10 Times Daredevil Was Forced To Kill

Bullseye, not a fan of his own medicine...

There were some viewers who were surprised when they tuned into Netflix's Daredevil series, not expecting an entry in the mostly sunny, PG-13 action world of the Marvel Cinematic Universe to be quite so...bloody. Matt Murdock does not go for the diplomatic approach in that show, frequently breaking bones and just torturing bad guys to get what he wants. Morality is slippery in the Marvel Universe. Wolverine has admitted to killing countless people €“ it's difficult not to with those pig-stickers that pop out of his hands €“ but he's still treated like a hero. The Punisher, meanwhile, is a pariah to the rest of the superhero community; they consider his shoot first, shoot some more, and not bother asking any questions approach repugnant. Even when the pair crossed paths, when Matt Murdock's secret identity was outed and he wound up in prison alongside Frank Castle, Daredevil made it clear that his morality was not comparable nor compatible with The Punisher's. He doesn't kill people. Well, except for all the times that he totally has. Sometimes because he didn't have a choice. Other times... Where the likes of Spider-Man and Superman have agonised over mercy killings and the like, the Man Without Fear is far more likely to off an enemy, then revel in Catholic guilt for years after. Most of the time, anyway. Sometimes, he's killing Bullseye, and you can't really blame him for enjoying it. Here are ten times Daredevil was forced to kill...

10. Slain So Many Ninjas

Where is your precious moral code when it comes to The Hand, huh Murdock? As much as all the bone-crunching violence came as a surprise to virgin Daredevil viewers, eventually they got settled into that. It was gritty, street level stuff. Like a realistic cop drama! And then ninjas starting turning up and everyone was confused again. For what it's worth, their appearance in the comic was just as sudden and jarring as well, with Frank Miller introducing his love of chop-socky cinema around the same time he ramped up the Catholic guilt thing by about 1000%. The Hand have since become a big part of Daredevil lore, a ninja clan violently opposed to Murdock's continued existence. The Man Without Fear tends to return in kind, not holding back quite so much with his other enemies as he does with The Hand, cutting them down with ease. Sometimes they turn into piles of dust, because they're mystical demons. Sometimes he's just stabbing lots of Japanese people to death to avoid being overwhelmed, which isn't cool.

9. Murdered Seemingly Everyone In Daredevil Reborn

An even stranger turn recently was when Matt Murdock became leader of The Hand, the ninja clan that had seemingly spent the rest of his life trying to kill him. He made an ultimately unsuccessful attempt to run Hell's Kitchen by building a huge pagoda in the middle called Shadowland and, thrown out, had to go on a soul-searching journey. That's exactly what the Man Without Fear did in Daredevil: Reborn, a four-issue limited series from 2011 written by Andy Diggle. Matt Murdock goes to Mexico and meets a kid who's clearly meant to be an avatar for his younger self: blind, orphaned, confused, and in need of some moral guidance. What the pair actually come across is Calavera, a mob boss who can split open a person's soul and show it to them. In Daredevil's case that apparently means having visions of standing atop a pile of corpses of people he thinks he killed over the course of Shadowland, including (but not limited to) Iron Fist, Spider-Man, and Bullseye.

8. Threw The Masked Marauder Through His Own Force Field

That's not to suggest that Daredevil only got stabby in the later years of his career, however. No siree. Matt Murdock was already well acquainted with the blood all over his hands, even if he couldn't see it, way back in the sixties. A lot goes on in 1967's Daredevil #27, including a confrontation with Stilt-Man and a Spider-Man team-up. The stand-out of the events in €œMike Murdock Must Die!€, however, is when Daredevil accidentally just kills the Masked Marauder. Inexplicably becoming a recurring villain later on when this death was retconned, it was revealed eventually that the Marauder was the landlord of Murdock and Nelson's building for some reason. Before then, however, he was simply another supervillain threatening a hero's girlfriend (Karen Page, in this case). Daredevil fought tooth and nail to retrieve her safe and sound, accidentally tossing the Masked Marauder into a forcefield he created, incinerating him instantly. Later they went back and claimed it was a teleporter, not a forcefield, but still.

7. Empath In The Age Of Apocalypse

The Age Of Apocalypse was not kind to anybody. Whilst crossover leaders the X-Men were dealing with bad costumes, worse haircuts and stupid plot twists, the rest of the Marvel Universe didn't escape from this dystopian future where genocidal maniac mutant Apocalypse orders all regular humans (and their sympathisers) be put to death. Matt Murdock still had his magical radar-vision following an incident with some toxic waste, and so he was mutated enough to be worthy of employment by Apocalypse. Not quite a villain but not all that nice either, Keeper Murdock was charged with handling a prisoner of Apocalypse lackey Mikhail Rasputin. Empath has the ability of projecting his feelings out to those all around him, which Rasputin utilised by hooking the young mutant up to a computer so that he might better subjugate an entire country. Murdock realises how much pain this puts Empath in after touching him, and kills him to put him out of his misery.

