These Brilliant AEW Success Stories Should Have SUCKED

Injury bugs, cursed belts and "No fans? No problem!" when the whole world came to a standstill.

Billy Gunn Daddy Ass
AEW

How great is The Righteous' entrance music?

Vincent and Dutch speak in vague idiosyncratic tones about trances and the like, but they needn't bother talking the nonsense talk when the entrance walks the walk. Or clicks its fingers along with it. It's a captivating tune, a total earworm, and a perfectly pitched accompaniment to their act.

It's also probably the biggest takeaway from their flirtation with the Ring Of Honor Tag Team Championships. Defeated by MJF in a handicap match at WrestleDream (and per the irrelevant numerical advantage and match layout, presented as relatively harmless clowns in the process), there hasn't been much else to particularly ponder about the immediate future of the defeated challengers other than when another opportunity arises to hear the awesome theme. And it's 2023, so that's pretty much when you go to YouTube to track it down.

But don't go yet! The backwoods pair are rule-proving exceptions at present - AEW has managed to make more seemingly doomed prospects work out. So much so that it'd be foolish to completely right off The Righteous, especially if you're still clicking those fingers. Now clicking "Next" for more...

10. Billy Gunn & His Sons

The Acclaimed Gunn Club
AEW

Somehow getting multiple newer acts as over in 2023 as he was in 1998, Billy Gunn's transition from Dad-to-two-idiot-kids to Daddy Ass-to-one-awesome-tag-team was far from seamless, but it was objectively successful.

After trying for a time to maintain order between The Acclaimed and The Gunn Club, the WWE Hall Of Famer turned on Max Caster and Anthony Bowens to side with his biological boys. Fortunately for the fans (and the company's merch-related income), the reunion was short-lived. Realising that he'd rather use his guiding hand for scissoring, AEW's original Big Bill saw the light and once again saw gold.

Aiding The Acclaimed in Tag and Trios Championship victories, Gunn got to see his kids thrive in the aftermath too. The future Bullet Club Gold men dethroned Caster and Bowens in order to transition the belts onto FTR in early-2023, and have finally found their place on the roster since shockingly linking up with Jay White and Juice Robinson.


9. Athena

Athena transformation
AEW

By the letter of the law (or more specifically, the letters of the promotion), this entry should perhaps be picked back up whenever the current Ring Of Honor World Champion makes her return to All Elite Wrestling. But Athena deserves credit for doing what hardly anybody else exclusive to that show has managed to since the show settled into its niche spot on Honor Club in March 2023 - she's forced herself back into the conversation.

Having hit a ceiling as a babyface in AEW all-too-quickly following her Double Or Nothing 2022 debut, the heel-turned star became a revolution on ROH. She won the top strap almost immediately and embarked on a tour of violence and menace that has recently morphed into a doomed and comedically cruel master/gutsy apprentice relationship with Billie Starkz.

That story seems destined to end with "minion" Starkz breaking Athena's tyrannical reign, allowing the former Ember Moon a seamless return to Dynamite and Collision as a reborn and refocussed nightmare for whoever's holding company gold.


8. Jeff Jarrett

Jeff Jarrett
AEW

With the exception of the pops that could be heard by a small-but-vocal community of right-minded Jeff Jarrett lifers, the mood was fairly sour when 'Double J' shockingly debuted in All Elite Wrestling in what had already proven to be quite a challenging period for the company.

The drama coming out of the post-All Out 2022 press scrum suggested that perhaps some of the more controversial figures in wrestling history might not necessarily be the best fits for the challenger brand, but - for more reasons than just the obvious - the 'Last Outlaw' has left the doubters in the dust once again.

Understanding of the reputation he's carried for decades, Jarrett plays the clown so well that he doesn't remotely scan as a threat to a title until he's gleefully punching the air ahead of what he thinks is a certain three-count. In that fleeting moment, he gets to be the biggest threat of all. And therein lies the continuing magic of the character - an AEW with Jarrett holding gold is so unthinkable that he can get crowds to root for just about anybody in order to stop it.

