WWE: Was The Rock's 2011-2013 Return Electrifying Or A Short Circuit?
The most electrifying man in all of entertainment. The People's Champion. The Brahma Bull. He is known by these and many more names, but suffice to say that when it comes to wrestlers that are true megastars, one can hardly go past Dwayne 'the Rock' Johnson. His ability to wow the audience when he was in the WWE was phenomenal, so it seemed a natural transition to move on and try his hand at the silver screen- a move that few begrudged as he had given sterling service to the WWE. So, when the Rock returned as part of a 3 year deal culminating in two main events at Wrestlemania 27 and 28, one could be forgiven for thinking that the idea was a natural- with nothing to really hold it back. After all- who wouldn't want to see the Great One (there's another name) back in the squared circle laying the smack down against many of these people of the PG Era? Yeah, well... There is no doubt that while the Rock drew some numbers to Wrestlemania, many were disappointed with his return- thinking that it had the potential to be so much more. In No. 3 of these articles (Part 1 was the Miz's championship reign and Part 2 examined the World Heavyweight Championship), I will look at the virtues of the Rock's return before looking at why it didn't go as well as it could have. Then I'll conclude by looking at how it might have been made better with the benefit of hindsight.
Cross Promotion
There is no doubt that the Rock appeals to more than the hardcore wrestling fan (the unkind may suggest he appeals to anything other than the hardcore wrestling fan). Being a massive movie star it makes sense to give wrestling that same sort of showbiz legitimacy that the Rodman/Hogan vs Malone/DDP match did in the 1990s. However, it also represents two generational icons going at it like Rock vs Hogan at WM 18. So Rock and Cena should be the best of both worlds- two pop cultural giants who can put on a great wrestling match (hypothetically). It's no surprise then that the WWE made their WM28 match the main event the day after Wrestlemania. Not only was the hype still hot from Wrestlemania 27, it automatically put the whole of the wrestling audience on notice that this was an event not to be missed.
His Mic Work
Now, many in the IWC will complain that the Rock phoned it in occasionally with his promos and that Punk smashed him out of the park during their feud (more on that later). I personally think this is a bit unfair. Looking back to when he did his first promo as the host of Wrestlemania- otherwise known as the 'fruity pebbles' promo- and he was firing on all cylinders. When the Rock returned in 2013 to ignite the feud with CM Punk, he did his job against CM Punk- particularly in the first week. I will be the first to admit that I am have had it up to the back teeth with so-called Rock concerts (more on that later too...) but when the new WWE title was unveiled by the Great One he had the audience eating out of his hand and did more to legitimise the new title design in one night than so many stars had done with the previous one.He Laid The Smacketh Down
This is going to seem like a trivial point and in some ways it is but I think it is one worth mentioning. When one looks at the part timers on the WWE roster most of them are faces (except for Brock Lesnar and recently Triple H). However, when these guys return they don't usually interact with heels that are not on their immediate radar. So heels that are not on the top rung of the ladder often don't get the chance of having a segment with these icons of the WWE- simply because wrestling doesn't really work like that. Nobody would interrupt Triple H- he's the COO of the company and it would look weird, and it would be even dumber if a midcarder interrupted the Undertaker. But the Rock? That's part of his schtick! Rock comes out to do a promo- some heel interrupts him during his interactions with the crowd and the crowd are outraged by this heinous act. They do a bit of back and forth before the Rock lays the Smackdown and everyone is happy. The crowd feel the Rock has 'brought it' while the heel gets some time with the Great One, showing that they can work with him. And if you don't think this is a big deal, remember this is how Chris Jericho entered the WWE. So with all these things going for the idea, why are people so down on the venture?
