purely negative, only a few months prior, The Fiend was nearly killed by an endless barrage of weapons shots and Curb Stomps by Seth Rollins, only to kick out every time.
That all changed in Saudi Arabia, as one Jackhammer later and the Universal Championship reign of The Fiend was over. While the result may not have been surprising given WWE's treatment of Goldberg, it was just another example of WWE leaning on the stars of the past over their current roster. The only thing ranking this match above Goldberg’s dispatching of Kevin Owens was that The Fiend was at least able to get some offense in.
9. Vs. Bobby Lashley: SummerSlam 2021
In Goldberg’s return to WWE, only three times would a match go longer than six minutes. Of all people, two of those outings are against The All Mighty. Of those matchups, this was clearly the worse of the two bouts.
This was yet another example in a growing line of times Goldberg would return just to be quickly placed in a feud for a world championship. At SummerSlam 2021, neither Bobby Lashley nor Goldberg would come out of this WWE Championship clash looking strong. Goldberg was made to look weak, losing by referee stoppage, while Bobby Lashley failed to live up to his Almighty moniker, needing the help of MVP to defend his championship.
At this point, fans who had just returned to WWE events, were so against Goldberg that even beating down Goldberg’s son post-match could not turn them in the former WCW Champions favor. Thankfully these two would make up for this clunker of a match a few months later in Saudi Arabia.
8. Vs. Braun Strowman: WrestleMania 36
Following Roman Reigns’ decision to leave WWE at the onset of the Covid-19 pandemic, Universal Champion Goldberg was left without a dance partner for WrestleMania. The Monster Among Men stepped in on the final SmackDown before WrestleMania, allowing for literally zero build between the two goliaths of wrestling.
At The Showcase of the Immortals, fans got what they would expect between the two behemoths with Spears and running Powerslams galore. In the end, Braun Strowman was finally able to put Goldberg away with his fourth Powerslam and won his first Universal Championship. Even if it was a move done out of sheer desperation, it was still a welcome sight to see the former Wyatt Family member toppling Goldberg.
The absence of fans inside the WWE Performance Center obviously took away from the match, as did the last minute booking, but it was far from an awful showing from Goldberg and Braun Strowman.
7. Vs. Brock Lesnar: WrestleMania 33
Remember when we would play wrestling games and you would change the settings to unlimited finishers? You would spend the entire game spamming the L2 button, trying to hit as many bombs and end the match as quickly as possible. That was basically this bout between Brock Lesnar and Goldberg at WrestleMania 34 in a nutshell.
In less than six minutes, this Universal Championship match saw ten suplexes, four Spears, another through the ringside barricade, a Jackhammer and an F-5 before Brock Lesnar walked away with the win. The culmination of a 14-year rivalry, The Beast Incarnate was finally able to avenge all the losses given to him by Goldberg over the years.
Coming into the Universal Championship match, fans were not expecting much as their first WrestleMania encounter was soundly rejected by the fans, and their most recent matchup lasted only 86 seconds. Although this was certainly not a wrestling classic, it was about as good as you could have expected from Goldberg and Brock Lesnar
6. 2017 Royal Rumble Match
WWE built up Goldberg's appearance in the 2017 Royal Rumble match as Brock Lesnar's opportunity at vengeance following The Beast Incarnate's embarrassment at Survivor Series. Coming into the match, Goldberg along with The Undertaker and eventual winner Randy Orton were three of the favorites to win WWE’s marquee match.
On the previous episode of Raw, the show closed with Goldberg, Undertaker, and Brock Lesnar staring at each other, hyping up their potential encounters during the Royal Rumble. What followed at the event was Goldberg entering at number 28 and immediately eliminating Lesnar, continuing his dominance over The Beast. Goldberg would continue to run roughshod over the field before being eliminated by The Undertaker.
While his appearance accomplished its goal of setting up the rematch with Lesnar and a future bout with The Phenom, this was nothing special from Goldberg.
5. Vs. Drew McIntyre: Royal Rumble 2021
On the 4 January episode of Raw, Goldberg returned after Drew McIntyre successfully defended his WWE Championship against Keith Lee. Once again, Goldberg was able to insert himself as the number one contender and make a title match for the Royal Rumble pay-per-view.
