WWE: 10 Worst Gimmicks Of All Time

Clay Woggle Gimmicks have long been a staple of the WWE - they help to sell stories, get wrestlers over, establish heels and make or break the longevity of a character. Good gimmicks are usually those which are centred around the wrestlers' personality and ability to hold both storyline and audience. Arguably the greatest gimmick in the history of WWE is The Undertaker, who has been around almost consistently since 1991, becoming more than just a simple gimmick and representing far more than "The Dead Man" Of course, other simpler gimmicks (like Doink The Clown) have been enjoyed because of their simplicity. Doink has never been achieved or hailed as a WWE Legend (except maybe in his own head) and used simply to remind WWE fans of the past and forge a link with a forgotten era. However, the WWE (like any other corporate body) is never short of bad ideas, it's bad gimmicks being some of the more infamous reminders that not everyday is a Wrestlemania 3 moment. This list counts down those considered to be the worst Gimmicks, simply because they presented either good technical wrestlers in wasteful situations, or because they destroyed legacy and tradition in favour of cheap pops and PPV ratings.

10. Repo Man

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TUloyxPWZGI We start the countdown with a rather technically gifted wrestler. Barry Darsow received much of his most well known exposure in the WWE as one half of the tag team Demolition, replacing Randy Colley as 'Smash' alongside 'Crush', going on to win the WWE Tag Team Championships at Wrestlemania IV and holding the belts for a record 16 months. Unfortunately all good things must come to an end, with Crush deciding to leave the WWE for a year and Smash being left as a singles card wrestler, who (as you might have guessed) didn't have much to do outside the typical tag gimmick that he'd come to be known for. Darsow was eager to remain in the WWE and they were obviously eager to keep him, so a new gimmick was decided, with Barry playing the role of the 'Repo Man' who would come and take back items that people had purchased on credit and not been able to keep up the repayments with. Naturally, to the largely working class fan base of the WWE, this was someone to be despised for the very act he embodied. Repo rivalled with a number of top wrestlers (including The British Bulldog and Randy Savage) and lost to almost every single one of them. His character was introduced in late 1991 and lasted less than a year; he was last featured on PPV being eliminated by Randy Savage at the Royal Rumble to officially end their feud. Repo represented a character who was almost assured to be a heel from the moment he first reposed a car on screen, his feud with Savage was originally based around stealing Savage's hat on Monday Night Raw and his matches (of which he lost virtually every one he wrestled) were lacking in the technical experience deserving of a wrestler of his calibre. Darsow and Repo made a rare appearance at Wrestlemania 17 as part of a special Gimmick Battle Royal. According to guest commentator Bobby Heenan (although this cannot be confirmed as the camera didn't pick it up) the Repo Man was eliminated first from the match, just a second after the bell rang, though we doubt that many people in attendance that night really cared too much.

9. Fake Diesel And Fake Razor

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C05BCLPIn54 Hulk Hogan's signing with WCW in June 1994 had been the first major purchase Ted Turner was to make since aquiring the brand. Although Hogan had left the WWE for Japan before any indication of his arrival in WCW, the move was closely watched by other big name superstars, who feared that their age and veteran status in the WWE would mean a swift replacement for the younger emerging wrestlers. A number of big name departures occurred in the mid 90s, two of these being Kevin Nash and Scott Hall, whose in ring persona's of Razor Ramon and Kevin Nash were extremely popular with fans. When these wrestlers left the WWE took the unusual steps of attempting to simply replace the individuals responsible for the roles and continuing on the "copyrighted element" of their character. Rick Bognar was introduced, and billed, as Razor Ramon while Glen Jacobs (who would go on to play a much more important gimmick in WWE history) portrayed Diesel. The idea proved majorly unpopular (fans consistently booed the duo) and was dropped almost immediately, despite some moderate success in the pair receiving a WWF Tag Team Championship match against Owen Hart and the British Bulldog at In Your House 12: It's Time. The last major appearance from the "fakers" occurred during the 1997 Royal Rumble match, by which point the matter had worn thin and both were gradually phased out.