Digging into his vast bag of tricks as a cartoonish scoundrel alongside a crew of equally ludicrous villains he's elevated along the way, Jarrett has made himself the perfect person for so many roles that it's hard to imagine the company without him occupying a little corner of it.

Or maybe not so little...


7. Satnam Singh

Jeff Jarrett Satnam Singh
AEW

Jeff Jarrett raged for the AEW camera operator to "SLOW PAN" upwards when filming ex-NBA player Satnam Singh during his first appearance alongside him, not-that-tacitly implying that maybe the the company hadn't done the best job of highlighting just how big the newest big man was.

Months on from that, he's slotted in quite nicely as a heater for Jarrett and partner Jay Lethal, and it looks to be the spot that will hopefully be the making of the unrefined monster.

Singh shows fabulous poise in the ring for a man of his relative inexperience, but there are few positions more robust than being ringside to watch one of the all-time masters of crowd psychology. Literally so, based on his most memorable moment in the company so far; no-selling a killer Darby Allin dive was one of the coolest spots of 2022. And with just 20 matches contested since his debut, AEW seem in no rush to burn through the best of 'One In A Billion'.


6. The Butcher & The Blade

Claudio Castagnoli Jon Moxley The Butcher Blade
AEW

The Butcher and The Blade will perhaps never ascend to a point where they can believably challenge for or hold the AEW Tag Team Championships, but the levels they have risen above can't be forgotten. And won't be, as long as their 2019 Dynamite debut remains easily accessible.

In terms of starts to life as part of the new wrestling revolution, theirs was one of the very worst. One of several acts at that time to get the lights on/lights off debut despite live crowds not necessarily knowing who they were and reacting accordingly, The Butcher & The Blade as MJF's Cody-hating mercenaries was a good idea on paper that bombed in practice.

They were...a lot all at once, with the work not particularly sparkling and a strange aesthetic veering a little too close to putting-a-hat-on-a-hat than putting-a-beating-on-an-ass. All in good time, as it turned out. Valuable assets during a beloved pandemic period (more on that later) for the company, the pair went from cult hits to TV regulars and purpose-serving gatekeepers for challengers on the rise.

Their lowkey presence in 2023 is strictly due to roster bloat rather than any sort of dip in form. A profiled programme doesn't exactly look like it's around the nearest corner, but the next hilarious promo is only ever - at worst - a Rampage away.


5. Hangman Page Vs Jon Moxley

Hangman Page concussion
AEW

The long-awaited Hangman Page/Jon Moxley rivalry got off to the worst possible start when, during their October 18th 2022 Dynamite encounter, a King Kong Lariat was all too effective and left the Elite man with a devastating concussion.

This was, to put it mildly, a stressful viewing experience. The cameras panned in tight on Jon Moxley as he attempted to cut a victory promo whilst putting over a guy that - for all we all knew in the moment - might never wrestle again. Page's medical condition was unclear, and concerned punters were stunned into scared silence as MJF arrived to challenge the reigning Champion to a showdown at the upcoming Full Gear pay-per-view.

After a rocky post-"Brawl Out" summer at the top of the card, it was the last thing two big money programmes needed. Luckily for all three men and the fans, the belt wasn't about to face yet more uncertainty. 'The Salt Of The Earth' seized his treasured possession, and Hangman's heroic return came three months later on a Dynamite that saw him gain a measure of revenge against Moxley. The original moment was maximised for their rubber match - Page's Revolution 2023 Texas Deathmatch win was the most brutal and bruising of the Blackpool Combat Club leader's AEW career.


4. The Kingdom

The Kingdom
WWE

The Kingdom didn't ask for the air of indifference that accompanied their arrival in the Tony Khan universe in 2022, but wrestlers associated with Ring Of Honor have unfairly carried that with them by default. Especially when it felt as though the inclusion of ROH's existing world was actively damaging the pristine quality of AEW's television output.

