Ranking The Biggest Rivalries In Wrestling Every Year 1990-2020

The Art Of War.

Shane McMahon Hangman Page Kenny Omega
WWE/AEW

It was during the infamous - and not unsuccessful - "Cure For The Common Show" state-of-the-union address by Vince McMahon where the Chairman dared to suggest that his show was no longer about "good guys" and "bad guys".

It was total b*llocks, of course.

In the months leading up to that very speech, Stone Cold Steve Austin had become the company's hottest hero since Hulk Hogan. After screwing Bret Hart a few weeks before at the Survivor Series, McMahon himself was 'The Rattlesnake's ready-made heel. You wouldn't know it, the way he spat the words out. This was about forcing through change, g*ddamn it.

Like the 1984 commencement of Hulkamania or 1994 New Generation roll-out that compared the 41-year-old 'Hulkster' to a collapsing biplane, this formal commencement of the Attitude Era was designed to signify that everything was going be different, pal. This despite the wrestling industry relying on the same familiar and financially fruitful tenets for its entire existence. Those heroes and villains he spoke so caustically about are what made him a millionaire once and what'd make him a billionaire again in the years that followed.

Wrestling's about stories, but for the ruse to work, the stories have to have conflict at their foundation. Everything from love, hate, friendship, betrayal to hat theft and shampoo commercials has to end in a fight. And these were the most epic of the lot...

31. 1990 - Hulk Hogan Vs The Ultimate Warrior

Hulk Hogan Ultimate Warrior
WWE

The bubble was about to burst for WWE, but few could have predicted just how steep the decline would be during the WrestleMania VI's main event.

An epic with all the bombast and pomp of the company's greatest moments of the 1980s, Hulk Hogan Vs The Ultimate Warrior felt like the biggest match in this and every other world. Bigger than that, in fact. This went beyond pro wrestling and Sports Entertainment and into psychotic theatre between two neon warlords.

A Vince McMahon voiceover kicks off the 'Show Of Shows' by presenting both men as individual constellations that dominate all of space and time. It was only just barely hyperbolic.


30. 1991 - Hulk Hogan Vs Ric Flair

Hulk Hogan Ric Flair 1992
WWE.com

...sort of.

Ric Flair's WCW exit (and subsequent WWE arrival) was by far wrestling's biggest story of the year. When Ted Turner's JCP purchase neatened the war narrative between two leading organisations, a long-established dream match reached mythical proportions. Proportions begat expectations, but those were more than met when Bobby Heenan left Gorilla Monsoon and millions of television viewers flabbergasted at the sight of the iconic 'Big Gold' belt during a 1991 edition of Wrestling Challenge.

The title defined Flair's dominance and foreshadowed his arrival, and an attempted SummerSlam confrontation by 'The Brain' made it clear that he was coming directly for this organisation's Champion.

The dream was becoming a reality! Until it didn't. McMahon programmed the two to be at odds with one another on television (and in action on house shows and at the end of television tapings), but couldn't and wouldn't wholeheartedly commit to it completely before effectively distracting Flair with Roddy Piper and Hogan with The Undertaker. And then again with Randy Savage and Sid Justice respectively.

Their time would come, but not on McMahon's watch.


29. 1992 - Mitsuharu Misawa & Partners Vs. Jumbo Tsuruta & Partners

It's a slight disservice to only include this in 1992, in truth. The All Japan war between Mitsuharu Misawa and Jumbo Tsuruta had been waged for several epic and transcendent years after one earth-shattering loss by the legend Tsuruta to thrilling upstart Misawa in 1990.

The defeat marked a shocking change in plans behind the scenes for the company as well as gradual changing of the guard on screen. Enraged by the loss, Tsuruta swore revenge on the Misawa, but getting one singles win back wasn't enough to arrest the changes occurring underneath him.

1992 saw the legendary heel continue to utilise the help of Akira Taue, Masanobu Fuchi and Yoshinari Ogawa against the Super Generation Army unit of Misawa, Kenta Kobashi, Toshiaki Kawada and Tsyoshi Kikuchi, each a celebration era-defining change and unparalleled commercial and critical acclaim.


28. 1993 - Bret Hart Vs Jerry Lawler

Jerry Lawler Bret Hart
WWE.com

The lean North American scene was lacking anything that brought the good times back despite Vince McMahon having one more go with Hulk Hogan and another with Lex Luger playing Hulk Hogan. As was always the case, Bret Hart could be relied on in times of strife.

'The Hitman's King Of The Ring victory in June kicked off a blood feud with Jerry Lawler that kept houses from collapsing for the bulk of the year, crossed over to Memphis' USWA for some amazing mirror universe alignment switching and delivered a total pay-per-view banger at SummerSlam that also featured an underrated gem between Hart and the original incarnation of Doink.

Without a payoff due to Lawler's legal troubles at the end of the year, the company returned to it nearly two years later to squeeze some remaining juice from the fruit.


