WWE Payback 2016: Every Match Ranked From Worst To Best

Zayn and Owens steal the show.

kevin owens sami zayn
WWE.com

WWE Payback has come and gone for another year, and as usual, it was a generic filler PPV where little of actual significance happened. If you missed the show, you didn't really miss anything.

Though there weren't any strictly terrible matches, it's nevertheless another shining example of WWE's "F*** you, that's why!" booking, where several promising bouts were killed by a terrible creative decision, done merely for the sake of "shock value" rather than because it makes sense story-wise.

Still, at least half of the show's matches were entertaining enough even if little here was truly memorable, and it's likely a PPV you won't remember watching later on in the year. At least it wasn't as rage-inducing as WrestleMania though, right? 

Here are WWE Payback 2016's matches ranked from worst to best...

8. Dolph Ziggler Vs. Baron Corbin

baron corbin dolph ziggler
WWE.com

Result: Ziggler rolls up a cocky Corbin for the surprise victory (7:46).

Rating: The show's first match got us off to a dubious start, but at least we got the PPV's worst match out of the way as quickly as possible.

Ziggler winning just makes zero sense booking-wise: why have Corbin win the Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royale at WrestleMania if you're not going to let him have some serious heel momentum moving forward?

It was a dull match on the whole, Corbin came out of it looking dumb because he toyed with Ziggler too much, and though the ending is clearly intended to play off Corbin's cockiness and Ziggler's speed, it doesn't really help anyone in the long run. Atrocious. 4/10


7. Tag Titles #1 Contendership: Enzo & Cass Vs. The Vaudevillains

enzo amore concussion
WWE.com

Result: The match was called off after Enzo was hurled into the ropes by Gotch and suffered a concussion (4:00).

Rating: What a bummer this one was to start the PPV on. The match had so much promise, started so well, and then came to an abrupt halt. What seemed like a potential work at first was very clearly not that soon enough: the concern on the faces of the wrestlers and the commentary team made this one pretty scary, until they thankfully later confirmed that Enzo was moving his extremities and responding to medics.

Though there's not much point in rating this one, the little wrestling we saw was of the high standard we expect from these two teams, but of course, sadly we didn't get a payoff. 5/10


6. U.S. Title: Kalisto (c) Vs. Ryback

Kalisto Ryback
WWE.com

Result: Kalisto retains the title after nailing the Salida del Sol (8:40).

Rating: Even though the WWE keep forcing this match pairing on us despite the two wrestlers having no natural ring chemistry, it could've been a lot worse. And again, the U.S. Title should absolutely not end up relegated to the pre-show.

Kalisto carried a good portion of the match with a bunch of entertaining spots, even if as usual he botched a few potentially graceful moves, and Ryback ended up looking silly a few times as a result.

Ryback at least got to nail the champ with an awesome top-rope throw, but if Big Hungry's not going to win the title this time, why do we have to keep sitting through this match? Kal wins and the crowd goes mild. Watchable, but just pretty uninteresting and unimaginative booking-wise. 5/10


5. Women's Title: Charlotte (c) Vs. Natalya

charlotte natalya
WWE.com

Result: Charlotte locks Natalya in the Sharpshooter and referee Charles Robinson calls for the bell...despite Natalya not tapping (13:07).

Rating: This was a decent match completely derailed by its embarrassingly crappy ending, because Vince McMahon apparently couldn't resist recreating the Montreal Screwjob with Bret Hart in Natalya's corner.

While it was at least a little refreshing to see Charlotte get a dirty heel win that didn't come directly from her dad, it was still horribly cheap and made zero sense booking-wise. Considering that kayfabe-wise this decision presumably wasn't the doing of the McMahons, wouldn't Robinson be called to order for basically being bribed into screwing a competing athlete?

It just makes no sense, and unless we get an extremely satisfying explanation on Raw (which we probably won't), all this did was undermine two solid athletes trying to put on an otherwise entertaining bout. At least we got to see Bret put Ric in the Sharpshooter post-match, though. 5/10


4. Intercontinental Title: The Miz (c) Vs. Cesaro

the miz cesaro kevin owens
WWE.com

Result: After getting distracted by Sami Zayn and Kevin Owens brawling at ringside, Cesaro gets rolled up by The Miz (11:11).

Rating: A solid match with an atrocious ending, this one gave Cesaro a great opportunity to show off his insane strength, decisively destroying Miz for most of the match, except when he got outside help from Maryse or actually managed to target the Swiss Superman's injured shoulder.

Kevin Owens' commentary added some hilarity to the match, though Zayn returning to fight him arguably distracted from the actual bout taking place in the ring.

The ending, where Cesaro made Miz tap but the ref was distracted by Zayn and Owens, is pure pantomime bulls*** and led to a highly unsatisfying win for The Miz. This really felt like Cesaro's time to take the title, but instead, we get a result that doesn't really help anyone. 6/10


3. Dean Ambrose Vs. Chris Jericho

Chris Jericho Dean Ambrose
WWE.com

Result: Ambrose scores the pin after nailing the Dirty Deeds (18:30).

Rating: This was a solid bout that wasn't especially remarkable but at least made both men look strong, even if it clearly suffered from having to stretch time due to Cass' injury earlier in the show.

This one ran at least five minutes too long and concluded in highly underwhelming fashion, but the meat of the match was totally decent and watchable.

Jericho is obviously well past his peak at this point in his career, but he did a fine job putting Ambrose over while not seeming too over-the-hill himself, even if there are surely more interesting opponents for Ambrose to be taking on right now. 6/10


2. World Heavyweight Title: Roman Reigns (c) Vs. AJ Styles

roman reigns payback dive
WWE.com

Result: Reigns retains the title after drilling Styles with the Spear (23:10).

Rating: It was hard to be too excited about this main event considering the end result was so obvious and it gave AJ his second consecutive PPV loss. That said, it was for the most part surprisingly enjoyable, as Styles and Reigns work well together, and the match technically gave Styles two victories over Reigns in a single night.

The match being restarted not once but twice was a fairly predictable spot after it happened the first time, reminiscent of HBK-Vader at SummerSlam 1996, but at least it cushioned the blow of AJ ultimately losing.

Many have argued that the match was overbooked with too many spots detracting from the athleticism, and in fairness it certainly didn't need Anderson, Gallows and the Usos, but the variety on display ensured it ended up being more than a bland LOLROMANWINS main event.

It's just a shame a rematch has already been booked for Extreme Rules, so AJ can lose his third PPV match in a row. 7/10


1. Sami Zayn Vs. Kevin Owens

kevin owens sami zayn
WWE.com

Result: Owens drills Zayn with the Pop-Up Powerbomb for the win (14:25).

Rating: To the surprise of just about no-one, Zayn and Owens decisively stole the show with another wrestling clinic that demonstrated their off-the-charts ring chemistry.

To be honest, this match could've gone a good 5-10 minutes longer and nobody would've complained: why Jericho and Ambrose got the time-stretch match instead is anyone's guess.

On its own terms, this was a terrific technical contest with a ton of brutality, as both wrestlers sold their total desperation to get one over on their opponent. It's also satisfying to see a clean heel win, especially one that doesn't make Zayn look weak: either wrestler could've won and it would have made sense creatively. 8/10

What did you think of WWE Payback? Shout it out in the comments!


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.