Ranking WWE's First Ever NXT Class - From Worst To Best

34. Oliver Grey

Oliver Grey
WWE.com

Oliver Grey made some minor history in NXT after becoming the brand's first Tag Team Champion alongside partner Adrian Neville.

As "British Ambition", the pair defeated 3MB members Drew McIntyre and Heath Slater and the pairing of Kassius Ohno and Leo Kruger en route to a victory in the final over The Wyatt Family to become inaugural Champions. 

Winning the straps was the WWE developmental highlight for Grey, not least because he never got to be there to lose them. Bo Dallas stepped in as a substitute when he was shelved with a torn ACL, and the makeshift team were dethroned by the same Erick Rowan and Luke Harper unit that lost in the tournament. 

After missing over a year of time to an injury, he was released in 2014 but has since worked consistently as Joel Redman for multiple UK independent promotions and All Japan Pro Wrestling.


33. Brad Maddox

Brad Maddox
WWE.com

By the time Brad Maddox broke through to the main roster, it was as a discredited referee and even-more-discredited authority figure. 

Maddox was the man behind the fast-count that cost Ryback the WWE Championship at Hell In A Cell 2012 - a night where the former Skip Sheffield had never been so hot nor ready to be the person the company could take a chance on.

In kayfabe and reality, WWE was a wholly inept organisation inside and out by this point, so naturally the way to punish the useless tosser was to make him an appalling Raw General Manager. The main roster was the place undercard wrestlers went to die for so long that people lost their energy to push back, and Maddox was caught amongst the very worst of it.

Standing virtually no chance of getting over as a credible wrestler, he was eventually let go from the company in 2015.


32. Leo Kruger

Adam Rose Nxt
WWE.com

A total gimmick reinvention in 2014 transformed a struggling Leo Kruger into the temporarily-white hot Adam Rose on NXT, but the gimmick devastatingly died on the main roster before it had the chance to reach its potential. 

An out-of-nowhere success story after the one-note Kruger had ran its course, Rose was suddenly the life of his own party and parlayed that into matches by simply being too zoned out of reality to get bothered by whatever his opponent was trying to do. His "rosebuds" accompanying him to the ring for grandiose entrances and exits added magnificently to the aesthetic, and he was wanted for Raw and SmackDown long before the ceiling was reached in NXT.

This was the beginning of the end. Following a rushed re-introduction of the character that was lightweight 

He was gone from WWE by 2016.


31. Bo Dallas

Bo Dallas
WWE

Released in April 2021 after 13 years in the WWE system, Bo Dallas rarely felt like the right man in the right place at the time on the main roster.

More's the pity, because the total opposite came to define his time in NXT. An unlikely babyface choice to end Big E's NXT Championship reign (and with it, undefeated streak), Dallas struggled to gain the adoration of the Full Sail University faithful but that represented a significant turning point for his time on the show. The booking pivoted, resulting in him earning the loathing of the locals to such an extent that it became an earnestly great bit. By the time he lost his title and NXT career, he seemed perfectly primed for Raw and SmackDown. 

Alas, nothing he did on either show was ever as fun as his time on the black-and-gold brand, even if a run alongside Curtis Axel in The Miztourage brought him close.


30. Conor O'Brian

Konnor WWE
WWE.com

It'd be fair to say that The Ascension were done fairly dirty by the main roster after NXT made it abundantly clear exactly how to use them. 

A glorious run as NXT Tag Team Champions extenuated the positives while hiding the negatives as Triple H booked a Road Warriors-adjacent act in an era full of fans predisposed to find the reduced violence just as appealing. Longer matches never really pulled up trees but it wasn't like the squashes flattered to deceive either - the act were over and as the bigger of the two, Konnor was one of NXT's more effective monsters of the week. 

It all appeared so promising, but WWE's main roster and some of the dinosaurs inhabiting it had other plans. The only squashes that came their way were at their expense, particularly as wider audiences were given no reason to take them seriously before the humiliations began. 

Konnor was released in late-2019, along with...


29. Rick Victor

Viktor The Ascension WWE
WWE.com

Viktor, who was perhaps the more charismatic of the two despite a size disparity. 

