WWE Survivor Series 2017: Every Match Ranked From Worst To Best

What the hell was that main event?

Triple H Shane McMahon
WWE

They say that the better a WWE PPV looks on paper, the more disappointing and underwhelming it typically is in reality, and sadly, that was totally the case with this year's Survivor Series.

Coming hot off the heels of another consistently thrilling NXT TakeOver show the previous night, Survivor Series fell victim to all the usual WWE pitfalls: atrocious booking that makes no sense and seems intended solely to irritate fans, the old guard being given precedent over the hungry young talents, and a misplaced focus on surprising fans rather than just delivering a satisfying in-ring story.

Was it a terrible show? Absolutely not. In fact, there's only one match that even got close to being flat-out bad, but the it was largely filled with mediocre, forgettable bouts, with just a few scattered contests of real mention. At least Brock Lesnar actually showed up and seemed to care, which was nice...


10. Team Raw (Alicia Fox, Sasha Banks, Bayley, Asuka & Nia Jax) Vs. Team SmackDown (Becky Lynch, Naomi, Carmella, Natalya, & Tamina)

Asuka Carmella
WWE.com

Result: Asuka makes Natalya tap to the Asuka Lock to become the sole survivor (18:35).

Rating: Yikes, what a horribly booked match. It says a lot that the most entertaining thing here was the hoss brawl between Nia Jax and Tamina.

Where to begin? Becky Lynch being eliminated first was infuriating, Bayley going out next was almost as bad, the horrendous three-count botch during Alicia's elimination was embarrassing, and there was never any doubt that Asuka would be the sole survivor (which at least was the right call story-wise).

It would've been way more interesting to see Asuka and Becky square off at the end, but ultimately a match full of talented performers was fatally compromised by awful, nonsensical booking. Only Asuka, Nia, and Tamina really came out of this looking good. 4/10


9. Elias Vs. Matt Hardy

WWE Survivor Series 2017 Elias Sampson Matt Hardy
WWE.com

Result: Elias nails Drift Away for the win (9:15).

Rating: Poor Matt Hardy, having to wrestle in a near-empty arena for the second time this year. As expected, this was your most typical, garden variety pre-show match, with a slack, dawdling pace and general lack of interest.

On the other hand, it didn't do much to actively offend and Elias winning was absolutely the right call, but most everyone surely forgot it the moment it was over. It's worth cutting them both a little slack for the dead crowd, but still, this one didn't even touch the sides. 5/10


8. Cruiserweight Title: Enzo Amore (c) Vs. Kalisto

Enzo Amore Kalisto
WWE.com

Result: Enzo takes Kalisto out with the JawdonZo to retain the strap (8:45).

Rating: Though Enzo's victory was never in doubt, this was a fairly solid, almost legitimately decent showing from the champ, even if it's fair to say that Kalisto basically carried him to the finish line with some terrific high-flying spots.

It was sloppy in parts with a few too many botches, but at least Enzo seemed like he was actually trying, and Kalisto once again proved that he's worthy of far better opponents. Not really what you want from the only title match on the show, but it was fine-ish. 5/10


7. Charlotte Flair Vs. Alexa Bliss

Charlotte Flair Alexa Bliss
WWE.com

Result: Charlotte makes Alexa tap to the Figure Eight for the win (15:00).

Rating: This one was incredibly odd from a creative perspective: it didn't make much sense for Alexa to dominate the match so thoroughly, especially considering how much smaller and less-skilled than Charlotte she is. Quite what Alexa has done to deserve such strong booking is anyone's guess.

This was exacerbated by the match's excessive length, with the middle-section in particular feeling incredibly slack and padded. Though it was a relief to see Charlotte come out victorious, the match felt pretty rough and poorly thought-out for the most part. That Big Boot botch was particularly atrocious. 5/10


6. Kevin Owens & Sami Zayn Vs. Breezango

WWE Survivor Series 2017 Breezango Kevin Owens Sami Zayn
WWE.com

Result: Owens drills Fandango with the Pop-Up Powerbomb for the win (7:45).

Rating: This one evoked mixed emotions: on one hand it was slightly depressing to see Owens and Zayn on the pre-show against a joke team, but the crowd was into the match and it was intermittently entertaining to that end.

