The Division: 3 Ups & 6 Downs From The Beta Playthrough

This really is NOT a "great single player game."

You can expect to hear a hell of a lot more about Ubisoft's latest triple-A gamble from here on out. The Division is easily one of the most ambitious and interesting games the studio have produced in quite some time - yet when you start to go hands on with the near-full version, the same old issues that plague many of their titles start to rear their head - alongside some worrying features that are hopefully only present in the beta. Initially unveiled in 2013, what we saw appeared to be 'yet another' military shooter; albeit one with a more realistic take on what it would look like to see New York City evacuated en masse, right in the middle of a viral pandemic outbreak. Initial footage was supremely gorgeous to look at, whilst also being gritty and impactful, particularly when citizens of New York started recognising their own boroughs and street corners. Now it's out though... you can almost kiss goodbye to that ideology. Whilst The Division is reportedly still going to have a healthy injection of story to keep things going, the reality is a stat and loot-heavy RPG; one that features bullet-sponge enemies, an emphasis on forming parties for raids and ensuring that if your primary pursuit isn't levelling up, there's not a whole lot else on offer. It's certainly going to strike a similar chord as Destiny with certain gamers if Ubi iron over some substantial creases, but right now it's looking like one hell of a mixed bag...

Downs...

9. Gameplay Is Immediately Very Basic

There was a moment right as I emerged from the initial safe area HQ, where I approached my first set of enemies. You'll see all sorts of augmented reality pop-ups telling you that a certain street or city block is ruled by enemies of a particular level, but for me it was just two random hooded goons, doing their best to pillage a corpse. Now you might think, "Can I approach silently and get the drop on them?", "Maybe deploy some sort of item that will trigger when they see me?" The game's tonality suggests an element of seriousness when you're kitting up and heading out to 'take back the city' from the assorted thugs, but then it hits you... your only option is to blow them to smithereens. No stealth kills, stance-swapping, bringing them in alive, not even a crouch button. Unless you discuss which direction to fire from with a teammate, there aren't any discernible tactics, leaving you with no real options other than taking cover and returning fire when necessary. You do have access to a melee button for close-quarters, but it's not one that triggers an animation on the part of the enemy. Instead, it'll take a good three hits to down a thug who's charging you, the entire time their animations play out as normal, reacting occasionally but mostly making everything feel extremely awkward. The general approach to combat favours multiplayer, no matter what Ubisoft may say, and that's because...

8. It's Fundamentally Broken As A Single Player Game

Across the evolution of Gears of War and every third-person shooter in the 2000s, they cottoned onto the idea that if the player character suffered enough damage and went down, your A.I. buddies should be able to revive you, rather than simply watching yourself bleed out or be swiftly greeted by a restart option. The Division... doesn't realise this, not in a self-imposed 'single-player mode' anyway. If you've not partnered up with anybody and fall to your knees, it's an awkward crawl around on the floor with no way out other than to hold the 'give up' button, or to prey the enemy finishes you off. I even had a moment where my character was down, yet the enemy was just standing there, half-stuck in a nearby car. Eventually I crawled up to the guy as if to say, wheezing, "Please... kill me" and he did, but until then, it was a shining example of why The Division's gameplay has a fundamental flaw when going solo.

7. Texture Pop Is Everywhere

Another Ubisoft game, another batch of technical issues. For the most part things like character animations not transitioning fluidly or texture pop are always going to appear in some form - even Jonathan Blow's The Witness will throw an extra layer of detail on a background item when it thinks you're not looking. Here though, it's not just background. Chances are within the first few moments of taking to the streets you'll see blurry and muddy textures sticking out from shop signs and adverts, until the game seems to kick back into gear and everything is okay again. As far as the feel of gameplay goes, bugs and glitches haven't been an issue whatsoever. Where in Assassin's Creed it can feel as though you're 'forcing' the game to deal with your many inputs, TD has your character flowing perfectly from one place to the next, mantling, firing, taking cover and more with various very smooth animations.

6. Enemy Design Is Very Repetitive

Onto the enemies, and you're going to be going up against a hodgepodge of... actually very naff-sounding enemy types. Seriously, one of the groups that's emerged are called the 'Cleaners', who want to... you guessed it... "Clean up the streets!" Either you'll love how dumb that is, or it'll clash with the serious tone they look to be aiming for elsewhere. For me, it's the latter. That said, in-game is what matters, and therein lies a bit of a harsh rub. See, after a few hours in Ubi's version of New York, you'll have maybe fought more than two types of enemy. If you're lucky. The most common are the standard hooded thugs, who are split into two types where one will rush you with a baseball bat no matter what, and the others will fire from cover. In addition you've got the aforementioned Cleaners, who are Division's version of 'heavy' enemies, and wield flamethrowers in abundance. These guys are a piece of cake to take out, as you simply run back and fire from afar, their A.I. dictating that they'll attempt to scorch you from across the street... with a car's length jet-stream of flame. Ubisoft are surely holding back the entire city's worth of villains for the full release, but it's still pretty disheartening to see such a level of repetition so fast.

