10 Outstanding Documentaries About Subcultures

Jgoth Cruise Sociologists refer to subcultures as groups that reflect values, tendencies, interests, and activities that fall outside of the norm. We are likely familiar with subcultures as they have been profiled in notable feature films, on television shows, and in advertising and marketing campaigns. One of the most important ways in which subcultures have been introduced to us is through documentary film. Documentary filmmakers use the evocative and personal medium of film to express some of the insights that would otherwise be lost if we were to merely read about subcultures. Here, then, are 10 outstanding documentaries about subcultures.

10. Trekkies and Trekkies 2

Nnn Roger Nygard's Trekkies (1997) and Trekkies 2 (2004) offer a unique look at Star Trek fandom. His first film focuses mainly on the U.S. Trek scene, while Trekkies 2 illustrates the many instances of Trek fandom from around the world. Nygard's interviews with Trek fans show us the deep and personal connections that they feel with the legacies of the Star Trek world and its creator Gene Roddenberry. What is most significant about the films' expressions of subculture is the sense that we get that its members are not nerds, geeks, or people who need to "Get A Life" as William Shatner once famously joked; they are often dedicated people who take their oaths to the Federation seriously and who are involved in many noble social causes. In the end, Nygard's two documentaries humanize the misunderstood Star Trek community.

9. Darkon

Darkon2 Luke Meyer and Andrew Neel's film Darkon (2006) looks at a popular LARP (Live Action Role-Playing Game) community in Baltimore, Maryland whose game is centered in the mythical place of Darkon. In the world of Darkon, players create characters, participate in mock battles, and strategize about the conquest of territories. What works quite well is the directors' choice to tell much of the story through the in-game conflicts of Skip Lipman ("Bannor") and Kenyon Wells ("Keldar"). Interspersed with the many battle scenes are interviews with Lipman, Wells, and other major players. These interviews are especially important in the film as they highlight (much like Nygard's Trekkies films) the seriousness of the game and its players€”ultimately highlighting that there is much more at stake to the game than the characters and their battles. We might call such games forms of "deep play" as they appear ridiculous on the surface but have much greater stakes beneath.

8. The King Of Kong: A Fistful Of Quarters

kingofkong Seth Gordon's The King of Kong: A Fistful of Quarters (2007) follows the pursuits of Billy Mitchell and Steve Wiebe as each tries to achieve the world's highest score in the video game Donkey Kong. The popularity of video games today would suggest that video game players represent more the mainstream than a subculture, but the obsessive levels to which Mitchell and Wiebe chase their dreams offer that such levels of devotion are outside the mainstream. When the film was released, it was praised by critics€”in part due to the way that Gordon portrays the passion of Mitchell and Wiebe. At first glance the viewer might find the pursuits of these video game players to be quite odd, but as the film develops this view likely changes as we are exposed to the different personalities of Mitchell and Wiebe (who are portrayed as the "bad boy" and the "good guy"). This becomes the strongest value of the film as we see the different paths that each of them takes down the road to Donkey Kong stardom.

7. American Pimp

American Pimp The film American Pimp (1999) was directed by Albert Hughes and Allen Hughes (the Hughes brothers who brought us feature films like Menace II Society and the Book of Eli). American Pimp looks at the mostly illegal trade of pimping and prostitution and shows us some of the most colorful personalities in this subcultural industry. Dennis Hof, of the world-famous Bunny Ranch in Nevada, is interviewed as are many other "pimps" who makeup the illegal prostitution trades. We also hear the life stories of the many prostitutes (or sex workers) who work for the pimps. Some have said that the film glamorizes these sex trades, but one of the things that we must remember about subcultures is that they reflect values that are typically rejected by the mainstream yet are celebrated by those within the subculture. Thus, the "glamour" of such a subculture may be read as an accurate depiction of who live and breathe it. As well, at the end of the film, the Hughes brothers show us the tragic sides of the industry in the lives of prostitutes who have been killed and pimps who have been incarcerated.

6. The Gleaners And I And The Gleaners And I: Two Years Later

The Gleaners Experimental French filmmaker Agnès Varda's The Gleaners and I (2000) and The Gleaners and I: Two Years Later (2002) represent two of the most curious films that focus on the ever-growing subculture of "gleaning." Gleaning is the French practice of collecting thrown-away or uncultivated foodstuffs on farms, as well as recycling of various forms. In other cultures, gleaning may be called scrounging or reusing, and many people are familiar with the practices of "freegans" (or the more derogatory "dumpster divers") in the United States who find new use from discarded food and other items. Agnès Varda's two films about gleaners are experimental and charming at the same time. She shows us the significance of a practice that may seem foreign to us€”especially since many of us have been trained to live the consumerist lifestyle of buy-throw away-buy. The practice of gleaning may seem eccentric, but on closer inspection Varda shows us that a subcultural curiosity could better serve the mainstream society were it to take notice. Equally significant in this regard is Mai Iskander's Garbage Dreams (2009), which profiles the Zaballeen of Cairo, Egypt who employ extensive practices of local recycling.

5. Goth Cruise

Goth Cruise Jeanie Finlay's Goth Cruise (2008) is an intriguing look at the U.S. and U.K. goth subcultures. The film follows goths on a Caribbean cruise and offers numerous insights about their musical tastes, style and fashion tendencies, body image, and values. The film is the best on this list in terms of how it parallels the worlds of the goths and other mainstream people (who are referred to as "norms" by the goths). What's quite remarkable about this comparative aspect of the film is the fact that the goths, even in the face of negative reactions of the "norms," are quite content with their own self-image and sense of self. One of the key points that we learn about subcultures is that many are composed of some of the most ethical and non-judgmental people. This point is often missed as many of us are inclined to react negatively about what we note in people on the surface instead of trying to get to know them and see what lies deeper, inside their character.