As has been the case for every Goldberg match during his second stint in WWE, fans knew what to expect from the bout.
A brutal back and forth clash before the bell rang kicked off the night for Goldberg and Drew McIntyre. Then both Goldberg and The Scottish Warrior took turns hitting their big moves before McIntyre was able to hit one final Claymore to end the WWE Championship bout. In the end, Drew McIntyre looked strong as ever being able to put away the former WCW Champion, and Goldberg shook the hand of McIntyre, something he had not done after any of his previous matches.
The action was fast-paced and the pre-match war on the outside really built the intensity of the bout. Nobody will argue it was a five-star classic, but an entertaining and quick match without Goldberg winning was all fans could have hoped for.
4. Vs. Brock Lesnar: Survivor Series 2016
Following a summer of teasing the fans, for the first time in over 12 years, Goldberg was back competing in a WWE ring. He spent weeks leading up to Survivor Series building up the hype of his monumental clash with Brock Lesnar, who in turn took it personally. Once we got to Survivor Series in Toronto, Canada, nobody could have guessed what would happen.
In the main event, with no championships on the line, the former WCW Champion was facing off against Brock Lesnar, who was arguably at his peak. Fans were left speechless when the unstoppable Beast Incarnate was not only defeated, but put down in a shocking 86 seconds. One Spear and one Jackhammer later, and one of the most dominant and protected runs in WWE history was squashed.
While this was a precursor of things to come, the sheer shock of this match left fans wanting to know who, and what, was next for Goldberg.
3. Vs. Roman Reigns: Elimination Chamber 2022
If rumors are to be believed and this past Saturday at Elimination Chamber was Goldberg's final match in WWE, he went out exactly how he should have.
Goldberg and Universal Champion Roman Reigns put on a solid affair, capitalizing on the strengths of both the former WCW Champion and The Tribal Chief. While there was little chance Goldberg would be the one to end the reign of The Head of the Table, it was still a shock to see the former WCW Champion lose by submission for the first time in his career. Despite fans growing tired of seeing Goldberg in championship matches, when put in the right situation with the right opponent, he is able to shine.
While this match carried the typical Goldberg formula of signature moves in quick succession, he did everything in his power to showcase Roman Reigns as the top star in all of WWE.
2. Vs. Dolph Ziggler: SummerSlam 2019
When Goldberg returned to WWE, and following his feud with Brock Lesnar, this was the exact version of the WCW standout fans wanted.
Goldberg never needed to be in a title match, let alone win two Universal Championships. He should never have been chosen to defeat some of WWE’s rising stars in The Fiend and Kevin Owens. All he needed to do was have matches exactly like this with Dolph Ziggler. A quick Spear and Jackhammer lead to a brief squash match, and a quick exit for Goldberg. This was followed by two back to back occasions of Goldberg returning to the ring to deliver more signature offense.
Credit to Dolph Ziggler for proving why he is one of the best sellers in WWE history. Not only did he make the two moves he received during the match look deadly, but his post-match promo was exactly what fans needed to want Goldberg to keep coming back. At SummerSlam 2019, Goldberg looked his absolute best, harkening back to what made him a fan favorites in WCW.
1. Vs. Bobby Lashley: Crown Jewel 2021
Goldberg who built his legacy on dominating opponents quickly, and almost never wrestling more than five minutes. That being said, it's astonishing his best match in his return to WWE was also his longest.
At Crown Jewel 2021, Goldberg proved once again that he does not need to be thrown into championship matches haphazardly to have a great showing. Following their lacklustre performance at SummerSlam several months ago, Goldberg was out for revenge against the former WWE Champion Bobby Lashley.
Fighting all across the Mohammed Abdu Arena, this was a personal, bloody and violent war that the sometimes tame Saudi crowd was more than into. Goldberg took out Cedric Alexander, Shelton Benjamin, and finally The All Mighty with a gnarly looking spear off the entrance way through a table for the win.
Goldberg winning was partially a shock given the dominance of Bobby Lashley since becoming WWE Champion. Nevertheless, during this match fans were reminded of what made Goldberg one of the best acts in WCW history.