5. Side-Missions & Encounters Need More Variation

Maybe this is just down to a beta being a beta, but the handful of times I attempted to carry out some optional side-missions, they were hostage rescues with the exact same goals, played out in the exact same fashion. Take the hostage rescues. You arrive an a point on the map where the game has told you there's someone in need, and are told to wipe out all opposing forces. You do, and then get a prompt saying to look for a 'key' that will open the door said hostages are trapped inside. Once you've located this key (easily spotted thanks to the game's HUD drawing a massive golden line over the top) you'll free the hostages and be on your way. The entire process takes about five minutes, and if the beta IS indicative of what we can expect, means you'll be doing this a lot in the full version. Other side missions that dynamically trigger depending on what direction you're exploring involve fixing broken antennae for your home base, or clearing out a stronghold of enemy units, Far Cry-style. Again, none of these take longer than a few minutes to get through, and whilst they're fun, aren't anywhere near substantial enough to be talked about positively.

4. If You Don't Like Loot Grinds, Stay Away

Loot is the name of the game, not story or character-progression. The vast majority of your customisation and 'build' is comprised of which loot you'll be picking up, and seeing how Ubi have applied such a time-tested system to a realistic setting is both incredibly novel, and immediately restrictive. See, in the likes of Diablo or Destiny, their innate fantasy or sci-fi settings allow for all manner of fancy clothing options or weapons to emerge over the course of several hours. You literally have no idea what shape a gun or piece or armour can take in those genres, but in The Division - and granted it's only been the beta so far - everything is resigned to a set of padded kneepads, another shotgun, a slightly cooler looking jacket, etc. In the full game there could be riot gear or more stylish clothing options that'll make going out in the Dark Zone to fetch loot more rewarding, but there's an encroaching feeling of "seen it all already" that starts to permeate your play time far sooner than it should.

Ups...

3. The Dark Zone Is A Phenomenal Selling Point

Whether they realise it or not, Ubisoft have happened upon one of the most interesting multiplayer modes in quite some time. The 'Dark Zone' is an area of New York that still features heavy contamination from the virus that's wiping people out left, right and centre. The main city you'll explore is chock full of enemy AI, leaving the DZ to basically be the game's multiplayer mode, but in a neat way, you approach it in the open-world, where merely stepping through a doorway 'boots' you into a server. It's all very seamless, and saves having to search for any games. You walk through, and suddenly the enemies within are almost always human, the loot they're carrying up for grabs... if you want to go 'Rogue'. Doing so turns the eyes of the entire Zone your way. Extraction points will pop up and count down to a helicopter's arrival, which if you can offload your gear without scores of teams baring down on you, means you get away with all your treasures. Die, and it all gets dropped again. Everything is up for grabs, and there's no thrill like betraying your fellow man and attempting to survive long enough to make it back out again. Regular enemies roam this area too, but as its the real-world players that have amassed the most goodies, you'll want to weigh up teaming up with taking out whoever you're rolling with - knowing they could do the same to you at any moment.

2. Concept And Atmosphere Are Fantastic

Even if none of this comes together in the final product, the fact that Ubi have taken the idea of an open-world MMO and applied it to a realistic New York setting is one for the history books. Seeing enemies get shot and having numbers fly off to dictate your damage may look a little strange at first, but you can't deny the immediate sense of identity you get watching it in action. The Division feels very fresh, and a big step forward - we just don't know whether it'll stumble along the way. XP counters fly up, beams of coloured light stand out from dropped pieces of loot, augmented reality visuals tell you everything about health, equipped items and the space left in your backpack. The HUD itself does look considerably more cluttered than the initial footage, but once you're in motion it doesn't get in the way. Story-wise there's more yet to be revealed, but the setup revolves around a viral infection spreading through marked bills during Black Friday. The more sales and transactions that went down on that day of pure consumerist greed, the more people were infected and put on life-support, or worse. A brilliant Kojima-esque comment on the violence inherent to this annual event, as it already exists in real life? Absolutely, and a very unique one at that. Here's to Ubi capitalising on it in full.

1. Partnering Up Makes It All Come Together

To extrapolate on an earlier point, The Division certainly isn't intended to be a single-player experience, and so even if you don't have a band of friends looking to grab the game and play with you, diving into the matchmaking option is the next best thing. You can hop into an established party either by going into the main menu and then the Matchmaking options, or better yet; form an alliance out on the streets with another player. By using the various emoticons and, well, not firing on people right away, you can easily mimic a real-world apocalyptic scenario, where multiple scavengers start building up a posse by forging allegiances to agree on exploring in unison. The game comes into its own when you have somebody, anybody, by your side. Many of the perks heal allies or aid them in various ways, and the tactical side of things (what little there is) comes into its own when you start taking on the hordes by combining to conquer. Did you get some time on the beta? Are you still excited for The Division after reading all the impressions? Let us know in the comments!

Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.