Star Wars Battlefront: 10 Crippling Issues That Must Be Fixed

Balanced matches where the Rebels stand a chance? Don't count on it.

It's been a whole decade since Star Wars fans with a love of large scale battles could really get stuck into a worthwhile experience, but now - two console generations later - Battlefront is back. As of October 8th, 2015 we finally got hands-on with the latest build. and now a few days have passed and a few thousand people have alternated between getting blown to smithereens by the Empire, to tying tow cables around an AT-AT's legs to win the fight at the last second, there's a lot to talk about. With it being an open beta EA are looking for people to break down their experiences in the most verbose way possible (they even pop up a "How was your experience?" questionnaire after a few matches) and, as is always the case with the gaming public, it took but only a few minutes before players took to forums across the land to sound off their displeasure at a number of things. From imbalanced matches to a breakdancing Darth Vader hurtling across the skyline, EA and DICE in particular have a reputation for delivering one hell of a graphical punch initially, before the mechanics and overall lack of polish seep in over your remaining play-time. Can Battlefront be the "ultimate Star Wars experience" EA advertised? Maybe. Right now, there are simply too many crippling flaws that need to be addressed.

10. Matches Must Be Balanced And Fair

The most obvious point, and thing people pointed out immediately after their first match, is just how weighted the Walker Assault mode is towards the Empire being victorious. Two things have came of this; 1. The idea being that it's intentionally asynchronous, assumedly to thematically play out the 'might of the Empire' as the Rebels struggle to fight back, and 2. DICE have bowed to peoples' complaints somewhat, saying they're working towards sorting it for retail. However, that's not going to be an easy task. As it stands, all the Empire/Imperials need to do to win is play the level like a standard deathmatch, as eventually the auto-piloted AT-ATs will arrive at the Rebel's defences and blast them to Kingdom Come. Said Rebels on the other hand, need to coordinate to call in Y-Wing strikes by ensuring twin satellites are online, as only then can the lumbering mechs take damage. Granted, if you're in possession of an orbital strike and time it just right, you can deliver massive damage to them, but in terms of specific kill-animations to pull off or the impact your average blaster - it's meaningless. Throw the fact the Empire have AT-STs on the ground, AT-ATs can still be piloted and will easily one-shot anything in sight and the fact you can simply sit at your enemy's base and kill troops as they spawn in, and it's going to require a complete reworking from the ground-up to make it feel close to fair.

9. Bonuses For Winning/Losing Streaks

Something that essentially comes with the territory in first-person shooters these days are streak bonuses, either for winning or losing a significant number of times in a row. With the sheer size of Battlefront's skirmishes (20 v 20 if your game is full) it's going to make that a bit tricky, but as it stands there's really no incentive to give your all to the fight. There are no bonus abilities locked away behind achieving a handful of kills in a row, and the only thing you'll get as a reward for your troubles are XP bonuses - which are useless until you finish a round and can allocate your points anyway. For those of us who end up getting ventilated as soon as we spawn over and over, we too should have a perk that gives us more of a fighting chance. There are already personal shields you can pick up that'll deflect many types of laser fire, but have these spawn on characters who have just bitten the dust multiple times in a row - or more powerful bonuses triggered by multiple team members dying in a short space of time. At the end of the day we're talking about a game that's balanced at its core, and when spawn-campers can hide out and rack up the kills, there needs to be a way to reverse the odds immediately.

8. Heroes Need Way More To Do

This takes me onto the Heroes you can play as (which in the beta, are a Return-styled Luke and standard Vader). Now, if you've played any of the Jedi Academy games or any first-person title that has a third-person mode for melee attacks (think Skyrim), you'll know just how glitchy and unnatural-looking this sort of thing can be. When it comes to the various frenetic confrontations in a typical Battlefront match, these should-be-epic showdowns boil down to two players spamming their attack buttons, before watching everything from server load to overlapping transitional animations get in the way. There is a 'lightsaber clash' move that can be triggered - leading to a button-mashing minigame to win - but for the most part playing as these heroes feels more like you're breaking the game and going on a mod-powered killing spree, over than cutting enemies down with any depth or fidelity to the controls. In addition to this, they don't feel like 'heroes' in regards to your side, more glorified power-ups. Point being, there's no gameplay mechanic to rally the troops or lead them into battle in defined units, something that especially on the Rebel side, would benefit hugely. If, when the AT-AT shields go down, whoever's controlling Luke could force a prompt that focusses fire on certain parts of their armour, it'd factor into the balancing side of things greatly - alongside giving whoever's playing him a real cause in the battle other than just "Kill everything that moves".

7. Squad Commands & Marking Enemies

The killing blow to Battlefront in the long run - as I'm sure it's too late to implement this - is the lack of a dedicated quick-fire command system. Metal Gear Online and countless other shooters have implemented a 'quick-select' dialogue wheel to rally soldiers behind a common objective, and considering these days it's one in every 30 players who actually mics up and talks regularly like the first few years of Xbox Live, it's this lack of working together that's crippled most matches so far. For both sides, Battlefront could implement Battlefield's marker system, allowing for a "Focus fire on X target" command or letting you mark your attacker if you know you're about to be taken out. Right now you barely even feel like one cog in a giant machine - more a detached piece in desperate need of implementation, desperately searching for purpose as you shoot, die and respawn until it's all over.

