10 Stupid Arguments About Batman That Don't Make Sense

You think the no killing rule is BS? WRONG.

You might think there are a ludicrous amount of Batman comics, and you'd be right in thinking that. But equally as much as there is written of Batman, there is truckloads written about the Caped Crusader. For ever creative team coming up with new adventures for the Dark Knight, there are academics and internet commenters alike penning missives on him that run into thousands €“ if not millions €“ of words. The 75 years the character has been in the public consciousness has given readers and commentators plenty of time to form opinions and ask questions about Bruce Wayne, but it isn't just that. The varied characterisations, the hinted-at psychology, the sidekicks, all almost require some sort of deep analysis. And strong opinions formed from such analysis €“ since this is comic books €“ will naturally lead to arguments. It's the natural form of dialogue between geeks. It's why the internet is such a hostile place. Obviously you will jump to yelling at someone that they're completely wrong about their diagnosis of Bruce Wayne's mental state instead of a rational debate. No doubt you've had such heated debates yourself, either online or with friends. Maybe you considered the likelihood of him keeping his secret identity, or the validity of his €œno killing rule€. Regardless, you were probably wrong. And here's why. These are ten stupid arguments against Batman that don't make sense.

10. His Secret Identity Doesn't Make Sense

Now this one is just plain foolish. There was a Reddit discussion not too long ago where users discussed how quickly, in real life, it would take the authorities to uncover the secret identity of the Dark Knight. They figured a few weeks, months, tops. The assumption that Bruce Wayne's evening activities should be strikingly obvious to everyone, though, makes a few assumptions. First of all, why would Bruce Wayne even be considered? Besides living in Gotham City, there's nothing that would connect him and Batman. Oh yeah, he's absent whenever Batman is, and has all the resources to do what the Caped Crusader does. Well, you don't see Donald Trump in public all that often, and he's rich as balls, and he's definitely not Batman. The other assumption you make when you express your incredulity that nobody in Gotham has realised the strikingly obvious €“ that Bruce Wayne is Batman €“ is that they'd even want to know. He keeps the city safe, or as safe as it every can be. Why would you jeopardise that by snooping?

9. Neither Does His "No Killing" Rule

This is another big one that gets reeled out frequently, apparently attempting to apply €œreal world€ logic onto a superhero comic. You know, for kids. Trying to introduce any sort of complex morality into a thing for children is bound to bog it down in the banal and the troubling. Watchmen is good and all, but sometimes you just wanna see Batman beat up Clayface and drag him back to Arkham. Therein lies the problem for some people. Every villain Batman subdues and returns to prison at some point breaks out to commit more crimes, then gets arrested, breaks out, and the cylce continues. Sometimes that means some low-level thievery by The Penguin; sometimes it means mass murder sprees by The Joker. Clearly being locked up doesn't work, so why doesn't Batman just kill them? Even with the €œno killing€ rule designed to stop him from stooping to the level of a criminal, surely giving them the chance to continue being criminals is doing more harm than good? Basically that means you are for the death penalty. Which is not legal in Gotham City anyway. Probably.

8. He Shouldn't Be On The Justice League

Now this one is just some wilful foolishness. The Justice League is the home to some of the biggest powerhouses in the DC Universe: Superman! Wonder Woman! Green Lantern! The Flash! Aquaman can talk to fish, or whatever! What do all these superheroes €“ some of them bordering on being literal gods €“ need a smart dude in a rodent suit? Here's another question for you: what is the most boring kind of superhero comic? It's the one where it's just wall-to-wall action sequences, right? Beautifully rendered but totally tension-less battles between superpowered beings who really can't be hurt. It's why the last half hour of Man Of Steel was so boring. There weren't really any stakes. It was just like bashing a couple of action figures together, with no consequences. Sure, Wonder Woman and Superman can take down any physical threat to humanity with one hand tied behind their back, The Flash can go deal with a crisis (but, crucially, not a capital-c Crisis) in a fraction of a second, Green Lantern's job is literally policeman in space. Who comes up with strategies when brute force isn't enough? Who can solve mysteries? Whose car do chicks dig? Batman's.

7. All The Robins Are Kinda Creepy

Now really, if you're going to make this argument, that basically means you're on the side of Fredric Wertham, and you really don't want to be. Wertham was a quack pop psychologist who, in the fifties, at the height of the comic book boom, came out with a book called Seduction Of The Innocent, denouncing these four-colour superheroes as Satanic tracts pulling kids off of the straight and narrow. One of the principal offenders in turning the nation's children into sinners and the like? Batman and Robin, of course, who close relationship definitely harboured some signs of homosexual goings on. Besides the obvious, super offensive assertion that being gay is the same as being a paedophile, Wertham's conclusion requires deliberate misreading. Again, it's applying real life logic to a story about a dude who dresses as a bat to fight crime €“ which is neither big nor clever, Alan Moore/Mark Millar/David S Goyer, delete as applicable €“ but also, clearly nothing's going on between Batman and his various Robins. He just sees in them a similar tragedy to his own lonely, orphaned childhood. And he wants them to get those feelings out through vigilante justice.

6. He's Insane

Besides the €œlol he shags Robin€ thing, one of the primo novice psychologist analyses of the Caped Crusader is that he is definitely insane. For sure. 100% around the twist. He's a man that dresses up like a bat, for Christ's sake! Which, by that logic, you have to denounce basically every superhero in existence for being a crazy person who wears lycra and has some sort of gimmick, usually based on an animal. The idea that Batman is mentally ill is, again, borderline offensive. The idea is that seeing his parents gunned down in front of him must have sent him off of the deep end €“ and hey, who wouldn't? Like, besides the hundreds of thousands of kids in history who have seen that very thing happened to them, and not been diagnosed with anything. Sure, they'll be disturbed, and many will suffer from mental trauma as a result of such a childhood tragedy, but the human mind is a resilient thing. And considering Bruce Wayne's meant to have one of the most brilliant minds on the planet, he's probably not doing too badly. There's a difference between determined and psychopathic.

