Triple H's 10 Most Notorious Urban Legends

Did CM Punk leave because he didn't Triple H? It's possible.

The career of Hunter Hearst Helmsley (real name Paul Levesque) in WWE has spanned nearly 20 years. He started in 1995 as a midcard wrestler that was using the rich aristocrat gimmick. His rise to prominence in WWE was similar to a lot of wrestlers in that he started at the bottom, became an Intercontinental Champion, King of the Ring and eventually a WWE Champion as well. Hunter became a top guy mostly as a heel known simply as Triple H. He noted on Chris Jericho's podcast this week that his good friend Shawn Michaels was calling him Triple H at the beginning of his career and eventually Vince McMahon okayed it as a full time thing in 1997. Hunter went on to win 13 WWE World Titles and was a fixture in the main event scene from 1999 to 2011 when he stopped wrestling full time. These days his career is mostly out of the ring. While he did wrestle in a few matches this year, his main job is that of the Executive Vice President of Talent Relations and the on screen Chief Operating Officers of WWE. Basically he's in the same role that his father-in-law Vince McMahon was doing on television nearly every week 15 years ago. Whether you like him or not, there's no denying that he's been a major player in WWE for a long time and will continue to be for decades to come. He's the right hand man to Vince, he's running the developmental system and along with his wife Stephanie, he has a major say in everything that WWE does. There have been a lot of stories about Triple H over the years too. Some good. Some bad. It all depends on what you think of the man. As always we'll tell you what the story is, why people believe and whether we should believe it too. Here's a closer look at some of the urban legends about WWE's on screen COO, "The Game" Triple H.

10. He Is Hated By Bill Goldberg

Story: There have been a number of stories over the years about how Bill Goldberg doesn't really like Triple H. You might recall that they worked together in 2003 when Hunter put Goldberg over to become the World Champion on the Raw brand, but when Goldberg flopped as the champion it was Hunter that got the title back from him a few months later. Some might say Goldberg never had a fair shot to be "the man" and Hunter buried him quickly. A few years ago there were also reports that Triple H and Shawn Michaels told others backstage saying that they didn't think Goldberg was worthy of being in WWE's Hall of Fame. While Goldberg didn't have a long career, anybody that was a top guy (in his case in WCW) for 3-4 years is usually going to get in. He's certainly more credible than somebody like Koko B Ware. Goldberg hasn't wrestled for ten years and his name never comes up for Hall of Fame discussions, so it sounds like that opinion that he's not a HOFer could be true. It's worth mentioning that earlier this year Goldberg noted that he did talk to Triple H about possibly coming back to WWE although nothing ever happened. Why People Believe It: Goldberg only had a one year run in WWE and after he left he complained about a lot of things that happened while specifically mentioning Hunter. His name is rarely mentioned by anybody in WWE even though he was one of the biggest stars in WCW. It's as if he didn't even exist. Should We Believe It: Yes. There definitely was bad blood there. Whether it's still there or not, it's hard to tell. As we've seen in wrestling when guys get older they tend to repair relationships that were negative, so the idea of them working together in the future is a possibility. Friends? Probably not.

9. He Wanted To Quit WWE To Pursue A Movie Career

Story: During the mid 2000s, Triple H was bit by the acting bug and there were all kinds of rumors that he was contemplating a full time movie career similar to The Rock. His biggest film role at that time was in the Blade: Trinity movie starring Wesley Snipes. He did a good job in the film although it wasn't a huge hit. Aside from a few TV roles here and there, his acting career didn't take off. He did star in two WWE films The Chaperone and Inside Out in the earlier 2010s, but aside from that there's not much to speak of. Why People Believe It: Hunter has a big ego. In his mind he may have felt that if he was able to succeed at wrestling then he could be a movie star too because wrestling is acting in a lot of ways. Should We Believe It: No. It seems like one of those farfetched stories that was out there because maybe somebody in WWE wanted him to become more of a movie star since they knew he would never leave the company for an extended period of time like The Rock did. If he was able to get a big role it would have been a huge thing for the company. Hunter seems to be locked in his position with WWE and wouldn't even take a movie role if it was offered to him.