27. 1994 - Hulk Hogan Vs Ric Flair

hulk hogan ric flair bash at the beach
WWE.com

Presenting what Vince McMahon simply hadn't deemed worthy of main eventing WrestleMania with two years earlier, WCW started hot with Hulk Hogan by giving him a WCW Heavyweight Title clash with Ric Flair for his in-ring debut.

'The Hulkster' won, but so too did Eric Bischoff for taking the substantial financial gamble. Their Bash At The Beach headliner drew the highest buyrate in the history of WCW and almost instantly reinvented the company as effective North American opposition to WWE.

The pair ran back the blockbuster to diminished returns throughout the rest of the year, but dragged another monster number from their Halloween Havoc steel cage match.It'd take nearly two years before WCW had anything that approached the box office success of this legitimate dream match.


26. 1995 - Tommy Dreamer Vs Raven

Raven, Tommy Dreamer
WWE.com

Born out of an industry in commercial and creative decline, ECW's true influence on the mainstream would be felt in the years that followed thanks to purchasing of talent and theft of concept by WCW and WWE respectively. But as the big companies played catch-up, Paul Heyman's baseball cap may as well have been a crown.

In Tommy Dreamer Vs Raven, he established a feud that came with an elaborate backstory dating back to their shared youth as well as a unique twist that justified hundreds of singles and tag matches between the two - Dreamer could never beat him.

Making for captivating television and healthy gate receipts, the programme sucked in Cactus Jack, The Sandman, Shane Douglas and countless others into its orbit thanks to the ingenious and idiosyncratic hero's journey.


25. 1996 - World Championship Wrestling Vs The New World Order

Eric Bischoff Scott Hall
WWE.com

Eric Bischoff always had the idea that he could eventually create two entirely separate organisations in WCW and the nWo under the Turner umbrella, and it was this ethos from the very beginning that powered the amazing and transformational group.

Combining the shock of ship-jumping by Scott Hall and Kevin Nash with Hulk Hogan's unthinkable heel turn, the story was perfectly balanced with the tone and register of war that had raged in wrestling since the debut of Nitro the prior year - but the angle ensured only WCW would profit from it.

An insanely prosperous period followed, but never were the twists and turns as potent as in those early few months. Sting was chased into the shadows by the mistrust of his colleagues, The Four Horseman aged a thousand years, and the return of Roddy Piper highlighted the drawing potential of flipping Hogan's old feuds as he donned this shocking new guise.


24. 1997 - Bret Hart Vs Stone Cold Steve Austin

Bret Hart Stone Cold Steve Austin
WWE

WCW dominated the commercial landscape in 1997, but their patient build to Hulk Hogan Vs Sting was slaughtered by the rotten conclusion of their record-smashing Starrcade at the end of that year.

In contrast, WWE presented Stone Cold Steve Austin Vs Bret Hart to their smallest ever WrestleMania audience and Raw ratings that couldn't touch those on the other side. But the end result catapulted the entire company into enough dominance that they'd have a North American monopoly four years later.

The WrestleMania 13 submission match was the most transcendent in company history. Masterfully mixing believable violence with cathartic pro wrestling theatre, the intricately crafted double turn set both off on the new courses the company needed, while the style foreshadowed the controlled and consumer-friendly chaos of the Attitude Era.


23. 1998 - Stone Cold Steve Austin Vs Mr McMahon

Stone Cold Steve Austin Vince McMahon
WWE

Moving from feuding with wrestlers to authority figures was a necessary evil of Stone Cold Steve Austin's 1997 thanks to the devastating neck injury suffered against Owen Hart that summer, but it proved to be the last step on the 'Rattlesnake's journey to megastardom.

By April 1998, Shawn Michaels and the entire Hart Foundation apart from Owen were all out of the picture, but new Champion Austin didn't need a production line of heels - he had Vince McMahon's queue of waiting allies.

Mick Foley, The Undertaker, Kane, The Rock and others all took on Austin with the shadow of McMahon's loathing of his new top star looming large. WWE won their first ratings war in 83 weeks by giving viewers a small sliver of an eventual Austin/McMahon match, but spent the bulk of the year teasing out the payoff all over again...


22. 1999 - Stone Cold Steve Austin Vs Mr McMahon

stone cold steve austin vince mcmahon
WWE.com

...and delivered it in 1999, when the angle was still white hot.

Everything clicked for the company by this point, but the rejuvenated body was still powered by the blood McMahon and Austin's rivalry had pumped through it.

'The Rattlesnake' finally got some physical comeuppance at the Royal Rumble and February's St Valentine's Day Massacre, and stood with one foot on the Chairman's chest as he became Champion again at WrestleMania XV. An uneasy bond that formed in the weeks that followed was undone by Vince's cartoonish reveal as the Greater Power, but that still furnished yet more pay-per-view main events at King Of The Ring and Fully Loaded.

They were numbers - ratings and buyrates - and magic right up until Austin's November injury exit.


 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.