WWE No Mercy 2016: Ranking Every Match From Worst To Best
The Miz steals the show (again).
Mediocre. That's one word to describe Smackdown Live's latest PPV event, which was 50% sub-TV fodder, 25% forgettably decent and only 25% good enough to actually be worth remembering.
It's not much of a surprise, as anyone who studied the card could probably figure it out for themselves, but it really only added more fuel to the fire that these brand-specific events invite low-effort booking for an easy buck.
Sure, there were quite a few satisfying results, but real quality wrestling was depressingly fleeting, and it just didn't do much interesting to move these storylines and characters forward.
Still, at least there was the amusing novelty factor of the main event going on first and the show closing out with an extremely anti-climactic final match. Cross your fingers for October 30th's Hell in a Cell showing a little more in the way of effort.
Here is every WWE No Mercy 2016 match ranked from worst to best...
8. Alexa Bliss Vs. Naomi
Result: Naomi counters Alexa's Cross Arm Breaker into a sneaky pin (5:25).
Rating: This one was doomed from the outset because pretty much everyone watching was massively deflated by not only the absence of Becky Lynch but her unimaginative replacement being...Naomi.
The live crowd were dead throughout and clearly just wanted it to finish as soon as it started. It didn't do a whole lot egregiously wrong exactly: its worst crime is merely being a forgettable, fairly dull match, complete with a bizarre anti-climax of a finish that felt like swerve booking for no sake but its own.
It made a lot of sense for Alexa to win here building towards her rescheduled November match against Becky, but alas, no dice. 4/10
7. Jack Swagger Vs. Baron Corbin
Result: Corbin beats Swagger with the End of Days (7:30).
Rating: Another TV-bait match few could really even pretend to care about, this one wasn't bad by any means but it just wasn't very interesting either, and really had no business being on the PPV.
If there was any time to turn over and watch any one of the billion other things that clashed with No Mercy as it went out live, this was it.
Still, the End of Days finish looked great, so there's that. However, with no intent of picking on the guy, Swagger might want to hit the gym because his physique appears to be slacking right now. 5/10
6. Nikki Bella Vs. Carmella
Result: Nikki nails Carmella with the Rack Attack 2.0 for the win (8:05).
Rating: It's safe to say there wasn't a ton of excitement for this (especially after that thrilling opener and then cruelly teasing Orton vs. Wyatt as the next match), but it was a fairly solid fight on the whole with Carmella delivering some of her most consistent work since being called up to the main roster.
Ring psychology was also better than expected (especially Carmella targeting Nikki's neck), but it ultimately felt like TV fodder filler, because that's exactly what it was. The bulk of it probably exited your mind before the show was even over: just totally down-the-line fare. 5/10
5. Randy Orton Vs. Bray Wyatt
Result: With the help of a distraction from a returning Luke Harper, Wyatt nails the Sister Abigail for the win (15:40).
Rating: It was incredibly suspicious that this match started with 40 minutes of the show still remaining...but it simply led to a very early finish.
This one had a slow start and failed to pick up much throughout, lacking energy or anything resembling a big fight feel. It sounds like a broken record on this show, but again, it was basically a TV match through and through with no "specialness" whatsoever.
The ending was also incredibly lame even if it was great to see Harper back. Doesn't Bray deserve a clean win after so much relentless PPV jobbing? 5/10
4. Smackdown Tag Titles: Heath Slater & Rhyno (c) Vs. The Usos
Result: Rhyno gores Jey Uso to retain the titles (10:20).
Rating: The ending seemed pretty clear-cut from the outset, so what a surprise it was to see the unlikely champs actually retain.
Slater got to nail some excellent high-offense (such as that Top-Rope Powerslam) and prove how under-valued he's been for years, so hopefully WWE are paying attention to how warmly the crowd are receiving him: perhaps that's exactly why they didn't drop the titles here.
It probably ran longer than it needed to and the decision to have the Usos lose is quite odd given their heel repackaging, but if it keeps the belts on Rhyno and Slater, it's no bad thing. Solid work all-around. 6/10
3. American Alpha & The Hype Bros Vs. The Vaudevillains & The Ascension
Result: Jordan and Gable drill English with the Grand Amplitude for the pin (9:00).
Rating: This was certainly an above-average pre-show match, largely enhanced by the immense physicality and athleticism of American Alpha, even if they probably weren't in the ring as much as most fans would like.
8-man tags tend to be so frequently, surprisingly boring, but this one kept the pace up for the most part and ended strong with a frantic breakdown with everyone getting a moment to shine. You probably won't remember you saw it in a week or two, but it was totally solid for what it was, and got the crowd pumped for the actual PPV. 6/10
2. World Title: AJ Styles (c) Vs. John Cena Vs. Dean Ambrose
Result: AJ kills Cena with a steel chair before scoring the pin to retain the title (21:40).
Rating: It's safe to say this is one of the greatest opening matches in No Mercy history, right?
This was electric from the outset, and it helped that the crowd were so fresh and fired-up. Also, it wasn't just your usual "two guys pair off while the third guy sleeps" Triple Threat laziness, and they really emphasised the brutality that the No DQ rule allows.
Things got confusing and intense after AJ tapped out, teasing a Dusty finish but thankfully not committing to it. Still, the steel chair ending was admittedly pretty weak, especially for someone as talented as Styles, and does bring it down a point. Still, a very enjoyable "main event" on the whole. 7/10
1. Career Vs. IC Title: The Miz (c) Vs. Dolph Ziggler
Result: Dolph kills Miz with a Super Kick to win the title (19:45).
Rating: As just about everyone has complained about already: why the hell didn't this go on last instead of the mediocre popcorn fart that was Wyatt vs. Orton? It makes no sense at all.
Anyway, this was the decisive match of the night, and the only thing that came remotely close was the opener. The build and booking for this match was excellent, as it really felt like either man could win, and Dolph could really be leaving WWE for good.
The Miz again shows how brilliant he can be with the right story and opponent, keeping up with Ziggler every step of the way and turning in a fast-paced, edge-of-your-seat clinic.
The two were so good that the Spirit Squad and Maryse shenanigans were basically totally unnecessary but worked fine anyway. It had an epic length, was full of emotion and the two told a hell of a story in the ring. 8/10
What did you think of No Mercy 2016? Shout it out in the comments!