10 Different Ways Batman Has Been Defeated

Bane broke him. So did all these other people.

Batman Defeated
DC Comics

Despite what bitter Superman fans or the more cynical pop culture-obssessive might tell you, Batman isn't invincible. They may carp and moan about him not being a real superhero, but they'll almost always insist that he's nonetheless as €œboring€ a character as Superman for the simple reason that nobody ever beats him. Which, well, first of all is a fallacy, since superhero comics €“and most traditional media in general is geared so as that the good guys always win. It's reassuring, an alternative to how the real world works. Batman and Superman never get beaten, but neither does Indiana Jones, the CSI team, or Manchester United. Except all of those things do get beaten, but Batman especially.

The Dark Knight is not invincible. He's smart €“ give him enough prep time, and he can reasonably be expected to take most people down (including the Man Of Steel). But really he's a comeback kid. He's an underdog. The Caped Crusader gets his ass handed to him all the time, but then he learns, comes back, and ultimately triumphs. Even those moments are rare, though, since he's usually prepared for everything. Usually.

Here are ten different ways Batman has been defeated.

10. A Single Kick To The Ribs

Batman Bronze Tiger
DC Comics

Oh yes, even with all his grandstanding and spending the better part of a decade travelling the world and training with various martial arts experts and hard nuts, the Dark Knight isn't quite unbeatable in hand-to-hand combat. It probably helps if he comes up against someone with even more training, though, as is the case with the Bronze Tiger.

A fighter on the level of Batman €“(who is routinely named one of the best in the world) “ who was brainwashed by Ra's Al Ghul and sent out to stop Batman and Batwoman. As a member of the League Of Assassins he managed to dispatch the Caped Crusader with a single kick to the solar plexus, putting him into such crippling pain he can't stop the Tiger from then stabbing Batwoman.

One punch? One kick!


9. Shot In The Chest By A Cop

Batman Dark Victory Shot
DC Comics

Not that it always takes a worthy adversary of the highest calibre to take down the Bat. Sometimes he just has an off day. Sometimes, as is the case in Jeph Loeb and Tim Sale's Dark Victory, he comes up against a police sniper who doesn't actually miss for once.

Obviously it helps to be equally as prepared for battle as Batman himself, as was the case with Bronze Tiger, but it can be equally as prudent to seize an opportunity when given it. So when Sergeant Branden of the Gotham City PD's SWAT team sees a shot, he takes it.

Branden gets a clean shot right at Batman's chest, like that insignia was a target. Obviously the Dark Knight had body armour on underneath, but he was more or less incapacitated, and would've been toast had the villainous Hangman not shown up to kill Branden before he could finish the job.


8. Hunted By A Predator

Batman Predator
DC Comics

In one of the weirder turns for either franchise, the mid-nineties saw Batman coming up against not only an Alien but also a Predator, and fared...well, about well as you'd imagine Batman would against such an unprecedented enemy. Which is to say, not very well the first time.

Completely unprepared for the vicious mercenary alien hunter stalking the streets of Gotham, the Caped Crusader nevertheless engages what he sees as a clear threat. Except when your whole shtick is skulking around in the shadows, and your enemy uses heat vision, you're kinda boned.

So when Batman started investigating the mysterious death of two boxers, he probably wasn't reckoning on a Predator showing up. And then totally whupping him. Like, to the point that Bruce is in a full body cast afterwards.


7. Electrocuted By Clayface

Batman Electrocuted
DC Comics

The pseudonym has been used by various supervillains throughout DC history, but the original is the bets. Basil Karlo was, at first, just a murderous actor driven insane when he was cut out of a monster movie. Then he met the later Clayfaces, who were literally made of clay and could shapeshift into all sorts, and then things really changed.

During the No Man's Land arc of the Batman comics €“ where Gotham suffered a huge earthquake and was cut off from the rest of the United States €“ he got by by imprisoning Poison Ivy and getting her to grow veg he could sell. The jerk. Then he disappeared for a while. Never that much of a threat, he only managed to beat Batman the once after attempting to absorb Wonder Woman (one of her origins is she was formed out of clay) and managing to gain some sort of electricity powers, which he zapped him with.

The Dark Knight only escaped because then Clayface and Mr Freeze were arguing over who got to kill him.


6. Sent Back In Time By Omega Rays

Batman Final Crisis
DC Comics

Final Crisis is a fantastic comic book. It's also almost entirely illegible without either an intimate knowledge of the minutiae of the DC Universe stretching back a good half century, or an innate tuning into Grant Morrison's frequency (a thing which few people can boast; even Morrison at times is second guessing himself).

Despite being so hard to grasp at times, it's one of the more daring and experimental crossover events in comics history, with cosmic villain Darkseid achieving his ultimate victory: in a world where good always prevails €“(ie superhero comics) the bad guys finally won. Superman was gone, Wonder Woman become a villain, everyone else otherwise incapacitated.

