The Problem With Tessa Blanchard That No One Wants To Talk About

Why the Diamond may not be in demand.

Tessa Blanchard
Anthem Sports & Entertainment

Impact Wrestling released their reigning World Champion, Tessa Blanchard, on 25 June. Fans haven't stopped fantasy-booking her next move since.

It's easy to see what this 'Diamond' would bring to the oft-criticised AEW women's division. Britt Baker, Hikaru Shida, Nyla Rose, Riho: these are skilled, talented performers who haven't yet reached their respective ceilings, though none is as well-rounded as the female figureheads in rival promotions. While Penelope Ford, Tay Conti, Kris Statlander, and Anna Jay boast immense promise, they are near the beginning of their development curves. Blanchard is a more complete performer than all of these names, and while only 25 years old, she could immediately be booked as a division-leading vanguard.

Between Raw, SmackDown, NXT, and NXT UK, WWE has no shortage of elite females, though only Charlotte Flair carries herself with the same assured superstar swagger as Tessa. She'd be a complementary addition to a scene already boasting Bayley, Sasha Banks, the absent Becky Lynch, and more, and, at her age, has the potential to one day succeed them all. Who better to eventually replace a Horsewoman than a Horseman's daughter?

Tessa could walk into AEW or WWE and be a huge deal right away. The thing is, there's a strong chance Blanchard won't end up working for either anytime soon.

Let's talk about why.

CONT'd...


Tessa Blanchard
ImpactWrestling.com

Impact's embrace of intergender wrestling reached its pinnacle at Hard to Kill on 12 January 2020, when Tessa Blanchard defeated Sami Callihan to become World Champion. A woman had grabbed the company's top prize for the first time in history. It was an unprecedented move, something that had never happened in a major American promotion before, and should have been the start of a progressive, game-changing run for Tessa, who was performing at her peak after a suitably attritional battle with Callihan.

Instead, Blanchard's run was poisoned before it began.

The NWA's Allysin Kay (who wrestled for Impact as Sienna from 2016 to 2018) broke the seal:-

Kay was joined by another former Impact wrestler in Chelsea Green, AEW's Shanna, Renee Michelle, and more. La Rosa Negra, the alleged victim of Blanchard's bullying, came forward to corroborate, citing an incident from three years prior. Tessa's first response was to call the situation ridiculous in a since-deleted tweet, before denying the accusations and issuing a full statement:-

Meanwhile, La Rosa Negra uploaded a video outlining her side of the story, confirming the incident happened in April 2017. It should be noted that Blanchard hasn't wrestled in Japan since a few weeks after the alleged abuse would have occurred.

Blanchard's Impact push wasn't hindered by this. Tessa won the World Title as planned and held it until June, when she was unceremoniously released from the promotion after failing to submit remote video content from self-isolation in Mexico, having not appeared for the group since the onset of the global health crisis. This bred fears of her no-showing the Slammiversary 2020 pay-per-view, where she was reportedly set to drop the belt.

Having seemingly escaped the reported behavioural issues that blemished her earlier career, the 25-year-old found herself drowning in them five months after making history. Recalling said issues goes some way to explaining why she's still a free agent...

CONT'd...


Tessa Blanchard
WWE.com

WWE emerged as the apparent frontrunners for Tessa's signature soon after her Impact departure, with talkSPORT's Alex McCarthy claiming a source had told him AEW President Tony Khan may not be interested. This would seem an easy transition, given that Blanchard worked NXT jobber spots in 2016 and was a participant in the 2017 Mae Young Classic, though the company opted against signing her alongside fellow MYC competitors Toni Storm, Shayna Baszler, and Piper Niven. On top of this, Tessa wasn't even brought back for one-off enhancement spots.

Vince McMahon, it seemed, had no interest in acquiring a young, talented up-and-comer with great heritage (Tully Blanchard is her father, Joe Blanchard her grandfather, and Magnum T.A. her stepfather) when doing so looked like a no-brainer.

But why?

That's one for the rumour mill, though talk of alleged behavioural issues stretches much further back than her Impact exit. People have been whispering about this for years. One frequently-cited incident revolved around a purported Performance Center confrontation with former partner Ricochet, leading to her blacklisting, though Blanchard shot this down in a 2019 interview with Fightful.

