WWE TLC 2013: 5 John Cena vs. Randy Orton Matches To Watch First

At TLC 2013, the WWE presents the most recent installment of the Randy Orton vs. John Cena rivalry. This time around, it will be a Tables, Ladders, and Chairs match to determine the Unified WWE and World Heavyweight Champion. The stakes could not be any higher. Some enthusiasts may scoff at two of the four most successful graduates of the 2002 Ohio Valley Wrestling class yet again main-eventing a PPV when the wrestling universe very clearly wants the Daniel Bryans and CM Punks of world occupying Cena and Orton's respective spots, but it is difficult to deny the magnitude of tonight's match. 12 years ago, when the WWE first created an Undisputed Champion, arguments were justifiably made against the final combatants chosen for such an historic occasion. Steve Austin certainly fit the bill, but Chris Jericho was a relative newcomer to the headlining circuit. Austin vs. The Rock would have, the pundits suggested, been more fitting. Seeing as how the titles were re-disputed nine months later, the objective onlooker could certainly buy into that critical train of thought. At the very least, Orton vs. Cena addresses that concern €“ each has a name value built over the past decade that makes him an ideal participant in a match in which the WWE and World Heavyweight Championships hang literally in the balance. Of all the active members of the current WWE roster, they are €“ by far €“ the two most accomplished. Also keep in mind that Cena and Orton know how to excel in big match situations. Their rivalry has been no mere blip on the radar of WWE history. To prepare for tonight's TLC main-event, let us look back at the five defining matches of their multi-year saga.

5. Triple Threat WWE Championship (also involving Triple H) - WrestleMania XXIV

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WqcGadDM2w0 Randy Orton seemed the logical opponent for two different grapplers as WrestleMania 24 season approached. The renewal of his long-term rivalry with Triple H immediately took a backseat to The Viper's more 2008-current story involving John Cena. When Cena began his routine of returning far earlier than expected from major surgeries by winning the Royal Rumble match at Madison Square Garden, it put him on a collision course to give Orton payback for "putting him out of action" in the fall of 2007. It would have made perfect sense to go Orton vs. Cena at WrestleMania. Given the nature of the story, it might have even put "The Golden Boy" in a role that the WWE has so often desired him to occupy but that he has rarely been believable in playing €“ that of the "comeback kid" triumphantly overcoming the odds. Obviously, the WWE went in another direction, keeping Orton as the focal point and surrounding him with two big name opponents to cement him as a major player with a huge victory at Mania. As triple threats tend to do, it watered down the effectiveness of the drama, but it was important in making Orton's 25th Anniversary of WrestleMania main-event happen. Winning is more important in wrestling than many let on, as credibility can be won or lost with a victory on a stage that matters. The other half of a WrestleMania closing match looks a lot more appropriate when he has high profile wins. Prior to 2008, Orton had lost every major bout at one of the "Big 3" WWE PPVs since defeating Undertaker at Summerslam 2005. As far as match quality goes, the triple threat was an admirable effort from all involved. Most assumed that they would main-event Mania 24 and some could have assumed that, when they were told that they were not, they could have phoned it in. Instead, the three of them came out motivated to prove that they should've been the last match. Working a fast-paced, but smartly executed bout full of the psychology often lacking in a triple threat, the three top Raw stars pushed the envelope with their conditioning and pulled off quite an addition to the card.

