The Most BRUTAL Wrestling Match You've Never Seen Before
Guerrero vs. JBL, Umaga vs. Cena, and Jon Moxley's Greatest Hits pale in comparison.
All wrestling is fundamentally brutal. It all hurts. Hulk Hogan is a shell of a man. He is also a physical wreck, and this is a bloke who got over primarily by flailing about on his knees and shaking his head from side to side.
All wrestling is brutal, and the brutality is the selling point. Even the most "pure" in-ring stories, a lot of the time, run it back with a weapons match.
Tables. Forks. Barbed wire. Fire. Barely protected falls from 20 feet in the air. Shoot bombs. Pro wrestling has experimented with violence and weapons to insane lengths, and yet, the most brutal match ever held only needed a guardrail, a chair, a hoss, and a bonafide f*cking lunatic. Oh, and some exposed concrete.
Samoa Joe Vs. Necro Butcher, June 11, 2005, promoted by IWA: Mid-South in the New Alhambra Sports & Entertainment Center (formerly, unofficially, the ECW Arena): this is the most unbelievably violent, sickening, grotesque pro wrestling match ever held.
CONT'd...
Samoa Joe entered the match as the preeminent demigod of the cult, rave-reviewed North American 2000s independent scene. His aura was so incandescent, at this stage of his career, that he was four months away from wrestling the legendary, omni-acclaimed Kenta Kobashi and being received as a peer, an equal, of one of the most imposing, stiff and mythical wrestlers of all-time. Nobody was a match for Joe in that era. CM Punk's ability to put him in a headlock was considered a strong fictional achievement.
Necro Butcher, meanwhile, was something else. If Joe was the hardest component of a new, underground scene that had filtered through the wider consciousness, there's always something harder. Necro was Xibalba, or some aural horrific monstrosity of gore noise, the fans of which would deem mere "extreme metal" too soft. Necro was the sort of artist so extreme in an anti-mainstream niche that you should never have heard of them - but he found himself interloping in the scene for a few unforgettable years, like a nightmarish hallucination almost. How hard was Joe, really, when Necro Butcher existed?
Ian Rotten, for once in his life, had a capital idea. He asked that question.
CONT'd...
On a level of principle, you could make the argument that this - technically - is a bad professional wrestling match. Without a doubt, certain icons of the industry would watch it with utter contempt. If the idea of the pro wrestling medium is to hide brutality through a careful, safe dance - to cooperate with the illusion of conflict - Samoa Joe Vs. Necro Butcher destroys it with as much abandon as they destroy one another. The match is not remotely safe. It is worked. Nothing goes awry. But it is as dangerous as the form gets.
"Form" is not the word to use because the match doesn't feel crafted in any way. There is one very obviously planned device early, but it still rules. To set the tone of a lawless fight, both Joe and Necro - after talking sh*t in each other's face - take turns battering referee Bryce Remsburg. Joe throws him out of the ring (and what a bump, incidentally). His services are not required.
They launch forearms. "Here we go!" shouts Eddie Kingston, who is joined on commentary by Dave Prazak and CM Punk. Necro doesn't register Joe's strikes and, where you are "meant" to do it hard but in a safer place, Necro throws his strikes right in the ear. Oddly, it's Necro who does the first thing one would normally associate with the wrestling form. He runs the ropes. He is met with an enziguiri to the back of the skull. After being sent sprawling to the outside, he fails to heed his lesson. Joe confronts him with a suicide dive. Necro, because of course, smashes his head back-first into the guardrail. He takes a powder on a nearby chair. Joe, holding nothing back, kicks the nipples off his t*ts with a barrage of kicks. In one swift motion, Necro rises from the chair and plants Joe with a headbutt. Joe eats two vile chops before grabbing Necro by the hair and cracking him with a series of headbutts. Blood materialises over Necro's forehead. Sickeningly, no blade is used, and if he secretly gigged himself in the back to the visual, Joe hits Necro hard enough to make it rain.
CONT'd...
Necro roars back, simply, by shoot punching Joe directly in the face multiple times. Joe tries to defend himself like a boxer, but he's never looked more vulnerable. The fans are already on their feet. They don't need their chairs, so Necro throws them at Joe's head. There's just such an intoxicating, alive quality to the scene. What if the fans had remained seated? This is improvised noise jazz played directly in a burst, infected eardrum.