8. Giant Gonzales

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zI3yQ0OGgPA The Undertaker's streak has been one of the proudest (and most profitable) selling moments for the WWE over the past few Wrestlemania. As we head towards Wrestlemania 30 in March 2014 we're reminded that The Undertaker is the most successful performer in company history to ever appear at the event - and we certainly hope he's fit enough to attend! But it's his third appearance at the annual event, in 1993 which sees him mentioned on this list because of his opponent. Jorge González (billed as El Gigante in WCW) made the move to WWE in January 1993 - appearing at the Royal Rumble match and eliminating the Undertaker. Jorge was an Argentinian basketball player who stood 2.42 m (7 ft 11 in) tall and had been drafted into professional wrestling by Ted Turner shortly after he retired from the Sport. His career in WWE was relatively short lived, with a match against the Undertaker at Wrestlemania IX being his highlight, even though he lost within four minutes. Wearing a fake body suit showing muscles and an excess of hair, the assumption was that his height made him some kind of mysterious creature to be feared, who was managed by Harvey Wippleman in order to destroy Paul Bearer's Undertaker. Gonzales had limited appeal, he wasn't a wrestler by trade and had learned very little during his time in WCW, with most of his strength based around (you guessed it) his height! By October 1993 Gonzales had made his last appearance on Monday Night Raw and within a year of his original arrival was a forgotten memory.

7. The Right To Censor

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xy1VZ4CwiZk Used as a parody of the Parent's Television Council (or PTC) the Right to Censor (or RTC) was founded by Steven Richards, who would show up on television removing the hardcore objects from matches and censoring nudity, in the same vein as the PTC who were threatening to boycott the WWE's sponsors off screen because of what they referred too as the excess of sex, language and violence portrayed. Unfortunately their popularity with fans was, well, non-exsistant as the group had chosen some of the most popular gimmick wrestlers (like The Godfather and Val Venis) to stop their sexualised routines and instead dress more like mormon preachers. It didn't help matters that the RTC were rather successful too, with consistent results for the group (who, at it's height, numbered 6) and even a Women's Championship and a Tag Team Championship in their collection. The problem with the faction was that they stood for everything the WWE didn't, although popular enough with the wrestlers themselves (Val Venis even personally requested to join RTC behind the scenes because he wanted to show more ability on his wrestling as a heel) the stable faced constant backlash from fans who just objected to their entire personna. The RTC eventually found themselves defeated, their former members returned to their original routines, before themselves fading out due to the Invasion angles and the limitation of time available for mid card wrestlers. As fate would have it, Steven Richards would blame The Undertaker on TV for the breakup of RTC, which in itself led to the debut of KroniK - and we all know how that turned out.

6. Tommy Dreamer's Time In WWE

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rx19_zdb9QA You might think I'm wrong to include a wrestler like Tommy Dreamer in a list of 'worst gimmicks' but that is, sadly, what the WWE does to wrestlers like Dreamer. Dreamer was seen as a living legend, being a former ECW Champion, he was also one of the only long standing big name talents to have crossed over to WWE immediately following the collapse of ECW. Even though wrestlers like Sabu and The Sandman would make appearances on WWE television in the years to come, Dreamer was one of the few to be among the first ECW talent to debut on July 9th 2001. Dreamer began appearing on programmes like Heat and Velocity during this time, getting involved in little of the actual main event wrestling, but instead "jobbing" and taking falls to lowly established and mid card wrestlers. Despite this having something to do with his background (Dreamer got into ECW as a jobber who could apparently withstand any pain) you'd be mistaken for thinking Dreamer was anything but the fall guy, with commenators during this period rarely mentioning anything about why this was happening. The WWE had inherited a living legend and had almost nothing to do for him. When the Invasion angle ended in November 2001, Dreamer was sent to the WWF's "farm territory" Heartland Wrestling Association, in order to both work on his own skills and help train a future generation of performers. He would later return to the WWE but would, once again, be mistreated and forced to share a toothbrush with a dog and eat food off the floor. Living the dream!

