What If... The Rock Didn't Go To Hollywood?
Charting an alternate PG era timeline.
On 17 July 2018, Forbes magazine named Dwayne ‘The Rock’ Johnson as the highest-paid actor in the magazine’s 20-year history, raking in an incredible $124 million between June 2017 and June 2018.
This is almost double the $65 million he earned the previous year, and more than any other actor listed on Forbes’ Celebrity 100 ever. Not bad, for a guy who had just $7 to his name after being cut from the Canadian Football League in 1995.
Johnson is, without question, the biggest mainstream crossover star professional wrestling has ever produced. He transcended the sport a long time ago, and now, the Attitude Era’s top attraction is an unprecedented box office smash, with roles in films like Jumanji, Moana, and the indomitable Fast & Furious franchise placing him on an earnings pedestal above everyone else.
Once one of Vince McMahon’s biggest money-making assets, Rock’s wrestling career faded as his acting one took off. He earmarked on his first sabbatical in March 2002, before taking another upon losing the WWE Championship to Brock Lesnar later in the year, and his run as an active performer effectively ended after a Backlash 2003 defeat against Goldberg.
Now restricted to sporadic appearances, Rocky hasn’t appeared live for WWE since squashing Erick Rowan at WrestleMania 32. He has been linked with a match at 'Mania 35, but given the immense physical toll wrestling supposedly takes on his 46-year-old body, this speculation should be kept at arm’s length until the man himself gives confirmation. It woudn’t be the first time the media have teased a non-existent return.
It’s easy to understand why they do. Rock is the most famous wrestler of all time, the most surefire ratings-booster in the business, and someone who has never forgotten his wrestling roots despite immense success elsewhere. On top of this, he was an era-defining Superstar whom WWE have never truly replaced. Lord knows they’ve tried, but neither John Cena nor Roman Reigns has filled that voice as a charismatic franchise player, despite their respective skill-sets.
Coupled with that of Steve Austin, Rock’s WWE departure effectively signalled the end of the company’s last boom period. Things would’ve been vastly different had he not decided to pursue more lucrative income streams on the silver screen, and had he not left (or persisted through notable box office flips like The Scorpion King (2002)), the business might be unrecognisable.
What would that mean for the man himself, his peers, and the wrestling business as a whole? Let’s theorise.
CONT’d...
To start with the obvious: the Hollywood Rock gimmick, widely considered one of the most entertaining runs of Johnson’s career, wouldn’t have happened.
The character couldn’t have existed had he not starred in The Scorpion King. Rocky would’ve likely been forced to turn heel anyway, as increasing portions of the audience had turned on him ahead of the 2002 Lesnar feud, though his unparalleled charisma means he’d have likely made it work even without the Hollywood hook.
In all likelihood, Rocky would’ve followed a career path similar to the man intended to replace him: John Cena.
He’d have remained a full-time roster member deep into his late 30s, adding countless new accolades, awards, and championships to an already glittering resume. The topic of “will Cena eventually break Ric Flair’s record of 16 World Titles?” wouldn’t have ever come up, because Rock would’ve surpassed ‘The Nature Boy’ sometime in the 2000s.
May fans have tired of Johnson as WWE’s sole franchise player in Austin’s absence? Possibly. They did so multiple times throughout his career, though each was solved by a timely face/heel turn. The company can only go to that particular well so many times, however, and diminishing returns would’ve kicked in had Rock flip-flopped continuously for another decade.
Feud-wise, his rivalry with Triple H would’ve been done to death. Old rivalries with the likes of Chris Jericho and The Undertaker could've seen revivals, and being around full-time would’ve allowed Rocky to work extended programmes with the next generation - the Randy Ortons and Batistas of the world.
CONT'd...
Most enticing of all is The Rock vs. Shawn Michaels. Their feud was supposed to go down in when HBK returned in the early 2000s, but per Dave Meltzer, Rocky refused to work with Michaels due to personal issues going back to Johnson’s first few years with WWE.
In 2005, Johnson openly told WWE.com that he never had any interest in working with Shawn. Still, him vs. Michaels would have been a WrestleMania main event-worthy dream match, and all parties would be leaving too much money on the table by not making it happen. One would imagine that professionalism and common sense may have prevailed.
Each of the above should have benefitted immensely from The Rock’s prolonged presence. Cena, however, almost certainly would not.
WWE would’ve had no need for him as an over-pushed main event commodity had Dwayne stuck around. Thus, there’s a strong chance we’d have never been subjected to his oft-painful elevation, and his years-long stranglehold on the main event scene.
That’s not to say Cena wouldn’t have become a star, but Rocky would’ve been the company’s true headliner, not him. John’s public perception may have benefited, though. He wouldn’t be as decorated, and certainly wouldn’t have made as much money, but it’s hard to imagine so many fans turning against him without the “shoved down our throats” argument. In all likelihood, he’d embark on a run similar to peers like Batista: a main event fixture, but not an obnoxious Hulk Hogan-esque figure.
But what of Cena’s intended replacement, Roman Reigns? Well, that’s a tad more complicated.
CONT’d...
Had Rocky stuck around, ‘The Big Dog’s’ emergence may have coincided with his cousin riding off into the sunset. Johnson was 41 years old when The Shield split in 2014. If he wasn’t already on a part-time schedule, he’d probably be looking at either transitioning to one or retiring outright, setting him up for a potential “passing the torch” programme with Reigns
There’s no way WWE wouldn’t use Rock’s rub to try and get Roman over as a babyface, as they did at the 2015 Royal Rumble, but would fans have been more receptive to the divisive star through a lengthier programme with his revered relative?
Much of Reigns’ backlash came from his perceived shortcomings as a performer. Not even Rocky’s magic wand could have transformed these, and he’d have still had to contend with the rise of Daniel Bryan (whose career would’ve probably panned out as it did without Rocky around, as his surge was a rebellion against his booking). This suggests he’d flop regardless.
But if Cena had never risen as such a resentful figure, and audiences weren’t already sick to death of WWE’s “top guy” being presented as a new era Hulk Hogan, maybe - just maybe - there’d be hope for Roman.
CONT'd...
Either way, the past 15 years of WWE main events would have looked vastly different. Johnson’s endearing value as an entertainer means he’d have held a top spot for as long as he wanted, and it's hard to imagine Vince McMahon relegating him from the spotlight as long as he was making the promotion money.
As great as he was, though, Rock couldn't have saved the company's plummeting TV ratings alone. His presence may have eased them somewhat, but the factors behind the slide are too big for one man to solve. WWE's declining creative department, focus on appeasing shareholders over audience members, and the complacency born of their lack of competition: they'd remain regardless.
Thus, the consequences of him staying through Ruthless Aggression and beyond would likely be more creative than financial. Many of the PG Era's brightest stars would've had to settle for smaller rules, while others may hae benefited greatly from working with 'The Most Electrifying Man In Sports Entertainment,' assuming he, himself, didn't become a Cena-esque burial merchant.
The modern product's framework would largely be the same, but the cast? Absolutely not.