Batman is a character who has lived under many different incarnations since his inception. With Christopher Nolan’s third and final film as director The Dark Knight Rises just around the corner, a reboot has already been mooted by studio Warner Brothers. Very little is known about the reboot at this stage and Warner Bros haven’t likely figured it out for themselves just yet, though when speaking to the LA Times back in March 2011, studio boss Jeff Robinov said:
“We have the third Batman, but then we’ll have to reinvent Batman…Chris Nolan and [producing partner and wife] Emma Thomas will be producing it, so it will be a conversation with them about what the next phase is.”
With Warner Bros. presumably keen not to take too much heat away from The Dark Knight Rises and understandably so, not much else has been mentioned regarding Batman’s cinematic future. What is known is that a probable ‘reinvention’ is on the cards and that Christopher Nolan and Emma Thomas will likely be involved as producers, that’s it.
With this in mind, speculation as to who might be the next Batman once the Dark Knight has risen may seem a little arbitrary, but its fun right?
After the success of Nolan’s first two efforts and the inevitable success of the third instalment, it seems unlikely that Warner Bros. will want to stray too far from their winning formula, but it doesn’t mean they won’t.
The recently released Spider-Man reboot, The Amazing Spider-Man didn’t mark a radical new direction for Peter Parker (ok, he’s a bit younger), and comes just 10 years after the Sam Raimi-directed original. Yet the box office hit $59m in two days, proving that an easily accessible franchise reboot is a no brainer for the studio. The superhero blockbuster is the cash cow that keeps on giving. By that rationale, its reasonable to suppose that the next Batman movie wont be too different in tone from Nolan’s. If the studio casts a younger Batman, they can start the franchise over, re-tell the origins story and get another three films from a well trodden, audience-friendly, familiar character with a pre-existing fan base.
If this is the case then unfortunately for some fans, this may mean it’s the masses that gets what it wants, leaving other directions uncovered. In 2000, Darren Aronofsky was set to co-write with Frank Miller on an adaptation of Batman: Year One. As a film the project was shelved, with the reboot perhaps Warner Bros. will give Aronofsky another shot? Perhaps a more comic book feel will be introduced, although with the darker tone of Nolan’s trilogy proving successful and the failed comic book style of Schumacher’s Batman & Robin, the studio may be hesitant.
Getting to Batman himself, with Christian Bale supposedly leaving, who will get to don the next Batsuit? Whatever direction Warner Bros. decides to go, there’s a number of common traits the lucky actor will need to fill and a number of elements the studio will have to consider.
Obviously they’ll need to be Batman and Bruce Wayne. They will therefore need to be equally adept at playing a billionaire playboy and suit-wearing, crime-fighting tough guy. The right choice will not only need to look the part, but be convincing in the role, Batman is an highly intelligent, serious character with burden and responsibility. With little known about the proposed reboot there are a number of things to consider. The studio may want to start a fresh and cast an unknown or up-and-comer, with the intention of not only making a new film, but a new franchise. Without a star there’s an element of risk (John Carter anyone?), though perhaps an A-lister or someone synonymous with another franchise would be distancing and thus distract the audience from believing in the character.
Taking all this into account, here’s 10 ways they could go when casting the next bat flick, and despite loving the idea of how awesome his chin might look in the famed Batsuit, Bruce Campbell didn’t quite make the cut, in no particular order, here’s who did.
Click “next” below to start our journey…
You Might Also Like...
- 10 Films That Gave The Game Away Too Early
- 5 Great Characters That Deserve Another Chance In A Superhero Movie
- 6 Reasons DC’s Cinematic Universe Will Never Rival Marvel’s
Want to write about the stuff you're passionate about and have your work read by an audience of over 10 million a month? Click here to become a contributor.









16 Comments
Read a theory about Dark Knight Rises being the death of Bruce Wayne, but somebody else taking the role of Batman. Apparently it has happened a few times in the comic books, but im not sure it would work or fit in with the films. They were suggesting that Joseph Gordon Levitt’s role will be quite major in the new film as either a continuation of the Batman legend or a kind of unoffical Robin role. As i said I wouldn’t expect Nolan to go that cheesy to have the mask passed on after Wayne, but interesting theory.
I’m hoping for a completly different comic book approach for the re-boot if it must happen, it would then fit nicely into the rumoured Justice League film.
Gosling NEEDS to play Finnick Odair in Catching Fire!
I’d go Guy Pearce but Gosling would be an interesting one.
i would love to see gosling as batman, i think it would work really well.
JGL, or Faaaastbender :)
what about Karl Pilkington
This I would love to see.
I find it funny that this website posted an article named “the 10 golden rules of superhero movies” in wich one of the Golden Rules was that an actor must not play a superhero in two different movies. And 2 actors in this list already played a superhero, and another one had a small part in another superhero movie.
Thos are not official, unbreakable rules, I know this. It is an article written for entertainment purposes. But I think this rule is one that’s in our heads, all of us. Everyone who saw the Fantastic Four movies back then all thought the same thing when Chris Evans was cast as Steve Rodgers “Haha, hey wasn’t that guy the Human Torch ?”. Fassbender might be a good pick (better than Nicholas Cage or Ryan Gosling, hahaha !), but it’d feel so unnatural to see Magneto suddenly living alone in Gotham, fighting crimes as a giant bat.
We all assosciate faces to characters (in superhero movies) and there is plenty, PLENTY of other good picks in the less-mainstream list of actors that could wear that cowl.
I think it all depends how closely they are associated with the character. X-Men: First Class is an ensemble, not led by one particular character and dare I say it, a more minor comic book film than Batman. Same with Fantastic Four, which is more minor still.
If someone like (not suggesting this is a good idea, but to illustrate the point), Toby Maguire or Hugh Jackman was cast as Batman, because they’ve played the same role in a number of blockbuster films, they’ve become too closely associated with their characters and therefore changing suits probably isn’t going to work.
For a reboot Arnie Hammer… For a continuation of the current story or for a story of a stablished Batman (I mean no origin story) Fassbender and Gosling… And for an adaptation of The Dark Knight Returns I choose John Hammer…. But the idea of Sgt. Slaughter is fascinating in a scary way.
This list is awful. Of these guys, the only ones who should even get a passing mention for the part are Manganiello, Hamm, Fassbender, and Gosling. I’m not sold on the former, Fassbender’s already Magneto, Hamm is probably too old, but after Drive, Gosling might actually work.
So 4 of the guys are passable and one is already Batman, 50% isn’t bad. The Fassbender as Magneto thing I don’t personally see as an issue. As mentioned, Hamm is older, the casting of him would bring something different to the table. Who would you have then?
This list is great. Cruise could wear some sweet stacked heels, and Cage’s Wayne could have a Trump (money money money…. money!) style hair-do/piece. McKellen is still Magneto, not Fassbender, but as suggested he would make a great Bond.
This list is great. Cruise’s Batman could wear some sweet stacked heels, and Cage’s Wayne could have a Trump (‘Money money money… Money!) style hair-do/piece. McKellen is Magneto, not Fassbender.
uhm Armie Hammer was cast as batman in that 2008 Justice league film that went no where.
He was indeed, but the film didn’t leave the production stages so he hasn’t played him, so he still could.