4. Hell In A Cell Match - Inaugural Hell In A Cell PPV (2009)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5QNKI1gD5P0 Hell in a Cell is a gimmick in which intensely personal stories thrive. Cena and Orton renewed their rivalry in the summer of 2009, culminating in a four PPV series of one-on-one WWE Championship matches, three of which provide the best examples of why Cena vs. Orton at TLC '13 will deliver the goods. Though never to be mistaken as one of the finest editions of the Cell, Orton-Cena did offer one of the stipulation's most underrated versions. The Viper character that Orton introduced in late 2008 was well-known by WrestleMania 25 as one of the most sadistic of the modern era. His cerebral tendencies were fascinating to witness, as he seemed to be a sort of strange mixture of in and out of control. Orton's persona bordered on the insane. He played the part to a "T." It was one of the rare moments in their storied saga where Orton seemed to have the legitimate advantage, locked inside a massive steel structure with plenty of weapons under the ring that he could use to maim and destroy a wrestler for whom he well displayed hatred. TLC certainly will not suffer from the common knock against the Hell in a Cell being amongst the most boring of the Cena-Orton matches; there will simply be too many tables, ladders, and chairs. A fan looking back to Hell in a Cell 2009 would need to pay much closer attention to the details to fully appreciate the mastery of Orton's performance, in particular. He never had a greater command of the ring than he did in 2009; he never had a better sense of the character that he was portraying and how to accentuate all the minute mannerisms en route to the 2009 WWE Superstar of the Year according to several critical publications. Hell in a Cell has always been known for its brutality rather than a mental chess game, so Orton-Cena struggles to hold up against the more popular matches in the history of Satan's Structure. However, that is more an indictment of the WWE's own policy changes that avoid blood and violence than it is a knock on Orton and Cena's ability to properly adapt to one of the most popular gimmick matches of the WrestleMania Era.

3. "I Quit" Match - Breaking Point (2009)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=skDUf_TC_Hc The ill-fated Breaking Point PPV was an attempt to condition the WWE audience to better appreciate submission-style wrestling. As evidenced by the lackluster buyrate and the fact that the PPV only had a one year run, the audience did not much care for the concept. It is a shame. Orton and Cena had an "I Quit" match with few peers in the modern context. Submission and "I Quit" matches evoke, to many a wrestling enthusiast, visions of Stone Cold Steve Austin and Bret Hart mixing it up at WrestleMania 13 or Terry Funk and the incomparable Ric Flair ending their personal war at the November 1989 Clash of the Champions. In all honesty, Orton vs. Cena was not far off of that mark. It certainly was not as good or as memorable, but it was something to see in its own right. Much as Hell in a Cell proved to be a month later, "I Quit" was a scenario that did not really benefit John Cena. Orton was the personality that had drawn comparisons to serial killers of Hollywood lore. His cold and calculating nature was a perfect fit for being locked inside a cage with a devil-inspired nickname and he was an ideal candidate to dominate a match that involved no rules and no other way to win but complete annihilation of an opponent. Cena has always gotten by on his wherewithal. It is what had allowed him to become a master of the Last Man Standing match and win the only other "I Quit" match of his career (against JBL at Judgment Day 2005). Not even Cena's biggest critic could deny his toughness. His gritty style had made him famous, but placed against a man who was once described as "one second away from snapping and attacking everyone in the arena," Cena's guts and hustle seemed no match. It made for a thoroughly-engaging story, with Orton doing everything short of castrating Cena to retain the WWE Championship, but ultimately coming up short. Cena proved too resilient; Orton simply not tough enough.

2. WWE Championship - Summerslam (2007)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QpiABSXZBqo Back at Summerslam 2004, just a short time before Randy Orton beat John Cena in their figurative race to the World Heavyweight Championship, they found themselves quarreling in a backstage segment in one of those great foreshadowing moments. Three years later, Orton was challenging Cena at Summerslam 2007 in the main-event for the WWE Championship. When you consider that they were in the same rookie class and that they debuted just a couple of months apart, they seemed destined to eventually clash in a manner similar to Shawn Michaels and Bret Hart in the New Generation and The Rock and Triple H from the Attitude Era. Orton had once seemed on the fast track to being "The Man" for this current generation. One of the worst babyface turns in wrestling history (on the day after his World title victory) doomed Orton and forced him to overcome a roadblock named "main-event failure." Cena swooped right in and took the throne, emerging as the Hulk Hogan of his era. Orton went from youngest World Champion in history to starting a three year climb back to the main-event. Waiting for him when he got there was a new face of the franchise in Cena, who had been passed the torch by Orton's mentor, Triple H. The whole thing provided a fascinating backdrop to the on-screen story, giving the Summerslam '07 match €“ already of historical importance due to it being the first match in the multi-year Orton-Cena saga €“ an added bit of intrigue. At the time, Orton was transitioning to his more unpredictable Viper persona. His experiences had humbled him, personally, and revitalized him, professionally. Cena, meanwhile, needed a foil. He had emerged as the #1 star in the industry, but had nobody on the other half of "versus John Cena" that made the fanbase feel as though he had a heel counterpart to his heroic babyface character. Orton seemed poised to fill that void, dominating their Summerslam match. In what became a theme for their story, Cena overcame in the end to pin Orton and retain the title. It was a great match.

