Ranking Tommaso Ciampa's 10 Greatest NXT Matches

Bidding adieu to the Blackheart of the Black and Gold.

Tommaso Ciampa NXT Champion
WWE.com

In one of the most poignant moments of NXT’s recent Stand & Deliver show, it was all but confirmed that Tommaso Ciampa is done in WWE developmental. He preceded the match by showing off a chair inscribed with the dates of his NXT debut and (presumed) goodbye. He then followed his loss to Tony D’Angelo with a surprising, and genuinely moving, embrace from his erstwhile boss Triple H.

Most reports suggest Ciampa is headed to the main roster, something he said he’d never do (but absolutely should), so WWE fans won’t need to wait too long to see him again. For NXT fans, though, particularly those who lived and breathed the black and gold, now’s the time to take stock of everything he gave to the brand.

It’s fair to say that, probably even more so than frenemy Johnny Gargano, Ciampa was Mr NXT. Not just for the time he put in and the matches he put on, but the variety of his work, from monstrous heel to beloved hero, and the effort he made to stick around as WWE transitioned in the next generation. Whatever the Psycho Killer does next, he leaves with an amazing NXT resume.

10. Vs. Moustache Mountain - Worlds Collide 2020

DIY Moustache Mountain
WWE.com

The saga of Ciampa and Johnny Gargano in NXT took so many twists and turns that it can be easy to forget it only lasted around six years. We’ll cover some more matches alongside and against Gargano later, but early 2020 found the pair in an interesting place, a long feud behind them and ready to try teaming once again.

Their match against Trent Seven and Tyler Bate was the highlight of a stacked NXT vs. NXT UK card, with four incredible pro wrestlers unsurprisingly tearing it up. Using an always enjoyable format, the bout starts off respectfully competitive before ultimately becoming a stiff battle for supremacy.

It’s Ciampa who takes things up a notch. Bate and Gargano do their technical thing, shake hands, tag out. Ciampa and Seven start to do the same before Tommaso loses patience, decks both Englishmen, and it’s on.

This is 20 minutes of fast paced fun, subverting spots like the dual submission holds and exhibiting the fantastic chemistry of each team before finally seeing DIY take it with the knee/kick combo - and to top it off, a sign of mutual respect at the finish.


9. Vs. Aleister Black - NXT 25.07.2018

Tommaso Ciampa Aleister Black
WWE.com

In the middle of Ciampa and Gargano’s feud, the addition of a certain Goldie took things up a notch. The Blackheart’s capturing of Aleister Black’s NXT Title is very sports entertainment, but booked far more intelligently than most shenanigans-heavy encounters you’re likely to see.

Ciampa’s heel persona is sneaky and shrewd but not cowardly; he tackles the hard hitting Black head on, but has no intention of getting into a striking contest with the kickboxer. The first stage of the match sees the two trading holds and moves, but Ciampa backing off before the Dutchman has any opportunity to deliver the Black Mass.

It comes down to a distraction and a ref bump, but an unusually logical one; Ciampa ploughs into a cameraman, whose health referee Drake Wuertz is obliged to check on. Wuertz then spills onto the exposed concrete, giving Johnny Gargano the opportunity to make the interference - only he accidentally tags Black with the belt, leading to the three count.

Ciampa consistently tells the crowd that he only needs one opportunity to snatch the belt - and when the opportunity comes, he takes it. A fantastic TV match, leading to an all-time great title run.


8. Vs. WALTER - Stand & Deliver 2021

Tommaso Ciampa WALTER
WWE.com

Showcasing the true versatility of the man, here we have the jacked and savage Ciampa play an incredibly convincing and relatable underdog. That’s a little easier to do when your opponent is WALTER, of course, but it’s impressive for a man as frightening as Tommaso to be this sympathetic.

One of the best matches of 2021’s WrestleMania weekend, Ciampa threw absolutely everything he had at WALTER, laying in his best offence and even coming close to the win, especially after a second rope Air Raid Crash. WALTER’s hand was damaged early on, neutralising his greatest weapon, that monstrous chop.

The Austrian absorbed all of Ciampa’s arsenal, though, and retaliated with plenty of his own. Ciampa was suplexed, powerbombed, and slapped around the ring, though he kept coming back. One great sequence saw Ciampa repeatedly clothesline WALTER to no avail, then get knocked to the floor by one lariat, only to fly back to his feet and send the big man sprawling with one more attempt.

