WWE: 10 Biggest Things Creative Did That The Fans Didn't Want

Why is it that a customer or consumer uses a certain service or product? The answer is they like what they get. How ironic then in the case of WWE that Vince McMahon is making millions on a product that fans aren't liking. McMahon's company is of course a monopoly, the only retailer of pro wrestling in town. TNA and other companies are like a sandcastle to a fortress in comparison with WWE. It means that as bad as it gets, fans are pretty much going to keep on watching the World Wrestling Entertainment product - in the hope that things get better. The most recent example of WWE doing something with the product which the fans don't want is the usage of Daniel Bryan. All through the Autumn we have seen Bryan screwed out of the WWE title and losing matches. At the Royal Rumble, the payoff of Bryan finally putting himself back in contention was expected to take place. It seemed the perfect scenario. Bryan would win the Rumble, thus giving the Authority no choice but to put him in a straight Championship Match. It wasn't to be. WWE knew fans wanted Bryan winning the Rumble, but showing contempt for their consumer they didn't even put Bryan in the match. Instead, the popular star lost clean to Bray Wyatt in an opening bout. This isn't the first time that WWE has offered up content which is way out of line with what the customer is wanting. Here we take a look at other incidents of WWE's ideas not matching up with fans...

10. Wrestlemania 2ooo Main Event

The big heat on WWE right now is because they have monumentally screwed up a Wrestlemania main event. It makes absolute sense that Daniel Bryan should be going on last at Wrestlemania 30 to win the WWE Championship. The fans expect it, but WWE doesn't want to do it. It all harkens back to a similar misguided judgement in 2000. The WWF was at its very hottest in this period, more often than not hitting home runs with creativity. Everything seemed to be perfectly set up for a huge main event between two of the Attitude Era's biggest stars at the 16th Wrestlemania - Triple H versus The Rock. The WWF didn't need to anything with this match other than write the names of Rock and Hunter on the marquee. It sold itself. Rock was the biggest star in wrestling, at this point a huge babyface who had just won the Rumble. Hunter was a merciless heel who was holding reign over the WWF Title in a series of brilliant matches since being elevated to the main event role. Fans couldn't wait to see the bout. The WWF however couldn't resist tampering. It would have been looked back on as a legendary Mania, Triple H vs The Rock, but instead Mania 2000 is barely remembered. The reason is that Vince killed the main event with the additions of Big Show and Mick Foley. Why? Basically Foley had done some hot business in the run up to Mania, and Big Show was a recent signing who Vince wanted to be a big star. However, Show wasn't at the main event level yet, and Foley had recently retired a month earlier. They were needless additions. There was also a McMahon in every corner. The main event ended up being a forgettable four way won by HHH, when it should have been an epic one on one where The Rock had his biggest Wrestlemania moment. As an after note ... Rock got his big moment at the next PPV which sparked a huge buy number. Could something similar happen with Daniel Bryan - the next PPV after Mania 30 is after all coming from Bryan's home town in Seattle Washington.

9. Bringing Back The N.W.O

Wwenwo The red and yellow of Hulk Hogan in the 1980's WWF was iconic. As such, when Hogan finally returned to the WWF in 2002, fans wanted to see The Hulkster who was best remembered from the glory years. Fans wanted to cheer Hogan, who was viewed as the man the WWF had been built upon. Vince McMahon was on a different page altogether. The WWF brought Hogan back as a heel, cladding him in the black and white of the NWO. It wasn't a good move. WCW had beyond killed the NWO, it was a stale and uninspiring stable. The result was that Hogan ended up being loudly cheered when he was meant to be booed, most notably at Wresltemania X8 against The Rock. It worked out in some ways, because that match was hugely memorable thanks to the crowd reaction. But it is yet another example of the WWF not being in tune with the audience, fans wanted Hulkamania not the NWO. So badly received was this WWF reboot of the NWO that it was all over in a couple of months. Hogan had to be turned face and Kevin Nash tore his quad. The whole thing had been a dismal failure and a black mark in the first few months of 2002.