Owens milked rest holds to the point of boredom as usual, but Breezango actually seemed surprisingly credible here at times, to the point that it almost would've been cute to see them score a fluke win. Overall, it was a pre-show match, and it was fine. 5/10


5. Baron Corbin Vs. The Miz

Miz Corbin
WWE.com

Result: Corbin kills Miz with the End of Days for the win (9:35).

Rating: It was undeniably fun and novel to see a heel vs. heel match, though it's a shame the concept was wasted on a nothing match few even remotely cared about.

Even though it didn't really come together, there wasn't much egregiously wrong here: Corbin put on one of his more compelling performances of recent times and Miz did everything in his power to make him look good.

The pair just didn't have particularly interesting chemistry, and even with its brief run-time, it felt a little stamina-draining. 5/10


4. Team Raw (Kurt Angle, Braun Strowman, Finn Bálor, Samoa Joe & Triple H) Vs. Team SmackDown (Shane McMahon, Randy Orton, Bobby Roode, Shinsuke Nakamura & John Cena)

WWE Survivor Series 2017 Kurt Angle Bobby Roode
WWE.com

Result: Triple H trolls Shane with a Pedigree to win Team Raw the match and the night (33:20).

Rating: After last year's epic, superbly-booked 53-minute Survivor Series match, this just felt like a total letdown. Though there was a ton of potential to see some wish fulfilment match-ups, daft booking quickly scattered a lot of the promise.

Nakamura, Roode and Joe being eliminated so hastily, and the match's general focus on older talents over rising stars just felt incredibly misguided.

Sure, Braun Strowman got a nice rub out of it, but the Triple H fake-out at the end was more confusing and weird than entertaining, and from the flat crowd response it's clear the moment didn't play out how it was intended.

Once again the McMahons made themselves front-and-center of a match that had so much more potential elsewhere. It had fun moments and certainly wasn't a bad match, but it was also a fair few notches below where it should've been. 6/10


3. The Usos Vs. Sheamus & Cesaro

The Usos The Bar
WWE.com

Result: Jey lands a Top-Rope Splash on Sheamus for the win (15:55).

Rating: Considering how fantastic these two teams have been performing lately, this match was ever-so-slightly underwhelming, only because this should've been a four-star classic and fell a little short of that.

Still, on its own terms it was a lot of fun, with the Usos once again proving themselves to be one of WWE's hottest tag teams right now, while The Bar were as consistently strong as ever.

There were a few moments where things didn't connect as neatly as the four men clearly wanted them to, but it kept up a strong pace and the final stretch was spectacular. 7/10


2. The New Day Vs. The Shield

WWE Survivor Series 2017 The Shield The New Day
WWE.com

Result: Kofi gets murdered with a Triple Powerbomb to give The Shield the victory (21:20).

Rating: Though it took the teams a few minutes to find their rhythm, this quickly evolved into one of the night's few truly great matches.

For a match to wake the crowd up for the main show, this was a fantastic choice for an opener, with The New Day putting up a strong showing against The Shield, who were nevertheless always going to come out on top.

The hope spots were great, it was allowed to run long, and though not everything connected quite perfectly, everyone was really trying to put on a high-calibre battle, and largely succeeded. New Day winning would've been a fun surprise, but it's hard to be mad about the inevitable finish. 8/10


1. AJ Styles Vs. Brock Lesnar

Brock Lesnar AJ Styles
WWE.com

Result: Brock counters the Phenomenal Forearm into an F-5 for the pin (15:25).

Rating: Though Smackdown beating Raw 3-2 at this point made it even more obvious that Brock was going to win, this was pretty much the best possible version of an AJ/Brock match.

It wasn't just a squash, it ran a decent length, Brock actually put some effort in, and it surprisingly played out like an honest-to-God main event title match.

Styles' selling throughout was absolutely incredible, again proving that even in defeat he can make both himself and his opponent look like a million bucks. Lesnar similarly played his part, selling the Calf Crusher like it was death, and though the Forearm/F-5 spot was incredibly predictable, the match as a whole was immensely satisfying.

A few nasty botches aside, this far exceeded expectations and was by far Brock's best match in quite some time. Considering how disappointing the actual main event was, this really should've gone on last to send the crowd home with a rush. 8/10

-

What did you think of this year's Survivor Series? Shout it out in the comments!


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.