Ranking Every WWE SmackDown "Throwback" From Worst To Best

From big fists to playas making a comeback; which WWE SmackDown "Throwback" outranked the rest?

Teddy Long
WWE.com

Unless you've been living under a rock (no, not the one with the funky eyebrow) for the last week or so, it likely came to your attention that WWE were set to "Go Back" to the old days on this week's episode of Friday Night SmackDown on FOX. Then those in charge decided "Throwback" sounded better and ran with that instead.

Either way, things were about to get very retro in an attempt to give the blue show a little shot in the arm coming into the healthy dose of déjà vu that is WrestleMania Backlash.

With the thought of the company dusting off some of the Friday night delight's greatest and most recognisable visuals/moments for this one-off special, naturally, fans began to fantasy book precisely which iconic pieces of the show's history would be making a comeback. Everything from big silver fists to a Great One cookin' up a storm on his brand were dreamed up, but were WWE on the same wave length as those tuning in for the good stuff last night? Sort of.

From rather peculiar choices of themes, to unexpected returns of faces synonymous with the beloved blue programme, "Throwback" SmackDown certainly delivered on its concept, but just how well did each nod to the past land on the night?

Let's get right Down to it...


8. Ruby Hits Rock Bottom (Sort Of)

Ruby Riott
WWE.com

Best to get this "Throwback" out of the way early as it was likely more Pat McAfee being on the ball on commentary than anything else.

In one of the only major acknowledgements of the star who gave birth to the name of the show that has gone on to become a WWE staple, Ruby Riott threw a cheeky Rock Bottom into her losing display against former SmackDown Women's Champion Carmella. Well, kind of.

Michael Cole referred to the move as a "leg-sweep takedown", which was pretty much what actually went down. However, sensing the moment to put over The Great One, the newest member of the SmackDown broadcast team noted the move's similarities to The Rock's finisher of choice.

We'll let you decide if this was an intentional tribute or not...


7. Virtual Fist And Retro Tron

SmackDown Fist
WWE.com

Guess what? They did it! They actually did it! They only went and brought back the legendary MASSIVE SmackDown fist set. Well, once again, kind of.

Putting their recent obsession with 3D graphics to good use, the iconic fist was beamed into the arena on the night... yet, it didn't actually hang around long. In its place, WWE instead opted for a rather odd choice of having the now-typical modern LED tron plastered with the '80s WWE logo and a funky assortment of colours.

Would it have been so hard to just bring back the genuine thing for one special night? Clearly so.

WWE SmackDown Throwback Set 2021
WWE.com

Still, it was nice to see the company bring back such an adored visual in some way, shape, or form, even if the end result felt like a bit of a let down on the night.

This also brings us nicely into the next entry on our list...


6. Logos And Match Graphics

Throwback SmackDown
WWE.com

In another nice-touch-tinged-with-stupidity, last night saw the return of the SmackDown! logo of the early 2000s for everything from the opening signature to the little branding WWE uses on its YouTube clips of the show. But then WWE went and pointlessly muddied the waters once again.

Instead of having the various match graphics, highlighting upcoming contests on this show and next week's edition of SmackDown, be sold in the style of say a 2006-esque moving image of the stars set to clash, another '80s-style alternative was used... for a show which debuted at the end of the '90s. Makes sense. This also applied to the graphics showcasing a talent's name as they made their way to the ring.

It's almost like those in charge had no plan whatsoever coming into last night and just splurged whatever imagery they associated with the word "retro" onto our screens. The lack of cohesion in the type of "Throwback" this night would be unfortunately made what could have been a lovely dose of nostalgia into a unexpectedly jarring experience at times, and the use of mis-matched graphics and logos highlighted this perfectly.


5. Old School Adverts

Ice Cream bars
WWE.com

Right, now we've had a right old moan at some of the more disappointing elements of this "Throwback" special, let's turn our attention to the things WWE and FOX got right on the night.

In a moment that would've even likely made CM Punk crack a smile, old school advertisements were re-introduced to WWE programming for one night only. Things such as the much-loved WWE ice cream bars and the bodybuilding supplements ICOPRO once marketed by Vinnie Mac back in the day popped up on the show and likely left a whole new generation begging the question, "Where in the hell are my WWE ice cream bars?".

Again, if we're nitpicking, you could argue that the choice of an '80s ice cream advert was a bit weird to lodge into a SmackDown "Throwback" show. But we were too giddy on the sight of those delicious retro treats to give a damn at this point.


