WWE: 6 Superstars Who Could Replace Roman Reigns In The Shield

BeFunky_theshield When The Shield exploded into WWE in late 2012, they made an impact not seen for years. Dean Ambrose, Seth Rollins and Roman Reigns made up the three hungry rookies from NXT who proceeded to run roughshod over the entire locker room, from John Cena and Ryback all the way to The Rock and The Undertaker. Fast forward to 2014, and the powers that be seem firmly committed to the push of Roman Reigns. Despite being the most inexperienced of the three, in the last four months he has tied the all time record for Survivor Series eliminations and broken the record for Royal Rumble eliminations set by Kane in 2001. He's also the member most over with the crowd by miles, and his split from the group is expected either in time for Wrestlemania 30 or very shortly after. You'd be forgiven for thinking this would set him up nicely for an initial feud with Ambrose and Rollins. However, wrestling insider Brian Alvarez recently stated that WWE management are looking to replace Roman to keep the stable as a three man group. Whether or not this comes to pass or if its a wise idea remains to be seen, for now we look at the likely (and not so likely) candidates. Some criteria: Reigns' move away from the group would indicate a face turn, so potential members must either become a heel or already be one. Also, Reigns is the "Power" third of this metaphorical triforce, so his replacement would most likely (but not necessarily) be a powerhouse. Aside from that, all bets are off. Now lets SPECULATE!!

6. Jack Swagger

Jack Swagger

The All-American American is currently a member of the Real Americans (I'm noticing a theme here) alongside Cesaro, with Zeb Colter as management. Now personally, I think Swagger growing a beard and pairing up with Colter was the best move in his career, he'd been stale as a character for a long time proceeding it. And when Cesaro was added to the mix, all the better. They make a strong tag team, the "We, The People!" thing was over with the audience, and Swagger's never been that good on the mic, so giving him someone to act as a mouthpiece made sense. However, there's a problem.... Over time, the whole xenophobic, mock tea-party gimmick got kind of silly (ironically, mostly due to Zeb Colter; you can only twerk and carry signs with bad puns on so many times before you sacrifice your dignity). On top of that, due to amazing feats of strength and swinging his opponents, Cesaro got popular with the crowd, whereas Swagger.... not so much. With Cesaro seemingly aimed for the title picture, management seems to be speeding towards the Real Americans breaking up, which would be a real step back for Swagger. If he splits from Colter, he still needs a mouthpiece. Fortunately, if The Shield have a vacancy, he'll be partnered with one of the best mouthpieces in the business in Dean Ambrose. Swagger has the strength to be Roman's rival, and he would add a technical, submission-based style to the group that, for all their strengths, The Shield have never possessed. For all the positives, I don't see this happening. Its a random addition to The Shield and moves Swagger nowhere on the ladder, a step sideways rather than up or down. Odds: 65-1

5. Brodus Clay

The former Funkasaurus seems determined to leave his goofy dancing image in the past. A move to The Shield could do it! It may strain credulity to look at him now, but before Clay moved to the main roster, his vignettes made him look like a monster. It was actually him who came up with the "Hall of Pain" gimmick that eventually went to Mark Henry, whereas poor Brodus got stuck with Rikishi's old one. But since breaking away from his former dancing partners, he's been kind of adrift. This could be just the direction he needs. That being said, Clays past as the big dancing guy seems to have damaged his credibility beyond repair in the immediate future. For maximum effectiveness, he needs a bit of time away from the spotlight before coming to re-establish himself as a monster heel. Besides, where are you going to find a protective vest to fit him?? Personally, I don't see it. In time, if he doesn't end up Future Endeavoured, Clay could make it as the monster heel he was supposed to be. Would he benefit from joining The Shield? Definitely. Would The Shield benefit having him as a member? No. Odds: 95-1

4. Ryback

Ryback came into the company as a face, then a weird kind of bully heel, then Paul Heyman's weird fiancé-type.... thing, before now settling into a tag team with Curtis Axel which is basically Heymans Handmedowns. To say he is in a rut would be an understatement. He went from being an unstoppable machine in his debut to being everybody's favourite jobber. Oh, and he's still followed around by those Goldberg chants. If anyone in the current roster could do with a change of direction, its this guy. No-one deserves to be in a team called Rybaxel, that's just cruel. But he has taken so many losses in this past year that his stock has plummeted, he needs a big change to get him back in the game. Joining The Shield could be just the thing for him, what better way to re-establish himself as a dominant monster than by beating down Roman Reigns? We KNOW Roman is a serious powerhouse, so leading a beatdown on him is as good a way as any to get some credibility back. As Ric Flair always said, "to be the man, you gotta beat the man" and in the eyes of the WWE fans, Reigns is definitely the man. It's a good match, and if they go with anybody on the current roster, Ryback is one of the most likely. He'd definitely suit the uniform more than he does Rob Van Dam's old singlets. Personally, I think he'd be better served if he allowed his sarcastic troll persona that we see so often on twitter to be part of his in-ring character, but The Shield could do worse, and so could Ryback Odds: 12-1

