Ranking EVERY WWE Royal Rumble Pay-Per-View From Worst To Best

The highs and lows from 'The Road To WrestleMania's' first significant stop...

Royal Rumble
WWE

There have been some good, bad and f*cking ugly Royal Rumbles over the years, but that's not the only reason why the cliched categories have been employed here when assessing every single edition of the company's 'January Classic'.

The Royal Rumble is a pay-per-view unlike any other, in that it promises virtually not only an entire roster appearing in something significant, but an advertised main event almost guaranteed to go over an hour. This seems less of a creative flex in the era of Network specials and dollars-per-minute viewbait, but the stipulation suffered so much in the middle of the 2010s that the match engineered to generate reactions briefly became a graveyard for pops.

The company aren't quite out of the woods yet - Shinsuke Nakamura and Asuka won 2018's editions but suffered for their art for the rest of the year - but the Rumble's prestige is all but resorted ahead of the Road to WrestleMania 35. What then, of those that came before the darkest days? Or those that shone as lights at the end of creative and commercial tunnels? WWE have done a grand job of getting the fanbase to bolster the Rumble as a banker, even if it's occasionally been a bit of a ripoff...

32. Greatest Royal Rumble

Braun Strowman Greatest Royal Rumble
WWE.com

The Good: John Cena and Triple H's contemporary take on an old Hulk Hogan/Ultimate Warrior classic was predictably well-recieved by the wrestling-starved crowd. Daniel Bryan's 76:05 stint in the 50-man main event was a Rumble record, but the rest of the contest committed very little else to memory other than the subversively cathartic sight of Titus O'Neil falling flat on his face.

The Bad: Almost all of the undercard was pitiful filler. The Undertaker tarnished his legacy further with an extended squash of Rusev, Roman Reigns and Brock Lesnar sh*t things up in a cage, AJ Styles and Shinsuke Nakamura disappointed again, whilst Jinder Mahal's match with Jeff Hardy contained one of the most embarrassing botches of the year from the 'Modern Day Maharaja'.

The Ugly: The mere existence of the event made the whole experience rather unpleasant, with WWE's women's roster unable to work the event whatsoever, despite Michael Cole's forced platitudes about the changing attitudes of a nation. WWE's deal with Saudi Arabia tiptoed towards even murkier territory later that year.


31. 2014

Batista Royal Rumble 2014
WWE.com

The Good: Daniel Bryan's opener against Bray Wyatt was the latter's best WWE singles match ever and did much to make him a credible WrestleMania opponent for John Cena. A lone highlight of the event, the match is tinged with unnerving unease throughout due to an audience already sensing a grim reality they they don't want to believe.

The Bad: Brock Lesnar Vs The Big Show was a soul-destroying waste of time and is only forgotten because 'The Beast' scored one of the biggest wins in WrestleMania history a few months later. Fans sh*t on John Cena Vs Randy Orton a) because it was rubbish and b) the foreboding sense of doom that was increasing by the second in the building.

The Ugly: The grim reality and foreboding doom being realised in a horribly misunderstood Royal Rumble. Roman Reigns got away clean for a change, but only because a livid crowd spewed their bile on Batista, Rey Mysterio, Sheamus and anybody else that wasn't Daniel Bryan. The company had one backup plan that could have satiated the masses, but like so many actual fan favourites over the years, he was bantered off by Kane. CM Punk's WWE farewell was as futile as it was tragically fitting.


30. 1988

Hulk Hogan Andre Royal Rumble 1988
WWE.com

The Good: There had to be a first edition of the show, but it didn't exactly race out of the blocks. A contract signing between Hulk Hogan and Andre The Giant and a superb Jumping Bomb Angels/Glamour Girls tag team encounter were the only things worthy of the elevated status, but WWE's free TV experiment was successful - NWA's competing pay-per-view Bunkhouse Stampede fell short with something almost as good offered for free.

The Bad: The Rumble itself wasn't much to much, nor was the bulk of the card either side of the 20-man proving ground for the future January classic. Like a lot of supershows from the era, what it lacks in quality it just about makes up for in nostalgic charm.

The Ugly: The inaugural televised Royal Rumble (it didn't debut on pay-per-view until 1989) will always be an invention rooted in competitive cynicism, but the brave undertaking alone was legitimately impressive.


29. 2015

Roman Reigns Royal Rumble 2015
WWE

The Good: Brock Lesnar, John Cena and Seth Rollins constructed one of the finest WWE triple threat matches ever over 'The Beast's WWE Championship. An intricate masterclass of timing and execution, it completely revived a sagging reign ahead of another surprising Seth-based outing for Brock at WrestleMania.

The Bad: Everything else before the wretched main event was awful enough that the Rumble match needed to deliver before the first even entrants arrived. A selection of sh*te tag matches didn't exactly help audiences warm up before the aforementioned amazing WWE Championship battle, even if it helped them forget what they'd endured.

The Ugly: The Royal Rumble as we once knew it died on January 25th 2015 as WWE broke a seemingly unbreakable gimmick for the good of a push that categorically would not take. Everything felt engineered to enrage, though the worst thing was that it probably wasn't. Daniel Bryan spent a criminally short time in the ring,


28. 2009

Legacy Triple H Royal Rumble 2009
WWE.com

The Good: Melina and Beth Phoenix' Women's Title match was one of the division's best ever before it was any good. Everything good about Jeff Hardy Vs Edge (including Matt Hardy's swerve turn) remains rooted in cynicism from the time. The entire programme and match was designed to welcome Christian back into the company, but the fans' receptiveness to the idea cooled Vince McMahon on it. Matt wasn't the worst person to parachute in, but it was a depressingly needless change of plans.

