WWE: 8 Most Shocking Results In Extreme Rules History

Extreme Rules has offered up several shocking results over the years, outcomes we never would have predicted. The event returns this weekend, with The Shield taking on Evolution in the main event. If history is anything to go off, anything could happen. If there has been one event over the years which has genuinely surprised us fans, it has been Extreme Rules. That's what has made the event so interesting since it first started in 2009, the knowledge that WWE likes to book some crazy results on the show. Surprise as much as 'extreme' has became a staple of the event. The origins of Extreme Rules actually started out at the ECW One Night Stand show. When that brand became defunct, WWE directly stated that the 'Extreme Rules' pay per view was a continuation of the hardcore event. As such, we get all the extreme gimmicks of an ECW show, but under a WWE banner. By filling the One Night Stand spot, Extreme Rules is the last remaining vestige of ECW in WWE, which perhaps explains the 'shock' factor in match results, something ECW was noted for. Just some of the shocking results that occurred on Extreme Rules's previous incarnation as One Night Stand included Lance Storm beating Chris Jericho in 2005 and Rob Van Dam beating John Cena in 2006. More than that, we had the plain bizarre in Bobby Lashley defeating Mr McMahon in 2007. The most shocking result may have been Edge beating The Undertaker at One Night Stand 2008, which meant Taker had to leave the WWE (he was back by SummerSlam of course). Extreme Rules has kept the tradition up, with 8 shocking results in particular...

8. Jeff Hardy Defeats Edge For The World Title - Extreme Rules 2009

Edge won the World Championship in 2009 by beating John Cena in a last man standing match at Backlash. Following that victory, you might have expected Edge to run into the Summer as 'the man' in WWE. One person standing in his way was Jeff Hardy, the daredevil athlete who was breaking into the WWE main events in a career rejuvenation. Hardy had previously won the WWE Title back at Armageddeon 2008, where he had pinned Edge in a triple threat also including Triple H. Despite Hardy's booming popularity, it was Edge who was World Champion in June 2009, Hardy was merely the pretender to the throne. All that was about to change. Extreme Rules 2009 marked the night that Jeff Hardy finally got a decisive one on one victory over Edge. It came in a ladder match, the contest they had both made famous back in the Attitude Era. In an epic main event which was rammed full of stunts, Hardy shockingly dethroned Edge to become the new World Champion. It should have marked the start of the Hardy era, Jeff seemed primed to become a huge star and the number two guy in the company. Not so fast however...

7. CM Punk Defeats Jeff Hardy For The World Championship - Extreme Rules 2009

Unbelievably, just moments after Hardy had defeated Edge for the title at Extreme Rules 2009, CM Punk came down to the ring with the Money In The Bank briefcase he had won at WrestleMania 25. Hardy looked on in shock, Punk was cashing in his title shot, against a man who had just competed for 20 minutes in a hurt filled ladder match. This underhanded tactic served to turn Punk heel, Hardy could barely stand, the audience were stunned at the turn of events. A shock within the shock was that Hardy actually managed to kick out of a GTS Punk used. The under siege star then managed to wrap up Punk in an inside cradle pin. Would the new Champion actually survive the cash in attempt? No, Punk resolved to get his shoulder up, recovering to hit a kick to the head and another GTS. This time it was enough, Punk won the 1-2-3, making him the new Champion. It was a result nobody could have expected at the start of Extreme Rules 2009, first Hardy dethrones Edge for the title, then CM Punk shocks the world by cashing in 'money in the bank' to defeat Hardy. As the new heel champion and with Hardy a sympathetic babyface, Punk vs Hardy went on to be the feud of the summer.

6. Jack Swagger Beats Randy Orton - Extreme Rules 2010

It seems hard to believe now, but WWE really did believe Jack Swagger would be a future main event icon. Swagger was set on the push of his life in 2010, he won the Money In The Bank Contract at WrestleMania 26, going on to successfully cash it on Chris Jericho to become World Champion on the March 30th Smackdown. WWE supplemented this with a successful title defence against Jericho and Edge on Smackdown a few weeks later. The push didn't stop there. On April 25th, Swagger defended the belt against Randy Orton in an 'Extreme Rules' match at the Extreme Rules pay per view. Shockingly, Swagger beat Orton cleanly, reversing an RKO into a gut wrench powerbomb. This marked wins over three WWE legends in the space of a month, Orton, Edge and Jericho, all defeated by Swagger. You can't ask for much of a better push than that! For Swagger though, he just clearly didn't have what it takes to be a main event star. He squandered everything WWE gave him in that initial spot, ending up in lower midcard feuds by the end of the year. The company tried again with Swagger in 2012, pushing him hard as the number one contender to the world title at WrestleMania 29. Once again, Swagger failed miserably, even getting busted for a DUI during the build up. His Extreme Rules victory over Randy Orton in 2010 was wasted effort.