8. He Really Cares About Winning Matches

Story: When Hunter was in the prime of his career he was a top guy for many years. He had earned a bad reputation as a guy that didn't put over others very much. For this we've got this quote from a former WWE writer that provided this information to Powerslam magazine a few years ago. €œI remember being nervous the first time I delivered the script to the McMahon dressing room where HHH would dress (he would never use the locker rooms with the rest of the boys). When HHH answered I told him the RAW script was ready for his review. On the first occasion, he grabbed the script, flipped through it but did not read it, and asked me point-blank: €˜Am I f***ing going over?€™ This first time that I delivered the script to him, he did indeed win his match, so I said yes. Then he politely gave the script back to me without reading it and said, €˜That€™s all I needed to know,€™ and walked back into the McMahon locker room. A few months later when Gewirtz had another weekend off, I delivered another RAW script to him on a PPV Sunday. And it was the same routine. He nonchalantly flipped through it and said, €˜Am I f***ing going over?€™ This time, however, he was to lose his match via disqualification. He would keep his title. I said to him, €˜Well, sort of.€™ Then Hunter froze. He said, €˜What do you f***ing mean, sort of?€™ I said, €˜You lose the match via DQ, so you still keep the title.€™€˜What page?€™ he growled. After I told Hunter the page number this occurred on, he ripped that page out, threw the rest of the script to the floor in a rage, and slammed the door in my face. Needless to say, the next day during the agents€™ meeting, the script had somehow changed and now HHH won his match €“ cleanly. This was hardly an isolated incident.€ If that's true then it's proof that when he was wrestling he had a huge ego and really did all he could to use his influence backstage to stay in a top position. Why People Believe It: He has more influence than any wrestler in WWE, so if anybody could get a finish changed after it was already in a script it's probably him. Should We Believe It: It seems very possible for the most part although there have been times when he put over others too. While the times where he lost don't stand out as much, it did mean a lot when he put guys over. Vince McMahon is also the one with final say and he did book Hunter in awful storylines from time to time too, so it's not like Hunter was able to get out of stories all the time. This is one where we'll say it seems about 75% legit and 25% that the former WWE writer could have been fabricating a bit because it makes for a nice story.

7. He Was Never Truly The Top Guy

Story: Triple H was a main eventer in WWE starting in late 1999 and throughout the 2000s. His run as a top guy lasted longer than most. He deserves a lot of credit for wrestling at a high level for so long and overcoming the injuries he had to last as long as he did. Not everybody is a fan of his, though. There are some people in wrestling that aren't big fans of him. Here's how former wrestling manager and booker Jim Cornette spoke about Triple H in an interview from January 2014: "Well, I would love to give you an opinion, but I am clean and sober from WWE programming for several years now, and I do read what is going on, but it seems like it€™s more of the same. In my opinion, he was never the star, he was always the guy that worked with the guy that drew the money, and he continues to push his boring self down the people€™s throats. You know, what more can I say, I haven€™t seen it first hand, but at least he got a haircut." While he admits to not really following WWE for several years, he was paying attention to it when Hunter was at the top of the card. Why People Believe It: Cornette brings up good points when he says that Hunter worked with guys that drew the money since Hunter was in feuds with the likes of Steve Austin, The Rock, John Cena and others. Cornette's one of the smartest guys in wrestling and when he talks people should listen. Should We Believe It: Yes and no. It's a tough one because there weren't a lot of times in his career where he was the overwhelming top guy or the biggest draw. Then you look at how long he was at the top and it's hard to just ignore that. He wasn't Austin or Rock, but it's not like many guys were ever at that elite level either. Hunter deserves credit for being where he was for as long as he was. It's not easy to last at the top of the card the way he did.

6. He Was Never A Huge Fan Of CM Punk

Story: When CM Punk left WWE the day after the Royal Rumble earlier this year, he was on the brink of being put into a major storyline with Triple H that would have led to a match at WrestleMania 30. CM Punk knew this was going to happen, yet the next day when he went to talk to Vince McMahon apparently he didn't like what he was told and he ended up going home. We haven't seen Punk on WWE TV since then. Punk hasn't talked openly about why he left. He doesn't have to. However, right before he left he did interviews where he talked about having a great relationship with Vince McMahon and how they would text each other late at night with ideas because they were night owls that were friends. He didn't speak so openly about Triple H. There are also stories that have been told by former WWE writer Alex Greenfield where he quoted Triple H as saying that "this kid isn't ready" regarding CM Punk. There have been a number of stories over the years where Punk and others talked about how certain people within the company didn't really believe Punk could be a star. They rarely mentioned a name, but it's believed that Triple H was one of those people. Why People Believe It: When they feuded in 2011 it was bad for Punk. He shouldn't have been taking on a part timer like Triple H and Hunter even won their match thanks to the interference of Kevin Nash. There was no reason for them to be feuding. It angered a lot of fans because Punk was as hot as ever and the whole feud was pointless. Should We Believe It: Yes. Punk left earlier this year right before a Triple H feud. If they got along great and they were friends then he probably would have stuck around to work with him. The feeling is that Punk didn't like Hunter much and he wasn't happy that Hunter was gaining more power in the company, so he decided to walk away. It seems like a reason that makes sense although we'll never know for sure unless Punk speaks up about it.