It's up to Batman to take down Darkseid, by using a gun that fires an €œomega ray€ bullet which travels through time. Which promptly explodes, sending the Caped Crusader into the distant past. Which was Darkseid's plan all along, meaning he's probably the only person more over-prepared than Batman.


5. In Hand-To-Hand-Combat (By Someone Who Matrix'd Himself)

Jla Batman
DC Comics

Really hoping that takes off as a verb. Grant Morrison is a man who returns to similar themes and tropes again and again, and his run on JLA in the early nineties was a riff on the same concept as Final Crisis. Principally, how exactly does a villain prevail in a universe that's rigged in favour of the good guys? Simple! You cheat. That's the tactic that Prometheus goes for, a character named for figure in Greek mythology, is essentially the anti-Batman.

His parents were criminals gunned down by police, which caused him to swear eternal justice against law enforcers. Which is why he wants to destroy the Justice League. By that logic, Batman is his first target. With nary the training nor motivation that the Dark Knight has, Prometheus elects to download the skills of the thirty greatest martial artists in the world, including Batman, into his helmet.

Like Neo in The Matrix, see? He knows kung fu.


4. Kidnapped, Drugged, Tortured, Brainwashed

Batman Shooting
DC Comics

One of the weirder entries in the pantheon of Batman comics (and some of them are pretty weird, like the one where he's a Nazi, because of course there is) is The Cult, a four-part prestige format story from the late eighties by written by Jim Starlin, illustrated by Bernie Wrightson, colored by Bill Wray, takes the cake.

For one thing, it's one of the few places €“(outside of Final Crisis) that you'll see Batman wielding a gun. He sort of has a rule against them. He also kills people, too, which isn't really in line with his usual MO.

Forgive him, though, for he knows not what he does. The whole premise of The Cult is that the Dark Knight is abducted by, well, a cult. Specifically an underground cabal lead by Deacon Blackfire, whose homeless followers make quick work of kidnapping Batman, keeping him for ages, and brainwashing him. All it takes is man power (and lots of drugs).


3. Back Broken By Bane

bane batman back
DC Comics

Probably the most famous defeat the Caped Crusader ever suffered, and not one he's liable to suffer again (literally, there's an in-universe decision he makes immediately after to integrate a reinforced spine into his costume). Knightfall was a first for comics, around the time DC were also mixing things up by killing of Superman. For, like, a few months or so.

In the same way they took Batman out of commission by having his spine broken by new villain Bane. Which left the cowl to be taken up by unhinged Christian assassin newcomer Azrael, who really didn't do a very good job. Certainly not with the costume.

The way Bane took Batman down is pretty simple. He's a hulking big guy, addicted to the steroid-like Venom, which buffs him up to superhuman strength. He's also really smart, freeing the inmates of Arkham Asylum so they can all attack Batman at once, leaving him weak and tired and vulnerable. That's when he struck.


2. By Going After His Loved Ones

Dead Robin Batman
DC Comics

Ultimately, the way you get at Batman is the same way you get at any supposedly €œinvincible€ hero (so any hero, really). The third act of Man Of Steel was boring because there were no stakes €“ seeing a couple of superpowered dudes duke it out isn't all that exciting, because you know neither of them is really in any peril. When people call Superman boring, they're thinking of that. When Superman is interesting, it's when he's forced to go rescue someone mid-fight, cos he's a good guy. Same applies to Batman.

All of these ways of €œdefeating€ him are fine, but the ones that involve brute strength are just boring. Watching Batman fight someone for twenty pages isn't all that fun €(most of the time, unless you're Frank Miller) €“when you know Batman's probably going to win. You defeat Batman not by taking him out, but those around him.

The Joker's greatest victories over Batman don't involve him fighting the guy. It's when he crippled Barbara Gordon, killed Jason Todd. That's how you €œdefeat€ Batman.


1. Or Killing His Parents

Bruce Wayne Parents
DC Comics

Which is why Joe Chill €“ or whoever they're saying did the deed these days, the continuity is kinda screwy thanks to all the retellings €“ is Batman's ultimate enemy, because he's the architect of his first, most tragic defeat. You reign victory over the Dark Knight by going after his loved ones, so it stands to reason the greatest victory involves those closest to him. Batman's greatest defeat, greatest failure, is when Bruce Wayne was a child, leaving the theatre with his parents Thomas and Martha, and they were gunned down in an alleyway during a botched mugging.

But here's the thing: Bruce turned that defeat into his driving force. His inspiration. His reason for being. Which is the important thing to take away from this, about the Caped Crusader as a character. He's had his ass handed to him countless times, sure. The whole narrative of Batman is that he's somebody who doesn't give up. He's never down for long. He always gets back up. Whatever doesn't kill him makes him stronger.

Although the broken spine thing he could probably have done without. Alfred's not that good of a doctor, surely?


In this post: 
Batman
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Tom Baker is the Comics Editor at WhatCulture! He's heard all the Doctor Who jokes, but not many about Randall and Hopkirk. He also blogs at http://communibearsilostate.wordpress.com/