5. The Gobbledy Gooker

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JODV1xJNlrU Héctor Guerrero joined the members of his proud wrestling family when he appeared, dressed in a Turkey outfit, at the Survivor Series 1990. In this one off appearance he danced with commentator Mean Gene Okerlund and left fans wondering what the point was. The Gooker hatched from an Egg that had been featured on WWE television for months beforehand, hyped up to suggest it could have been the arrival of an incredible wrestler that would shake the WWE to its very core, which is strange when you consider less than a year later the greatest gimmick in the history of the WWE (arguably) would make his own personal debut. In any case, it's been well documented why the Gooker was despised, crowd reaction to the gimmick was extremely negative, with fans loudly booing as the costumed Guerrero danced in the ring. The commentators that evening attempted to keep up good spirits but the character was immediately scrapped and never mentioned again on air for over 2 decades. Gooker returned at Wrestlemania 17 (in the same Gimmick Royal event as Repo Man) and made an attempt to interact with Mean Gene again. Apparently as it was now 21 years later you could call what they did "retro" and therefore cool. Most of us held our breath for a match between the Gooker and Triple H (seriously, who wouldn't want that!) but have been left disappointed - even now that he hasn't been revealed as a DLC for WWE 2K14 Then again, the simple fact remains, the Gooker is not a wrestler and never fought an actual match, so what he was meant to do and why he was meant to be there still eludes us all. The fact he was eliminated after the Repo Man in the Battle Royal deserves some credit, however, as a man in a Turkey costume (with no arms) surviving longer in a professional wrestling "encounter" than a former Tag Team Champion always needs to be pointed out. Thanksgiving = Turkey?

4. Harvey Wippleman/Santino Marella (as their Female Alter Ego's)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j4LaiNj-zWg I wanted to embarrass Wippleman so I included this photo, when I could just have easily included one of him shaking hands with Arnold Schwarzenegger, but that would only make him seem cool. In 2000, he became the first and only man to win the WWF Women's Championship, in a very misguided attempt from the WWE to show they took everyone's feelings and beliefs into account when writing story lines. For some bizarre reason Wippleman entered a match under the name 'Harvina Wippleman' and quickly won the title in (and this is the only time this match has ever been held in the WWE) a "Lumberjill Snow bunny" match, a match that took place in a snow filled pool surrounded by female wrestlers whose purpose was to keep the competitors from leaving the pool. He lost the title a day later to Jacqueline (a real female wrestler btw) in a match that lasted under a minute ending the reign. What makes this so embarrassing is that Wippleman proclaimed (live on television) that he'd won the title because a woman didn't deserve to hold it. If his openly sexist comments weren't enough from the WWE writers it was the incredible mistake of repeating the incident which leaves them so high on this list. Santina Marella won an all female Battle Royal - at Wrestlemania - because he wanted to connect to his female side - in the process sparking complaints from female activist groups who argued that their already sexualised portrayal of young women on WWE television was not helped by such an overtly sexist gimmick. At least Marella can always take pride in the fact that he was eliminated from the Royal Rumble 09 in 1.9 seconds - a record which finally beat The Warlord's previous in 1989 by a tenth of a second. It's the little things.

3. Gillberg

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ci-78OxKROw Introducing a bad gimmick is one thing; but the introduction of a wrestler into the WWE who can't even wrestle is quite something else altogether. It was once listed on the WWE website that Gillberg's "finishing move" was the roll up pin, and that gives you the kind of idea what wrestling ability Gillberg lacked, in direct correlation to one Goldberg of WCW - who the character was solely created with the intention of mocking. I imagine that when the writers in WWE first suggested the idea of a wrestler whose sole purpose was to "piss off the competition" it was the kind of thing Mr McMahon absolutely loved, but in truth, it did nothing but help to make even more of a spectacle of an Entertainment Industry that was suffering during this period at the expense of cheap gags and focusing on one liners and sexual innuendo as opposed to great, technical, wrestling. I should also say that, before anyone thinks you just might be able to "try this at home", Gillberg still had to be professionally trained - he still had to be fit, agile and know how to take a fall before he even set foot in the ring. Duane Gill had been wrestling in the WWE for almost a decade before he made his debut as Gillberg - filling in as the occasional jobber you might see on Superstars and helping lower card wrestlers like the 1-2-3 Kid to actually register legitimate wins. If you don't believe me - look that up - it really happened! Gill knew his way around a wrestling ring and so the gimmick made it seemed rather absurd that the average length of his matches were about 30 seconds! In a rare show of wrestling ability, at WWF No Mercy 99 (a PPV event held right here in the UK) Gillberg faced Tiger Ali Singh - and the crowd actually cheered when he managed to begin the match by throwing a few punches and defending himself with competence. Gillberg features so highly on this list because of the decision taken by Commissioner Shawn Michaels on an episode of Raw in 1999. Obviously Goldberg was a major champion and Gillberg didn't have a chance of winning anything resembling a belt, before Michaels ordered Christian (then a member of the Brood) to put the Light Heavyweight Championship (which, itself, has now been lost to history) on the line against Gillberg. The resulting match is one of the worst examples of a title changing hands in the history of the WWE and made Shane McMahon's successful "defence" of the European Championship against Gillberg a few weeks later look credible. Gillberg retained the title (and I'm not sure he ever defended it) even after being released from the WWE - a total of almost 2 years - and was paid to make a once off return to Sunday Night Heat in 2000 in order to issue an open challenge and be defeated by Essa Rios. If that sentence hasn't put you off the WWE then I really don't know what will.

