10 Disastrous Superhero Redesigns
Wolverine has no nose. How does he smell?
There are countless celebrities who apparently have analogues in the fictional DC and Marvel comic book universes. The Avengers were once guests on David Letterman's chat show, Batman and Robin tried to wrap their heads around the Paul Is Dead Beatles conspiracy theory, and Spider-Man teamed up with John Belushi to fight the Silver Samurai back in the seventies (all of those are things that actually happened, because comic books).
What they could really use, though, is a Gok Wan, or a Trinny and Susannah. It's not like superhero costumes are the most dapper get ups in the first place. Even in a world of morphsuits and Lady Gaga, you'd get some funny looks walking down the street donning the Batman cowl, or clanking about in that Iron Man suit of armour. Still, the spandex outfits do the job, and everybody's sort of accepted them as the norm now.
Where the makeover kings and queens would come in handy is when they try and stray from those tried-and-tested costumes. Whether it's a change in the times, a merchandising or movie tie in, or an attempt to boost sales, comic book characters have toyed with different outfits a bunch of times. And usually they're terrible. Here are ten of the most disastrous superhero redesigns.
10. Iron Spider

There isn't much to recommend Mark Millar and Steve McNiven's Civil War miniseries in the first place (which makes it potential adaptation into the third Captain America film a cause for concern), although it did have some nice ideas.
The superheroes of the Marvel universe being pitched against each other in an argument over secret identities and responsibility was a neat concept and, obviously, when you include two of the watchwords of the character, you just know Spider-Man's getting involved. Originally on the pro side of the Superhero Registration Act, Peter Parker wound up revealing his alter ego live on television sending J Jonah Jameson into a fit, and endangering the life of his doddering old Aunt May.
He did, however, team up with Tony Stark, her furnished him with a brand new costume! Which looked like an eleven-year-old's felt tip drawing where he mashed up Spider-Man and Iron Man's costume, only with about half as much charm. It looked like a freakin' Power Ranger.
9. Angsty Aquaman

How do you solve a problem like Aquaman? For the Cinematic Universe it looks like DC are going down the route of casting noted badass Jason Momoa (of Game Of Thrones) in the role, ensuring that he enjoys a better reputation than he does in the comic. Recent iterations of the sea-dwelling superhero have played up to the unpopularity he faces from readers and other characters alike, with many mocking his ability to talk to fish and admittedly pretty goofy orange overalls.
Once upon a time, rather than embrace it, DC tried to fix it. Apparently the way to fix a hopelessly goofy Golden Age hero is to totally transform him into a grim 'n' gritty nineties superhero, which is exactly what they did. The short haired, mostly fancy-free Arthur of Atlantis lost a hand, replaced with a hook, grew a goatee, grew his hair out, and for some reason wore a metal breastplate that covered only half of his chest.
The original Aquaman get up wasn't the height of style or anything, but it was better than being a Thunderdome reject.
8. Extreme Namor

Not to be outdone, Marvel used the totally tubular grimdark tone of nineties comics as an excuse to give their undersea anti-hero a little makeover as well. With, well, interesting results. Designed by now-feted artist Jae Lee, the outfit Namor The Sub-Mariner got saddled with for the better part of a decade wasn't befitting of a king of his stature. Like, at all.
Before that Namor was content to swim around in little green, scaly underpants, and not a whole lot else. A rare example of a character who appeared to be for those other than the straight male gaze, as mostly every superheroine is. The beefcake has been toned down a little in recent years by spoilsports who insist on him wearing a weird black trousers-and-waistcoat (but no shirt still) combo, which doesn't seem like itd be much good when you live underwater.
Still, thats nothing compared to the weird outfit Lee saddled him with, which was more American Gladiator than Prince of Atlantis: the short cropped hair became a wild Tina Turner mane, the speedos swapped for some pointy armour that looks ready-made for an action figure. Which might explain it.
7. Armoured Captain America

The same motivation was almost certainly behind the big, shiny robot suit Steve Rogers donned for a good period of the nineties as well (theres a pattern emerging here). Right now in the Marvel Universe Captain America is no more, as a result of the super soldier serum that gave him his superpowers - and stopped him from aging, despite having been knocking about since the Second World War - suddenly deciding to up and stop working. Now the man who would be Cap is a withered out husk, with the mantle being passed onto former sidekick Sam Wilson, aka The Falcon.
Steve Rogers will eventually return to the Captain America name, by hook or by crook, probably around the time the next films out; plus readers remember the time the same thing happened to him in the nineties, only instead of throwing in the towel, he had one of his many boffin SHIELD pals fashion him a big power suit so he could continue punching inexplicably reverent Nazis.
What was supposed to look like a cool twist on the classic Cap outfit resembled more the get up of forgotten icon NFL Superpro and, yes, seemed like another cynical attempt to launch a toy line.
6. Frankencastle

The Punisher is an inherently serious character. You cant really do jokes with him, unless its the Garth Ennis brand of none-more-black humour, or that page from a few years ago where somebody makes him a machine gun that fires knives. Yes, that really happened. Despite existing in the frequently ridiculous Marvel Universe, Frank Castle tends to remain a lot more grounded.
Whenever he pops up in a superhero title the tone inevitably changes, because the four-colour fun of mainstream comic books doesnt really suit a guy whose criminal killing spree was inspired by his wife and children dying in the middle of a gang war. Still, Jason Aaron gave it the old college try during one of the few attempts to launch a Punisher series in the mainstream Marvel U (previous classic runs were part of the MAX mature readers line), which ended when he got torn to pieces by Wolverines son Daken - long story.
At least, that seemed like the end, until a self-explanatory group called the Legion Of Monsters pieced him back together, and he returned from the dead. Rather a lot like Frankensteins monster, complete with bolts in the neck and stitches all over. Yeah, this one didnt last very long, as he was turned back to normal at the end of the series.
5. Azrael Batman

