21 Most Replayable Video Games Of The 2000s

There are few titles gamers won't go back through to get their money's worth, but these beauties ate up entire lifetimes for many different spectacular reasons.

Gaming The idea of a game being replayed is nearly always par for the course for any player, and it most definitely goes quadruple if you've just purchased the likes of Metal Gear Solid Ground Zeroes. Being that its average runtime seems to be around the one hour mark you're going to need to squeeze every bit of content out of it to get your money's worth. Then you have guys like Heavy Rain writer and director David Cage stating upon the game's release in 2010 that he would prefer you only play through the title once, thereby having to live with whatever choices you made for all eternity. Yet most of us genuinely want to go back through any game, for a whole plethora of different reasons; anything from the sheer joy of the games' mechanics, to character design and art direction or just to see certain moments or animations over again have made gamers who we are; all wanting to find that last hidden collectable and explore every corner of the world laid out in front of us. That very idea of playing something through once is a strange concept in comparison to other artforms though, as we all know when diving back into whatever experience you're dedicating your time to the outcome will be different. Gamers author their own experiences to some degree, which is something that many have used in the past to state that 'games cannot ever be art'. However it is through exploring the coding of the games themselves and through combining the 'authorable' (or playable) sections of a game with the other directly expositional sections that create some of the greatest gaming experiences of all time.

21. Spider-Man 2

Treyarch's second movie tie-in was the first to take the wall-crawler and put him in a free-roaming city where the only limit to your playtime was when you got sick of leaping off the Empire State and thwipping your way down Main Street. The answer to that is never. Of course being in the throngs of a post-GTA III world, everybody and their granny was developing open-world titles, yet in this case the very idea of giving you infinite time to wear the iconic red 'n blue costume and dole out precognitive Spidey-Sense'd justice throughout the city was genuinely salivating. Chuck in a bunch of random pedestrian side-missions involving everything from ferrying people to hospital who had life-threatening injuries to reprising Peter Parker's pizza-delivery job (except with added rooftop-leaping), and you had a thoroughly enjoyable experience where most people had a blast flinging Spidey through Central Park, never mind doing the missions in between. Even today although Spider-Man: Web of Shadows almost reached the same heights as S2, and last year's Amazing Spider-Man tie-in was a surprisingly fun romp through a city with some pretty cool spectacle-infused boss battles, the weight of the above title's web-swinging and sense of immersion in a city relying on you to save it has yet to be beaten. Replay it specifically for: Hitching a ride on a helicopter to visit the Statue of Liberty.

20. Super Mario Galaxy

"Just one more star...I just need one.more.star" you utter as the clock once again strikes midnight and the sinking realisation (or utterly pride-worthy) sensation you've spent the evening collecting digital stars begins to take hold, as Mario Galaxy and Crackdown both have the honour of being able to call themselves the only games over the years that have collectables worth collecting for the sheer fun of it. Whilst the latter was another great super-powered romp that turned things up to 11 in certain spots before Saints Row IV came along and ripped the dial off altogether, the former was another perfect entry into the Mario franchise, replete with system-selling graphics and that oh-so exquisite gameplay that only Nintendo can get just right. Although it's easy to look at Nintendo these days and question their ability to move past the 90's in terms of introducing any new characters to the regular fold, when what they're turning out is as proficient and !*$% adorable as this Pixar-esque wonder, many are glad they stick to their guns and repeatedly tickle the nostalgic nerve in the most satisfying of ways. Replay it specifically for: That feeling you get with every Mario game where the platforming is so perfect you just want to control him that little bit longer, except this time you can venture our for one more notch on your score.

19. Mass Effect 2

A gear-change now, and over to the best sci-fi franchise ever created this side of Star Trek. Yes, it is that damn good. Whereas the original Mass Effect nailed the idea of a fully-immersive sci-fi world chock-full of loveable characters and races, all ripe for the conversational-prodding, it was with Mass Effect 2 that the overarching narrative took a skyward flight, sitting the reputation of the franchise so high in the clouds it would take some sort of blue space child with strange motivations to.....well we all know the rest. Before Bioware shot themselves in the foot with a twelve-gauge through the godawful ending of the original Mass Effect 3 (there's now an extended cut available that tries to somewhat pacify the masses, but it's rather like throwing a battered sandwich at a homeless shelter), ME2 delivered the perfect cocktail of narrative drive and character-embodiment. Giving you the keys to the hovercar and then some, sans spoilers ME2's story puts you back in the resurrected boots of Commander Shepard - a character you can fully customise by the way - and throws you into the middle of a galactic suicide mission against one of the biggest enemies the universe has ever known. The twist in the tale though? It's a group of mercenaries from the first game who bring you back, meaning you're going to have to pick your sides pretty quickly, as well as amassing a suitable Final Fantasy-esque band of rogues to take on the aforementioned enemy. Replay it specifically for: The final suicide mission, where a laundry-list of choices you've made throughout the game decides who makes it through and who dies trying. Can every character actually die, including yourself? Oh yes.

18. Hitman: Blood Money

Following a pretty genre-defining first game and one of the best sequels of all time in Silent Assassin, the series stalled slightly with the floaty controls of Contracts, still turning in a great game but not one that had as much fan-reverence as part two. Enter part four, and the game that shall forever be referred to on playgrounds and in water-cooler-contexts the world over as the question tagged onto every future instalment; "But is it as good as Blood Money?". Absolution certainly wasn't, taking a series whose bread and butter was stalking targets through incredibly huge open areas and planning a hit just like a test-tube-grown laboratory-badass should do, and putting you in increasingly linear levels that also relied on Agent 47 developing Desmond Miles-esque Eagle Vision to mark opponents in bright primary colours. The series' magnum opus, BM gives you a fantastic array of memorable levels, each building in scope from the last and all allowing for you to think of increasingly tactile and hilariously-nefarious ways of offing your targets. Replay it specifically for: The ability to play around with the physics engine that props the game up, planning the perfect assassination by tinkering with the NPC animations and patrols for the sheer 'what if I do this' reward of the gameplay.

