What If... Roman Reigns NEVER Turned Heel In WWE

With no 'Tribal Chief', just how different would the wrestling industry look today?

WWE SummerSlam Roman Reigns The Fiend Bray Wyatt
WWE.com

WWE warned us that we would never see it coming on the night of SummerSlam 2020.

And they were right... for a change.

Not only did fans and many of the talents behind the scenes have zero clue 'The Big Dog' was set to spear his way back into the promotion that night, they also didn't see the exciting, white hot, and fresh Roman Reigns-led future that was heading their way in the years that followed this crucial moment in WWE history.

Everything changed that night, folks.

Reigns' days of trying to be 'The Guy' as the most generic wrestling hero imaginable were over. After wrecking both Bray Wyatt's Fiend and Braun Strowman and leaving, the industry's newest bona fide superstar was born.

And it was that dramatic and deeply unexpected decision to finally take a walk on the dark side that kicked off an often riveting (cinematic, even) spell, even against the initial backdrop of bizarre LED screens and cheers/boos.wav.

Roman Reigns Paul Heyman Jey Uso
WWE.com

WWE's long-time project had finally found himself alongside his 'Wiseman' Paul Heyman. But he also found a way to bring his family and more along for the thrilling, long-term ride, elevating Usos, underdogs, and NXT call-ups as the captivating years rolled by.

'The Head of the Table' even made the often ridiculed Universal Championship somehow feel like the most prestigious belt in the industry, too.

Turning the current era of sports entertainment into the hottest since the 'Attitude Era' wasn't a one man job, of course. But having the most badass, fascinating, and believable person in the business leading the charge certainly made a difference and then some, forcing all around him to up their game and acknowledge that the bar had been raised.

It simply cannot be understated then exactly how important the night of August 23, 2020 was in not just Roman's ongoing story, not even just WWE's, but the industry as a whole's.

So, what if none of that actually happened, eh?

What if Roman wasn't able to convince his bosses that it was finally time to leave the dull babyface schtick behind?

What if this former Shield man hadn't been allowed to burst back onto the scene with a chip on his shoulder, a newly perfect and gloriously arrogant grin, or a much-needed lack of tactical vest?

Well, for a start, this megastar may not have even decided to come back at all...


Roman Reigns Paul Heyman
WWE.com

Even before 'The Big Dog' had opted to put his family first and take a break away from all things WWE in those early pandemic days, Roman Reigns had been eyeing a long-awaited descent into darkness.

In fact, the multiple-time World Champion admitted to Ryan Satin a year on from that eventual villainous change-up that he'd been wanting to be bad since his days in the Shield. However, even with TV reactions often being split at best, the numbers from live events and tours, for example, were too strong to take a chance on pivoting away from Roman as the number #1 WWE babyface.

But even with those live event numbers still being decent enough to keep him at the top of the babyface pile, Reigns had definitely had enough of all things bark bark by the end of 2019. Paul Heyman ultimately recalled how his beloved 'Tribal Chief' felt he couldn't "go any further" in the wake of that infamous dog food mess with Baron Corbin.

And after he opted to step away for a spell a few months later, Reigns soon decided he wasn't going to be coming back as the same bland hero that hadn't gotten over in half a decade.

The Fiend Bray Wyatt
WWE

But what if the ever-volatile Vince McMahon refused to give Roman his wish?

Firstly, that iconic SummerSlam comeback would have likely been scrapped, meaning the late, great Bray Wyatt's Fiendish reign as Universal Champion may have lasted longer than a week.

Or maybe there was a world there where Reigns was given no choice but to return with the tactical vest and overly scripted promos - he was being paid to do a job, after all - before being shoved into a potentially disastrous feud against that demon clown.

Those were some dark, dark times, never forget. And it wouldn't have been all that surprising to see WWE attempt to offer some light in the darkness in the form of what they saw as sports entertainment's white knight.

Hell, they could finally control your audible response to their forced hero, too!

