8 Changes That Would Have Completely Fixed Batman Forever

batmanforever

I was twelve years old when Batman Forever came out in theaters. This was in the dark ages before everybody had the Internet, so I didn€™t even know this movie was being made until I saw the poster, and I was ridiculously excited about it. Batman Returns was one of my favorite movies as a kid, and I made my parents buy me almost everything that had Batman€™s name on it back then€”toys, video games, comics, clothes, if it was related to Batman, I probably had it and I watched Batman: The Animated Series religiously. When I actually saw the movie, I loved it. Again, I was twelve, what did I know at the time? I thought it was great that we finally got to see Robin on the big screen and I thought Jim Carrey was totally entertaining as the Riddler. But as I got older, I started to realize that although I still loved Batman and Batman Returns, Batman Forever was just really bad. Unfortunately, it didn€™t have to be. The story goes that there was a huge backlash to Batman Returns, which was perceived to be a movie for children and parents complained about how it was too scary. McDonald€™s pulled their endorsement for the movie and Warner Bros ordered director Tim Burton to lighten up the third movie. He refused, so they replaced him with Joel Schumacher. And what we got was€well, you€™ve all seen it (if you haven€™t count yourself lucky). But if I had access to a time machine, there are ways it could be fixed.

8. Do Away With The Humor

humor

I€™m not saying the movie has to be completely melodramatic. Nobody really wants that. Nolan€™s Dark Knight Trilogy, despite being darker than the original quadrilogy, still managed to squeeze in moments of levity. But they were more organic. You didn€™t have stupid puns and one-liners, but rather real exchanges that were peppered with a few chuckle-worthy lines. There were lots of scenes involving Michael Caine and Morgan Freeman interacting with Christian Bale when they manage to pull off some genuinely funny lines. Not laugh-out-loud screaming funny, but they bring a smile to your face. Batman Forever went too far. Instead of interactions that felt real, we were given painfully un-funny gags. Like Batman€™s one-liners about stopping for drive-thru, or how €œchicks dig the car,€ asking of Chase Meridian €œare you trying to get under my cape, Doctor?€ or quipping that she should go after firemen because there€™s less to take off. Or Dick Grayson taking the Batmobile to a street race and then telling everyone he€™s Batman and he just forgot his suit. All this needs to be completely excised from the script. This is too much levity and it brings the film away from its origins as a dark, serious, and respectful take on the Batman and pushes it into the realm of over-the-top absurdity.

7. Keep It Dark

dark

One of the biggest complaints about Batman Returns is that it was too dark. This doesn€™t only come from over-protective parents and McDonald€™s executives who were pissed they weren€™t selling enough Happy Meals, but also a criticism from a sizable portion of Batman fans. Personally, I don€™t agree€”Batman Returns is my favorite of the original series€”but I can see their point. More than that, I€™ve always said that the problem with Batman Returns is that it€™s a good movie, but not a good Batman movie. I think Burton pushed the envelope too much with the weirdness factor with things like Penguin being a mutant bird-man, Catwoman being resurrected by cats, and€commando penguins. That being said, I didn€™t think it was too dark. I can understand some things, like Batman€™s ease with killing people (he sadistically straps a bomb to one criminal€™s chest and sets another on fire with the Batmobile€™s jet engine, just as two examples). Batman Forever could have found a more appropriate middle ground and taken the movie back towards the tone of the first Batman film. For that, you need to go back to the gothic-inspired architecture in the design of Gotham. I don€™t know who thought day-glo paint and neon lights in the Batmobile would be a good idea, but whoever did clearly needs to have their head bashed against a wall.