Ultimately, The Ascension have been immortalised by the WWE Network's NXT archives even if their Raw and SmackDown runs left very little to get enthused about. Pointedly, the low ebb for the duo came at the hands (more specifically the arms and fists) at some of the teams that should have been there to put them over. Viktor was almost credible talking down to the New World Order on the January 19th, 2015, until the APA and New Age Outlaws arrived on the scene to easily decimate the pair of them. 

It was the typical reductive trapped-in-the-past nonsense from a creative team obsessed with it, and The Ascension were just the latest losers caught in the crossfire. 

But believe the hype if there's still any kicking around - those black-and-gold tag squashes were a blast. 


28. Briley Pierce

Briley Pierce
FCW.com

As Ryan Nemeth, TAFKA Dolph Ziggler's brother eventually broke through, though it never really happened via the market leader. 

His run in WWE's system was long but wholly uneventful, and he took three years away before returning in 2016 to kickstart the career he now finds himself managing to carve.

Billed "Briley Pierce" for the duration of his two years in FCW and NXT, his penultimate match for the market leader was effectively his peak. Entering a battle royal on a May edition of NXT to become Number One Contender to the brand's top title, Pierce was eliminated in short order. Winner Bo Dallas went on to end Big E's winning streak and take his belt in the same outing. 

A semi-regular on AEW television since 2021, Nemeth's always been kept in relatively low stakes situations, but even within the confines of Dark rather than Dynamite, it's clear that he shares plenty of attributes with his sibling. 


27. Mojo Rawley

Mojo Rawley
WWE

Former Andre The Giant Battle Royal winner and current friend of Rob Gronkowski Mojo Rawley was cut in 2021 having spent the better part of a decade doing everything asked of him. Such is life for a WWE midcarder then, now, forever.

A frequent bench-warmer on the main roster, Rawley wasn't that big a hit during his original black-and-gold brand run but seemed perfect for a decent babyface run on the main roster. Particularly as a member of Hype Bros with Zack Ryder. One guy trying to make it paired with another trying to make it back was a strange brew, but one that had real charm until a badly-timed injury to Ryder following a main roster call-up hobbled their trajectory. 

The eventual split resulted in a Rawley heel turn had multiple false starts, and he never recovered the scant momentum he'd managed to build up. It seems as if he might never do so again - as of this writing, his last match in WWE was his last match full-stop. 


26. Jason Jordan

Jason Jordan
WWE.com

It took a while to get going, but when Jason Jordan's NXT career finally came to life, it burst forth beyond almost everybody else on the roster.

Alongside Chad Gable, American Alpha helped reinvent and redefine tag team wrestling within the WWE system, contributing some of the best doubles matches in company history in the process. Their series with The Revival was the pre-cursor to Scott Dawson and Dash Wilder's follow-up run against #DIY and #DIY's with The Undisputed Era and so on and on. Architects in that respect, it wasn't something they were able to take advantage of - a main roster run fizzled and the reveal of Jordan as Kurt Angle's son split the team up for good.  

With a career cut devastatingly short due to injury in early 2018, Jordan has since taken up a role as producer within WWE. It might not be the route he imagined taking as a prodigious Performance Center standout in the mid-2010s, but it's kept him as close to the action as he could realistically be. 


25. Sofia Cortez

Sofia Cortez
WWE

Sofia Cortez may not be a name that rings too many bells at this point, but a year-long run during the FCW-to-NXT transition in 2012 is a footnote in a career with a lot more landmarks. 

A 20-year pro with less than a year spent in FCW/NXT, the artist better known as Ivelisse has been a headline-grabber for Lucha Underground and - for a period - AEW. She left that company under a cloud of controversy, and though that wasn't for the first time, her record is better than to just saddle her with a tag of being too difficult to work with. 

She didn't leave WWE quietly either. She has since noted that she had reported Bill DeMott for alleged misconduct, and was the first to do so, indirectly or otherwise resulting in his eventual exit from the company. When he resigned, he did so amidst a slew of multiple misconduct allegations, which only bolstered her brave initial claim.

Outside of an stint in the industry that's had its fair share of controversy, this is a legacy worth celebrating.


 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.