WWE Royal Rumble 2018: Star Ratings For All 6 Matches

In which WWE cracks the Rumble curse like the Liberty Bell.

John Cena Roman Reigns
WWE.com

Ultimately, to gauge the success of any given Royal Rumble pay-per-view, we must reduce the polarising fallout to one crucial question: did WWE engineer excitement - or apathy - ahead of WrestleMania?

Almost unanimously, this is a task at which WWE has comprehensively failed in this Network era because the existence of the Network itself allows WWE to tell the stories WWE wishes to tell. They already have your money. A tenner a month is less than delivered food, less than a few post-work drinks. In that respect, it barely feels like even a humdrum everyday treat - and the irony of that notwithstanding, the company offering the service offers a complete bargain, which in turn means the core consumer has less reason to bargain internally. It's only 9.99. Who cares if the Rumble was terrible, really? WrestleMania is cheap now. Besides which, 'Mania itself is the brand - the international travel packages for which are snapped up months before the Rumble, once the enticing teaser trailer, is even booked. Vince McMahon last week formally revived the X F F*cking L. He can do whatever he pleases.

All of which makes the result of the Men's Royal Rumble match, excellent in itself, beautifully rewarding. At last, WWE delivered a fresh Rumble winner to unite the public in both excitement and palpable relief. Roman will surely drive to Suplex City - there is no Elimination of that doubt - but the crowning of a new star has firmly restored fan relations...

6. AJ Styles Vs. Kevin Owens & Sami Zayn - WWE Championship 2-On-1 Handicap Match

AJ Styles Sami Zayn
WWE.com

Better than it could have been.

That's a sentence we probably shouldn't be writing, given the immense talent of all three men involved - but we are where we are, and we are on the SmackDown brand circa 2018.

The knock endured by Kevin Owens was obviously unfortunate for him, but in an insensitive take - it's either this, or receive him as a geek - it at least made coherent the match layout, in which Owens and Sami Zayn were almost comprehensively out-wrestled and outwitted by one man. Owens and Zayn were too entertaining in the role to concern ourselves with hysterical protests of burials and the like, and the layout allowed Styles to showcase his almost peerless brilliance - but really, this was a slight disappointment, even if, thankfully, it did not masquerade as a Shane McMahon ego stroke.

The monkey flip reversal into a hurricanrana spot was exactly the sort of sequence that elevates Styles into the echelon of the greats - just great strategy fused with crowd-popping theatrics. It's little wonder that Styles is the unanimous choice of old and new school fans alike as the best wrestler in - at least - North America. Watching him is just exhilarating - and this was Styles mostly unencumbered by road agent stupidity.

It was all a bit easy for Styles in the end, and at the start, it was all a bit slow in the going. The initial crawling pace seemed to foreshadow something epic that did not materialise.

Star Rating: ***1/2


5. The Usos Vs. Chad Gable & Shelton Benjamin - SmackDown Tag Team Championship 2 Out Of 3 Falls Match

CHAD GABLE
WWE.com

Strange is probably the word; a victim of a match layout WWE has contrived to ruin in recent years, the excellent work assembled by The Usos and Chad Gable and Shelton Benjamin ultimately didn't matter for much. The overriding emotion was one of pure WTF, given that sudden, anticlimactic ending.

Prior to that, The Usos proved why they are the best tag team on the planet (if only the road agents shared their creativity); they halve the ring in such a way that you never see the Superkicks coming which, given that they throw about five per match at least, is some feat. The sequence leading up to the first fall-winning stereo Superkick spot was magic, in which the brothers showed tremendous ring presence. Gable ducked one only to be bludgeoned by another. It was typical Usos all-action stuff. That they manage to stave off constant exposure is something very special. They are bloody workhorses.

The layout was strange - the first fall was a wall-to-wall kick-out festival promising the elusive Usos Big 4 PPV classic. Where could the match possibly go from there? Down, was the dispiriting answer. The second fall was as decided as quickly as it commenced. It felt, even watching live, like a good portion had been edited out. Ultimately, the talent was as mystified as the audience when the bell rang.

It was too surreal to rate too highly - yet too worthy to scrutinise pedantically.

Star Rating: ***


4. Men's Royal Rumble Match

Randy Orton Andrade Cien Almas
WWE.com

This was an utter triumph. The below star rating may reflect the pure relief of the endorphin rush - but is that not the point? The match is calibrated to generate excitement and hope. It didn't just meet the remit; it shattered all reasonable and wildly optimistic expectations. The Rumble is a platonic dream match never quite as good its impossible promise. This was the promise manifested. This was, ultimately, a checklist of awesomeness.

Finn Bálor entered a superb performance, the likes of which renders months of moaning on this Author Page redundant. Andrade Cien Almas and Adam Cole entered credible showings in a welcome continuation of the NXT teaser trope. The Heath Slater running gag, in which he ran into a battering each time a new entrant entered the fray, set a tone of immense creativity - a theme reflected in the work itself. Bálor and Nakamura wrestled a blinding, state-of-the-art match-within-a-match ahead of the closing stretch. The returning Rey Mysterio - Rey Mysterio! - looked the best he's looked (in a WWE ring) in a decade. Kofi Kingston restored the lustre of his near-elimination spot; before the camera panned down - even Kevin Dunn did his bloody job on the night - it looked as though this spelled the end of the trope. The athleticism required of the leap back into the ring was jaw-dropping. It's no wonder the New Day remain so over - they are as creative as they are well-versed in the This Is Awesome chant-generating modern WWE formula match.