5. He's Not Insane

On the other hand, it seems somewhat disingenuous to assume there's nothing abnormal at all going on in the Dark Knight's head. After all, he has dedicated his life to eradicating all crime, to the point that he pushes himself to limits €“ mentally, physically and otherwise €“ that no other human being would consider, let alone be capable of. Not every kid who sees their parents killed goes crazy, but they don't become Batman either. So what is going on with old Bruce Wayne? Well, the idea of him suffering a psychotic break, or else the Batman €œpersona€ being some figment of a multiple personality disorder, are both pretty trite. Much more compelling is the recent characterisation by Scott Snyder which has Bruce Wayne's trials and tribulations in Gotham being symbolic of struggles with depression. In fact, Snyder thinks Gotham as a whole is almost a test of your mental durability, a place where troubled minds can be driven to a breaking point and then, having hit rock bottom, build itself up again. Think about it: guy who had horrible childhood trauma, goes away and reinvents himself, returns stronger but still prone to dark days? Sounds a lot like depression.

4. The Dark Knight Films Are Realistic

The fans who revelled in bringing the crushing banality of the real world into the escapist fun of Batman were like pigs in pig mess when Christopher Nolan came along with his Dark Knight trilogy, with Christian Bale playing a Caped Crusader who is nominally more €œrealistic€ that any other that's come before. As if you get get more grim 'n' gritty than Adam West... Right, so when you're coming out and saying that Batman Begins, The Dark Knight et al are realistic depictions of how Batman would work in the real world, you are therefore accepting that somebody could invent a fear toxin like the Scarecrow's, that anybody with an accent as ridiculous as Tom Hardy's Bane could ever exist, and that Katie Holmes has the ability to shape-shift into Maggie Gyllenhaal at will. Which isn't to do down those films or their achievements at all. They're great films (well, 2 and a half great films, perhaps). But any attempt to make Batman more €œrealistic€ is doomed to failure. He's not supposed to be realistic. He's a superhero. You know what happens when superheroes become real? They suck. Like, really.

3. His History Makes No Sense

DC Comics has a particular propensity for dumping large swathes of its continuity, with the very first history-wiping event €“ the classic miniseries Crisis On Infinite Earths €“ being an attempt to tidy their house after having never before paid much attention to their fifty or so years of back story, which in some cases had become needlessly complex, contradictory, and usually involving Super-Babies. Batman especially has been through a lot of changes in his long career. He began as a pulp hero, inspired by radio serials and cheap magazines, who had a much more bat-like look and routinely shot people. Then he got more cheerful, and then €“ after that whole Seduction Of The Innocent thing €“ him and his villains became more like playfully scrapping friendly rivals. Obviously stuff has gotten darker and darker, more serious ever since. How do you coalesce all those things? How is the Christian Bale Batman the same character as the Adam West one? It makes no sense! Nuh uh, Grant Morrison totally explained it in-comic during his run: all those jaunty Golden and Silver Age adventures? Mainly the fault of hallucinogenics. Problem solved!

2. He Isn't A Superhero

So it turns out this list has been organised in order of how ridiculous the arguments are. Obviously, with a character as inherently ridiculous as Batman, you're going to get some patently ridiculous arguments, but this one absolutely takes the biscuit. A favourite of know-it-all dirtbag teens and people who never grew out of being know-it-all dirtbag teens is this pearl of wisdom: technically, Batman isn't a superhero. Why? Because he has no superpowers, of course! Once again, this requires some very foolish assumptions you will feel stupid for making. First of all, really? Superpowers is how you characterise a superhero? Okay, well Iron Man isn't a superhero, because he just has a fancy suit. Same for Green Arrow, and basically every other power-less vigilante. Secondly €“ and most importantly €“ saying that Batman is just a regular person is a total misnomer. He's a man with the motivation to go train his body and mind for the better part of his younger years, who then applies his incredibly muscular bod, crazy fighting skills, and genius-level intellect to fighting crime. Sounds like a normal person? Reckon you could do that if you wanted? You couldn't. So hush.

1. Bruce Wayne Is The Mask, Batman Is His True Self

Oh good, this old chestnut. How long did you spend thinking about this one, genius? A whole five seconds? Seriously, that last one was pretty silly, but this argument about Batman is so old, tired and full of holes it may as well be a pair of Harvey Bullock's socks, which are presumably very old and very gross. That's sort of the guy he is. That's why nobody likes him. So the argument goes that, whilst generally Batman is generally considered as Bruce Wayne's secret identity, it's actually the other way around. Bruce Wayne is a mask he wears, and Batman is in fact his true self, the thing he wants to do, the most sincere iteration of his personality. Absolute hogwash. Both of them are complete fictions. Batman is, obviously, a construct €“ he wasn't born to Mr and Mrs Man, after all €“ but Bruce Wayne is equally as calculated. In fact, nobody knows who the real Bruce Wayne is. Even he probably doesn't know. Batman is a mask, the public Bruce Wayne is a mask, and there's never been any room or time to develop who he truly is as a human being. Woah, all existential. Given a lot of the tripe people speak about the Dark Knight, it probably would do you well to consider something new about old Bats, eh? Like maybe he is super sad.

Contributor
Contributor

Tom Baker is the Comics Editor at WhatCulture! He's heard all the Doctor Who jokes, but not many about Randall and Hopkirk. He also blogs at http://communibearsilostate.wordpress.com/