2. Hornswoggle

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YiOqP0eNoq4 I was born and raised in Dublin but the fact that he's not even Irish (born in Wisconsin) or that he was billed 'At the end of the Rainbow' has nothing to do with his inclusion here. Alright, so maybe a little, but there's still a few more very good reasons to include him. Hornswoggle made his debut as the partner of Finlay (Dave Batista, also not Irish) and quickly established himself under the gimmick of a leprechaun. Initially he was viewed as an irritant, until he helped Finlay win a title, performing what would then be called a "Lepreton Bomb" and officially be one of the worst puns ever used in WWE History. Hornswoggle proved he could wrestle (or maybe he didn't) when he won the WWE Cruiserweight Championship - in a move akin to the storyline given to Gillberg in 1999 - and then went on to have an even more astonishing story, claiming that he could be Vince McMahon's illegitimate child. Personally I think it would have been funnier to see Triple H in that position and he and Stephanie explain to the children that Mom and Dad weren't actually related it was all just pretend. To make matters worse it later turned out that HW was actually the son of Finlay, but only after Mr McMahon had beaten him with a leather belt, much akin to what he no doubt used to raise Shane all those years beforehand. If this wasn't bad enough it was his association with DX - one of the longest standing credible factions in the WWE - that puts him squarely on this list. There was no reason why the WWE needed to recruit a man who looked like a miniature Triple H to stand between him and Shawn Michaels while they bought grabbed their crotch. D Generation X, surely, would have had more genuinely offers for real members if the others had retired by that point? We hope, whatever he's doing now, that he recovers from his injuries sustained in January and decides never to return to the WWE. For all our sakes.

1. Vince McMahon; ECW Champion And Royal Rumble 99' Winner

430px Vince As Ecw Champ The boss. The Corporation. The main man. Vin-O-Mac. OK, well maybe that last one was used more for his son, who actually proved that he could take a fall every now and then. When Vince McMahon first inherited the WWWF from his own father he knew that there were a few things you could take for granted. It's probably hard to imagine that this would mean he'd one day have to go into the ring himself and defeat a professionally trained superstar. Vince McMahon is featured in the No 1 spot on this list, primarily, because he won the 1999 Royal Rumble. In his first "professional" WWE match the owner of the company managed to survive 29 other opponents (well, just one really, since both he and Stone Cold Steve Austin spent the majority of the match outside the ring) in order to dillute the very fabric of the company. This was the first time that such an obvious gimmick had been used to effect the result of a PPV event (ignoring Survivor Series 97 of course) - the fans knew there was no way that McMahon would ever be the headline at Wrestlemania XV - but they were certainly scared by the prospect. If that wasn't good enough, of course, the WWE did it again - attacking the name of ECW (which it had legally aquired anyway) by making Vince the Federation's Champion. McMahon won the Championship at Backlash 2007 - pinning Bobby Lashley in a Handicap match - and then having Lashley win the title back in a Street Fight match later that year. Of course, this was all done for PPV ratings, with ECW already failing in the charts. But McMahon's desperate gimmick to award himself a title once proudly held by the likes of Tommy Dreamer, Sabu, Christian and Jimmy Snuka meant that for the second time, through fakery, he had destroyed a longstanding heritage. Nothing ever changes then.

 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

First studied Journalism in Ireland in 2003, returning to Sunderland University on the tenth anniversary of my first studies in the subject to continue towards an MA. Interested in all sorts including WWE, Music, Film, TV and Games. Has travelled around a bit to places like California, Ontario and Mexico and plans to do more of the same soon again. Recently I've been writing pieces on my favourite topics which have included obscure theme music from nostalgic shows, Guns N' Roses and a few other surprises I'll be happy to share in time!