For the second time - telling the core story - Necro makes the mistake of running at Joe and misjudging the fact that Joe is tremendously skilled at grappling. Joe catches him with a scoop slam, but Necro doesn't take it on his back. On exposed concrete. His head and neck collide with exposed concrete. This physics and common sense-defying "spot" delights Punk, who sensibly asks "How do you power slam somebody on their forehead?
In a match brimming with wrong, even the bodies don't land or fall as they should. It, in every way, is utterly f*cked.
Joe props Necro on a chair. He sprints into Necro's face and kicks him square in the noise. A barely coherent Kingston can't even complete the thought without giggling in disbelief: "Oh! He done kicked him in the f*ckin' head!" You can hear a pumped-up dude in the crowd at this point echo his enthusiasm by roaring "F*CK YEAH!"
CONT'd...
Joe Vs. Necro is a derangement of pro wrestling, an almost complete subversion of what it seeks to do. It is not how it is meant to be done. Conversely, it is also a major achievement in crowd psychology that - for reasons you can fairly understand - has never been repeated. The atmosphere generated is unlike anything two performers have ever conjured. These fans in that building aren't just hardcore, knowledgeable. They are denizens of the old ECW Arena. They are watching, having paid money for the privilege, a show promoted by Ian Rotten. They are the sickos. They have watched every spectacularly ill-advised spot imaginable and should, by rights, be desensitised to the ugliest stripe of pro wrestling violence. Punk and Kingston are workers. They more than anybody else know that what they are watching is predetermined and discussed ahead of time. They don't act like it, nor do they act at all. They are losing their minds. In the intimate confines of an unwashed ass-scented sh*thole, the audience and the professionals alike react to the pro wrestling match as if they're watching a real bar brawl break out, and somebody just withdrew a knife.
Joe takes Necro back in the ring and attempts a pin, which feels surreal in whatever context this is. It's easy to forget in this moment that pinning the other guy ends it.
Necro introduces a guardrail. He drapes it over Joe and delivers a senton, which is probably the tamest moment. The most horrifying moment, however - possibly in the entire history of the form! - follows shortly thereafter. After a brief struggle on the apron, Joe splatters Necro onto the concrete with an overhead throw. Necro, again, takes it on the forehead. Prazak screams. It's a sustained, high-pitched squeal, actually, one that feels like it lasts forever, as if he could spend the rest of his life failing to comprehend how Necro survived. The thick, congealed blood that pools below him is grotesque. Upon impact, his head looks like a burst, bruised fruit dropped from the top shelf. Joe hits what is left of the back of it with a chair before, back in the pointless ring, smashing him with a powerbomb onto the suspended guardrail. Necro takes it on the back of the head. There's such little give and it happens to dangerously fast that it's as if it's happening at 1.75 speed. The squelching, the thudding, the squealing from the crowd and from wherever you are watching it: the match is such an onomatopoeic disaster that you feel animalistic, maybe even immoral, for lapping up.
Necro survives another jarring pin attempt, to Joe's disbelief. Remsburg, who you also forget existed, again counts to two when Necro takes a German on a chair to the sharp point of his elbow.
CONT'd...
It ends, finally and mercifully, when Joe withstands Necro's last-ditch punch barrage and attempts to knee a hole in his face. The lunges are as horrible as anything else. It's like Joe wants to turn Necro's face into mush when he was already quite successful at it. When his thigh connects with Necro's face, every millimetre of it is soaked, instantly, in blood. Joe then aims one last full-on kick to the bridge of Necro's nose. It's over. You feel exhilarated, disgusted.
The head trauma endured in the match is sobering, when you look at the absolute state of Dylan Summers today. This match in isolation didn't do that to him, but it hardly helped. Joe meanwhile was lionised in the aftermath.
A match perfect for the crowd, a match that makes you feel something at a bone-deep level, a match that in every conceivable way is a triumph and a disgrace, Samoa Joe Vs. Necro Butcher is the very concepts of right and wrong smashing one another, turning bones and blood into jam. It is the concept of professional wrestling done so well or so horribly - or so well and so horribly - that the medium has never before or since been pushed to such an absolute limit.
It is a match that should not ever be attempted again, which is just as well: nobody else could.