6. Why Is Chase Meridian Even Here?

chase

From here, I€™m going to look at some character-specific problems. And Chase Meridian has a huge one. Namely that she isn€™t really much of a character. She€™s supposed to be a professional psychiatrist, but she spends most of the film acting like a teenage groupie. The only thing she seems to care about is getting Batman into bed, throwing herself at him relentlessly. Until she meets Bruce Wayne, at which point her life becomes all about him. Nicole Kidman is a great actress, but this role is just badly written from start to finish. This whole love story is just completely unnecessary and it serves as a poor subplot. You could cut every single scene with Chase out of this movie and no one would bat an eye. That€™s how completely ineffectual she is to the plot. But if you wanted to completely rewrite her character, that would be acceptable. Chase Meridian should be someone who is a lot less interested in what€™s under the black rubber and more interested in the effect Batman has on Gotham City as a whole. He basically created the Joker and since he appeared in Gotham, the city has had to contend with a steady stream of freaks. That€™s what her role should be, examining the impact Batman has on the world, and figuring out for herself through her sessions with Bruce that he€™s Batman.

5. A Consistent Batman

batman

When Burton was replaced by Schumacher, at first previous Batman Michael Keaton had agreed to stay onboard and was looking forward to playing the Dark Knight once more. But shortly after, he turned down what would have been his highest salary for playing Batman because he didn€™t like the direction the movie was going in. At that point, he was replaced by Val Kilmer. Kilmer is a good actor, but his performance was hampered. A big part of that is probably because he accepted the role before reading the script, so he probably thought he was in store for a completely different movie, and ended up having numerous problems with Schumacher and the crew. Batman co-creator Bob Kane, however, felt that Kilmer gave the best interpretation of Batman ever (by that point). But this movie really hampered Batman. He€™s just all over the place. He€™s fixated on the death of his parents, but he meets Chase Meridian and suddenly he€™s all, €œI€™m shutting it down, Alfred€? More than that, he€™s shutting it all down when he knows two villains are out there terrorizing the city? His one-liners were mentioned earlier. The decision to take Batman away from feeling no qualms about killing criminals was definitely appropriate and far more in line with the Batman of the comics, but without any sort of development of that, it felt totally hypocritical when compared to the last movie. Bruce€™s speech to Dick about how if he kills Two-Face, his pain will only grow and he€™ll go out to find another face and then another until revenge becomes his whole life was one of Kilmer€™s shining moments in the movie. Unfortunately, when compared to Batman Returns, there€™s no real explanation for that character change. I€™m actually of a mixed mind whether or not I€™d keep Kilmer. On the one hand, Keaton was far superior and seeing him in a third outing would have been great. On the other hand, I believe Kilmer had it in him to be a great Batman if not for the problems. And it should go without saying, but just as another reminder: no bat-nipples. Seriously, Joel. What the hell?

4. Recast Robin

robin

I have no idea what casting directors were thinking when they chose Chris O€™Donnell to be Dick Grayson. For one, he and Kilmer are so close in age that the whole father-figure thing came off like Bruce was trying too hard to act older than he was, while Dick seemed extremely immature. Adding to that, O€™Donnell is just not a very good actor. I can€™t think of a single movie I€™ve seen where I actually enjoyed his performance and in this, he really is the odd man out. The rest of the cast, although they don€™t show it in Batman Forever, are great actors. It€™s all the more baffling how O€™Donnell got the role in the first place given far better actors who auditioned for the role. Matt Damon, Jude Law, Ewan McGregor, and, ironically enough, Christian Bale were all considered, as were others. The final choice actually came down to O€™Donnell and Leonardo DiCaprio. But instead of making the decision based on acting ability, instead they took photos of O€™Donnell and DiCaprio, showed then to eleven-year-old boys, and asked them who would win in a fight. When they overwhelmingly said O€™Donnell, he got the part. DiCaprio was still in his pretty-boy teen heartthrob stage of his career at that time, but had he done a serious Batman movie as Robin, he might have been able to move away from that at an earlier point. More than that, his youthful looks would have made the father/son dynamic between Bruce and Dick make more sense. Plus, he€™s just flat-out a far better actor than O€™Donnell.