6. Longevity To Gameplay - Play Your Class

There are ranged rifles and shorter blasters in SWB, but right now - and for the foreseeable future, as the game doesn't favour class-builds - it's straight-up "I can hit the right trigger faster than you!" territory. Maybe it's just not a route they're going down, being EA are making a game for one of the biggest entertainment properties of all time, but all the same this is being put together by DICE - the Battlefield guys - and they know how to program a shooter that keeps people enthralled for months, if not years, after release. Honestly, it feels like you can see everything SWB has to offer gameplay-wise within about 20 minutes, the remaining hold it'll have on you being a mix of love for the source material and online shooters in general. Playing as the heroes is a mad flail to see how many people you can cut down as possible, but for everyone else on both sides of the Imperial/Rebel divide, we all play exactly the same (even having the same guns). Let's have snipers holding back, assault guys with more health up the front, the middle ranks filled by mid-range firearms and specced-up grenade-throwers - the entire thing led by that sides' respective hero calling the shots. It could be glorious.

5. Dedicated Vehicle Spawn Points

Battlefront's vehicles are amazingly fun, especially seeing as DICE have added a left-trigger lock-on to let you dogfight with ease, the only thing you have to worry about is not smashing into the ground and occasionally dodging enemy missiles. The problem comes with the fact you never feel as though such things are available to you freely or dependably, as they're lumped in with other random power-ups like Thermal Grenades or Squad Shields. Even if you head to the iconic X-Wing hanger as the Rebels, you'll see plenty of them waiting to be piloted, but you can't hop in - instead you'll have to venture out and locate a specific power-up to then 'warp' to one that's already in-flight. That goes for the Empire too, as although these spawn points do have some semblance of being regularly placed across Walker Assault's three stages, it'd just be a better system if we always knew exactly where to take off from. After all, what army doesn't know where its own vehicles are located?

4. More Basic Abilities - Dive-Rolls, Vehicle-Stealing Etc.

Class-specific stuff is one thing, but your standard animations and abilities are as basic as they come. It's literally just a case of running and shooting. There aren't any dive-rolls, vehicle-stealing, healing-boosts or any implementation of a cover system to survive gunfights. You could argue this is to get across the idea of you just being 'one more soldier' contributing to a slowly heaving war effort, but at the end of the day, many of these things were in past Battlefront games. It's possible they're locked away behind upgrade walls or points to unlock, but even if that is the case - why have a tactic as basic as evading fire put behind a tier? There's nothing wrong with appealing to the masses (this is Star Wars, after all), but in doing so you should honour the legacy of the Battlefront series by at least starting from where they left off.

3. Some Worthwhile Single-Player Content

Ever since EA announced the new Battlefront would have a huge focus on multiplayer, it's been the most divisive element in gaming since the Kinect (remember that?). First this was going to be multiplayer-only, then we got wind of some arena-based single-player content, then those scenarios looked to be nothing more than siphoned off chunks of the multiplayer top n' tailed by cutscenes. Now the beta's out fans can confirm it's the latter. The real meat of the experience is clearly in the online multiplayer where all 40 players can blast holy hell out of each other, and the 'Survival on Tatooine' mission opens with a tiny cutscene laying out the predicament of a couple of Rebels struggling to survive against waves of Stormtroopers. Thing is, it's a Horde Mode. It's the Gears of War 2-popularising Horde Mode, where gameplay consists of killing swathes of 'troopers in a boxed-in environment, as Admiral Ackbar sends you drop-pods full of supplies. "How many waves can you last??" touts the menu, but unless you really fancy mindlessly blasting enemies in a fashion that could be in any other shooter, there's zero impetus to replay. With the incredible (and it is incredible) game engine DICE have built here, just give us even the barest version of replaying more scenes from the movie, complete with voice-acted cutscenes and set-pieces where they matter most. Going multiplayer-only with a side of "Oh but, you can play this one part offline" killed both Titanfall and Evolve stone-dead at launch, and once Episode VII's Star Wars fever has worn off, we'll be left with something that could be effectively titled 'Online Shooter: The Video Game'.

2. Split-Screen Co-Op Online

Much has been made about the 'death of couch co-op' in gaming (something Rocket League promptly flipped the middle digits to earlier this year with some impeccable team-based gameplay), and Battlefront does include split-screen for the Survival modes. However - and this just seems to be a technical limitation on the new hardware - split-screen doesn't apply to the online mode. The older Battlefronts didn't feature this either, forcing you to buddy up with someone online rather than locally, but being the PS4/Xbox One and new-age PCs are meant to be these all-singing all-dancing dream-machines, surely there's a way to make it happen? At least having your friend over and hopping into a match together from the same server would aid immensely in the tactical side of things, letting your coordinate tactics that could then be told to teammates through either of your headsets. Hopefully the offline missions will be fulfilling enough to scratch the local multiplayer itch, but man - you and your buddy getting dropped onto Hoth simultaneously? That would be pretty damn special.

1. Don't Make The Gameplay Rely On Scripted Events

In the pursuit of ensuring everyone involved on a match of Walker Assault has an experience that mirrors that of the film, DICE have took to Call of Duty or Battlefield'ing it up a little bit - which is to say, there are certain events that occur in the world, regardless of your input. It's both good and bad; the look of a Snowspeeder barrelling out of control and embedding itself upright in the snow is one hell of a sight that grounds the reality of what you're up against perfectly - but we're going to be playing these exact scenarios ten, twenty, fifty-plus times over the next few years, and already the strings are starting to show. This isn't to mention the auto-walking AT-ATs, where the game's scripting must be set to grant victory to the Empire after a certain time has elapsed, rather than their physical proximity to the shield generator. Case in point; even if you manage to down them at the last second, 'Victory' can go to the Empire as the game doesn't count the Snowspeeder tangling its legs as something that impedes progress towards the goal. It's scripted to only stop the shields blowing up when both AT-ATs have hit the floor, meaning Rebels can still lose mid-animation, getting the cutscene of the generator blowing up for no reason when both AT-ATs are crumpled heaps in the snow. How have you found the beta so far? Is Battlefront on your Must Play list for the rest of the year? Let us know in the comments!

Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.