3. Alexander Rusev

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xxliSwDrKuM If you weren't aware of Alexander Rusev before the Royal Rumble, you DAMN sure were afterwards. He copied Bo Dallas' feat of the previous year of entering the Rumble match straight from NXT, causing most wrestling fans to cry out "who the hell is this jobber?!" And while he didn't eliminate anyone, he looked very impressive with the big dogs, and was only eliminated with the efforts of four men. Since then, he's appeared in numerous vignettes on Raw and Smackdown hyping his imminent television debut, alongside his translator/valet Lana. Is he right for the job? A powerhouse, he certainly is. The Bulgarian Brute mixes mauy thai style strikes and grapples with old school wrestling. He even uses a camel clutch as his finisher which he calls The Accolade. Could he step up to Reigns in terms of power? I'd like to see them go at it, put it that way. Again, however, the differences that set him apart from Rollins and Ambrose may be too great. His characters language barrier is a big potential stumbling block. Lana would also come along as part of the deal, adding a female dynamic to the stable for the first time. That's not to say he couldn't work as a member of The Shield, but you'd know for definite that it was a short term thing. Odds: 18-1

2. Mason Ryan

Welsh Batista. Need I say more? So far, we've only looked at potential replacements from the main roster. Which is fine, but ultimately, not as realistic as the alternative, which is taking possible recruits from the place where The Shield came from in the first place, NXT. Mason Ryan has been languishing in the developmentals ever since The New Nexus was abandoned by CM Punk due to "the pipebomb" But in his day, he took on the likes of Kane and The Big Show. In the 2011 Royal Rumble, he eliminated The Great Khali by himself, so he definitely has "Big Guy" credentials. He's a former FCW champion, an accolade which has also been held by Seth Rollins. Could he be the one to replace Roman Reigns? Its very possible..... He has equal, if not greater strength than Reigns, he stands a few inches taller, which could help to sell Reigns as the underdog in what would probably be a handicap feud where he needs to overcome the odds to truly break away from his former teammates. And lets not forget the importance of fitting in, he'd look right at home in combat boots and a stab vest. Mason Ryan is due a return to the big time in the future. But I think the key here is "in the future" He has a little bit more time to kill in NXT before jumping back up, in my opinion Odds: 7-1

1. Corey Graves

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EOun9Q0GmGY I am at a total loss as to why Corey Graves has yet to be called up to the main roster. It's completely inconceivable to me. He has a look like no one else in the company does right now, he has excellent mic skills, and more importantly, he can WRESTLE. Whereas nearly everyone else on this list would play the power game with Reigns, Corey Graves has the cold ruthlessness of the Cerebral Assassin and the submission skills of a young Lance Storm. Why play the power game when he can get over on Reigns just as easily by making him tap out? He will target a body part and pursue it like a shark that senses blood. Is he the one to replace Roman? I think so. Like Rollins and Ambrose, he has a ton of experience on the independent circuit. He has a ton of experience in tag teams and has achieved success in stables and as a singles wrestler. It'd be a bit of a swerve to most people, who would EXPECT another big strong giant like Reigns, whereas Graves, skinny and diminutive as he is, is a whole other kind of deadly. He is a calibre of technical wrestler that we NEED on the main roster. Above all else, he would FIT with Ambrose and Rollins. I see him in the Shield uniform alongside the other two, and I believe it. And when the time comes for The Shield to eventually disintegrate, he will have no problem standing out from the crowd. And that's why he is my odds on favourite. The call up time is finally here with odds of 3-1. Those are my picks on who could fill in the gaps in The Shield. Can you think of any more? Let me know your thoughts!

 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stephen Maher has been a rock star, a bouncer, a banker and a busker on various streets in various countries. He's hung out with Robert Plant, he was at Nelson Mandela's birthday and he's swapped stories with prostitutes and crack addicts. He once performed at a Gay and Lesbian Mardi Gras by accident. These days, he passes the time by writing about music, wrestling, games and other forms of nerdery. And he rarely drinks the blood of the innocent.