10 Worst WWE Royal Rumble Final Twos EVER

The best idea in wrestling history isn't always executed perfectly...

By Matthew Allen /

Rumble season is upon us, and the biggest question is the same every year: who will win? Being that the match is taking place in Saudi Arabia, don't be surprised if Undertaker limps out at the last minute and steals the win just like he did with his Tuwaiq Gauntlet Trophy! 

Advertisement

Anything can happen in WWE, don't forget.

The majority of the time, the winner is never really in doubt; other times, it's anybody's game. What blurs the line between the two can indeed be a nail-biting final two. A last stretch of false finishes, bum-clenching close calls and a final cathartic release when your favourite wrestler pulls off the final elimination, punching their ticket to the WrestleMania World title scene. Awesome.

There have been some phenomenal final twos in Rumble history: Undertaker & Shawn Michaels in 2007, Sheamus & Chris Jericho in 2012, Stone Cold & Kane in 2001, to name a few. Any of those names could have won the match - and its that unpredictability and/or showmanship that makes you believe it could be anyone.

Not every time though. 

Sadly, as fun as the Royal Rumble is for the majority of the time, a hot 30-superstar gauntlet can be dampened by a cold finish, be it bad spots, dodgy eliminations or just the wrong person winning the match (at least one entry on this list has all three!). Fingers crossed for another pair of amazing Rumbles this year, but now we look back at the finalists of the biggest match of the year that certainly didn't fit the bill...

10. Jey Uso & John Cena - 2025

It was very much up in the air as to who would win the 2025 Royal Rumble, although most fans were fairly vocal about CM Punk being the one to win it. According to Unreal, that was apparently the plan before they pivoted to Jey Uso. Jey had been slowly catching fire as a singles competitor following the breakup of the Bloodline, winning the Intercontinental Championship and battling his cousin Roman Reigns in some great matches during the pamdemic shows.

Advertisement

But despite his prowess and a very infectious "Yeet" chant, something never really clicked when it came to "Main Event" Jey Uso in the, erm, main event. This coupled with the fact that the fans choice Punk was white hot going into the Rumble, and John Cena's retirement tour had begun in earnest, Jey was never given a realistic chance of winning the big 30-man gauntlet.

In the match itself, CM Punk finished 4th, being eliminated by Logan Paul of all people, and the final two came down to Jey and John Cena. The two had a small amount of back and forth until Uso just kind of shoved Cena off of the apron, with John landing on his feet looking more baffled than disappointed, almost as if Jey had won the match by accident. Something of a deflating end to an otherwise excellent Rumble.

9. Randy Orton & Roman Reigns - 2017

The most star-studded Rumble in a long time, there was a feeling that anyone could have walked away with the win: the Undertaker, Brock Lesnar, Goldberg, Chris Jericho, Bray Wyatt, Braun Strowman. Anyone would have been happy with the choice on offer apart from who we ended up with.

Advertisement

Roman Reigns was still in his post-Shield limbo in which he was relentlessly pushed as "the guy" but was firmly rejected by the fans, and earlier in the night, Reigns had lost a Universal Championship match to Kevin Owens. So when an unannounced superstar was going to enter the Royal Rumble at number 30, fans expecting someone like Finn Balor were very disappointed when the Big Dog emerged and threw out fan favourites like Undertaker, Jericho and Wyatt before coming face to face with Randy Orton.

The final two didn't last all that long, spear countered into RKO and Reigns lobbed out in short order. With the last two years of Roman coming scarily close to winning the Royal Rumble for a second time, fans cheered loudly when he was thrown out. However, the cheers quickly died down when they realised who had won. From the sea of big and more deserving names, WWE choosing Randy to win the match was thoroughly uninspired. But at the time, the choice between this final two was the lesser of two evils.

8. Asuka & Nikki Bella - 2018

The first women's Royal Rumble was historic in many ways. Memorable though? Not so much.

Advertisement

The women's roster wasn't as swollen as it would eventually become over the next few years so had to pad out the numbers by bringing in a number of women from yesteryear: big names like Lita, Trish Stratus and Mickie James, and they also had room for Kelly Kelly I guess. A pair of names they had on speed dial that day were the Bella Twins, Nikki & Brie.

Neither of them had a chance of winning but that didn't stop the powers that be from having them eliminate iron-woman Sasha Banks and make it to the final three to take on the unstoppable Asuka, who was the bookie's choice to win the match. Once Nikki eliminated Brie (probably still sore about what happened in 2014), the former Diva's champion was left in the ring to battle the Empress of Tomorrow.