So, let's say Roman did do exactly what he was told like the professional fans know him to be then, and came back as that painfully stale babybully in the summer of 2020. Well, one of arguably the greatest tales ever told would never have made its way to the table...


Jey Uso Roman Reigns
WWE.com

In the time that followed the arrival of this new 'Tribal Chief' villain, Roman began engaging in an increasingly gripping family feud with his cousin Jey Uso. Horrendously manipulating his 'Right Hand Man' and bullying him over the coming months, the pair clashed in Universal title bouts that would later be described as pure "cinema".

Whether you were a fan of melodramatic monologuing and the drawn-out wars or not, there was no denying that this was something different. And that "different" was planting the seeds for a deeply compelling long-term story that is still being told today - one that has unquestionably thrown out more hits than misses over the last four years.

With no heel Roman dominating his family and eventually unleashing the Bloodline on his enemies then, the likes of Jimmy and Jey Uso would likely not have been given the space to breathe as individual performers.

Those wonderful little exchanges backstage with and about their 'Head of the Table' - Jey's inner turmoil, Jimmy's initial refusal to fall in line - helped the brothers flourish on SmackDown and eventually become easily the most interesting tag champs of the last five years. They'd even carry those belts into the main event of 'The Show of Shows', with 'Mania 39 being the first time that had ever been done.

The Usos
WWE.com

It's hard to imagine any of that being possible with those two super talented lads just acting as babyface Roman's two-dimensional sidekicks. Instead, they likely would have continued stealing the occasional show in doubles action and regularly being mistaken for the other twin, sadly.

Without Heyman by his side and perhaps not becoming the level of star he is today after no epic heel switch, it's unlikely Roman would have possessed the same degree of creative control he has for much of the Bloodline run, too.

So, you can almost guarantee he would have spent less time engaging in civil wars, and more on vanquishing moustache twirling baddies as the company continued to cram that unwanted protagonist down fans' throats.

Pulsating Civil War showdowns in London, entirely shocking Saudi and SmackDown superkicks, and enough iconic Moments to fill hours of WWE highlight packages - none of that probably goes down with a squeaky clean Roman still reigning.

And if Roman wasn't given that freedom to explore his own and utterly intriguing family affairs, all while holding the top belt, then a number of massive developments for other much-loved figures would have likely never seen the light of day...


Roman Reigns Sami Zayn
WWE.com

WWE currently boasts more ridiculously over babyfaces than they actually know what to do with.

When you really take a close look at those super popular heroes occupying the likes of Raw and SmackDown, though, their rise to becoming some of the major reasons the company has arguably never been hotter can all be traced back to Roman's jaw-dropping turn.

Without Reigns pulverising those monsters at SummerSlam 2020 and eventually taking control of WWE via The Bloodline, Sami Zayn doesn't find himself joining up with that dominant heel faction. He doesn't gradually transform into the most sympathetic underdog in the company after being abused and controlled by a maniacal 'Tribal Chief'. WWE then don't create one of the loudest nights in company history in Montreal when Zayn unsuccessfully tries to end Roman's unstoppable reign.

And Zayn and Kevin Owens' own long-term saga likely wouldn't have been gifted another few entirely gripping chapters were it not for their emotional collisions throughout the epic Bloodline tale, too.

Drew McIntyre Jey Uso - Raw Nov 20
WWE.com

A frustrated Drew McIntyre has taken the pain of having his big moment at Clash at the Castle taken away from him by Roman's crew - specifically a debuting Solo Sikoa - and used it as fuel for maybe the most complex and absorbing character in all of wrestling right now. And Sikoa himself probably wouldn't have become one of the most successful NXT call-ups of all time (that's not saying much, admittedly) without his heel family on top.

Seth Rollins wouldn't have kicked off his own effective "workhorse" run with the World Heavyweight Championship if his heel former Shield brother had done things the "right"/heroic way and defended his Undisputed WWE Universal strap more regularly.

Then you have Cody Rhodes, whose years-long mission to Finish the Story has been unquestionably enhanced by the fact a villainous former Dusty Rhodes student is still holding the title 'The American Nightmare' never won.

