WWE: Does Pro Wrestling Need Mystery in Storylines?

Over the years, Pro Wrestling has always attempted to surprise and shock its audience. In fact, the very core of the Sport is designed to fool, or 'work' viewers into believing what they are watching is genuine combat. Despite this fact, further attempts to try and pull the wool over the fans eyes have often seemed to have fallen flat. This is not necessarily true in regards to the illusion itself, but perhaps more so with the reveal. The subject being pertained to in this article is the place of mystery storylines surrounding the squared circle. With TNA Wrestling's Aces & Eights storyline apparently beginning to lose traction with fans, perhaps there is a question to be asked of mystery angles within Professional Wrestling. Every major Wrestling Organisation has had it's fair share of attempts at trying to create suspense and heightened excitement through a storyline that surround the 'Who Did It?' Or 'Who Will It Be?' angles played out on Wrestling programming throughout history. However, a lot of the time these reveals seem to be very poorly received, or interest is lost before the revealing moment arrives. Hollywood Thrillers and TV Crime Dramas are based around the very foundation that viewers are invested and intrigued by the investigation and the revelation, but why can't Pro Wrestling seem to tap into this facet of its viewers minds? This article will look at the reception to different mystery angles throughout the years, look to determine if there really is a place for them in Pro Wrestling storylines, and whether or not there is a given formula to getting them right.

Mystery debuts seem to always be a hit with fans, if the identity of the Superstar who is debuting is not widely known by them before it happens. Take for example Kurt Angle's debut in TNA. For weeks leading up to the No Surrender 2006 PPV there was word that a 'Big Surprise' would be occurring at the event. It came as a massive shock when the multiple time former WWE Champion was revealed through a video package on the night, very shortly after leaving the rival company. Because this was such a well guarded secret from fans, the announcement made huge waves with fans and critics, and can certainly be seen as one if the more successful reveals to a surprise. But was it the Superstar name of Kurt Angle that gave this such a positive response? It certainly added to the shock value, but it wouldn't seem it is entirely necessary to have a huge name in order to get this quality of reception. When Chris Jericho debuted in the WWF in 1999, he certainly didn't hold the name value he does now amongst Wrestling fans. He was certainly known for his work throughout Japan and WCW, and was a recognisable face, but he wasn't on the level of stardom Angle had when he jumped ship in 2006. In this case, the parallel to the Angle reveal was mainly in the fact that nobody seemed to really know who it would be. The WWF had done a great job building up the anticipation of the reveal with a weekly countdown to the moment, which is not an easy thing to do other a lengthy period. This however is something that will be touched on further on in this article.

So if well guarded mystery debuts work for singles Wrestlers, does this translate to reveals of mystery tag partners? Perhaps the most famous occurrence of this, Hulk Hogan joining the nWo, would suggest keeping the mystery in tag partners can be just as successful as singles combatants. On the flip side however, you have a moment like the Shockmaster debuting as a mystery partner in WCW in 1993, which could be seen as close to evening the scales when it comes to the success/fail ratio in this situation. Granted, the Shockmaster was somewhat of a unique case due to just how horribly wrong everything went with the reveal of that particular character. Watching it today will still bring a chorus of laughter from any fan, whether it be down to the fall or the glitter covered Stormtrooper helmet. I digress... Partner mystery reveals do seem to have more of a success overall. Owen Hart revealed Yokozuna as is mystery partner at Wrestlemania XI, and the team beat the Smoking Gunns for the WWF Tag Team Championships in the match up following. With Yoko having not been seen on WWF programming since Survivor Series the previous year, this was a surprise reveal and fans responded to the former WWF Champion being the man Hart had chosen. With the success rate of surprise debuts and mystery partner reveals being generally high, it would seem mystery angles do indeed have a place on Professional Wrestling TV. It seems however that when angles tend to go down the 'Who Done It?' route things tend to become a little less well received...