By the time Sasha was gone, all the tension went out of the air as the fans knew Asuka was going to run away with the victory. But the battle for victory between the final two was messy, particularly the final elimination spot. Asuka was prone on the ring apron and was meant to kick Nikki's legs out of her legs, knocking her to the floor. What actually happened was Asuka flailed her feet towards Nikki, missed by miles and Bella just fell off. A noticeable botch to spoil a worthy victory.

7. Alberto Del Rio & Santino Marella - 2011

40 men in a Royal Rumble is too many men. It was too long with not all that many memorable moments or big stars capable of winning the thing.

Advertisement

This is the first (and not the last) Rumble where the winner technically won twice. Alberto Del Rio was the latest participant at the time to win the Rumble, entering the match at number 38 and eliminating Randy Orton for the victory... or so he thought! Del Rio celebrated in the ring, his music played and Ricardo Rodriguez was screaming himself a hernia at ringside. Then appearing out of nowhere came perennial mid-carder and comedy act, Santino Marella.

Santino was never going to win the Rumble, not over a man once considered the heir-apparent to Rey Mysterio as the biggest Mexican star in the company. For a brief moment though, it looked like it might have happened. This was WWE in early-2011 after all, and if you remember that period of time, it was very bad indeed. The Italian Stallion struck Del Rio with the Cobra, soaked in the roar of the crowd before attempting to throw the Mexican Aristocrat out of the ring. A quick counter though put paid to that though and Alberto officially won the match.

Marella was another man facing against a bigger star who had no chance of winning. However, given what has come out about Alberto Del Rio in recent years, maybe he should have.

6. Batista & Roman Reigns - 2014

WWE was once a company that would always put the mainstream stars over, especially the big movie stars. So when Batista returned to the company in 2014 and declared for the Royal Rumble, it became the most predictable match possible. It didn't necessarily have to be that way though.

Advertisement

Going into the event, Daniel Bryan's popularity was reaching its peak. Everyone wanted him in the match, to pick up the victory and headline WrestleMania XXX. Bryan wasn't announced for the match, so when he didn't appear, the fans turned on everyone in the ring, especially Batista, but also Rey Mysterio just for coming out at number 30. It's sad but also quite funny when the luchador was eliminated to a big pop.

The final two came down to Big Dave and Roman Reigns (who had just broken the record for most eliminations in the match with 12), and was generating more of a face reaction than anything he'd receive when he was actually the face of the company. But even then, it wasn't Roman's time, and the fans knew that. Batista was going to win and sure enough, after exchanging Spears (Reigns' looking significantly better than Batista's) Reigns was thrown over and Dave voiced his gratitude for the fans reaction with a nice big "f*** you".

5. The Rock & The Big Show - 2000

The Rock did not win the 2000 Royal Rumble, and that started a chain reaction which lea to one of the worst WrestleManias of all time.

Advertisement

Going into the event, it was an open field as to who could potentially win the match. This was the year 2000, after all, and the roster was stacked with talent ready to break through that glass ceiling. It was The Rock though who was chosen to take the win and the WrestleMania main event that goes with it. In his way, however, was the Big Show, the 500lb goliath who couldn't possibly be thrown over the top rope, so WWE says with all their big boys!

Show had Rocky on his shoulder choosing a side to throw him out of, and for some reason chose to lean Rock over the ropes. Being the strong fellow he is, you'd think a press slam or something similar would be more effective. Regardless, his momentum was used against him, Rock grabbed the ropes, forced Show over and out of the ring, picking up the victory.

However, clearly shown in replays after the fact, The Rock's feet touched the ground before Big Show was anywhere close to the floor. The wrong man was named the winner and Show used that to put himself into the Mania main event, which would eventually bring in Mick Foley and every member of the McMahon family in the most jumbled storyline in years. And all stemming from this final two botch!

4. Ric Flair & Sid Justice - 1992

One of the best Royal Rumbles ever, almost ruined by one of the worst finishes.

Advertisement

WWE is constantly lauded by the online community for the 1992 Rumble as being the most star-studded in history: Randy Savage, Undertaker, British Bulldog, Ted DiBiase, Jim Duggan, Sgt. Slaughter, among others, and the stakes were higher than any Rumble before it, as the vacant WWF Championship was on the line. The final three came down to the face of the WWF Hulk Hogan, the face of WCW Ric Flair, and Sid Justice who was once touted as Hogan's replacement. 