Whatever way you slice it, all of those adored heroes and more have been well and truly lifted by the high tide that has been 'The Tribal Chief' throughout this never-ending run at the top.

That's not to say that a world without a heel sitting at 'The Head of the Table' would have been completely horrendous, though...


Roman Reigns LA Knight
WWE.com

Roman Reigns has been holding the Universal Championship for exactly 2,300,449 days.

Or at least, it feels like he has.

And while long, dominant runs with the top strap aren't always a terrible thing in wrasslin' sphere, Roman's era of singles dominance peaked at WrestleMania 39 and has been doing more harm than good ever since.

It's highly unlikely even WWE would have had the audacity to stick one of their top straps on a massively divisive babyface for over three years.

So, with no needle-moving villain holding that Universal and eventually WWE Championship hostage, perhaps the likes of the also super popular Kevin Owens, Daniel Bryan, Drew McIntyre, Cody Rhodes, or more recently LA Knight (YEAH!) would have enjoyed another or even their first-ever WWE world title reign.

While stars like Zayn, McIntyre, and Rhodes were all able to take those heartbreaking 'L's and turn them into something positive, you could argue that Knight and Owens in particular struggled to regain their momentum in the wake of falling to 'The Tribal Chief'.

But once WWE sniffed the chance to break even more records than the attendance and gross ones smashed - with Roman and his Bloodline proving that long-term stories=money - a dumb obsession with moving Reigns up the Longest WWE Champions of All Time list began to develop, too.

The fact this entitled heel champ has barely defended the strap over the last few years has entirely undermined those attempts at making more WWE history, of course.

However, even with so many days spent chilling with his feet up at home, it's still hard to argue against Roman being a major part in ensuring WWE became the hottest promotion in town again...


Jon Moxley AEW Champion
AEW

Determined to change the wrestling world and provide a much-needed alternative to the often painful WWE experience, Tony Khan and The Elite's AEW arrived in 2019 and proceeded to become the most exciting promotion in town.

And that momentum was sustained for a good few years there, with those Elite lads (including Cody Rhodes), CM Punk, Bryan Danielson, and many more helping create not just a brilliant escape from the still regularly dreary WWE programming, but a genuine challenger.

However, the tide began to turn once Roman and the Bloodline's saga began to really intensify, with WWE seeing the chance to appeal to a mass audience and giving them more of the easy to digest and incredibly satisfying soap opera drama they were looking for.

It's safe to assume WWE likely wouldn't have been able to lure in that many eyes and take a lot of the attention away from that vibrant new rival with their rather dry 'Big Dog' holding the gold for an eternity.

WWE likely wouldn't have even had the patience to commit to that kind of slow-burn and incredibly successful tale if Roman was still doing as he was told as the smiling leading man. He would have been put through the usual cycle of often nonsensical programs before eventually dropping the belt to Randy Orton at a B show for the shock value.

But with Roman, Heyman and co. at the wheel, all involved have managed to produce countless pieces of magic, regain their audience's trust, make more popular stars out of not just the Bloodline family members, but the other heroes fighting the good fight, and have even given a certain 'Great One' a reason to dip his eyebrow back into the sports entertainment pool.

Roman Reigns The Rock
WWE

So, many of the stars you know and love today would probably be on entirely different paths.

Records may not have been broken.

WWE wouldn't possess yet another undisputed megastar.

Exhilarating long-term storylines might not have become the refreshing norm.

The sports entertainment giant possibly wouldn't be thriving in the way it currently is.

Other super hot stars also may have had the chance to really capitalise on their obvious popularity and certain stories would have perhaps been finished earlier, too.

One thing is for certain, though, the wrestling business would be an entirely different place in 2024 if this 'Tribal Chief' never changed the universe all those years ago... with the heel turn we never saw coming.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Gareth has 6 years experience writing and presenting articles/videos covering all things professional wrestling within the fantastic WhatCulture team. Gareth is also a life long wrestling fan, so is clearly living the dream!