8. Bruno Sammartino Loses The WWWF Championship

bruno sammartino You can argue that Bruno Sammartino was the most over WWF star of all time, after all, who else could maintain at title run over nearly 8 years? Bruno did exactly that from 1963 to 1971, holding a dominant grip over north eastern wrestling in the United States. Such was his popularity that Bruno regularly sold out Madison Square Garden, becoming an icon for the Italian American working classes. It was unthinkable then that Bruno would lose the title to a hated Russian heel named Ivan Koloff. While this may have been a classic face vs heel match, the fans in no way wanted to see Bruno on the losing end. Such was the intensity of that feeling, Koloff after winning was not handed the belt for fear of a riot. It all went down on January 18th 1971 in Madison Square Garden, 22,000 fans in attendance to surely see their hero win again. The unthinkable happened when Koloff landed a knee drop that stunned the Champion, allowing the Russian to win the pin. Sammartino was beaten. The 7 year reign was over and a new Champion was made. Such was the shock that this would happen, a deathly hush is said to have came over the garden. Reportedly a pin drop would have been heard. Then people started to cry. It was 1971 and it all seemed real to many people, many in attendance absolutely heartbroken not to see their champion winning.

7. Mark Henry Takes On The Streak

When you think of great opponents for The Undertaker at Wrestlemania you think of the likes of CM Punk, Shawn Michaels, Triple H ... so what was WWE thinking when they booked the abysmal Mark Henry in a casket match at Wrestlemania 22? To be fair to Henry, in recent years he has really honed his craft. His in ring work and promos are strong these days. In 2006 however, Henry was arguably the worst performer in WWE - and here he was getting The Undertaker match at Mania. Just a year earlier Taker had contested a great bout with Randy Orton and now a year later we were having this inferior match? Fans were not happy. As expected, the match quality was poor. The added silliness of the casket concept didn't help matters, and the only good thing about this match was when the bell rang to say it was over.

6. Paul Heyman Removed As Head Writer Of Smackdown

BeFunky_paul-heyman It might seem hard to imagine these days, but there once existed a time when WWE Smackdown was far superior to WWE Raw. Not by coincidence perhaps, this time was also the period that Paul Heyman was being used as the head writer for Smackdown. From the summer of 2002 through 2003 Smackdown was spectacular. Seen by many fans as "the wrestling show" it boasted talent that included Kurt Angle, Brock Lesnar, Chris Benoit, Eddie Guerrero and Rey Mysterio in their primes. What really made these talent was the great creative they had to work with. It was Heyman who established the thrilling tag series that was a highlight of Autumn 2002 and it was Heyman who laid the groundwork for the Angle vs Lesnar feud. Fans loved it. And then Heyman was suddenly removed from power. The fans were loving the product but WWE changed it anyway. Stephanie McMahon would end up booking Smackdown and just a year later ratings had fallen dramatically. Perhaps WWE were embarrassed that Smackdown was overshadowing Raw, or more likely it was Heyman's creative differences with Stephanie that led to the decision. The big loser in all of this was the fans.

5. Removing Jim Ross From Commentary

jim ross Jim Ross is the greatest pro wrestling commentator of all time. The WWE legend has given drama to so many moments, greatly enhancing the narrative of WWE storytelling. Yet despite his obvious brilliance, WWE have on multiple occasions looked to get rid of good old JR. The reasons for this are baffling. The company first tried to ditch Ross in 2006, when WWE tried to sign UFC's Mike Goldberg. That deal never got done, with Goldberg sensibly deciding to stay with UFC. Instead WWE set about making Michael Cole the new lead commentator for Monday Night Raw. It went down in 2008 when Ross was drafted to Smackdown (by this point very much a B show) in favour of Cole on Raw. It was a terrible decision, made more unjust given that Ross had no prior indication of this - he found out live on air. By 2010 Ross was off the air completely and in 2013 the relationship with WWE was officially severed. To this very day fans still voice their upset at this - the best commentator in the business is willing and able but WWE prefer Michael Cole. What a shame.