4. Announce Desk And Announcer/Referee Wardrobe

Cole McAfee
WWE.com

As we've noted, WWE seemed to have their wires royally crossed when it came to the overall look of last night's "Throwback" occasion. And another example of this came in the form of the announcers' choice of attire and the desk they were operating behind for much of the evening.

Yet, you won't catch your writer crapping all over the sight of Pat McAfee donning his best early '90s Vince McMahon costume for the event. Simply put, it was a thing of beauty. Clashing with his co-commentator, however, was Michael Cole who definitely appeared to have understood the assignment as he dusted off his old denim number from the late '90s. Jumping back into the strange '80s feel the company regularly went for on this old school SmackDown, though, the two called the night's action behind a minimalistic, black-cloth-covered table - just like the good ol' non-SmackDown days.

WWE Ref
WWE.com

In-keeping with what should have been the theme of the evening, the referees tasked with controlling the chaos going down in the ring also opted for a retro SmackDown vibe with their choice of gear. The blue polos that became synonymous with the blue brand in the early 2000s were on show for the world to see, and it must be said, few would argue with bringing back this slick look full-time.


3. 2006 Signature Infusion

We'll level with you. This didn't technically go down on last night's show, but it dropped on YouTube just before "Throwback" SmackDown got underway, so we're counting it as an appetiser to the night itself. And oh, what a joyous little treat this was.

Combining the iconic 2006 Ruthless Aggression era intro - which once exhibited the likes of The Undertaker and John Cena strutting their stuff to get us hyped for the excitement to come - with the current crop of blue branded badasses, WWE produced one of the most satisfying 45 seconds you'll see today.

On top of the glorious sound of Rise Up by Drowning Pool invading your ears, the sight of stars such as Cesaro, Big E, Bayley and more clearly having the time of their lives being cut into the well-known signature was the sort of feel-good nostalgia we were looking for last night.

Also, the fact that Rey Mysterio didn't need to film a new segment for the video was both hilarious and equally impressive. The guy has barely aged!


2. Various Walks Down Memory Lane

It wouldn't be a celebration of all things SmackDown without a few pulsating walks down memory lane.

With over twenty years of material to choose from though, it was always going to be tough to settle on just a handful of notable showdowns, segments, and special guest appearances. But for the most part, WWE got their selections spot on.

Stone Cold Steve Austin and Booker T warring around a supermarket, Brock Lesnar and Big Show pulverising a ring, John Cena's eye-catching debut, Arnold Schwarzenegger's memorable showing, and Eddie Guerrero taking Vince McMahon for a spin in his low-rider are all undoubtedly all-timer moments from the blue brand. But they also depressingly acted as a reminder of just how unmemorable the modern product has been as of late.

Also, leave it to WWE to find a way to wedge Hulk Hogan into the celebration of a show that he only dipped his toe into for ten minutes, highlighting his tag title victory alongside Edge back in 2002. Yet, all in all, it was still pretty sweet to remember the good times before arenas were filled with more LED screens than actual live audience members.


1. Teddy Long (Playa)

Teddy Long
WWE.com

There was never any doubt when it came to last night's number one, was there?

Bouncing into the ThunderDome like he hadn't missed a beat, Teddy Long seized the headlines early by interrupting a brawl between Seth Rollins and Cesaro to reveal that the latter would earn a Universal Championship shot at WrestleMania Backlash if he was victorious over the former in their match. (Soz, Seth)

The former SmackDown General Manager wasn't finished there, however. After threatening to make Sami Zayn go "one-on-one with The Undertaker", before quickly remembering that old faithful card would be difficult to play in 2021, the GM for the night reverted to his other best-known ruling; setting up a huge 10-man tag for later on in the show. And it wouldn't by Teddy Long without a few of the WWE Hall of Famer's legendary moves, something Zayn wasn't very pleased about partaking in.

This is precisely what "Throwback" SmackDown should've been all about. Sweet returns from faces intrinsically linked with the Friday night show, aesthetically pleasing nods to the past via old SmackDown logos, ring gear, and sets, and just a general tip of the cap to all things blue.

Sadly, only a handful of those things left us feeling any way satisfied, so hopefully this night can act as a vital lesson to those booking future "Throwbacks"; More holla, less holograms.


Contributor
Contributor

Gareth has 6 years experience writing and presenting articles/videos covering all things professional wrestling within the fantastic WhatCulture team. Gareth is also a life long wrestling fan, so is clearly living the dream!