The match builds to a terrific, Chekovian crescendo, with WALTER finally throwing caution to the wind and busting out a terrifying chop to fell Ciampa for good. These are two men who seldom disappoint, and they met every expectation here.


7. Vs. Adam Cole - TakeOver: Portland 2020

NXT Takeover Portland
WWE.com

One great thing about Ciampa is that he doesn’t really need to change that much up to play either babyface or heel. Either which way he’s still a grizzled, ferocious fighter willing to do anything for the win; he’ll just fit into the storyline accordingly.

Here, taking on long time NXT champion Adam Cole, he’s about as purely babyface as we’ve seen him. Cole and his Undisputed Era stable had rocked up to NXT and turned it on its head, and perhaps Ciampa was the guy who could end his reign.

Spoiler: he couldn’t, but he puts on an amazing fight to close this final TakeOver prior to the pandemic. It’s a sprawling epic with no dud spots that mostly steers clear of the latter day Black and Gold propensity for too many improbable kick outs (though there’s some of that).

To say Ciampa fights the odds is an understatement. Aside from withstanding a reverse slam onto the announce table (terrifyingly stiff even without his history of neck issues), he has to fight off the rest of Cole’s faction, and even scores a visual pinfall towards the end of the match. He’d have reunited with Goldie were it not for the poetic but sickening intervention of Johnny Gargano, who clocks Ciampa for the Cole win.


6. Vs. Authors Of Pain - TakeOver: Chicago 2017

DIY vs AOP
WWE.com

Sometimes wrestling booking can be ever so simple. In DIY, you had two indie globetrotters who’d come to NXT to take another step in their career, two smaller guys with immense talent honed in companies the world over. Authors Of Pain, meanwhile, were two WWE-developed products, big bruisers with gimmicks who dished out beatings at the behest of former LOD manager Paul Ellering.

Put them in NXT’s first ladder match with the tag titles suspended above the ring and you’ve got yourself a good time. This one writes itself - Gargano and Ciampa use their quickness and guile, Akam and Rezar bring the pain.

That’s not to say it isn’t memorable, though, because it very much is. DIY hit twin splashes on bridged ladders; Ciampa hurls Rezar off a ladder and through another one propped up against the turnbuckle (which splinters in a most satisfying manner). In a great piece of drama, Gargano saves his friend from a ladder to the face (taking the bullet in the process) before AOP retain the titles.

It’s that final sequence that stings the most when Ciampa, after the match, turns on Gargano, battering him before an absolutely devastated crowd. It was a shame to lost DIY - but the best was yet to come.


5. Vs. Johnny Gargano - TakeOver: New Orleans 2018

ciampa gargano
WWE.com

The first match in the former DIY boys’ epic feud is one of the most emotional matches you can ever hope to see, and thanks to the long term storytelling, quality workmanship and match structure, and (most importantly) incredible investment on the part of the crowd, it completely works as a piece of drama.

After Ciampa turned on Gargano, he was quickly sidelined by injury, forcing their antipathy to percolate for many months. By the time the pair were actually able to lay hands on one another, the stakes had been raised yet further, with Gargano’s NXT career on the line should he fail to win.

That makes the result a little predictable, but no matter - the babyface/heel dynamic is so perfectly established here that a Gargano win is the only option. In the 30 plus minutes of action the two men give each other everything, taking hard back bumps on the exposed concrete, exchanging thrashings with crutches, and laying in flurries of punches.

The ending is just perfect - Ciampa teases a truce, but Johnny Wrestling isn’t your typical dumb babyface - he locks in the Garga-No-Escape, stretching Ciampa’s knee brace across his face in a painful looking spot, and Tommaso quickly submits.


4. Vs. Undisputed Era - TakeOver: WarGames 2019

WarGames 2019
WWE.com

One of the best WarGames matches in its rebooted format saw Ciampa assemble a superteam of Keith Lee, Dominik Dijakovic, and the returning Kevin Owens to take on the rampant Undisputed Era.

As you’d imagine, this one is just bell to bell nonsense, with abundant up spots, physics-defying agility from big boys Lee and Dija, a hero’s welcome for the energised Owens, and the usual sneaky heel work and wild bump taking from Undisputed Era (each of whom wind up getting pasted through tables by one of the good guys).

