Shawn Michaels' 10 Best Matches Ever

"Mr. WrestleMania" could steal any show he so desired.

Shawn Michaels WWE
WWE.com

Just as long as the list of acclaimed performances from "The Heartbreak Kid" is the number of individuals who have been irked or annoyed by Michaels' behavior in the icon's younger days. A lesser-gifted man might've been thrown out to the curb for being such a perpetual headache. Fortunately, Michaels was able to turn his life around, becoming a model citizen in his second go-around as an active wrestler. And to the delight of fans, the quality of his performances had not diminished over the passage of time.

In the eight years since Michaels' final match, there have been wrestlers that have reminded us of HBK, whether it's Seth Rollins' or AJ Styles' show-stealing athleticism, or Dolph Ziggler's propensity for exaggerated bumps. Time has shown, however, that Michaels was in a league all his own, cultivating the perfect blend of athletics, salesmanship, presence, and timing, boiling those elements in such a way that its consistency could not be duplicated by others.

The following list consists of matches that one would say are Michaels' ten greatest ever. It's entirely possible to come up with a similar list with eight of these matches swapped out for others. Shawn Michaels has had plenty of show-stealing matches, which is what makes these lists difficult - he was on a lot of shows.

Here are, in one man's opinion, the ten greatest matches featuring Shawn Michaels.

10. Vs. John Cena (Monday Night Raw, 4/23/07)

Shawn Michaels John Cena
WWE.com

In an interview years later, Michaels made the match sound really simple: he and Cena had worked with each other enough by this point to where everything they did came together easily enough. The fact that he and Cena enthralled the fans in London for close to one hour makes his modest assertion all the more perplexing.

Cena celebrated his thirtieth birthday by working with Michaels in what is arguably the greatest match of his own career, perhaps the modern equivalent of Ric Flair and Sting at the inaugural Clash of the Champions in 1988. The difference is this one ended with a clear-cut victor, as Michaels took Cena down with Sweet Chin Music close to the 56 minute mark.

Michaels also credited the London crowd for instilling their boundless enthusiasm into the match, which only energizes the wrestlers therein. Had the match taken place in any US city outside of Chicago or New York, maybe it's not quite the same. So on behalf of everyone who loved the match, thank you chaps.


9. Vs. Mankind (In Your House: Mind Games)

shawn michaels mankind
WWE.com

At least in one point in his life, the match was Mick Foley's personal favorite from his own portfolio, calling it, "the finest match of my career." He would add, "...try as I might, I don't think I've ever been quite that good again."

The match took place in Philadelphia, a city in which Foley had spent more time taking bumps than enjoying the sights over the years. This match would be no different, with Foley's head and body being subjected to the usual masochistic punishment that would be his norm. The most memorable spot was the countered back-superplex through the ringside table that tops any Shane McMahon leap of faith elbow, for sheer insanity.

And yet, considerable portions of the match saw the two actually trying to outwrestle each other, with Foley demonstrating his athletic mettle. It was another Michaels showstealer, mixing different styles with an opponent that isn't exactly his identical twin, but their differences and similarities combined for a true thrill.


8. Vs. Razor Ramon (SummerSlam 1995)

Shawn Michaels, Razor Ramon
WWE.com

Michaels and Razor managed quite the Houdini act. The two found out about two weeks before SummerSlam that they were forbidden from using the ladders as weapons, due to a strict anti-violence code in place at the time. How were they going to top their WrestleMania 10 all-timer if they were going to be shackled and cuffed like that?

They came damn close, pulling off a bonafide classic, even with the constraints. Their fellow Kliqsters helped them come up with ideas the night before, with a young Triple H reminding them that throwing each other into the ladders was okay, since it was like flinging an opponent into the corner buckles.

The only real weapon-ish spot was Razor dropping the ladder onto Michaels' outstretched leg, which may have been pushing it. Despite the hindrances, Michaels and Ramon equaled the drama of the original, and managed to be creative in spite of their circumstances. "The Showstopper" doesn't lay down for the needlessly-squeamish.


7. Vs. Chris Jericho (No Mercy 2008)

No Mercy 2008
wwe.com

The ladder match gimmick has been saturated not just from overuse, but from prioritizing mindless stunts over the story of the match. Stunts are one thing, but give me a ladder match with a little more hatred between the opponents. There aren't too many ladder matches in this particular one's league.

Jericho and Michaels had been feuding since the spring, and by this point it was as intensely personal as a grudge could be. As such, their ladder match at No Mercy 2008, for Jericho's World Heavyweight title, was more hate-filled than stunt-based. Little things like a dazed Jericho seeing the ladder's positioning and kicking it into a groggy Michaels' face (knowing his prior eye injury) added to the fiery tone.

The match is sadly neglected when one looks at the greatest ladder matches ever, and it was even overshadowed when considering the best matches of 2008 (Michaels/Flair was the "sentimental" pick). Give it a look some time, and you'll see why ladder matches are better when there isn't necessarily an arbitrary PPV dedicated to shoehorning them in.


6. Vs. Kurt Angle (WrestleMania 21)

Wrestlemania 21 Kurt Angle Shawn Michaels
WWE.com

Putting Michaels against Angle was a license to type asterisks. Two men whose in-ring brilliance set high-marks in their respective eras (not to say that Michaels necessarily represented "the past" in this match) were being put together with the idea of making a definitive WrestleMania match. Some "dream matches" just don't equal the anticipation, but this one managed to exceed it.

It's a credit to each man's natural skills that they only rehearsed one spot (a sunset flip counter) beforehand. The rest came down to each man's unparalleled ability, and a near-half hour blank slate with which to work. Michaels was months shy of his fortieth birthday, and still every bit the performer he was in his late-twenties.