It wasn't perfect, hence the near-perfect rating. The Hurricane's cameo appearance felt as anachronistic as the character itself. WOKEN Matt Hardy eliminating Rusev was a head-scratcher: are they actively trying to botch the act? Also: Dolph Ziggler's return, after all that, felt like yet another rib played at his expense. Even if he isn't as good as he reckons he is, he didn't deserve that.

That finish...that finish was perfect.

Almost unbearably suspenseful, this grabbed the audience by the throat and forced them to confront, yet again, the grim prospect of another desperately uninspiring revisit of an uninspiring recent past. We were allowed to breathe, and hope, and then despair again, as the field of six thinned to four thinned to two - with the future waged in a great war versus the past.

Arresting, emotional, and perfectly attuned to the fanbase, that future prevailed. What a thrilling, welcome result Shinsuke Nakamura's win was - and what an awesome subversion of a wretched night WWE treated us to on Sunday.

Star Rating: ****3/4


3. Seth Rollins & Jason Jordan Vs. The Bar - RAW Tag Team Championship Match

Jason Jordan Rumble
WWE.com

Subdued almost by design, even workers as well-liked and talented as Seth Rollins and Cesaro in particular were faced with an impossible remit here. The fans in attendance had just bore witness to a dream match made real, epic in length and exhausting to experience. Without wishing to appear too disrespectful - they worked hard, as they invariably do - this was a combination pummelled into submission on RAW for over half a year, and Jason Jordan. The match was a victim of timing on the night and a creeping, cloying sense of abject overfamiliarity in the wider sense.

There was enough to savour in the glorified handicap match - when eyes were prised from phones to ensure that Shinsuke Nakamura had just won the Royal Rumble match - but the match belonged to Jason Jordan. Enforced by an indeterminate injury it may have been, Jordan nonetheless delivered in his role as histrionic kayfabe injury victim, completely (and hilariously) overdoing the effects of his ring post spot. A slimy, knowing pr*ck, Jordan has finally grasped what it means to be Kurt Angle's son - tonally, at least; his performances aren't anywhere near his "father's" bravura level.

But, in a non-starter of a match, this was a good start to his formal heel turn.

Star Rating: **1/2


2. Brock Lesnar Vs. Braun Strowman Vs. Kane - Universal Title Triple Threat Match

Lesnar KANE
WWE.com

Ugly - but good ugly - this match was very much the expected pale imitation of the superb SummerSlam Fatal 4-Way headliner. It was more fascinating than fantastic, regardless of whether the much-replayed curio of an early exchange fell into work or shoot territory. Braun Strowman drilled his knee into the side of Brock Lesnar's head, to which the Beast responded with a skull-rattling receipt. That is more literal description than metaphor; the slow-motion replay captured both an unhappy expression on Lesnar's face and the rippling flesh on Strowman's.

In any event, this exchange imbued the match with the sense of danger Lesnar's best matches deliver - though it lacked the dynamism and heat of his classics, sagging as it did in the middle. Still, Strowman drilled Lesnar full-force in the face with a ridiculous front dropkick. That moment alone killed off any notion that this was to approach dreaded "methodical" territory.

Tables didn't break cleanly; pinfall attempts were not broken up at the last second. This wasn't an hermetic masterpiece, nor was it gripping throughout what was a mercifully brief duration. It was, however, closer to success than failure. Lesnar looked legitimately terrifying. Strowman bettered his No Mercy disappointment. Kane was a passenger.

That came as a relief.

Star Rating: ***


1. Women's Royal Rumble Match

Asuka Rumble
WWE.com

From absolutely farcical to genuinely gripping, this first ever Women's Royal Rumble Match represented the history of Women's wrestling in WWE in microcosm.

When it was bad, it was really bad; the dispiriting glut of inexperienced acts in the opening third took us directly from Suplex to Botch City, a destination as quiet as it was strewn with trash. Lita's contribution, pitched as a nostalgic goodwill bit, fell way short of the mark. Tamina remains employed for reasons that are impossible to parse. For too long, the wisdom of the creative decisions mirrored the quality of the in-ring performances. Kairi Sane, winner of the Mae Young Classic - as irrelevant as the Cruiserweight Classic, just months later - was quickly and unceremoniously thrown out by, of all people, Dana Brooke. Then, in a strange succession of cameos, Michelle McCool emerged as the storyline star of the match - despite the very foundation of the Women's Revolution being built upon the relative inferiority of her era. The dire quality became contagious; Becky Lynch and Carmella bent time and space by engaging in a strange protracted hug in what was an atypical off night for the Lass Kicker.

Nia Jax, to her credit, acted as an unlikely linchpin. The match coalesced, literally, around her. The arrival of Asuka elevated this into the realm of the excellent. Her character work alongside both Sasha Banks - nay, The Boss - (who recovered to put forth her best performance in an age) and Trish Stratus (who very much lived up to her legend) underscored that her victory was the only logical choice. Nobody is ready for her. Nobody can touch her in the ring.

With a Men's mirror image finish that, fittingly, doubled up on the goodwill, this ranged from * at its worst to **** at its best.

A note on Stephanie McMahon's commentary: it was so inoffensive, so bereft of insight, that it ironically bordered on the offensive. She might as well have stayed in the back, she contributed so little - but she has to be front and centre.

Star Rating: **1/2


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!