1. WWE Champiosnhip Anything Goes Ironman Match - Bragging Rights (2009)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tL65vWfBIys In a few hours, the classic Ironman Match between Orton and Cena will have become the penultimate showdown of their long and storied rivalry. What a battle it was. In the final chapter of their 2009 saga, much was at stake. The WWE Championship, which they had traded at back-to-back-to-back PPVs, was on its usual pedestal. Cena would also have had to leave Raw had he lost. 60-minutes were put on the clock and the most falls within an hour determined the winner. It is one of the most sparingly used gimmick matches in the WWE for a reason, reserved only for a handful of wrestlers who truly earn the right (and have the talent to entertain an audience for an hour). It took place at the height of Orton's storytelling ability and psychology and, subsequently, was the best match of his career. Cena, once again, emerged victorious, but it never seemed as though Cena was the focal point of the Cena-Orton matches. Each of their top matches has tended to highlight what makes Orton so good, while quietly but pronouncedly overshadowing Cena's contributions. Never was there a better example of Orton realizing his potential as a pro wrestler than against Cena at 2009's Bragging Rights. He was utterly outstanding in defeat. Football analysts sometimes speak of having a "high football IQ." Orton's wrestling IQ is off the charts. Cena is no slouch and has an unmatched mastery of engaging the audience, but Orton is a genius in the realm of facial expressions and match psychology. It is evident that his mentor was known as the "Cerebral Assassin." Orton is a wrestling psychology savant. He gets by on it just as Cena gets by on his charisma and grit. Here were just a few of Orton's highlights from the Ironman match, again taking nothing away from Cena's performance: Orton tapped out quickly to the STF to conserve energy, but lay in wait to catch Cena with the RKO while he was doing his silly 5 Knuckle Shuffle to tie up the falls at 1-1. He busted Cena open by using the butt of the microphone, adding a much needed crimson element to a match between two guys that are supposed to hate each other (blood was transitioning to being outlawed after many years of overuse). Whenever Cena kicked out of his pin attempts, he went from looking like a serial killer to looking like he just got out of the Arkham Asylum (Batman). He countered the Attitude Adjustment into one of the five greatest RKOs of all-time. When they were fighting on the entrance ramp, he noticed the pyro control board and looked like Sylvester the Cat with an idea of how to catch Tweedy bird. His expression before pressing those buttons blurred the lines between what's character and what's in this guy's head that allows him to tap into that character. He then proceeded to try to blow Cena up. He flipped out when it didn't work, like Gollum after losing his "precious" (with body language second to none). After gaining a 5-4 lead, he started playing defense with the clock winding down. Though Cena was notorious for being a babyface but getting heavily booed, Orton's heel work turned the crowd in Cena's favor. Unbelievable performance! 2009 was Orton's top year as a pro. John Cena and Randy Orton have knocked 'em out of the park before and they'll do it again at TLC.

Contributor
Contributor

"The Doc" Chad Matthews has written wrestling columns for over a decade. A physician by trade, Matthews began writing about wrestling as a hobby, but it became a passion. After 30 years as a wrestling fan, "The Doc" gives an unmatched analytical perspective on pro wrestling in the modern era. He is a long-time columnist for Lordsofpain.net and hosts a weekly podcast on the LOP Radio Network called "The Doc Says." His first book - The WrestleMania Era: The Book of Sports Entertainment - ranks the Top 90 wrestlers from 1983 to present day, was originally published in December 2013, and is now in its third edition. Matthews lives in North Carolina with his wife, two kids, and two dogs.