Ranking Every NXT TakeOver From Worst To Best
18. Brooklyn III
Following Adam Cole's debut after a Drew McIntyre/Bobby Roode main event, there was a bit of a joke doing the rounds that Indie Triple H ran in after Scottish Triple H defeated Canadian Triple H. It wasn't entirely unfounded.
Much like some of 'The Game's stinkers, the headline match itself had been a bit of a bore, but a suited and booted Cole alongside new allies Kyle O'Reilly and Bobby Fish had far more about themselves on formation than Evolution, regardless of what the Network documentaries say.
The night was highlighted by two exhausting epics. Johnny Gargano and Andrade 'Cien' Almas foreshadowed their eventual main event banger with a blistering opener that continued Almas' rebirth alongside Zelina Vega and the #DIY split in Tommaso Ciampa's absence. In the Women's division, Asuka yet again knocked back the challenge of Ember Moon but did so with honor and distinction at the second time of asking. It'd be her last defence, and what a legacy she left.
17. WarGames (2018)
A WarGames match remembered more for a moment of freakish magic from Ricochet more than just about anything else was evidence that NXT hadn’t quite figured out the double-ring/double-cage formula beyond the big spots, but the annual event’s undercard did far more the show at large beyond 2017’s uneven original.
Tommaso Ciampa was never losing the NXT Championship to 23-year-old enigma Velveteen Dream, but what a fabulous job the pair of creating the hope that he might. In one of Dream’s best matches to date, the Champion stripped away at the unchecked confidence of the Challenger before being subjected to a near-the-knuckle fightback that generated one of the best teasing two-counts of the year. Johnny Gargano’s descent into villainy saw him reach new heights in a fabulously-well handled tweener display against Aleister Black. A smart removal of Matt Riddle’s debut match against Kassius Ohno earlier that week initiated even more thirst for it on the a night, so much so that a six second flash win was the best case scenario for the ‘Original Bro’.
Lost to time already, Shayna Baszler’s two-out-of-three falls banger with Kairi Sane was an ingenious way to squeeze one more magnificent dream match from the tried and tested two. They barely appeared to pause for breath in an 11 minute sprint, robbing a frenzied audience of the same privilege.
16. Orlando
Shinsuke Nakamura's NXT farewell main event resulted in a Bobby Roode sequel far superior to the original - 'The Glorious One' had become the Champion in January but only felt like it after April. The sort of understated triumph some fans are now clamouring for in the superworker era of the black-and-gold brand, this was furiously hard-fought and worthy of the 'King Of Strong Style's swansong.
Underneath it in placement if not quality, a three way Tag Team Title clash featuring the Authors Of Pain, #DIY and The Revival was an equally epic sendoff for Scott Dawson and Dash Wilder. A masterpiece of a layout saw the four smaller men combine all their biggest hitters in frustrated compromise to take down the dominant champions. That they both failed only enhanced the aura of Akam and Rezar.
A lot happened here to shore up the future of a show still recovering from several big losses in 2016. Asuka's desperate victory over Ember Moon got the future Champion over in narrow defeat to set up their Summer rematch, Aleister Black got over-ish in his debut showcase against a still-floundering Andrade 'Cien' Almas and a mixed tag eight-person opener was way better than it had any right to be.
15. Brooklyn 4
The juice was out of the Tommaso Ciampa/Johnny Gargano fruit (in their guises then, at least) by August 2018, but the pair were forced into one last battle after Aleister Black's injury ruled him out of a triple threat main event that probably would have been better than the overblown Last Man Standing finale.
A lethargic main event undercut what was otherwise one of the most satisfying TakeOvers of the bunch. Undisputed Era concluded a magnificent trilogy against Moustache Mountain, whilst Kairi Sane (briefly) found her happy ending with a rare victory over dominant Women's Champion Shayna Baszler. Velveteen Dream and EC3 wasn't brilliantly worked but was a total triumph for the confidence and success of rising star Dream, not least with "Call Me Up Vince" slapped across his a*se.
As insane as they were, they couldn't steal the show from Ricochet and Adam Cole. The pair lit up Barclays Center a year after Cole's debut with a psychologically spectacular superfight. The Undisputed Era leader claimed not be impressed by 'The One & Only' and all he was capable of, and after leveling up and still not being able to beat him, tried to leave the ring to highlight just how easy it was to make his point. Ricochet's capture hurricanrana proved him wrong and took away his beloved North American title in the process.
14. WarGames (2019)
The best incarnation of the NXT-adapted stipulation show thus far, 2019's double-cage TakeOver benefitted from the black-and-gold brand's spectacular women's division, a screen-melting surprise and a white hot Chicago crowd.
Opening the event with a furious flourish, the first ever women's WarGames was an unabashed triumph, enhanced by Dakota Kai's brutal mid-match turn on her best friend Tegan Nox and Rhea Ripley's stature-enhancing win for her team over Shayna Baszler. Matt Riddle and Finn Bálor kept it simple in trying earnestly to kick the sh*t out of each other whilst a three way between Pete Dunne, Damian Priest and Killian Dain for the right to face NXT Champion Adam Cole the night after the show was far better than the midcard triple threat that dragged the Toronto card down earlier that year.