17. Call Of Duty 4: Modern Warfare 2

Unleashed on a world waiting to devote entire lifetimes to it's splendour back in 2009, it's funny to think back to those years when the tyrannical internet-buzzword-consuming behemoth of Call of Duty didn't engulf every gaming meme or spring to mind whenever someone mentions online play. Many say this first sequel to the 2007 original that continued the franchise's jump to modern times remains the series' best, contrasting the very well-worn minefield-infested path of the World War II genre by popularising the modern-day shooter like never before. Although going back to a previous COD game is something akin to revisiting an old sports title and knowing that the vast majority of the core fanbase have graduated to whatever the newest annual instalment is, Modern Warfare 2 is that rare kind of military shooter that is actually has a story worth playing through, as well as some perfectly-balanced online combat. Replay it specifically for: Featuring one of the most shocking and talked-about scenes in gaming history in the No Russian level, as well as a huge amount of set-pieces to widen your eyeballs to, with the aforementioned online modes not being overly-complicated or having the burden of forced iteration that plagues the series to this day.

16. The Sims (2 Onwards)

"Just place another plant pot here, and a chair here...and just one more bookcase here and HA! The little guy's stuck!" Such is 99% of people's interactions with their little helpless Sims first-time around. As is the case with certain titles with revolutionary concepts, they tend to shoot for the stars the first time round only for the sequel to have the requisite past-experience boosters needed to carry it all the way in round two. As was the case with Sims franchise and every iteration there's been since. Everybody under the sun knows what the deal is with this series is, such is it's mark on pop-culture that we've all had a go at creating our lives in-game, spending the funds to get that item of clothing that best matches our real-life one, or nabbing a certain accessory that defines our virtual self. The amount of customisation in the games is staggering, and as soon as EA realised there was a market to selling even more additional items, there have been no less than FORTY FIVE separate packs to get ahold of, letting you take your Sim everywhere from university to IKEA. Replay it specifically for: That barely describable feeling of satisfaction you get from your virtual self completing a day's work and not cacking themselves to death after getting stuck behind a bookcase.

15. Arkham Asylum

The debate will continue to rage on about Arkham Asylum vs. City, and although you can totally make the case that the latter's inherent nature as an open-world game provides more things to do, that argument just doesn't hold up when the city itself is practically empty and utterly devoid of said activities outside of working your way through a checklist of bad guys. Hurtling through a few rings with your grapple-gun doesn't count. Instead Asylum was Rocksteady's first attempt at a Batman title and they nailed it more effectively than a hardware store drill demonstrator. Taking influence from one of the most twisted tales ever written under the Batman name with Grant Morrison's endlessly-interpretable divisive masterpiece 'Arkham Asylum: A Serious House on Serious Earth', the final product here is a quintessential Dark Knight experience. Replay it specifically for: That moment after you've stalked a group of thugs through the shadows, eliminating them one-by-one until the last one's heart rate is pounding and you reveal yourself to the sound of scattered gunfire and terrified screams. From cape to cowl, you are the Batman like never before.

14. Halo 2

Although it's slightly died off in cultural relevance since the lofty heights of Halo 3 and the above title's Times Square launch-parties provoking mass hysteria back when original developer Bungie were at the helm, Halo was massively replayed on a religious level throughout the noughties. You can't really go far wrong picking any Halo title, but the reason 2 is the focus here is due to the series' first foray into online gaming on consoles. Many of us had been packing friends into increasingly confined spaces for the sake of split-screen exchanges on the first game, but it was with 2 that Bungie's world takeover began. Deploying you in some of the most memorable maps ever created (Blood Gulch anyone?) Halo 2 proved the Xbox had it's very own Counterstrike, and although we would later find that putting a microphone to the voice of the collective would reap almost universally bad things, those first few years were (and remain) completely unmatched in their fully-voiced, team-spirit-fuelled enjoyment. Replay is specifically for: The impeccable Halo multiplayer experience, comprising a great mix of memorable weapons, game modes and tactics that combine to produce one of the most enjoyable online multiplayer experiences of all time.

13. FIFA/Madden (The Latest Edition)

Sadly Americans reading this won't know the beauty of a casual game of FIFA in an afternoon, but obviously the reverse is true for the rest of us and Madden. The replayability of adding in any sports title is always going to be predicated on a love for the activity itself, and that alone takes many gamers out of the running when comparing the love of such a thing with anything else on this list. However FIFA over in England has still become something of a social institution - a bonding ritual forged in the fires of friend-circles the country over even for those who don't play in real life. Used to settle debates (or start them) as well as just being 'that game' that is the go-to time-killer for workspaces luckily enough to have consoles or generation-spanning households in need of a title to get the parents involved in something other than Call of Duty, FIFA has reigned supreme ever since taking the crown from Pro Evolution Soccer in 2008. Madden on the other hand is the American equivalent of such a game, yet aside from more and more fans becoming increasingly dissatisfied with the amount of new mechanics or content to justify forking out for a new instalment, they're still lapped up in their millions. Replay it specifically for: That sense of competition inherent to multiplayer sports titles that can never be replicated in any work of fiction.

 
First Posted On: 
Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.