WWE: 4 Ways 'I Quit' Matches Can Become Compelling Again

rock mankind WWE Extreme Rules was going to see a Triple Threat Ladder Match for the World Heavyweight Championship between Jack Swagger, former World Champion Alberto Del Rio and the current champion Dolph Ziggler in what promised to be an interesting showcase of the three superstars talents. The anticipation for the match, compared to some WHC bouts in recent memory was quite high as the superstars would no doubt have some time to strut their stuff with the absence of people like CM Punk. However soon it became clear that due to a concussion Dolph Ziggler would not be able to compete in the match and the bout was changed to a #1 contender's match for the title between Del Rio and Swagger with an 'I Quit' stipulation and with that the interest waned. Many people believe that the 'I Quit' stipulation is a waste of time and has no place in the modern WWE when there are stipulations like Last Man Standing and Hell in a Cell that have similar amounts of brutality. Some believe that the match is too slow and the audience doesn't get invested in it the same way as it does with other stipulations- particularly in this age of PG. However, I don't think it should be consigned to the trash just yet. Here's a few reasons how it can be saved...

4. An I Quit Match Is Not A Submission Match

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=14DK8PTl01Y Many people who hate I Quit matches and believe they should no longer be part of the WWE really just hate submission matches- the problem is that bad I quit matches really don't have anything to differentiate themselves from submission matches and so it can sometimes seem like waiting until one opponent or the other says 'I quit' from a submission move instead of tapping. An I Quit Match therefore should be one of a brutal nature, with opponents using weapons and the like to try and beat each other down and bend their limbs in all sorts of vicious directions. The best I Quit Matches have people quitting when they are in a precarious position and are frightened of what the next blow might do to them. Or heels screaming at faces to quit as they brutally thrash them with whatever weapon comes to hand. This can admittedly put a few people on edge in this age of PG- Rated television but the fact of the matter is that I Quit matches are usually reserved for Extreme Rules or a big PPV so they can be saved for special occasions in the same way that Hell in a Cell is.

3. Use Managers More

robert rodriguez One of the interesting moments of the I Quit Match at Extreme Rules was Zeb Coulter's attempt to help Jack Swagger defeat Alberto Del Rio by grabbing Del Rio's towel from Ricardo Rodriguez. While the ref saw through this and Del Rio went on to win the match, it does obviously open up the interesting wrinkle about managers in I Quit Matches. Often the wrestlers who have participated in I Quit matches have had no managers and so this has not been raised much, but there are lots of possibilities that can be used with managers. For example, a face manager can be to used simply to encourage their superstars to greater heights or perhaps holding the microphone to the face of the heel superstar for him to say 'I Quit'. Heel managers on the other hand, can indulge in all sorts of skullduggery- as I Quit matches are No disqualification after all and there would be nothing stopping the manager laying into the babyface with a few blows of his own. But perhaps one of the most creative ways to use a manager would be for the face manager to cost his star the match by the heel wrestler attacking him rather than the star- forcing the star to say I Quit lest his little buddy get more hurt. Not only would this be a great way to allow heels to win I Quit Matches while allowing them to gain serious heat, it would protect the face from serious harm to their momentum.

2. An I Quit Match Should Act As The Culmination Of A Feud

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N4VH-Rmzkao There are some match types that need heat and a build up to make the crowd want to invest in it. A singles match can be thrown with any two competitors in the blink of an eye on a normal show- that's why it often is with little or no heat. This doesn't mean that a normal match is worse- it just means that they can be used in more situations. Some stipulations ideally require a real nasty feud. Most of the best Hell in a Cell matches have come at the end of a long drawn out battle between two combatants which culminated in a brutal match- whether it be the Undertaker and Shawn Michaels in the first Hell in a Cell all those years ago or Triple H and Cactus Jack. The mediocre Hell in a Cell matches on the other hand, are often ones that seem to be thrown together for little or no purpose (the Hell in a Cell PPV has done little to make this better ). Suffice to say for I Quit matches to work the same thing needs to apply- the crowd need to believe that the two men will brutalise each other until one simply gives up. That way, the feud can end simply because one superstar has outlasted the other in a brutal test of wills.

1. I Quit Matches Are A Great Place To Do Turns

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ObbB7L5RCH8 Picture the scene: It's Wrestlemania XXX and the Undertaker is facing John Cena in an I Quit match. John Cena is dominating the match and is beating Undertaker's aging body around the ring. But as much as he does so, the Deadman will not quit. He wills himself on. At first Cena continues to persist, thinking the words are just around the corner, but soon it becomes apparent to him that the Undertaker is proving truly tough. So Cena begins to get frustrated in a way that is not like John Cena at all. He begins screaming at the Undertaker to quit while beating him mercilessly with all sorts of implements, getting angrier and angrier. Finally, when he believes the end is near, he grabs the mike and does the 'You can't see me' sign in front of the prone Undertaker. Suddenly though the Phenom's hand shoots out and yanks Cena towards him, wrapping his legs around Cena's throat in the Hell's Gate submission. Cena can't get out, and he's screaming in pain. He tries to thrash his way out, but the Undertaker has the hold in tight and is unrelenting. Cena struggles and struggles... then he tells the referee that he quits. The Undertaker's streak lives on. The next night on Raw John Cena comes out to address the audience. But instead of apologising to them, he gets angry and defiant, claiming that the crowd don't care about how much he's done for them over the past 8 years or so. So from now on, to hell with them. This may seem a little ham-fisted but there is a point to all this. One of the major advantages that an I Quit match has is the ability to build a story in the ring. However, much of this is squandered by the fact that for the most part the I Quit match is predictable by the notion that the face is going to win. But should the face lose...then a whole new plethora of options develop for the wrestler's character going forward. And who can forget Steve Austin's own face turn at Wrestlemania against Bret Hart in an I Quit Match simply by not giving up? In conclusion, the I Quit match has the potential to be a centrepiece of many a PPV, if it's handled right. What do you think?

Contributor
Contributor

Gamer, Pop Culture consumer and WWE watcher, Vectron44 has been described as a prophet of truth, a pain in the proverbial and everything in between. Approach with caution lest you get sucked into his world of geek.