WWE Payback 2017: Assessing The Potential Quality Of All 8 Matches
It won't be a "b*tch" to get through, at least.
On Sunday, WWE presents Payback - the first pay-per-view offering of WWE's apparent new "season" of television.
If WrestleMania was WWE's season finale (a cruel joke to the battered performers with no holiday allocation) Payback is the epilogue - a series of addendums designed to wring every last beat out of an existing story before the Superstar Shake-Up can begin proper. If the WrestleMania-as-season-finale bit is gallows humour for the performers, the punchline falls flat for the fanbase, too. Of the eight matches penned in, no less than four are retreads of matches we've seen very recently and or with brain-numbing frequency already.
The distinct air of inconvenience surrounds it: the show was clearly scheduled before the date of the Shake-Up was formalised. All hope isn't lost because WWE tends to deliver on the biggest stage - but if Fastlane is any indication, laziness and apathy can breed contempt and tedium. The card is strong on paper, but so was Fastlane - and that event was marred by dire time mismanagement.
Eight matches and one segment - that being Finn Bálor's appearance on Miz TV, a cup of coffee and a Coup de Grâce - have been announced for Sunday. Those matches might deliver - but the results have already been written down...
8. The Club Vs. Enzo & Cass
If it wasn't scheduled for the Kickoff portion of the show, the next natural fit would surely be the semi final death spot; this dynamic is beyond stale and devoid almost entirely of stakes and intrigue.
There is a maximum three star ceiling erected above it. It barely even works as a crowd-popping curtain-jerker because Enzo and Cass have suffered a sharp dip in popularity away from the familiar and friendly Full Sail environment. It doesn't help that the tone of their act has been mangled beyond recognition on the flagship. Enzo, once an affable pest, has devolved into an utter irritant. Big Cass meanwhile is Big Cass; he has a distinct and one-dimensional role, and he plays it well enough often enough.
But both men, even after years of experience, are still prone to botching - and even if the match is smooth and free of errors, it can only be an inconsequential and fine affair. The Club tandem of Luke Gallows and Karl Anderson are still barely over.
An eager arena audience might help it along, but it would sets eyes rolling if it were to take place on RAW. The match would be an insult if it were promoted on the main card in the pre-Network era - hardly the stuff of promise.
7. Neville Vs. Austin Aries - WWE Cruiserweight Championship Match
Neville and Austin Aries deserved far more at WrestleMania. They wrestled a barnstormer in front of a stadium that hadn't yet been filled - almost a philosophical debate of a pro wrestling match. If nobody was around or prepared to receive it, how good could it possibly have been?
For those who were paying attention, the answer was easy: their match was sublime, let down only (and only slightly) by a quiet crowd and a tentative presentation. It proved that WWE's much-criticised handling of Cruiserweight wrestling could interface spectacularly with what the vast majority of fans want it to be; it was far quicker and more urgent than anything else on the card, and the aerials were as spectacular as the impact spots were stiff. Neville even dropped Aries on his head with a brutal German suplex. They were intent on proving that they belonged on the main card, but an absorbing story underpinned the breathless content; Neville was dislodged from his comfort zone on the canvas by Aries, the greatest threat yet to his crown.
The pacing was phenomenal - everything built expertly to Neville's detonation of the Red Arrow - but it was criminally treated as filler. The Payback rematch has the potential to enter minor classic territory, but the events of RAW and 205 Live have unfortunately foreshadowed chicanery from an interfering TJ Perkins.
The purest wrestling match on the card will probably suffer from a dirty finish.
6. The Hardy Boyz Vs. Sheamus & Cesaro - WWE RAW Tag Team Title Match
The wave of nostalgia surrounding the return of the Hardy Boyz shows no signs of receding - but Payback poses something of a challenge. Unless plans change, the Hardy Boyz Vs. Sheamus & Cesaro is a straight singles match. There will be no ladders, no crazed compound setting, no BROKEN brilliance - no shortcuts with which to conceal the age and decreased mobility of the Champions.
Without those shortcuts, the Hardyz - on the surface - stand little chance of matching the efforts of their peers in NXT.
But the Hardy Boyz have spent their career making fools of their detractors. Few predicted that their bodies could withstand the brutal buckle of the classic ladder matches at the turn of the millennium, but they wrestled two in the span of twenty four hours over WrestleMania weekend a decade and a half later. Ring of Honor fans loathed Matt Hardy in 2013. He was their hero three years later. Jeff Hardy was a living obituary in 2011. In 2017, he's clean and motivated.
On that basis, there's no reason why Matt and Jeff cannot - especially when paired with the supernaturally talented Cesaro - trounce these mitigated expectations and deliver something approaching the dynamic efforts of #DIY on Sunday.
5. Chris Jericho Vs. Kevin Owens - WWE United States Title Match
The WrestleMania 33 match between Chris Jericho and Kevin Owens was a victim of circumstance.
Ultimately, it was an undercard attraction. It didn't matter that the Festival of Friendship was the best angle WWE had promoted in years, or that the tension had been percolating for months to ensure maximum audience investment; the match was presented and thus received as literal notch below the real feature attractions.
It was well-worked enough, even if the first half was flatter and more methodical than the heated wider storyline demanded. The brutal, apron-centric offence of the closing stretch unglued a crowd worn out by the lengthy stunt show that was AJ Styles Vs. McMahon, and there was a great moment of continuity and suspense when Owens reached the rope with only his outstretched finger. But it was only very good in patches.