3. Rein In The Riddler

riddler

Jim Carrey is a great actor when he tries. The problem with Batman Forever is he was cast because of his success in Ace Ventura, which became a hit because of the slapstick comedy. And so the Riddler in Batman Forever became a total slapstick character, complete with bad jokes and Carrey€™s manic performance. What was the point of the bright-red hair? Or all the cane-twirling? Or terrible lines like €œLike the jacket? It keeps me safe when I€™m€jogging at night!€ And all the absurd cackling. Plus the bizarre Bruce Wayne fixation. But watch Carrey in a movie like The Number 23, which although flawed, still showed that he can do dark. If he brought more of that into his performance instead of trying to do a Frank Gorshin impersonation, he could have given us a really special Riddler. If we are going to talk about recasting the Riddler, though, go with Robin Williams. The story goes that back when Warner Bros was trying to get Jack Nicholson to play the Joker in Batman, Nicholson was being indecisive. They then offered the part to Williams, who accepted. Warner Bros then went back to Nicholson and told him if he doesn€™t accept the role, Williams will get it and at that point, Nicholson took the part. When Warner Bros approached Williams about playing the Riddler, he apparently said only if they apologized for using him as bait to get Nicholson. They didn€™t and so Williams said no. And if there€™s one comedic actor who can tackle dark roles, it€™s Williams. He was awesome in movies like One Hour Photo and Insomnia and those give us a glimpse into what his Riddler could have possibly been like.

2. Two-Face Is NOT The Joker

twoface

Tommy Lee Jones said he took the role of Two-Face because his son told him Two-Face was his favorite character. Although watching Jones€™ performance, it makes you wonder if his son€™s favorite character was actually the Joker and Jones was just confused. Because there is pretty much nothing about Two-Face present in Jones€™ performance. Instead, he comes off as a poor man€™s Joker, constantly laughing with the occasional throw-away line to luck and chance. One of the most maddening scenes with Jones (and there are many) is when he and the Riddler break into Wayne Manor. As Bruce Wayne is fighting off their men, Two-Face sits in a chair and keeps flipping his coin, getting disappointed whenever it lands on the good side. Instead of just accepting the outcome, he continues flipping until it comes up the way he wants! As anyone who knows Two-Face will tell you, that is absolutely not something the character would do. The coin is how his decisions are made, if it comes up on the good side, that€™s his decision. He doesn€™t keep trying until he gets the decision he really wants. Referring to himself as €œwe€ didn€™t help, and he and Carrey seemed to have made a bet to see who could act the most outrageous in the film without being told to turn it down a notch. So to fix Two-Face, I say go with the original choice of Billy Dee Williams. When Williams was cast to play Harvey Dent in Batman, his contract guaranteed that he€™d get to play Two-Face in a sequel. In fact, that was the entire reason he signed on to the movie in the first place. But because Schumacher wanted Jones, Warner Bros had to buy out Williams€™ contract. That turned out disastrously, so bring back Williams. I would love to see how he could tackle Two-Face.

1. Let Schumacher Make His Movie

schumacher

I already know how pissed off this is going to make people. But the fact of the matter is Schumacher was in an extremely unenviable situation with Batman Forever. It doesn€™t matter what director was hired, they would have given us the same movie, or something much worse. Warner Bros was dead-set on making a more light-hearted movie and they would have made the same version of Batman Forever with or without Schumacher. They already proved with Burton that they weren€™t going to budge, they cut down Schumacher€™s final cut considerably, so why people continue to lay all the blame at Schumacher€™s feet is baffling. Schumacher can make good movies. He can make serious, dark films. Watch Falling Down or Tigerland. If Schumacher was given the freedom to make the Batman movie he wanted to make, it would have been a lot closer to the source material and would have been more pleasing to the fans. Of course, Schumacher€™s not perfect. It was his idea to put nipples on the costume and to give Dick Grayson an earring because it made him €œmore hip,€ plus all the neon. Those things would definitely need to be reined in. But as far as making a Batman movie that€™s dark without going too far into the surreal elements that Burton injected into Batman Returns, he€™s more than capable of it. So I say keep Schumacher, control him where it€™s necessary, like replacing Williams with Jones or throwing neon on everything, but let him go nuts if it will work for the movie. What do you think of these suggested changes to Batman Forever? Share your thoughts and reactions below in the comment thread.

Contributor
Contributor

Percival Constantine is the author of several novels and short stories, including the Vanguard superhero series, and regularly writes and comments on movies, comics, and other pop culture. More information can be found at his website, PercivalConstantine.com