But Matt Taven and Mike Bennett have maximised their minutes since being folded into the ongoing Roderick Strong-Adam Cole-MJF drama, propping up the preposterous Strong as he allegedly fights through unprecedented poor neck health and his complex feelings of upset and betrayal.

There's a glorious transparency to their act too - it's as though they're fully aware of what Roddy's up to, but more than willing to hitch themselves to his wagon if it gets them closer to the tag gold currently held by MJF and his injured partner Adam Cole. Regardless of how the friendship triangle pans out for the key players, it feels increasingly like Taven and Bennett will get what they're after, if renewed prominence in 2023 wasn't exactly that.


3. The All-Atlantic/International Title

Orange Cassidy AEW All-Atlantic Title
AEW

The social media groans were loud enough to be heard through the screens when AEW launched yet another new title that wasn't a Trios one in June 2022.

Long removed from the era where the name itself would have carried the nostalgic warmth of a time Tony Khan was keen to ape, the All-Atlantic Championship was felt to be the latest in a series of misfires from a challenger brand about to lose more ground against the market leader.

Whilst it didn't turn around financial fortunes, the belt became a beacon of hope when second winner Orange Cassidy defeated PAC in October 2022. He held it for just short of a year, elevating it beyond the status of the much-maligned TNT strap to the point where it credibly headlined a pay-per-view. The All Out 2023 loss to Jon Moxley was heartbreaking in kayfabe but vindicating for the company's unlikeliest workhorse, and served as a reality check for any of 'Freshly Squeezed's last remaining critics.


2. Pandemic Pro Wrestling

Eddie Kingston Jon Moxley
AEW

It was the worst of times, it was the worst of times.

But there was magic in the fresh air over Daily's Place, Jacksonville in 2020, and wrestling fans should still collectively thank All Elite Wrestling for two stress-free hours a week when they needed it most. Dynamite being as good as it was during its first year-plus wasn't just improbable - it should have been impossible.

As the market leader flailed away in the confines of its own gym and overspent on a ThunderDome that failed to inspire when the novelty wore off, AEW simply forged ahead booking utterly compelling programmes while also making good use of the unique(ly terrible) situation. And if Stadium Stampede, the Parking Lot Brawl and Le Dinner Debonaire were the empty arena headlines, the stories that made up the rest of the year will stand up decades removed from one of the stranger times in human history.

What made great television even better in hindsight was how rewarding it was to see so many of the big set-ups paid off in white hot buildings when the group were able to return to the road. The hard-earned euphoria was powerful and evident absolutely everywhere. Double Or Nothing 2021 has no right to be such a transcendent experience, but Jon Moxley looks ready to spontaneously combust as he makes a familiar walk through the Daily's stands with the unfamiliar feelings of fans back by his side.


1. Forbidden Door 2022

AEW NJPW Forbidden Door
AEW/NJPW

A dream show was plunged into nightmarish depths in mid-2022 when a minor injury crisis robbed the first ever Forbidden Door show of two of its biggest matches.

The planned CM Punk Vs Hiroshi Tanahashi and Bryan Danielson Vs Zack Sabre Jr contests were both taken off the whiteboard when the two regulars went down injured at the same time, but respective replacements Jon Moxley and Claudio Castagnoli didn't have to be lone saviours on a night that made good on years of electrifying promise.

The nine-match card boasted no duds and offered such a glorious range of different styles and stars that it felt like AEW and NJPW had put down a marker for every future inter-promotional supercard. Short on all the obvious compromise and backstage politics typically laid bare in front of the cameras, this was nothing more than the best possible version of itself and thus, totally awesome.

The show's biggest loss was AEW's gain over a year later too - Danielson and ZSJ eventually lit up a WrestleDream 2023 card, earning Match Of The Year plaudits for a contest that ultimately wasn't even a big miss 18 months earlier.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.