The Higher Power of the Ministry and Vince McMahon's Limo blowing up were two storylines involving the Chairman of WWE that did not get quite the reception the company perhaps thought they would. Of course, the Limo incident was cut short due to the death of Chris Benoit, but this seemed to really push the boundaries of Pro Wrestling believability from the very start, and fans never seemed to get into it before it got anywhere near the reveal. Another 'Whodunit' that ultimately seemed to fall flat was the storyline surrounding who ran over Stone Cold Steve Austin in 1999. This story spanned the majority of a year, and the man revealed to be the culprit was dancing big man Rikishi. It seemed this was designed to propel Rikishi into the main event as a heel, however the push never really seemed to take with fans, and the initial shock reveal of someone not many would've thought looked to be a bit let down by the follow up. Arguably, this storyline is mostly remembered for Rikishi's storyline reasoning for the act, 'I did it, for The Rock'. Perhaps even more memorable was The Rock's impression of this line in a promo shortly after. With the Whodunit angles not seemingly gaining much traction throughout the years, what about the 'Who is it' storylines? Vince McMahon again was involved in a not so successful mystery angle attempted from this approach, when there was a lengthy search into who his illegitimate son was in 2007. When it was revealed as Hornswoggle, there seemed to be quite a level of discontent amongst fans. Another reveal that, after many guesses from Wrestling fans, seemed to disappoint was Diamond Dallas Page being identified as the stalker of The Undertaker's then wife, Sara. For weeks, video footage the alleged stalker had been taking was shown on WWF TV, and whilst many fans had their theories on who it may be, it didn't seem many had top WCW babyface DDP on their list of potential stalkers. When this culminated in Undertaker and his brother Kane facing off against Page and his partner Kanyon, it can be seen that it didn't really give the payoff many fans expected. More recently in 2011, WWE presented viewers with the mystery of who text Kevin Nash to take out CM Punk after his Summerslam encounter with John Cena. Initially, this storyline seemed to garner a lot of attention, with a big list of suspects being discussed between fans as to just who it may be. When this was revealed to be Kevin Nash himself, and all other potential suspects surrounding the situation falling out of the picture completely, fans seemed to be a bit let down by this, and what could have been a potentially intriguing, drawn out story was over before it started with a resolution that didn't really sit well with viewers. One of the biggest 'Who is it?' mysteries was the identity of the final combatant of the Deadly Game tournament at Survivor Series 1998. Leading up to the event, many fans were speculating to who it may be, for it only to be revealed as Duane Gill. In storyline purposes, it did make sense as at the time, Vince McMahon was facilitating an easy route for Mankind through the tournament. However with fans getting great ideas in their heads as to who it may be, many seemed to feel let down by the man who would go on to be Gillberg.

So what is the difference between debut/partner reveals and mystery Whodunit based storylines that arguably results in such a gulf in success rate? Perhaps it's because of the length of time they run. Every Pro Wrestling fan likes to fantasy book, speculating in their heads what may happen next in any given storyline or even match. Fans are encouraged to do this by the form of entertainment they are watching. It is part of what makes viewers tune in each week, seeing if what they thought would happen would come true, or if the bookers will pit Superstars they want to see against one another. One drawback to this that goes against the plan of long term mystery angle booking though, is that it seems to give fans too much time to think up their own 'perfect' scenario as to who would be revealed as the person behind the given actions. When the reveal does not match what a fan thought might happen, inevitably in the main they feel let down, as a lot of the time the identity of the Superstar or Superstars is not on the level of who that fan thought it may be. This could arguably be the trap TNA are now falling in to, with many fans speculating as to the members and particularly the leader of the Aces & Eights group. As each week goes by, fans may be expecting a bigger and bigger reveal, to the point that when it happens they are likely to be disappointed. Debuts and mystery partners potentially look to resonate more with viewers because they're quick shot affairs (with a few exceptions such as Chris Jericho as mentioned earlier in this article). Also, debuts in the past have tended to be built up with quick vignettes and teases, whereas often Whodunit storylines will have a primary focus on an Organisations weekly TV shows. An example of a short Whodunit angle that could be seen as backing up the point that shorter is better, was the reveal of HHH as Shawn Michaels attacker ahead of Summerslam 2002. This was revealed very shortly after the initial act, and seemed to get the fans fully invested in the angle as intended. The danger is also that running too long with these stories can lead to them being left unresolved for years, and the ending having to be retrofitted later if at all. For example, the Anonymous GM storyline, which had the intended comedic resolution of having Hornswoggle behind it earlier this year. There have been many a mystery storyline in Pro Wrestling over the years, but perhaps fans will always make up a better ending in their heads than the script ends up giving them. If viewers were to be presented with quicker resolution, the results may become more satisfying.

 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

A watcher of Professional Wrestling since 1989, in that time has filled up too much of his mind with knowledge of the subject. Tries to see Wrestling from the viewpoint of all types of fan, once refereed an event during his teenage years and got a grazed chin from a Superkick to the face. Follow his daily musings on Twitter - @lmheir