The Wrestling Observer's Dave Meltzer reported that "attitude issues" were indeed the reason WWE passed on Tessa, saying "a lot of people wanted to steer clear of her, she had a lot of enemies." Other wrestlers remain on WWE TV despite their own controversies, showing WWE's willful "forgetfulness" when it comes to such instances. If the reports on her behaviour are to be believed, it seems the promotion hasn't been willing to extend this courtesy to Blanchard.

CONT'd...


Tessa Blanchard
STARDOM

It must be noted that despite her glittering lineage, Blanchard's entry into the wrestling business was far from straightforward.

Speaking to The Ringer in December 2019, trainer George South said "Tessa didn't ask for no favours and I sure wasn't gonna give 'em," citing her work ethic. "The wrestling ring don't care what your name is," he added. Performers with surnames like "Blanchard" are often treated cynically in this business, as if their family tree and perceived "silver spoon" pre-ordains them to receive opportunities above others. Tessa fell victim to this, suffering brutal, unrelenting bullying as early as 2014, with South saying other wrestlers would do "anything they could to break her."

Blanchard herself told The Ringer that she believes he 2017 tour of Japan was when "something clicked here I knew who I was and I knew who I wanted to be in the ring and out of the ring." Indeed, The future Impact World Champion excelled between the ropes during that tour. It was there that Tessa emerged as a global breakout star, slotting effortlessly into what was then the most talented pool of female wrestlers in the world, expelling memories of her disastrous 2016 tour (during which a bout with promotional mainstay Kagetsu turned into an uncooperative mess) in the process.

The Rosa Negra allegations emerged just two weeks after this Ringer profile was published, however. Truly, the 2017 tour had been a transformational one inside the ring and out, hence where we are today.

CONT'd...


Tessa Blanchard
Impact Wrestling

Tessa Blanchard, former Impact World Champion and elite-level professional wrestler, is currently gathering dust on a shelf after four months as a free agent, having wrestled only once since June. Meanwhile, Ben Carter (so new he doesn't even have a CAGEMATCH profile) is currently the most sought-after freelancer in the sport on the back of just three AEW appearances (only one of which went down on Dynamite).

Promotions are ravenous for new blood at the moment. Carter is already phenomenal, though he is in a position similar to Will Ospreay's prior to joining New Japan in 2016. The tools are clearly there and his ceiling appears to be limitless, though he would ideally spend the next 2-3 years on the indies, rubbing his rougher edges away before signing an exclusive deal. Not in 2020. Promotions are so desperate to secure wrestlers that they'll extend offers to anyone with even the slightest hint of buzz, regardless of their experience.

Four years ago, Carter would be allowed to grow, nurture, and add layers on the indies, as Ospreay was allowed to do under the freedom of his NJPW deal. Now, it's likely a matter of days before one of AEW or WWE snaps him up.

What does Carter's situation have to do with Blanchard's? Everything. If young Ben is a hot commodity after a single appearance on national television, Tessa should be like the surface of the sun. Unfortunately for her, it seems her reputation has blotted out the light, leaving her benched for the foreseeable future.

CONT'd...


Tessa Blanchard
Impact Wrestling

History tells us that professional wrestling will forgive even the worst transgressions: WWE even brought that vile, repugnant homophobe, the Ultimate Warrior, back into the fold. In all likelihood, Blanchard will find a home in one of the game's biggest promotions over the next few years. This will hopefully come as a result of her approaching these controversies as objectively as possible, learning from them, and demonstrating clear, tangible growth in a public forum.

Said controversies will always be part of her legacy, but they don't have to define her forever. At 25, time is on Tessa's side. She can atone.

For now, however, Blanchard may be better off looking abroad. Her husband-to-be, Daga, is a tenured Mexican wrestler with history in AAA and on the indie scene, so it's conceivable that Tessa could tread a similar path to the one he has taken between Impact appearances over the past few years. Lucha libre remains undercovered by English-language media: away from that spotlight, Blanchard may find the perfect platform on which to rebuild. Overturning an unsavoury backstage reputation won't be easy, though it looks an increasingly critical step in this process.

Tessa Blanchard is a once-in-a-generation talent with genuine best-in-the-world potential. Of this, your writer has no doubt. The road to hitting this level begins with making good for the behaviour that has seemingly made her a pariah - and preventing future blow-ups.


Watch Next


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.