5. He Married Stephanie McMahon Just To Get To The Top

Story: Stephanie McMahon is the daughter of WWE Chairman Vince McMahon, so there are people out there that think whoever married Stephanie would have a lot of power in WWE just because of who she is. Stephanie ended up marrying Triple H in 2003. The WWE's power couple work side by side as executives in the company. Triple H is in a position that no other wrestler is in right now. As he has mentioned many times in the past, he was sitting on creative meetings before he was dating Stephanie although his relationship with Vince's daughter has likely helped him ascend to the spot he's in. While other wrestlers just retire and work indy shows when they are done working full time, Hunter's in a position where he is am major decision maker regarding the future of WWE. Would he be in that spot if he wasn't in WWE? No idea, but it's no surprise that the husband of Stephanie is in an important role. Why People Believe It: It's wrestling. A lot of people in wrestling have done underhanded things to get what they want out of life and the people that don't like Triple H probably think he is one of those people. They were also a storyline couple before they were a real life couple, so the doubters point to that as a reason that it is not some true marriage based on love. Should We Believe It: No. They have three daughters together and appear to be legitimately in love. It's not one of those things where it looks fake. Some celebrity couples are like that, but these two work together and are around each other all the time. Obviously his marriage has helped his career, but to say that he only married her because of his job is a bit much.

4. He Refused To Put Over Booker T At WrestleMania 19

Story: Triple H was the heel World Champion on the Raw brand heading into WrestleMania 19 in 2003. Booker T was a babyface challenger that was on the rise. Even though he was a WCW World Heavyweight Champion (a title he also won in WWE), he wasn't in a spot where fans considered him a main event level performer. Booker's match with Triple H at WrestleMania 19 wasn't a main event match although it was for one of WWE's two major titles. We were used to seeing babyfaces challenges heels for major titles at WrestleMania and when that happens it usually meant that a babyface won. Prior to the match, Triple H was doing promos about how "somebody like you" (in reference to Booker) wasn't going to beat him. Some people took it to be racist although it could also be believed that he was just saying Booker wasn't good enough to beat him. Hunter ended up winning the match clean. Why People Believe It: As mentioned earlier, Hunter had the kind of power to change finishes if he wanted so there are those that believe that if he didn't want to put over Booker then he was able to get out of it. Should We Believe It: No. The World Title wasn't even a year old in WWE at that point, so WWE wanted to give Triple H a long run to establish him as a dominant champion. They also wanted Hunter to have a long title reign so that when he lost it to Goldberg later in the year it would mean something when somebody beat Hunter. It makes sense because of the storyline although Hunter's haters will probably always believe that he refused to put Booker over.

3. He May Have Used Steroids

Story: Triple H started in WWE in 1995 when he was 26 years old. Even though he had a background in bodybuilding he didn't look like one of those muscle head wrestlers that fans associated with using steroids. For the next two or three years he didn't look that big either. Things changed after a knee injury in 1998. When Triple H returned to action a few months later after that injury he looked a lot bigger. People online were mocking it calling it the "Triple H Diet" as a way of saying that he must have used steroids or some supplements to get bigger. In the summer of 1999 he ascended to the main event level. He looked much bigger than he did two years and even one year earlier. Here's how Hunter discussed the steroid subject in 2002: "I don't condone its use. But I understand its place. I don't have a problem with people who take steroids. It's a great medicine for people who need it, and it has a place in the world just like any other medication. If a doctor feels that's what you need to improve your health or life and puts you on it, then that's great. However, if you take it without any sort of prescription, then it's just like any other drug, and you shouldn't take it. It should only be given by a doctor." At no point has he ever publicly admitted to using steroids. It's unlikely that he would ever admit it. That doesn't mean he hasn't done it. It's also not a big deal because wrestling is entertainment not sport.
Why People Believe It: Look at how his body changed. It's not a natural progression. He was also much bigger when he returned to the ring in 2002 after his first torn quad injury. Should We Believe It: Yes because he probably took them at some point. His answer about using them during rehab suggests that he likely took them when he was coming back from injuries. That doesn't mean he's a heavy steroid user now, though. If you think he's 100% absolutely clean you're being naive about it.