The nineties was a time of transition for many comic book characters - usually into terrible new costumes - and nowhere was that more true than with Batman. Christopher Nolans final film in his trilogy of Caped Crusader adventures, The Dark Knight Rises, drew heavily from the classic Kinghtfall storyline which debuted towards the beginning of the decade; whats rather telling, though, is what they chose to leave out.
Much like in the comic, the hulking villain Bane snaps Bruce Waynes back, which puts him out of commission as Batman before he can heal. In the comics, though, he doesn't just let Gotham fend for itself. Rather than letting former Robin Dick Grayson don the cowl, however (which would make a lot more sense, and actually did happen - to great effect - during Grant Morrisons recent run on the character), that duty befell Azrael.
You know, Azrael? The guy who was trained as an assassin by a fringe Christian organisation? He was one of the most nineties characters going, and when he became the Dark Knight, he made some characteristic changes to the costume. Which included more colours, glowing red eyes, armour, and shoulder spikes that looked like a kids mash-up of Batman and a He-Man villain.
4. Sexy Sue Storm

Spare a thought for the poor old Invisible Woman. Back when people were still insisting on calling her a Girl, she frequently spent her time in the Fantastic Four comics contending with her husbands (and, to be fair, probably Stan Lees) typically sexist sixties view on women, being asked to cook, clean and fix costumes more often than she was called on to help defeat Doctor Doom. After a little while she graduated to being a Woman, her power set increased greatly, and she was finally seen as a valuable member of the team.
Which didn't make Reed Richards, aka Mr Fantastic, aka her husband of several decades, pay any more attention to her. He was more interested in his experiments and inventions. As a particularly drastic attempt to turn his head, she took some scissors to her classic Fantastic Four costume, cutting a 4 out in the chest to expose her cleavage, and swapping the tights out for thigh-high boots and gloves, with a plunging neckline too.
This ended up being her actual costume for a while, which was sort of creepy and not particularly battle-ready. Good thing she has those force fields...
3. Biker Wonder Woman

For decades writers and artists have struggled to figure out what to do with Wonder Woman. Her origin story has changed more times than Gerard Way changes his hair, nobody has quite felt comfortable with the undertones of misandry (and bondage) that were introduced with her original pre-war appearance, and the costume seems to be under constant need of redesign.
Inevitably it reverts back to the classic Lynda Carter get up, but she spent a good portion of the sixties dressed as a mod and solving crimes without her powers. Which was pretty silly, and it soon got fixed, but it wasn't anywhere near as bad as the redesign courtesy of Mike Deodato Jr, whose sense of style was about as developed as his understanding of female anatomy.
As in, not very. Thanks to him, Wonder Woman spent the better part of ten years rocking this weird biker look, with an exposed - and strangely shiny - bra, short shorts (at least they had stars on them!), and little leather boots to match her jacket. It was totally unsuitable for the character and pretty gross, all told.
2. Feral Wolverine

Logans been going through a tough time of it at the minute, but thats nothing compared to the trials and tribulations he had to put up with throughout the nineties (seriously, spot the pattern in these disastrous redesigns, why dont you).
During the Fatal Attractions storyline that was supposed to return Magneto to his status as the X-Mens most fierce nemesis - as well as pushing his rival, Professor X, further than he ever has before to stop him - Wolverine came up against the master of magnetism and tried to gut him with his claws, only for the villain to remove the adamantium from Logans skeleton, nearly killing him. Xavier unleashed a psychic attack that did much the same to Magneto, but the damage was already done to Wolverine.
Besides causing him intense psychological and physical pain, ripping the metal from his bones also turned him "feral": which meant that, along with losing much of the control and inhibitions hed spent years trying to crack, he also had bone claws, tore up his classic yellow-and-blue costume so he could wear a face mask like one of the ninja turtles, and his nose disappeared. Thats not just weird art, he had no nose. How did he smell? Probably as well as he looked.
1. Mullet Superman

One of the things that caused such an outcry against Zack Snyders Man Of Steel film from last year is that the Superman appearing on the screen didnt appear to have a whole lot in common with the Superman who had become a cultural icon over the course of decades of comic books, radio shows, TV appearances, serials and other (better) films.
Superman is an alien, sure, but hes also an all-American hero, and is supposed to be an example of what humanity can achieve. Hes a paragon, in the same way the United States see themselves. Part of that involves the red, blue and yellow classic costume - with pants over trousers, thanks; part of it is in the way he makes time not only to fight planet-eating enemies but also get cats down from trees, help old ladies cross the street, and rescue civilians from the destruction; but an underrated aspect is the haircut.
That short crop with the S-shaped spit curl of a fringe is as American as apple pie. Which means that when, in the late eighties/early nineties, he rocked a mullet? Barely recognisable. Superman looked like a member of Lynyrd Skynyrd, and an icon was single-handedly destroyed overnight.