4. Metal: A Headbanger's Journey And Global Metal

Metal: A Headbanger's Journey

Heavy metal, like video gaming, may be considered by some to be part of the mainstream and not a subcultural formation. However, when we explore the intricacies of this musical form€”which includes glam metal, pop metal, progressive metal, doom metal, and many, many other variations€”we learn something about the internal variations of a subculture. This is part of the subject of Sam Dunn and Scot McFadyen's two films Metal: A Headbanger's Journey (2005) and Global Metal (2008). These documentaries chart the evolution of metal throughout the United States, in the first film, and the rest of the world in the second film. A related series called Metal Evolution premiered on VH1 in 2011 and focused on one sub-genre of metal per episode. In addition to learning about the many varieties of heavy metal music, the musicians, and the fans, Dunn and McFadyen's two documentaries also chart the often conflicting values, social tendencies, and controversies that make up the interesting world of heavy metal music.

3. Vernon, Florida

Vernon Florida In 2003, Errol Morris won the Academy Award for Best Documentary Feature for his The Fog of War: Eleven Lessons from the Life of Robert S. McNamara. Morris is considered by many to be the greatest living documentary filmmaker, yet many are unfamiliar with his strange and fascinating portrayal of a small Florida community in Vernon, Florida (1981). Morris' work on the film began as a research trip investigating loss-of-limb insurance claims in the Florida panhandle. It turns out that this region of the U.S. had some of the highest claim rates for this type of accident in the 1950s and 1960s. This backstory is probably enough to see that there are some subcultural tendencies to be had in Morris' film. Because of death threats that he received, Morris had to cut out any mention of the "nub city" aspects from Vernon, Florida (you can read a great piece from the Tampa Bay Times about the story). What we get is equally curious, at times disturbing, and all the while fascinating€”an obsessive turkey hunter, a preacher who speaks incessantly about the word "therefore" in his sermon, a couple who says that they can grow sand in a jar, and an extremely bored local police officer. The result is an interesting rumination on the personalities of small-town people who represent a much different side of American life.

2. Jesus Camp

Jesus Cm Heidi Ewing and Rachel Grady's Jesus Camp (2006) is one of the most critically acclaimed documentaries of the 2000s. It was nominated for Best Documentary Feature at the Academy Awards, only to lose to An Inconvenient Truth. The film follows the life of youth minister Becky Fisher and her Kids on Fire summer camp in North Dakota. Jesus Camp introduces us to the work of Fisher and the other ministers and gives us in-depth, up-close portrayals of the many young people and their parents as they participate in the activities at Kids on Fire and other camps. The film also features radio talk show host Mike Papantonio whose presence in the film seems to be the devil's advocate (sorry for the pun!) to Fisher and the other ministers' perspectives. With Papantonio's perspectives countering those of Fisher's, we get a sense of the real stakes of subcultures. Many have claimed that Fisher's Kids on Fire camp was tantamount to brainwashing. In fact, as a result of the negative exposure that the film brought to the program, Fisher closed the camp. There has been much discussion about whether or not Ewing and Grady present the Pentecostals in the film in a positive or negative light. The answer to this issues lies in the subjective opinions of the viewer and in this way Jesus Camp is a great film because it forces all of us to measure our own levels of tolerance when it comes to religion.

1. Paris Is Burning

Paris Is Burning Jennie Livingston's Paris Is Burning (1990) is one of the most celebrated films on this list. The film was awarded the Grand Jury Prize at the Sundance Film Festival in 1991 and was listed by many critics as among their top 10 films at the time. The film follows the lives of a number of Latino and African American performers in New York City ball competitions. For many viewers, it is likely that Paris Is Burning was their first exposure to the subcultural performances of drag shows and voguing, but what is most significant about this film's focus on the ball scene is the sense of raw emotion that Livingston achieves in her representations of the many performers in the film. Homophobia, racism, and other social ills are highlighted in the intimate portrayals. Sadly, many of those featured in the film have since died. It is worth noting that the film (and its public reception) also illustrates the controversies that often surround the representation of subcultures. Some of the performers in the film felt slighted about their compensation for appearing in the film (which resulted in some litigation), while some critics (including bell hooks) stated concerns with the perspective of the director and her glossing over of many of the political aspects of ball culture. Livingston has offered many cogent responses to these criticisms, but the fact that such criticisms exist illustrates an important point about the politics of subcultures and their representations on film. No doubt these controversies will persist in the many other future films that will deal with subcultures.

In this post: 
Trekkies
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Scott A. Lukas has taught anthropology and sociology Lake Tahoe Community College for sixteen years and in 2013 was Visiting Professor of American Studies at the Johannes Gutenberg University of Mainz, Germany. He has been recognized with the McGraw-Hill Award for Excellence in Undergraduate Teaching of Anthropology by the American Anthropological Association (2005), the California Hayward Award for Excellence in Education (2003), and a Sierra Arts Foundation Artist Grant Program Award in Literary–Professional (2009). In 2006, he was a nominee to the California Community College Board of Governors. He is the author/editor of The Immersive Worlds Handbook (2012), Theme Park (2008), The Themed Space: Locating Culture, Nature, and Self (2007), Fear, Cultural Anxiety, and Transformation: Horror, Science Fiction, and Fantasy Films Remade, (co-edited with John Marmysz, 2009), Recent Developments in Criminological Theory (co-edited with Stuart Henry, 2009), and Strategies in Teaching Anthropology (2010). His book Theme Park was recently translated into Arabic. He appeared in the documentary The Nature of Existence and has provided interviews for To the Best of Our Knowledge, The Huffington Post UK, The Daily Beast, The Washington Post, and Caravan (India).