Ring Work
Now everyone has had their opinion about the Rock's ring work between 2011-13. Many in the IWC have complained that he wasn't equipped to match it with the full time performers- particularly during the 2013 Road to Mania. Once again, I don't think this entirely fair. The match with CM Punk at the Royal Rumble was in my opinion fairly good (except for a totally convoluted ending) but critics derided the Rock for being gassed during the match. The WWE's reaction to this was to make their rematch at the Elimination Chamber a sort of slower paced match based more around storytellng. This match became really dull, really fast, partly because the story was just predictable and partly because it didn't make either superstar look that great. What was worse, though, was it just emphasised the idea that the WWE was not confident that the Rock could go another 20+ mins with Punk in a big match. Having said that, I do have a bone to pick with the Wrestlemania 29 match. I always thought that the rematch may have needed a stipulation to make it more interesting the second time around, and unfortunately both Cena and Rock could not drive and compel the crowd to feel invested in the match- resorting to a bunch of finishers at the end of the match.
Is A PG Era Rock A Neutered Rock?
Yes, this is the part about the Rock concerts. The Rock in the Attitude Era was cocky, brash and just plain bad-ass. He really didn't change that much from heel to face- he was compelling with the stick in his hand and willing to lay the smack down to anyone who dared step in his way. He was also fortunate in the Attitude Era to have some ideal foils to his character including Mr McMahon, Triple H, Stone Cold Steve Austin and Mick Foley. Come 2013 and many of these aspects of the industry are long gone. Triple H is no longer the leader of the frat boys and the rest of them have pretty much bowed out of the limelight. Instead the Rock has John Cena and CM Punk- two completely different superstars with different characteristics. John Cena is as wholesome as they come while Punk is the Internet's darling- heel or face. This is not to mention the fact Raw is now 3 hours long with much more to fill and with a target market that is far, far more family friendly. Or that the internet has made the creative team's job much more difficult. So the Rock in the PG Era is definitely different from the one that we saw in the Attitude Era because of all of these factors- not to mention the fact that the Rock himself is now not just a wrestler- he's a movie star. So it'd be questionable if he would be willing to the more edgy things that he was once famous for. So instead the WWE tried to invest in his star power and we got things like the horrible Rock concerts that did nothing for anyone. It was a horrible attempt to try and reposition the Rock for the new age and it fell flat on its face (why they keep insist on doing it is a mystery...).
Was It Too Late?
John Cena is the top guy of the WWE, nobody can question that. But if one was to be truly realistic, his days as the top guy are very much numbered. Even giving him the World Heavyweight Championship may be a sign that the WWE is beginning to look beyond Cena as the guy to build their top title around. This could only be a good thing for the WWE, as they build to a roster with stronger depth, a guy like Cena fighting for the WHC could allow guys like Damien Sandow, Bray Wyatt and others a high profile match to see if they can mix it in the main event scene- much like the Undertaker and Chris Jericho did in 2006-2008. But if this is the case, then the idea of passing the torch becomes somewhat redundant. As for Punk, well the idea of mixing with the Rock may have been helpful had he won...but he didn't. Like much of the latter half of Punk's reign, he didn't come across as the Best in the World with the feud against the Rock, but a cowardly heel. So what about this return could have been handled better in hindsight?
Conclusions
The fact of the matter is that in some ways the hype around the Rock's return was always going to cause disappointment for somebody. If he was brilliant in the ring and flawless, the IWC would no doubt complain that he was taking TV time away from up and comers. If he actually worked more during the Monday Night Raws, he might have got pretty boring, pretty fast- particularly earlier this year when he and Cena were re-hashing old ideas again. The WWE should have been more careful about how they used the Rock- particularly with the feud with CM Punk. This really hurt the Rock's credibility as everybody knew that the Rock was going to win it, but if the feud was not up to scratch then Rock would have decreed an unworthy champion. Perhaps a way to get around this would have been for the Rock to actually lose to Punk at the Rumble and create a bit of doubt in the Rock's mind. Then, he could come back at Elimination Chamber and win the match there. We wrestling fans often claim to be nostalgic for the Attitude Era, but maybe we've moved on more than we'd like to think. Perhaps the Rock's return suffered because both the WWE and the IWC didn't realise how much the times had changed.