5. Sheamus Beats Triple H - Extreme Rules 2010

Also taking place at Extreme Rules 2010 was Sheamus vs Triple H. This was a brawling feud which had started at Elimination Chamber, taking in WrestleMania 26 where 'The Game' had left victorious. The reality behind the pair working together was that they got on well backstage, they trained in the gym together and Hunter like Sheamus's attitude. Truth be told, it was probably as much a case of 'flattery getting you everywhere'. Extreme Rules 2010 was a continuation of the feud, the two foes this time meeting in a 'street fight'. The Irishman had attacked Hunter at the start of the event with a pipe, building upon this with further blows in the actual match. It was a full on brawl, which Sheamus eventually won, defeating Hunter after a string of brogue kicks. This result was a remarkable thing when you consider how little Triple H loses, it remains arguably the biggest win of Sheamus's career, the victory that established him as a big deal in WWE. Hunter sold it fantastically, he didn't return to television for another 10 months.

4. Christian Defeats Alberto Del Rio For The World Title - Extreme Rules 2011

This one had been long awaited, so much so that when it finally did happen, it felt like a real shock. Christian overcoming Alberto Del Rio for the world title at Extreme Rules 2011 was remarkable for so many reasons. It was his first big championship win for one thing, but beyond that, it was also a tribute to real life best friend Edge who had retired as Champion just a month previous. This was a really emotional moment for us fans who had followed both Edge and Christian's career for so long. The other remarkable thing was that Christian won the title in a ladder match, the gimmick he and Edge had made famous. It felt like Christian's career had finally come full circle. What made the moment all the greater was the fact that the battle had been so good, Del Rio and Christian worked through a spot filled classic, with plenty of great technical work to boot. We finally witnessed what we thought we never would, Christian as a WWE World Champion.

3. Cody Rhodes Beats The Big Show - Extreme Rules 2012

The Big Show was making his first Intercontinental title defence when he ran up against Cody Rhodes in a 'Tables Match' at Extreme Rules 2012. As the new Champion and a good guy, most people expected The Big Show would beat the cowardly Rhodes. This wasn't to be the case. In an inventive finish, Rhodes won the match, hitting a dropkick which sent Show stumbling on a table. The key word is 'stumbling', Show wasn't actually knocked through the table, what actually happened was he steadied himself with his foot against the table - the force of his weight proving enough to break the wood. This proved a great spot, with some questions even being asked if the table break had been accidental, handing the win to Rhodes by unscripted default. The truth is it was meant to break, that's the brilliance of the subtlety of this spot, it was so convincing that it got people talking. The win helped give Rhodes a boost, protecting Big Show's integrity at the same time, he had lost by 'accidentally' breaking a table as he steadied his foot.

2. John Cena Pins Brock Lesnar Clean In Lesnar's First WWE Match Back, Extreme Rules 2012

Not just one of the most shocking results in Extreme Rules history, this was one of the most shocking results in the entire WWE history. It was an excellent match, full of hard hitting spots and weapons, but the result was completely unexpected. Brock Lesnar had been away from WWE for 8 years, in which time he had took up MMA and became UFC Champion, enjoying success as the biggest box office sensation outside of Floyd Mayweather. So what did WWE with the celebrity tough-guy who had been easily smashing a million buys a pay per view for UFC? They brought him in and instantly had him lose clean to John Cena. Nobody seen it coming, everyone figured there was no way Lesnar could lose, WWE had paid him too much money. In this sense, Lesnar vs Cena ended up being similar to Undertaker vs Lesnar at WrestleMania 30 where people had figured there was no way Undertaker could lose. When the unexpected result happened, it got people talking in a massive way - here we are two years after Extreme Rules 2012 and we still find it shocking. Perhaps it's good for WWE to throw these curve balls from time to time, but in the case of Lesnar's 2012 comeback, he really should have been the victor. One Cena 'Attitude Adjustment' on the steel steps and Lesnar was a loser, severely damaged in his stature as a tough guy.

1. John Cena Fails To Beat Ryback, Extreme Rules 2013

Extreme Rules 2013 John Cena Vs Ryback Ok, so Cena could beat Brock Lesnar at Extreme Rules 2012, but he couldn't overcome Ryback a year later at Extreme Rules 2013? The fact Ryback was in a WWE title match was shocking in itself, the fact it went 23 minutes was a further and unpleasant shock. This just wasn't very good, Ryback's heel character was nowhere near over enough, his physical style just wasn't built for long matches. Cena tried his best to make things work, WWE helping them out by having a 'Last Man Standing' stipulation. The bout just couldn't get interest, no matter what short-cuts were attempted, fans saw through this match for what it was. The shock at the end was that neither man answered a 10 count. Ryback slammed Cena through an electronic stage wall, rendering both himself and Cena incapable of standing up. The groans of the audience said it all, the crushing realisation setting in that WWE intended to continue this feud. The result sucked - Cena could beat Lesnar, he could beat Rock, but he couldn't beat Ryback. On this type of booking form at the annual 'Extreme' event, don't be surprised to see some 'shocks' at Extreme Rules 2014.

WWE Writer

Grahame Herbert hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.