The main event between Team Ciampa and The Undisputed Era was a Hollywood blockbuster of an encounter, loaded with explosive spots, a wild character re-introduction and the most satisfactory of ginormous endings. Ciampa put Cole through a table from the top of the cage after Kevin Owens' emotional NXT homecoming helped steer the babyfaces to a win.
13. Brooklyn II
A case of style over substance won out for approximately half of NXT's Brooklyn sequel in 2016, but the matches that anchored the top of the pile were stark reminders of the magnificent wrestling promotion Triple H had gradually created away from his father-in-law's withering gaze.
Ember Moon and Bobby Roode both looked fantastic in (relative) squashes of Billie Kay and Andrade 'Cien' Almas respectively, whilst Austin Aries sh*thouse win over No Way Jose triggered an electric return from a Hideo Itami that masked the realities of what would be another injury-ravaged stint.
Shinsuke Nakamura's NXT Championship victory Samoa Joe completed his rapit journey from debutant to deity on the show, but his efforts were overwhelmed by the blissfully brilliant women's and tag divisions. The Revival's tag title retention over #DIY and Asuka's pulsating win against Bayley were yet more entries into NXT's elite file - matches too good to be denied as the brand underwent a transitional phase started that summer.
The Golden Era was coming to an end, but platinum days were still ahead.
12. The End
NXT eventually subtitled this show "The End Of The Beginning", accurately noting that it was something of a goodbye to a host of stars that had come to exemplify the hottest ever period for the brand.
WWE were splitting the main rosters of Raw and SmackDown again, and the black-and-gold brand was set to be pillaged to fill space on the revitalised Raw and SmackDown rosters, and it what turned out to be the last over TakeOver at Full Sail University, several big names were about to say goodbye to this glorious stage.
American Alpha, Nia Jax and Finn Bálor all lost strong matches to The Revival, Asuka and Samoa Joe respectively ahead of main roster call ups just weeks later. Elsewhere, Shinsuke Nakamura's breathless war with Austin Aries kept both in the conversation for future title contention whilst Andrade 'Cien' Almas' misguided debut was brilliant...even if it got his opponent Tye Dillinger over instead.
11. Toronto (2016)
Always awesome, the Canadian crowd were clearly thrilled to have a TakeOver North of the Border for the first time, roaring full-throated approval for one of the greatest TakeOver matches of all time as well as a main event that gladly welcomed the heat.
Shinsuke Nakamura losing the NXT Championship back to Samoa Joe so they could trade it on an upcoming Japan tour was undone by its primary function, as was the the Authors Of Pain/TM-61 Dusty Cup final by the placement of Paul Ellering in a toy-flogging shark cage.
Luckily, Bobby Roode's battle with Tye Dillinger was a victory for NXT more than the wrestlers for how over both men were, whilst the two-out-of-three falls tag battle between #DIY and The Revival. This doubles masterpiece was as rich and rewarding as anything the legendarily brilliant league ever curated.
Dash and Dawson tried to stop each other from tapping before surrendering to challengers that hadn't previously able to get the job done. Their run wasn't destined to be long, but the reaction for the win was one of the loudest in NXT history.
10. XXV
The task of having to follow what many fans have called the greatest match in company history was a bold one for Adam Cole and Johnny Gargano to undertake, but oh how they managed it as the Undisputed Era leader finally took his place atop the brand.
Going to the same lengths as their New York scorcher, Champion and Challenger exercised enough restraint early on to inform an explosive all out war as the tensions mounted. Crucially, Cole did this one alone - on a night where his UE troops failed to win, he managed it. Order had at last been restored.
Roderick Strong's bruising back-smashing loss to Matt Riddle was the highlight of another pant-p*sser of an undercard that saw Kyle O'Reilly enter in one of the solo showings of the year in a match featuring seven other men. Street Profits winning the vacant Tag Team Titles in a ladder match put Montez Ford and Angelo Dawkins over as money players so impactfully that they were transplanted onto the main roster within weeks.
Though Velveteen Dream and Tyler Breeze couldn't quite live up to dream match expectations, Shayna Baszler and Io Shirai absolutely f*cking did as the first foreshadowings of the Challengers eventual heel turn came following a soul-crushing loss.
9. London
A blisteringly exciting show that again separated NXT from lots of stuff fans came to hate about WWE's main roster, the event's London locale was a gift to British fans that had waited for a major pay-per-view event since SummerSlam 1992.
They were rewarded with a genuinely magnificent over-delivery of an event.
A wrestling buffet at its best long before AEW poached the term, the London card was diverse in its direction and dynamism, with only Baron Corbin's passable match with Apollo Crews giving the audience reason to dare take a toilet break.
This was firing-on-all-cylindars for wrestlers and sports entertainers in blissful harmony. Nia Jax had her best ever singles match with peerless Women's Champion Bayley, The Revival's sh*thouse win over Enzo & Big Cass made gutsy babyfaces out of the mouthy East Coast connection, whilst Asuka's win over Emma remains probably the most underrated TakeOver opener ever.
Finn Bálor and Samoa Joe had better matches in them than their firecracker main event, but nobody was to know that then - this was big time headliner sh*t for what was by then the most coveted prize in North America.