2. The Survivor Series 1997 Screwjob Of Bret Hart Was His Idea

Story: There are so many theories and opinions about the Bret Hart/Shawn Michaels match at Survivor Series 1997 that it's hard to know what is true at this point. All we really know is that Bret had no idea that he was going to lose the way he did that night and because of that "The Montreal Screwjob" has taken on a life of its own. When WWE published a Shawn Michaels autobiography in 2005, he mentioned that it was Triple H's idea to come up with the Screwjob. Others have claimed to come up with it too, including WhatCulture's very own Vince Russo. There have been stories that maybe it was Gerald Brisco that came up with it because he was one of Vince McMahon's closest confidants. The quote attributed to Triple H in the scenario was this: "F**k him. If he doesn't want to do business, you do business for him." On the Hart/Michaels Rivalry DVD, Michaels admitted that he only thought a few three or four people knew about it beforehand, but he didn't know if it was true. Why People Believe It: Hunter has always had a great mind for the business. He's also the best friend of Michaels and at that time he was especially close with him, so he definitely could have suggested it. Should We Believe It: This is a tough one because it's one of those things where there's really no way of knowing for sure unless Vince McMahon gives the answer. He's the only one that would know who suggested it whether it was Russo, Brisco, Triple H or Shawn. For all we know it was Russo that got it in Vince's ear, then Hunter ended up suggesting it to Shawn and then Vince. There's really no way of knowing for sure although it wouldn't be that surprising if it was Hunter. It should be noted all these years later that Bret has been very critical of Hunter and called him an average wrestler, so there's still bitterness there.

1. He Cheated On Chyna With Stephanie McMahon

Story: Triple H brought Chyna to WWE. She became his bodyguard and it was well known that they were a couple. She was part of the original DX with Shawn Michaels and Hunter in 1997. She remained at his side for the next few years as well. When Hunter got his big career break in 1999 they started to break away with Chyna becoming more of a wrestler that was competing with the guys, even winning the Intercontinental Title. Hunter was a top guy that was thrust into a major storyline when, in the storyline, he "drugged" Stephanie McMahon into marrying. That led to a match with Vince McMahon where Stephanie turned on her dad. Hunter's storyline marriage with Stephanie was a big angle in 2000 when Hunter became a top guy while Chyna was still in the company. By 2001 apparently Hunter cheated on Chyna with Stephanie and Chyna's career in WWE was over that same year. Here's how Chyna explained it in a 2011 interview: "This was my love, this was my career. I need to know because I didn€™t want to lose my career. He just kept saying, €˜It wasn€™t, wasn€™t wasn€™t,€™ but his attitude had changed. I actually did the snoop. I found a love letter from Stephanie McMahon that had been dated from the previous year so I knew that there was a year affair going on. Within five minutes I called Vince McMahon and he was basically like, €˜Okay, well, the jig is up.'" Hunter went on to marry Stephanie in 2003 and Chyna is almost never mentioned by WWE. Why People Believe It: Chyna has been blackballed by WWE. She's probably not going to be in the WWE Hall of Fame even though she deserves it based on her credentials. She did hurt her cause because she went into porn after her WWE run, so they can always use that as an excuse. Should We Believe It: Absolutely. Hunter was dating Chyna, he cheated on her with Stephanie and Chyna's WWE career was over as soon as her contract was up. They absolutely destroyed her career just because they were a couple. It's pretty cruel when you think about it. Then again from Hunter's point of view he dumped Chyna to date the daughter of his boss. That's quite the upgrade. --- That's all for this week's Urban Legends feature. The three previous editions were about Hulk Hogan, Vince McMahon and The Undertaker. Let us know who you want to see next!

Contributor
Contributor

John wrote at WhatCulture from December 2013 to December 2015. It was fun, but it's over for now. Follow him on Twitter @johnreport. You can also send an email to mrjohncanton@gmail.com with any questions or comments as well.