Ranking WWE's First Ever NXT Class - From Worst To Best
How many managed to make it beyond the Performance Center? And just how far did they go?
Full disclosure before we get started - this class doesn't include a great deal of women from the 2012 FCW/NXT changeover.
That's not to say there weren't some megastars-in-waiting in the system by then, but you weren't encouraged to care about them and quality had to rise up from the smallest of quantities.
John Laurinaitis' Florida Championship Wrestling didn't put a lot of stock in the future of women's wrestling. Some would argue it didn't put that much in the future of the men either, but at least some of the performers below weren't reduced to bikini contests and dance-offs on the barely-attended house shows. They got their own roster page as "Superstars", in contrast to the marginalised "Divas" that just happened to include the likes of Paige, Bayley, Sasha Banks and other future Hall-Of-Famers.
It was a disaster of a time. Enough so that Triple H's overhaul was desperately needed when it finally took place. The period between the two systems was a sticky one though, with many of the talents not making out of the Orlando gym before getting out of wrestling altogether. The same applies with every new class, so consider this list not so much a retrospective, but a realisation of what to expect in the near future...
Article originally published March 2021. Revised and republished March 2024.
54. Anya
Boasting one of the smallest Cagematch records on this list (and indeed all of Cagematch) Anya never made it to screen following just five matches under the NXT umbrella on the fabled Largo Loop Floridian house show circuit.
Like several on this list, she bizarrely even didn't have to do business on the way out. In a collector's item for the ages for those that are fans of any of the four, she teamed with Yoshi Tatsu (!) to defeat Angelo Dawkins (!!) and Charlotte Flair (!!!) in her farewell bout. As evidence of the moving parts still occurring during the transition between Florida Championship Wrestling and NXT, this even took place in the "FCW Arena" facility.
Outside of that oddity, she worked with several wrestlers that either went on to much bigger things. And some that...didn't. Including...
53. Dani
Dani was another blink-and-you'll-miss-her wrestler who happened to be part of the WWE system during the transition between Florida Championship Wrestling and Triple H's reimagined NXT.
Working a similarly small number of matches as Anya, she entered (and won!) the odd battle royal here and there and was also successful in her final bout for the organisation. Alongside Sasha Banks, she defeated Charlotte Flair and Audrey Marie, but the win was her last.
She left wrestling behind in early 2013 for a WWE corporate job, but briefly resurfaced for two more dates for Ohio Valley Wrestling and Queens Of Combat before calling it a day at the end of 2014.
52. Chad Baxter
Chad Baxter's great body didn't equate to a great body of work. The developmental talent worked twice for FCW before amassing a handful of mostly non-televised NXT matches before eating a release at the end of 2012.
Reduced to squash fodder even when the cameras weren't switched on, he was one of many that lost to an unstoppable Big E Langston on NXT, and even fell short in a handicap match against Trent Barreta even though the future best friend was the one flying solo.
A collectors item match - should you wish to track it down - would probably be the second of his entire career. In a fatal four way elimination match at an FCW event in 2012, he worked against the original version of The Ascension (Connor O'Brian and Kenneth Cameron), Jason Jordan & Mike Dalton (Tyler Breeze) and Brad Maddox & Rick Victor.
His partner for that was...
51. Adam Mercer
Despite a great look, Adam Mercer wasn't long for NXT or, as it turned our, wrestling in general.
He ended up working a handful more times than the aforementioned Chad Baxter, but didn't even make it to the Largo Loop even when the NXT branding started going.
A Cagematch listing finds him with just 15 matches to his name total, suggesting that the industry wasn't for him, vice versa, or both. Of those, just four were for the rebadged developmental in 2012, and he was mostly used as fodder for future NXT Champion Big E Langston during his unstoppable run as the brand's biggest star.
Never cracking more than two minutes before falling to the count of five against Langston, Mercer suffered what he described as a "serious head injury" against Erick Rowan in what proved to be his final bout. His last interaction with WWE was a legal one - he was part of a group of wrestlers that lost an injury lawsuit to the company in 2018.
50. Tac
Brandon "Tac" Carter has the look, name and sporting pedigree of a guy that would have probably gone a little further had Vince McMahon or at least one of the snivelling yes-men he surrounded himself with caught sight of him in the Gorilla position. Unfortunately for the rookie, he never made it that far.