4. WWE To PG

John Cena1 One thing WWE fans definitely didn't want was the company to go PG. In fact we wanted the exact opposite, with several calls for a return to the "Attitude Era" in the late 2000's. WWE did the exact opposite, going in the direction of PG content designed to curry favour with corporations and backers of Linda McMahon's senate bid. That's right, the WWE showed contempt for it's loyal fanbase in preference of satisfying the fickle whims of politicians and businessmen. Whilst the move has had its plus points, it often seems like we are getting "WWE Lite" with the PG enforcement. It may seem superficial, but the fact remains that all the swearing, beer drinking, sex and strong violence of the Attitude Era made unmissable entertainment. PG content in contrast is designed for kids, whereas in the past adults and kids alike enjoyed the show because it had a "cool" factor.

3. Donald Trump In The Hall Of Fame

The inclusion of Donald Trump in the WWE Hall of Fame 2013 class was met with an angry response from wrestling fans. How can we take seriously a Hall of Fame that features Donald Trump but not Randy Savage? The advantage of Trump going in was that it secured WWE some mainstream media coverage. In fairness to Trump, he also played a pivotal role in early Wrestlemanias as well as the top drawing McMahon vs Trump angle a few years back. Still, WWE did this purely as a PR stunt, with Vince McMahon himself inducting the business icon. Fan outrage was scathing. Mick Foley couldn't resist a few digs either, especially when he discovered Trump would be booked ahead of him. Foley ended up going into a meltdown on social media, with WWE officials having to change arrangement plans in order to appease the former Mankind. On the actual night a chorus of boos rained down on Trump's acceptance speech. The fans didn't want Trump, but Vince McMahon did.

2. McMahon Screws Bret

Shawn Michaels Vs Bret Hart Bret Hart was a much loved 14 year WWF veteran when Vince McMahon unceremoniously screwed the Canadian in 1997. To make matters worse, the screwjob went down in Montreal, Canada. The fans who paid good money that evening were expecting to see their hero overcome the evil American. What actually went down was a none finish that was passed off as a Michaels win. In one unthinkable move Vince had ripped off his 20,000 strong audience in attendance. Worldwide fans were equally fuming, the popular Hart had been cheated by the hated Michaels - it wasn't heel heat on Michaels, it was genuine heat. It was ironic that Vince ended up doing HUGE business off the back of all of this. Cheating the audience for most businesses would be a disaster for future trading. The opposite ended up here, spurred on by seeing this bad McMahon get his commupence, fans tuned in their droves to see Steve Austin beat the boss down. Perhaps the whole Daniel Bryan business could go much the same way, time is often the great decider in the wrestling business.

1. Austin Turns Heel

Stonecold Steve Austin is the definition of a babyface. As a beer drinking blue collar guy he pretty much felt like one of us, the WWF audience. Despite this, at Wrestlemania 17 in 2001, the unthinkable happened. In order to take the WWF title from The Rock, Austin sold out his entire character to join nemesis Vince McMahon. At the conclusion of a brilliant main event, Austin took a McMahon chair and started whaling on The Rock ... however, what should have been boos was a chorus of cheers. The simple problem is you can't turn a guy like Austin heel. He is too edgy and over as a face for it to ever catch on. To compound the stupidity, the WWE chose Austin's home state of Texas to try and get the angle over. I mean seriously WWE, what did you expect? The proud Texans cheered their home boy on as if the chair involvement was the biggest babyface move ever. The failure of this angle ultimately ended up killing the Attitude Era. The WWE's success had been based off of Austin vs McMahon with the added dynamic of Rock. This one angle killed all three aspects. Austin has since admitted he should have called an audible there and then "I should've stunnered Vince and carried on as I was."

 
Posted On: 
WWE Writer

Grahame Herbert hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.