6. Kicked Typhoid Mary Out A Window

This is another one that got retconned, but back in the day, it really seemed like Matt Murdock kicked a sex worker out of a window and accidentally killed her during an early vigilante outing. Obviously this is in Frank Miller territory €“ dead women, especially in the sex trade, always smacks of Miller €“ in origin story Man Without Fear. The 1993 mini-series, written by Miller and drawn by John Romita Jr and Al Williamson, retells Daredevil's origins in greater detail, and greater grimness. If you're thinking that sounds almost exactly like Batman: Year One, then you've probably figured out what Frank Miller's one-sentence pitch was. One incident in the story involves a pre-Daredevil Matt Murdock, concealing his face with a ski mask, breaking into a brothel and beating up the pimp. The women, concerned they won't get paid, pile on Murdock and in the fray he kicks one out a window. Her death haunts him throughout the series...until it gets retconned as Typhoid Mary's origin story.

5. Beat The Kingpin To Death

If Frank Miller's run on the book, or the Netflix series, seem depressing €“ then you probably haven't read Daredevil: End Of Days. Returning to the character to cap off his long stretch of writing (probably amongst the best post-Miller Man Without Fear stories), Brian Michael Bendis penned what was supposed to be the last Daredevil story. It's set way in the future, but Bendis invoked another Miller classic in talking about it: €œThis is in continuity; not too dissimilar to how Dark Knight Returns became continuity through sheer force of will.€ Which means that there are even darker days ahead for Matt Murdock, ending with Bullseye killing him in a final battle. Years before that, however, he has made contact with The Kingpin. Wilson Fisk, returned to New York City from exile in another country after brokering a deal with the federal government, is confronted by Daredevil in a restaurant, and refuses to leave the country once again. So Daredevil kills him, in front of a lot of people, and says he had no choice.

4. Killed Three Muggers On A Subway Train

That said, Frank Miller is somewhat unparalleled in his ability to make the most unrelentingly grim superhero stories this side of Man Of Steel. His own alcoholism, misogyny and fascist leanings probably help in constructing such a worldview. And the first place he tried it out for a sustained period was on Daredevil. What was once a mostly fun-loving vigilante (albeit with a tragic origin), Miller made a man driven to the brink of insanity time and again by his actions. €œBorn Again€ saw Frank Miller go all in with making Daredevil into a violent, deranged psychopath, thanks to The Kingpin systematically ruining his life. He probably can't blame Wilson Fisk for one incident in the story, however, where Matt Murdock is mugged on a subway train and defends himself in a slightly more zealous fashion than usual. It's not shown on panel but heavily implied with the narration that he just kills the three guys. Sure, they're muggers, but they didn't deserve that...

3. Convinced Mysterio To Kill Himself

Kevin Smith should not write comic books. He should stick to what he knows: penning gross-out comedy films with a strangely intricate continuity and obsessive audience, and tweeting about his sex life with his wife. Because when the card-carrying fanboy turns his hand to actually writing the superhero stories he so loves, they don't turn out well. Whilst €œGuardian Devil€ is regarded as the storyline that brought Daredevil back to the mainstream after falling into popularity limbo for much of the eighties and nineties, it's not a good book. Long suffering Murdock love interest Karen Page dies, Daredevil is hypnotised into thinking a baby is the anti-Christ and nearly throws it off a roof. In the end, it turns out the whole thing has been orchestrated by Spider-Man villain Mysterio, who is dying of cancer and couldn't get final revenge on his nemesis because the Clone Saga was happening. So he messes with Daredevil instead, the confrontation ending with Matt convincing Mysterio is so useless he should kill himself. So he does.

2. Stabbed Bullseye Through The Heart

To describe Bullseye and Daredevil's relationship tumultuous is not so much an understatement as a lack of understanding about how the English language works. Even before he killed Karen Page, the assassin was already committed to destroying everything good in Matt Murdock's life €“ beginning with his murder of Elektra back in the day. Daredevil very nearly killed Bullseye after that, dropping him off a building so he broke every bone in his body. The hit man only survived that because his skeleton was replaced with adamantium. It seemed like Bullseye was destined to live forever, and to forever kill anyone Daredevil got close to. He sorta forced his hand. When Daredevil finally just up and stabbed Bullseye through the chest, mimicking how Elektra got killed, you can just about understand. Turns out Matt Murdock was literally forced into that, however, since he spent the entirety of the Shadowland epic that occurred in possessed by a demon. Thus, he didn't have a choice.

1. Actually, Killed Every Bullseye In Every Reality

Yeah, right. As if Matt Murdock wouldn't kill Bullseye if he got the chance. In fact, after dropping him off a building there was an entire issue of Daredevil dedicated to him sitting in the hospital room playing Russian roulette with the paralysed Bullseye. It was messed up. You can use possession as an excuse, but that isn't always the case. Basically every single €œWhat If?€ €“ that is, alternate-reality stories that consider how famous Marvel storylines might have gone with one key change €“ story involving Daredevil has him killing Bullseye. Not whilst a demon's controlling him, or by accident, or by proxy. Just going up to him and murdering him. In €œWhat If Daredevil Died Saving Elektra?€, both he and Bullseye kill each other. Daredevil kills him in the futuristic Marvel Knights Millennial Visions #1. He fantasies murdering him in €œThe Murdock Papers Part 6€. The aforementioned Daredevil: Reborn sees him stabbing him right through the chest again. Sometimes, Daredevil is driven to kill €“ he's literally forced, he has no choice, he does it by accident. In the case of Bullseye, though, he just really, really hates him. And murders him every chance he gets.

In this post: 
Daredevil
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Tom Baker is the Comics Editor at WhatCulture! He's heard all the Doctor Who jokes, but not many about Randall and Hopkirk. He also blogs at http://communibearsilostate.wordpress.com/