Pulling it all together, though, is team captain Tommaso Ciampa. Not long back from surgery, he nonetheless puts in a hell of a shift, wrestling every moment of the match’s 38 minutes and change. He’s built for the gruelling stipulations of the cage, showing up in war paint and carrying artillery.

He’s saved the biggest spot of the night, capturing the scampering Adam Cole at the top of the metal structure and dealing an Air Raid Crash through yet more wood for the win.


3. Vs. Velveteen Dream - TakeOver: WarGames 2018

NXT TakeOver WarGames Ciampa Velveteen Dream 2018
WWE

Perhaps not since Austin in 2001 has one WWE performer had such a connection to a title. When Ciampa got his hands on the NXT belt, he wasn’t just a proud champion, he was an obsessive. Nicknaming the strap “Goldie”, he puts across its importance beautifully en route to the ring, clutching it tight to his body, paranoid eyes detecting threats everywhere.

The young, brash Velveteen Dream was the perfect foil in every way for Ciampa. For Dream, wrestling was a hoot, a chance to show off and be flamboyant. For Ciampa, it was something he needed to do in order to retain his treasured prize.

In the ring, the two mesh brilliantly. Both have a fairly old school bent, but Dream attacks with speed and flair, Ciampa with pure brutality. It’s a relentless affair, with plenty of spills to the outside, Hogan-aping offence from Dream, and increasing desperation from the champ.

It helps that the crowd digs Dream in a big way, completely sucked in by an incredible near fall after his Purple Rainmaker elbow. But the veteran Ciampa has other ideas, catching Dream with a DDT on the metal between the two WarGames-ready rings and keeping Goldie in his grip for another day.


2. Vs. Johnny Gargano - TakeOver: Brooklyn 4

gargano ciampa match
WWE.com

The final match (for a bit) in Gargano and Ciampa’s all- consuming feud was already personal enough without gold on the line, but surprisingly the addition of Ciampa’s coveted NXT title added yet more drama to the rubber match rather than muddying the waters. Many will plump for the unsanctioned match as the programme’s finest, but the inventiveness and devilish ending of the Brooklyn IV showpiece tips it over the edge.

Here it’s a last man standing match, and it’s up there with the finest the stipulation has ever produced. It’s all out carnage from the off. The announce tables fall victim to an Air Raid Crash early doors. Not satisfied with the exposed concrete spot, this time the ring mat is ripped up for some killer DDTs on the wooden boards.

Poetically, the match’s conclusion takes place up on the stage, the location for Ciampa’s great betrayal. The champ is handcuffed to a rail and begs mercy from Gargano. Johnny considers it, then drops the knee pad and hits one last thunderous strike. But his descent into wrath is his undoing. The attack sends him flying off the stage; both men are down, but before the 10 count, Ciampa rolls from the platform, to his feet, and escapes once more.


1. Vs. The Revival - TakeOver: Toronto 2016

9 The Revival DIY Tommaso Ciampa Johnny Gargano
WWE.com

NXT put on some incredible tag team matches in its time, but few come so close to perfection as this one. It’s not too surprising given the personnel involved, but what these two teams achieve in about 22 minutes is quite incredible. It’s a two out of three falls match that never feels rushed, tells such a cohesive story, delivers catharsis at the end, and is wrestled perfectly at every moment.

The Revival are the ostensible heels, but the tricks they turn to are those of a pairing who understand what tag wrestling is all about. They lay in a few extra shots when the ref’s not looking, they break up any attempt for DIY to gain momentum. They grab the first fall with the Shatter Machine.

The second fall is mostly one big heat spot on Gargano, whose hot tag to Ciampa is missed by the ref. Finally after a gutsy performance he brings Tommaso in, and the faces hit their tag finisher to even things up.

The final fall is just sublime. Each team attempts the other’s finisher, The Revival to no avail, DIY successfully. The room is electric and the pace relentless. Finally, Ciampa and Gargano catch Dash and Dawson in twin submissions. The Revival urge, beseech each other not to tap, the tension builds - and both submit at once. It’s a joyous moment, even with the knowledge that the group isn’t long for the world.


Contributor
Contributor

Yorkshire-based writer of screenplays, essays, and fiction. Big fan of having a laugh. Read more of my stuff @ www.twotownsover.com (if you want!)