In Orlando, there was no clear winner, even if the odds were skewed heavily in favour of Kevin Owens. Jericho was pencilled in for more dates beyond 'Mania. The sequel has the (presumed) luxury of more focus and a more flattering slot - but the heat of the feud has receded in parallel with any notion that Jericho might emerge victorious.
There's simply no way that Owens, with his new Face of America Open Challenge bit, isn't retaining the US gold. Not for the first time, the Jericho Vs. Owens programme has been undermined by the prize for which it has been contested.
4. Bayley Vs. Alexa Bliss - WWE RAW Women's Championship Match
The problem with long-term planning within the endless episodic TV model is that the destination is obviously telegraphed every step of the way.
And, when there is a swerve in the road, fans blast it. The long-running Charlotte-as-pay-per-view-queen-bee arc trundled on with despairing predictability. Everybody knew that Charlotte would win on pay-per-view - until she didn't at Fastlane. WWE couldn't have it either way, but it was as much an indictment of the schizophrenic creative process as it was the spoiled fandom.
Mercifully, the formula has been stripped of its anchoring variable. Bayley Vs. Alexa Bliss might be the most anticipated RAW Women's match in aeons because it's fresh; the combination hasn't been exhausted on NXT nor the main roster. Bliss isn't as talented as her Four Horsewomen counterparts, but she's less played out and far more relevant. As the recent diminished returns attest, that is a welcome compromise.
The setting should help. Bayley's home city crowd should furnish it with an atmosphere to die for. The emotion should carry it to a level beyond the relatively disappointing body of work Bayley has assembled since her main roster promotion.
It's that setting which also lends the match that sought-for unpredictability. WWE enjoys humiliating talents in front of their friends and family - while it maintains a pretence that bullying is an awful, terrible thing - so for once, the result isn't nailed on.
3. Seth Rollins Vs. Samoa Joe
Seth Rollins Vs. Samoa Joe can only be considered a major disappointment if it doesn't bring home Match of the Night honours.
Rollins was (constructively) criticised by Steve Austin on a recent edition of his podcast. Austin suggested that Rollins was not "all the way over," and that he has leaned too heavily on his sequences and athleticism. Rollins according to Austin needs to develop his character before firmly establishing himself as a main event presence.
His match with Samoa Joe has the potential to put him over the top because it has everything going for it. Both men on their day are world class workers; even a throwaway RAW exhibition would promise much, given that they are as well versed as anybody in the stiff and athletic modern style. The physical contrast between them suits the story-heavy WWE environment, and the serendipitous meta slant of Joe's literal destroyer act lends it a certain credibility and organic dramatic heft. The match is also very difficult to predict. Both men desperately need the win, but Rollins arguably needs to deliver a killer babyface performance even more. The stage is set, the players capable. The show should - should - be a classic.
Rollins has promised and must deliver a personal, brutal war if he is to compete with Finn Bálor as the brand's no. 2 babyface.
2. Roman Reigns Vs. Braun Strowman
The match between Roman Reigns and Braun Strowman at Fastlane smashed expectations as effectively as it did the ringside area. It was carnage, an impossibly entertaining and athletic big man match, one in the eye for those still of the disposition that both men were little more than limited and undeserving Vince McMahon pet projects.
As violent and over the top as it was, it benefitted from the restraint WWE demonstrated in building the Strowman character. Those months of patient squashes were worth it when Strowman, faced with the competition he had craved, was forced to ascend the turnbuckles and attempt to flatten Reigns with a frog splash.
It will be difficult for Reigns and Strowman to recapture that novelty element, but Strowman improves by the week. His recent match with The Big Show was an improvement on the original. There's no reason why Strowman and Reigns can't at least equal their blinding effort in March.
The sequel is altogether more difficult to predict. As well as both men did to manufacture doubt at Fastlane, there was no way WWE was about to put Strowman over when he was penned in to retire the Undertaker in Orlando. The unpredictability could well compensate for familiarity; Strowman is a lock to challenge for Brock Lesnar's Universal Title in the summer, and Reigns has been practically murdered in the build to justify a loss here.
Anything else would make no sense whatsoever - but little about Roman's booking does.
1. Randy Orton Vs. Bray Wyatt - WWE Championship House Of Horrors Match
It's almost impossible to predict how good the House of Horrors Match will be because nobody is entirely sure exactly what that entails.
Even WWE themselves seem to be operating on a title first, content later basis. They surveyed the WWE Fan Council a few weeks back to ask what they'd like to see, and the options were as baffling as you'd expect. They listed cage, darkness, fire, pitchforks, mirrors, projected images, a "match done outside the arena" in a "creep scary venue", music, and "Sheeple" - which is a strangely cuddly term for the purportedly terrifying extras in sheep masks. Hilariously, the option "nothing different" was also listed. Why even call it a House Of Horrors match?
Those averse to Wyatt's act might cynically observe that another straight singles match would be horrific in itself, given the tedious and weird for weird's sake bout at WrestleMania 33. The match does have the potential to veer across the spectrum from unique and entertainingly camp to so-bad-it's-good - but the Superstar Shake-Up fallout has all but telegraphed the winner.
The predictability of the match doesn't end with the finish.
On Monday's episode of RAW, the commentary team shed a fraction of light on what we might expect. The match will apparently begin in the "house" and end in the ring, which renders any near falls - or really, any of the action at all in the titular house inconsequential.