There are many matches that remind me of Michaels/Angle, with the tons of false finishes and a dramatic closing stretch, but they're mostly pale impersonators. Michaels' selling, particularly in the recesses of the Ankle Lock, does more in this match to demonstrate his justified legendary status than any other spot or bump.


5. Vs. Triple H, Chris Benoit (WrestleMania 20)

WrestleMania XX Triple Threat
WWE Network

If there were a Hall of Fame solely for blade jobs, Michaels' gusher at WrestleMania 20 should get in on the first ballot. It didn't take long for Michaels's blood to spill from his forehead to his torso, with the speed of a pyroclastic flow. Michaels has bled buckets before, but this was enough to make even Eli Roth squirm.

That particular bloodletting is lost to the now-depressing ending, in which Benoit finally reaches the apex and becomes World Heavyweight Champion. For the smarter Garden crowd, no other ending would have been acceptable. Michaels, for his part, gets booed whenever he takes the offense, and at times feels like an intruder, usurping the spotlight meant for Benoit. Of course, that was also to raise further doubt on the Canadian underdog's chances at winning.

Michaels' efforts in the match go a long way toward its presently-muted greatness. Without him, Benoit and Helmsley, gifted as they are, don't have quite the same match. It's probably the greatest triple threat match ever, so naturally, Michaels had a hand in its success.


4. Vs. Triple H (SummerSlam 2002)

Triple H Shawn Michaels Summerslam 2002
WWE.com

According to Michaels, he was cautioned before the match by Arn Anderson that wrestling was not like riding a bike. After four years away from the ring, there was no guarantee that Michaels would be able to duplicate the brilliance that was once standard for his performances. After watching the match, "The Enforcer" would concede to Michaels that, apparently, he was the exception to the rule.

Michaels' comeback bout against his treacherous former friend was of the "unsanctioned" variety. In one sense, it felt like a classic Dusty Rhodes showcase, in that Michaels was the old gunslinger out to right a wrong, to act as avenger against unrepentant evil. The back injuries that ended his career were being put to the test against a match with a good amount of risks.

The story and the action were equally superb, with fans living and dying on Michaels' fight for what was right. When he narrowly prevails, even cynical New Yorkers in the crowd explode with joy. Few could tug at heartstrings the way Michaels could, no matter the era.


3. Vs. The Undertaker (In Your House: Badd Blood)

Badd Blood In Your House
www.wwe.com

The ending occupies most of the memories, as Kane made what could very well be the greatest debut in WWE history. His evacuation from red-tinted hell, in order to unleash fury upon The Undertaker, goes down as a historic moment. It doesn't, however, take away from the fact that Undertaker and Michaels perfected the Hell in a Cell match on the structure's first go.

For two months, fans had wanted to see Undertaker brutalize an increasingly-arrogant Michaels, and fans were treated to just that sight. As the match wore on, Michaels was genuinely beaten into a bloody pulp, enduring chairs to the head, battering rams into the cage wall, and falls from the side of the Cell. If you hated Michaels and can forgive the ending, this was pure catharticism.

In those larval stages of the Attitude Era, the combination of visceral carnage and multi-pronged emotional connection (for Shawn getting killed and for the Kane/Undertaker confrontation) was the recipe for a classic. More than 20 years later, this stands up as the greatest Hell in a Cell match ever.


2. Vs. The Undertaker (WrestleMania 25)

undertaker shawn michaels
WWE.com

Undertaker was coming off two straight WrestleMania classics with Batista and Edge, while Michaels has never had even a remotely-bad WrestleMania match in his life. The two didn't have much story beyond Michaels yearning to be the one to end The Streak, and that was fine. It's Undertaker vs. Michaels, what else needs to be said?

More than any other match in recent memory, Michaels vs. Undertaker inspired the desire for WrestleMania to have a token "classic", usually without a championship on the line, to try and anchor the event. Its half-hour length, litany of false finishes, and mostly-basic storyline were all contributors to the match's excellence - the match was about the match. The result was all that mattered.

It's also telling that for the first time in years, it seemed like Michaels had the most realistic chance of conquering the perfect record. Other opponents, while of star quality, don't exist on the same plane as Michaels, whose work can make agnostics temporarily find divinity.


1. Vs. Razor Ramon (WrestleMania 10)

Shawn Michaels Razor Ramon WrestleMania X Ladder Match
WWE.com

The Pulp Fiction of wrestling matches, in that people watching it for the first time today (without timely context) may not see why it was so special. Sure, ladder matches since then have delivered more bone-crunching stunts than a Jackass marathon, and some of the high spots in Michaels vs. Ramon may seem a bit tame by comparison.

In 1994, what Ramon vs. Michaels put together had never been done. There had been ladder matches previously, but all were about the drama of the climb, not the can-you-top-this ethos of a full-blown spotfest. There was no template in place for what Ramon and Michaels achieved in 19 minutes. They had to build a template themselves.

That's not to say the match wasn't alluringly dangerous - both men take their share of perilous bumps throughout, with Michaels at his uninhibited ragdoll best. But the end result still headlined over the spots, as pride over ownership of the IC Championship was paramount. It was a stunt show with a purpose, where everything they did made perfect sense. It's the best of its kind, and it's Shawn Michaels' masterpiece of masterpieces.


Contributor
Contributor

Justin has been a wrestling fan since 1989, and has been writing about it since 2009. Since 2014, Justin has been a features writer and interviewer for Fighting Spirit Magazine. Justin also writes for History of Wrestling, and is a contributing author to James Dixon's Titan series.