The Secret Weapon AEW Holds Over WWE

Gambling with a royal flush.

Jon Moxley
AEW

Saturday night’s Double Or Nothing, the very first show presented by All Elite Wrestling, was an almost inconceivable triumph.

Digital impressions dwarfed—quadrupled—that of ALL IN, the very success of which mapped this groundbreaking destination. Even beyond the critical acclaim and the turned heads of the WWE-disenfranchised, no less an influential figure than rising Democrat star Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez put over Executive Vice President Cody’s strive for genuine diversity. AEW didn’t just seduce the wrestling world this week; the company penetrated the mainstream sphere.

Fittingly, for a company that leaned on a gambling aesthetic and narrative in Las Vegas, AEW holds several hands over the competition.

AEW radiated cool and danger throughout that instantly iconic closing angle. Jon Moxley disrupted Jericho’s masturbatory promo—if anything, he demanded the audience jerk him off, in a great character moment—by planting him and the referee with the Dirty Deeds. He stood on the ropes, breathed everything in, and let out a silent Motherf*cker roar. He, just like everybody else, was high on an atmosphere of revolution and defiance.

MJF almost stole the show by delivering his unique, big-time, hilariously nasty promo on its rightful stage. Cody and Dustin Rhodes formally stole it with a match as beautiful as it was disgusting, following which no less than four much-anticipated matches were either formally or all but announced: Cody and Dustin Rhodes Vs. The Young Bucks; MJF Vs. Hangman Page; Kenny Omega Vs. Jon Moxley; Hangman Page Vs. Chris Jericho...

CONT'D...(1 of 5)


SoCal Uncensored Ricky Havlik
AEW (Ricky Havlik)

Talents afforded the agency to connect, unforgettably, with the crowd; the manifest promise of long-term storytelling; the proper treatment of tag team wrestling; a thrilling and incredible throwback to the days of talent jumping; unregulated comedic creativity that, at the very least, marked AEW as an alternative: all of this converged to make AEW’s various promises an awesome, manifest reality.

AEW holds the cards. The Royal Flush, the potential game-changer, is the sheer tonal range of Double Or Nothing’s epic five-hour runtime.

Double Or Nothing wasn’t the best pro wrestling show of 2019, gauging by online consensus. That distinction still belongs to NXT TakeOver: New York. Double Or Nothing, however, was by some distance the easiest show of this super-served era of pro wrestling to take in.

WWE is an endurance test in these George Barrios years. The marathon run-times of the pay-per-views are not helped by the sequencing problem, in which countless would-be great matches are lost to fatigue, and yet more midcard attractions are lost entirely. The matches themselves are largely patterned in structure—the heat spot is predictable often to the second—and the limited move-sets do not help the homogeny, nor does WWE’s apathetic, token approach to tag team wrestling. At best, WWE is over-familiar in its presentation. At worst, the company is such an abject joke that it spawned the very beast that challenges it now.

In contrast, Double Or Nothing celebrated the diverse and colourful fabric of pro wrestling at large.

The Casino Battle Royale incorporated the niche comedy that has revolutionised the Independent scene, which has long evolved from its delineated days as the ultra-violent or technical alternative. The opening match proper, SoCal Uncensored Vs. Strong Hearts, folded in the classic drama of American tag wrestling with CIMA’s influential puro-lucha impulses. Britt Baker’s Fatal 4-Way victory over Kylie Ray, Nyla Rose and Awesome Kong maintained interest, particularly through Ray’s eye-catching, fierce feminine spirit.

CONT'D...(2 of 5)


Dustin Rhodes Ricky Havlik
AEW (Ricky Havlik)

The Best Friends Vs. Angélico and Jack Evans delivered the sort of soaring high-flying action tethered on 205 Live. The joshi six-woman tag team ripper was particularly effective in expanding the boundaries of the show; incorporating kawaii charm, killer neck-first action and badass last stand psychology, the match was both off-kilter comedy delight and the most brutal of serious business.

Cody Vs. Dustin Rhodes was as timelessly brilliant as the old-school dynamic promised—just a palpably emotional bloodbath worked by a new megastar and an old master. Both unbearable and so compelling the molten crowd had to bear it, it appealed to even the most staunch of curmudgeons—those fans, perhaps, so averse to modern wrestling that they stopped watching it altogether.

The Young Bucks Vs. The Lucha Brothers delivered on the state-of-the-art super-work that is the Elite’s calling card in a match that also boasted the richest of psychology. Matt and Nick Jackson revealed the interior lives of their rusty onscreen characters in a dramatic spectacle loaded with nuance.

The main event wasn’t the most spectacular Kenny Omega match, but it set a convincing tone of pure blood feud hatred, nonetheless. The immersion aspect and the legitimacy allowed fans to suspend disbelief.; for 23 minutes and 50 seconds, the two offscreen friends performed as if they despised one another in the sort of deeply personal match sorely missing from wrestling in 2019. And, when Kenny Omega does present the best version of himself, AEW fans will encounter the very best pro wrestling performer among the most critically-acclaimed generation of all-time.

AEW Double Or Nothing was a love letter to every subset of the wrestling fandom, and, gauging by the coverage and the buzz, every subset of the wrestling fandom was seduced.

CONT'D...(3 of 5)


Hikaru Shida James Musselwhite
AEW (James Musselwhite )

Really, this isn’t an advantage AEW holds over WWE alone.

New Japan Pro Wrestling is exponentially more diverse than an outsider might suspect, presenting comedy and an epic big fight feel alike under a sporting framework in which several genres are showcased. New Japan does not, despite a recent and not inconsiderable groundswell of protest, present women’s wrestling—and its tag team output leaves much to be desired, in terms of both match quality and committed booking.

NXT TV is often logical not to a fault, exactly, but its detriment. There is an almost dry, clinical quality to the storytelling. Everything makes sense, and the best performers are booked with consistency and conviction—but rarely does the brand produce truly wild or inspired angles. Obviously, those five Saturdays a year are true highlights of a lifetime fandom—but the weekly TV show creates few, unmissable talking points. New Japan is beholden to tradition. NXT is beholden to a distinctly melodramatic WWE vision, albeit the perfection of it, and a taped schedule that prohibits curiosity. This lack of immediacy in a warp-speed world is why more hardcore fans complain on Tuesday mornings more than they celebrate on Thursdays.

Moreover, both brands prohibit accessible, week-to-week investment. The New Japan World streaming service is deeply unintuitive; keeping track of the various storyline threads requires users to navigate and jump around its confusing bowels.

CONT'D...(4 of 5)


Moxley Omega James Musselwhite
AEW (James Musselwhite)

New Japan offers a seminal product, but a splintered grind of a package for new users. NXT meanwhile has long evolved from its original purpose as a developmental territory—and yet, various performers exist for management to track more so than the enjoyment of the audience. Wednesday nights aren’t so much eclectic as very uneven.

There is too much of even the best wrestling, creating a fractured fanbase.

AEW’s real hand is its mission to do everything possible not to exhaust that super-served fanbase with a readily-accessible live package packed with the demonstrable power to reward long-term investment and offer can’t-miss, unhinged angles. AEW can’t sign a Jon Moxley figure every week, of course—but the crucial live element promises at least the chance of the unexpected.

AEW is headed up by five very smart minds. Each has a certain speciality, and together, on admittedly scant evidence, this collaboration has resulted in a coherent and diverse product, and it’s ironic: AEW feels like a Universe of ideas opposed, on this new battleground, by an enemy producing literally more uninspired output than ever.

More than any throne-breaking digs or coffee cup Easter eggs, this feels like the biggest flex of them all.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!