At the end of the very-good-indeed match, Hogan was thrown out by Sid to rapturous applause from the New York crowd. Hogan, incensed that he had been betrayed by his apparent good friend, went full sore loser mode and grabbed the future Sycho, attempting to pull him over the top rope. The Nature Boy took advantage of this and scooped Sid's leg over the rope, knocking him to the floor winning him both the match and the World championship.

It's phenomenal that Flair lasted a full hour in the match, and he definitely deserved the win. The final elimination spot however sullied the victory in that the winner of the match did very little in eliminating the final man, and ultimately the match laid the groundwork for one of the worst WrestleMania main events of all time.

3. Mr. McMahon & Stone Cold Steve Austin - 1999

Prior to 2015, most named 1999 as the worst Royal Rumble on record. There weren't a great deal of spots to speak of, the majority of the entries were fairly low rent and the entire thing revolved around when Steve Austin will eventually come back to win the match.

Advertisement

Mr. McMahon and Stone Cold entered the Rumble at numbers 1 and 2 respectively, a short while into the match, Austin was lured backstage to be beaten down by the Corporation, spending the majority of the match out of the ring, as did Vince who sat at the commentary table until the Rattlesnake's inevitable return.

Austin has been apart of some pretty bad Rumble finishes in his time, 1998 and 2001 notwithstanding. In his first Rumble, he accidentally slipped out of the match and wasn't able to be part of the finish. He won the 1997 by fluke as he was clearly eliminated but because the referees didn't see, it didn't count. 1999 is the worst, however.

After a very nothing match, Steve Austin cleared the field, brought McMahon back into the ring where they fought until The Rock came out to distract his arch-rival long enough for the Chairman of the Board to throw Austin over the rope and win the match. No-one wanted this. No-one expected Vince to challenge for the championship at WrestleMania 15. 

Austin relinquished the opportunity shortly after and Austin fought Rock in the main event anyway, making the McMahon victory pointless.

2. Yokozuna & Randy Savage - 1993

1993 was the first year where winning the Royal Rumble meant a guaranteed World championship match at the main event of WrestleMania. This would normally put a great deal of excitement behind the Rumble match itself. Instead, 1993 ended up as one of the dullest matches in the history of the format.

Advertisement

Among the Undertakers, Mr. Perfects and Ric Flairs, there was also Max Moon, Papa Shango, Skinner and Damien Demento. As lightweight as a Rumble has ever been to that point, it's ironic that the match came down to both the heaviest star they had in Yokozuna, and the legendary Macho Man Randy Savage. The two men battled with Savage gaining the advantage, knocking down the sumo star and hitting him with his trademark elbow drop.

Now the Rumble had been a fixture of WWF for 5 years at that point - meaning the rules should have been clear by then. You can only eliminate a superstar by throwing him over the top rope and out of the ring. Macho Man somehow forgot the rules like he did the year before (but everyone decided to ignore that), and went to pin Yokozuna. 

Realising his mistake, Randy leapt full force over the top rope and landed on the floor. Well, that's what it looked like anyway. What was actually meant to happen was Yoko using his strength to push Savage off of him so hard that he was thrown out of the match. So Yokozuna won this final tussle, leading to, once again, one of the worst WrestleMania main events ever.

1. Roman Reigns & Rusev - 2015

Be honest everyone; until Rusev made his presence known in the final moments of the 2015 Royal Rumble, you forgot he was even in the match. Hell, you probably don't even remember the final two of that year because you were all so furious at what happened leading up to it.

Advertisement

The 2015 Royal Rumble is the equivalent of WWE telling us to, in the Rock's words, "know your role and shut your mouths". Roman Reigns was going to win the Rumble and no-one cared for that. The powers in the back though didn't care about what we wanted. We wanted Daniel Bryan to get his Rumble victory, like he should've got the year before. But no, he lasted 10 minutes and from then on the entire match broke.

In the closing moments of the match, Rusev was nowhere to be seen (he'd disappeared under the ropes at some point so wasn't eliminated), and all the remaining stars that everyone loved were dumped out of the ring by Kane and the Big Show. And as they were going to eliminate Reigns, for no reason at all, the corporate yes-men squabbled amongst themselves before Roman threw them both out. The Rock assisted with the ensuing beat-down and only then did Rusev emerge.

The Bulgarian Brute was disposed of in short order. The final hope of a winner that we liked was unceremoniously eliminated but by then, the fans were so checked out, they didn't care. The inevitable winner was crowned, and Reign's final two victory was essentially an afterthought in the sea of angry fans and #CancelWWENetwork.

Advertisement