With an NFL career that included stints with the New Orleans Saints, Tampa Bay Buccaneers and Dallas Cowboys, Carter is somebody that would probably stand a better chance getting in through the Next In Line pathway rather than FCW's jagged and crooked method.
Instead, he was an early-2013 release story, having tweeted-and-deleted various notes about the "TAC Revolution" WWE "deserved", referring to some of his (now substantially more famous and successful) colleagues as "generic cookie cutter wrestlers". He was half right of course, partocularly during the era he was referring to, but the 50% that got it wrong saw the door.
49. Chase Donovan
Of the 100+ matches Chase Donovan has worked per his Cagematch record, only eight of them were under the WWE umbrella.
With a fantastic look and a healthy resumé, what might have worked against Donovan - also known as Bryce Andrews, Drew Donovan and other monikers - was his experience. WWE, particularly during this era, were keen on performers that could be melded into exactly what they wanted, which amounted to what Vince McMahon woke up that day thinking a wrestler was. The parameters were hard enough without having to unlearn everything that got you noticed by the market leader in the first place.
Donovan found that out the hard way when he entered the system for real. An NXT jobber to the stars (literally so; he fell to Roman Reigns and Big E on his two television appearances), he was there and gone over the course of just eight months of a 12 year career in 2012.
48. Dante Dash
Dante Dash left wrestling behind when he walked away from NXT for the final time in 2013, having worked for the black and gold brand and forerunner FCW since January 2012.
A run in New Jersey's IWF got him noticed and signed, but the WWE developmental system was as far as he went.
Like many that unfortunately never experienced the brightest spotlight, he shared the ring with plenty that did. Dash investigated the lights for future WWE Champions Big E, Dean Ambrose and Bray Wyatt alongside a host of familiar names that went on to tremendous success in WWE, AEW and NJPW.
His proper farewell came on a house show with a loss to Erick Rowan, but his penultimate makes for surprising reading. Again with the cameras off, he partnered the 'Lone Wolf' Baron Corbin for a win over Colin Cassady and Enzo Amore. He might have been at the end of his run, but the opposition were evidently just getting started.
47. Garrett Dylan
A familiar story for many at the wrong end of a list like this, Garrett Dylan's wrestling career has more meat on the bone outside of WWE's walls than within them.
He found a serviceable run across the North American independent scene between 2008 and 2019 as Jody Kristofferson, but his 2012-2013 FCW/NXT run was made up of tag teams win that got him nowhere and 50/50 singles booking that held him back further than that.
Of note, he traded wins with future Revival/FTR man Scott Dawson/Dax Harwood, though their growth as a team was stunted when they lost a Tag Team Title #1 Contendership match to Corey Graves and Kassius Ohno on a May edition of the NXT telecast.
He was released just weeks later, and outside of a handful of 2014 enhancement duties right as the black-and-gold brand was becoming the most celebrated show in wrestling, he didn't trouble the market leader again.
46. Caylee Turner
Despite being the sister of company mainstay Alisha Fox, Christina "Caylee Turner" Crawford's two years in the WWE system were her only years in wrestling, outside of one TNA dark match defeat very shortly after her 2012 exit.
In that time, she was briefly the Florida Championship Wrestling Women's Champion, serving as a transitional champion between fellow FCW regulars Sofia Cortez and Raquel Diaz, but much like both of those, she didn't stick around long into the NXT run either.
Right as Triple H took full control of the system, Turner took her leave. Save for one appearance on a July 2012 edition of the show (a tag team loss alongside Kaitlyn against Paige and Tamina Snuka), she was neither seen nor heard from on WWE television again.
45. Kenneth Cameron
An original member of The Ascension in NXT, Kenneth Cameron became better known as Bram in Impact Wrestling following his release from the company in 2012, amidst various charges including battery of a law enforcement officer, driving under the influence and disorderly intoxication.
Though he continued to get work following his NXT departure, he continued racking up a run-sheet, including charges of domestic battery by strangulation and false imprisonment of his then-girlfriend in 2015.
He happened to be in the process of going through a divorce with future WWE Champion Charlotte Flair at the time, though it should be noted that she was not the party involved in these charges.
Many assumed this might be it for Cameron (real name Thom Latimer), but he's continued to perform under various guises for NWA Powerrr, Triple-A, a rebooted XPW and various independent companies on either side of the Atlantic.