The Bad: More boring than bad, the Rumble was boring, Randy Orton winning was boring, Legacy helping him was boring, Triple H being the great babyface hope against them was boring. The incessant mundanity carried over from a listless opener in which Jack Swagger defeated soon-to-turn-heel Matt Hardy in a contest that failed to cement him as a serious proposition on the brand before Hardy disappeared from view.

The Ugly: Though the match wasn't a complete bust, Shawn Michaels' acting certainly was during John Cena's World Championship clash with John Bradshaw Layfield. The premise that 'HBK' needed 'JBL's money was absurd. That drama killed any actual drama.


27. 2005

Muhammad Hassan Royal Rumble 2005
WWE.com

The Good: A half-decent Rumble match masked an ultra-lame undercard. John Cena and Dave Batista's accidental double elimination looked real enough to be intended, but inadvertently reflected just how close both were to the promised land. Loaded with mini-segments as good Rumbles should be, the battle royal whizzed by en route to the heavy favourites arriving late.

The Bad: Edge and Shawn Michaels' opener was a disappointment, but understandably so considering their roles in the Rumble later on. Edge in particular had a 40 minute stretch to save himself for. The novelty was already wearing off JBL's long WWE Championship run before another pay-per-view required another creative escape hatch.

The Ugly: Mohammad Hassan being turned on by the entire field during the Rumble felt more than a little icky. WWE had promised a new spin on the anti-American stereotype when the character debuted late the prior year, and they were already reneging on the deal. As far as WrestleMania feuds for The Undertaker go, a doubles affair alongside Kane versus Heidenreich and Gene Snitsky would have been an all-time worst based on his wretched singles match here.


26. 1991

Sgt Slaughter Wins The WWE Title Royal Rumble 1991
WWE.com

The Good: The Rockers and The Orient Express were about a decade ahead of the rest of the product in an exhilarating opener, but from a wrestling perspective little else could touch them afterwards. Virgil's turn on Ted Dibiase brought the house down, after the incredible sh*tkicking Randy Savage dished out to The Ultimate Warrior en route to his WWE Championship loss.

The Bad: The Slaughter/Warrior match was awful when Randy Savage wasn't involved in it, whilst The Big Boss Man and The Barbarian should probably both have been in the Rumble instead of having a bang average singles match to further Bobby Heenan's feud with the former prison guard.

The Ugly: A dry Royal Rumble capped off a middling show made worse by the jingoism whipped up by Sgt Slaughter's victory over The Ultimate Warrior. WWE had steered into the worst case scenario and wouldn't be punished for it until a WrestleMania VII venue shift was finally confirmed.


25. 1993

Royal Rumble 1993 Yokozuna Randy Savage
WWE

The Good: Bret Hart and Razor Ramon put on an understated clinic for the industry's top prize. 'The Hitman' wasn't ever going to be the draw former (and future) Champion Hulk Hogan was, but he was rapidly reframing what it meant to be WWE Champion. The pay-per-view debut of the Frankensteiner in the Steiner Brothers/Beverly Brothers opener was sensational.

The Bad: Outside of a hot early section spotlighting the Mr Perfect/Ric Flair rivalry, the Royal Rumble was awfully drab and utterly bereft of bonafide main event stars. Never had the reality of WWE's difficult future been as apparent than when the likes of Damien Demento and Carlos Colon made up the numbers just a year removed from what many consider to be the most loaded edition in the contest's history. Yokozuna was a realistic winner, but his performance in the match wasn't terribly exciting.

The Ugly: Shawn Michaels and Marty Jannetty had contenders for 1993 Match Of The Year over the Intercontinental Title, but this January debacle wasn't one. Amidst all sorts of backstage ugliness between the pair, the bad behaviour off screen helped craft a very bad match on. Jannetty was blamed and fired for it the very next day.


24. 1989

Savage Hogan Royal Rumble 1989
WWE.com

The Good: The Mega Powers came within a whisker of exploding shortly before their Main Event collapse just weeks later after Hulk Hogan sh*thoused Randy Savage out of the match. The tension was luxuriously palpable and clearly going to make the company millions.

The Bad: Boredom abounds in much of the battle royal itself as WWE continue to work out the kinks in the gimmick. Big John Studd winning makes sense because of his size, but the man himself inspired little interest otherwise. A tag team opener should have lit up the undercard but instead felt much, much longer than the 15 minutes it was afforded.

The Ugly: Harley Race and Haku fighting over WWE's fake crown was insipid, but still not the worst thing on the show. A Women's Title clash between Rockin' Robin and Judy Martin was carried by Sensational Sherri on commentary and more's the pity - the match needed her far more than the booth.


23. 1996

Vader Yokozuna Royal Rumble 1996
WWE

The Good: Shawn Michaels put in a fabulous shift in the Royal Rumble match en route to his second successive victory. As did Vader - 'The Mastodon' had one of his few only good nights as a battle royal debutant. Jake Roberts' enormous nostalgia pop betrayed his capabilities, but did much to enhance his star aura beyond the 'returning legend' tag.

The Bad: Ahmed Johnson and Jeff Jarrett were having a dangerously entertaining brawl before a guitar shot cut the match unnecessarily short. WWE's depth issues were as prevalent here as they were the year prior - though the Rumble lasted longer, there were still plenty of oddity entries, and the undercard left a lot to be desired.

The Ugly: The Undertaker and Bret Hart had an inexcusably lousy main event, wrestling as if they were protesting the even lousier finish. A Diesel run-in after nearly 30 minutes cheaply brought things to a halt before Undertaker could pin 'The Hitman' after a tombstone. With the exception of 'Big Daddy Cool's middle finger gesture, this was the absolute sh*ts.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.