Ranking EVERY WWE Royal Rumble Match - From Worst To Best
Looking back at every single Royal Rumble match from over the decades.
While WrestleMania may be WWE's biggest event of the year, for some wrestling fans, even more anticipated than the Showcase of the Immortals is the Royal Rumble.
Created by Pat Patterson, the first 'proper' Royal Rumble took place in 1988, with the match concept itself trialled at a non-televised live event the prior year. That '88 Rumble aired as a TV special, before the Royal Rumble became its own pay-per-view the following year and joined 'Mania, SummerSlam, and Survivor Series as the then-WWF's Big Four.
In the decades since, the Royal Rumble has gone from strength to strength and has long been cemented as the start of the patented Road to WrestleMania. A win in the over-the-top-rope Rumble match can propel careers, can cement legacies, and has set in motion some of the biggest matches in WrestleMania history. But with a mammoth 45 Royal Rumbles in the books, how do each of these Rumble contests stack up? Of course, that's a subjective matter, but we've done our best here to rank every single Royal Rumble match from worst to best.
Also, for clarification, that means every Royal Rumble match to take place at the eponymous event - and that initial TV special - and does not include those rare Rumbles that happened on standard weekly television, such as the 2011 Raw Rumble or 2008's Mini Royal Rumble.
Article written by Jamie Kennedy and Andrew Pollard.
45. 1988
The first televised Royal Rumble is a curious but understandably tough watch today. WWE was still ironing out the kinks and finding out what worked and what didn't in the match, and the commentators clearly didn't address the elephant in the room: that nothing was actually on the line. That kinda stomps all over the 1988 Rumble's importance when looking back.
Jim Duggan shouldn't be dismissed as a naff winner (he was a star on the rise at the time), but it says everything for the '88 version that it's only 20 wrestlers deep but still trundles along for 33 minutes. That duration feels like 1 hour and 33 minutes when revisiting. Sorry, but it does. Again though, the company was experimenting here and would refine the formula within a couple of years.
The first Rumble is rather underwhelming overall.
Highlights include Bret Hart's workmanlike 25-minute performance and Duggan ousting One Man Gang for the victory. Lowlights include the general atmosphere - some fans seemed bored out of their skulls around ringside after the first flurry of excitement, and that wasn't a promising look for Pat Patterson's bold new match type.
Oh well, better brawls were ahead!
44. 1995
Vince McMahon's roster was skinnier than those Slim Jims ex-WWF fave Randy Savage was chowing down on in 1995. Savage had fled for WCW to join fellow fed alumni like Hulk Hogan, and it showed. Of the 30 men involved in that year's Rumble, only Shawn Michaels, British Bulldog, Owen Hart, and Lex Luger felt like they had any chance of winning.
In fact, that quartet contributed 100% of the actual star power in the ring.
Check out these back-to-back entrant sequences for proof that McMahon had sod all to work with. Eli Blu, Duke Droese, Jimmy Del Ray, Sione, and Tom Prichard all entered between #3-#7. Later, Mantaur and Aldo Montoya were #20 and #21, respectively. Good lord, that's enough to make even the most hardcore New Generation mark ask for a refund!
HBK "skinning the cat" to win the match is timeless, but even that can't save the 1995 Rumble from a low spot. There were only 60 seconds between each worker for a reason. Vince knew he couldn't string this nonsense out for a full hour. He had to race through everyone as quickly as possible and hope his audience was in a forgiving mood when the likes of Timothy Well and Kwang hit the ring.
43. Greatest Royal Rumble
Remember that green and gold belt WWE handed Braun Strowman for winning the so-called Greatest Royal Rumble in 2018? It's cool if you don't. They don't either! The company didn't bring it back from Saudi Arabia with them. Or, if they did, creative couldn't find a spot for it on mainline TV. It was almost like nothing had happened over in Saudi at all.
"Greatest", eh?
The 50-man Rumble was forgettable for the most part. Daniel Bryan going chop-crazy with Roderick Strong did stand out, but that's clutching at straws. It perhaps says everything about the bout that all anyone could talk about afterward was poor Titus O'Neil clowning himself by slipping and sliding underneath the ring during his entrance. 'Titus Worldslide' memes were born that night.
Forgotten entrants include sumo wrestler Hiroki Sumi, Babatunde, and Dan Matha. WWE blatantly tried everything they could think of to fill up the full 50 slots, but the main priority was making Braun look like a monster with a bright future. Fair enough, but that's hard to do when downplaying his win on programming back in the States.
Godspeed anybody who dares to re-watch this event from start to finish now. You have our respect!
42. 1999
Anyone crying heresy at the placement of this one hasn't watched it in a while.
Sure, the match-long Steve Austin vs. Mr. McMahon stuff was always gonna be some laugh, but that was literally all the 1999 Rumble had to offer you. There were vast stretches of nothingness in between the red hot opening (Austin and McMahon were the first two entrants) and the finish. At times, there was only one guy in the ring waiting around for the next worker.
Thrilling? Hardly, and the rest of the Rumble's lineup didn't help matters. Golga, Gillberg, Tiger Ali Singh, The Blue Meanie?! Honestly, this was giving 1995 a run for its money at one point. Worse, far too many of the wrestlers only lasted seconds, and others like Kane eliminated themselves to go after "the men in white coats".
It's no surprise to learn that Vince Russo was responsible for laying some of this out. The Rumble had a car crash quality that suited Raw is War more than pay-per-view. Despite lasting 56 minutes, one could cut a solid 50 minutes of that out and just watch both Austin vs. McMahon portions without actually missing anything worthwhile. Where's that dud rating?
41. 2014
Batista's return was supposed to be a grand, crowd-pleasing moment that'd feed into events to come at WrestleMania XXX, but there was just one problem. Fans in Pittsburgh didn't want to see the Animal. No, no, no. They wanted to see one Daniel Bryan, because Bryan Fever had gripped the core audience and wouldn't let go.
Vince McMahon wanted Big Dave instead. Yikes.
Look, Batista is great, but he was the wrong man in the wrong place at the wrong time in January 2014. Things were so toxic in the arena by the end of the night that even the normally-beloved Rey Mysterio was booed out of the building for having the cheek to roll out as #30. This is all fascinating to revisit, but people hated the 2014 Rumble at the time and the match doesn't hold up too well.
A tired and soon-to-depart CM Punk burned through 49 minutes of uninspired kicking/punching, and the whole occasion fell flat once everyone realised that Bryan (who had lost out to Bray Wyatt earlier on the card) wasn't one of the faces strolling through that curtain. Then, things took a turn for the worst when Batista eliminated Roman Reigns to win. Keep that last name in mind...
40. 2015
It's probably cheap to piggy back on 2014 with the following year's Rumble, but here goes. Besides, fans still hadn't forgiven WWE for Batista-gate 12 months on. Worse, they'd decided they didn't want to cheer for McMahon's latest pet project Roman Reigns either. He had support the prior year because he wasn't Big Dave. That wasn't the case in 2015.
He still wasn't Daniel Bryan, for crying out loud.
Look, that's not even the only issue with this Rumble. Much of the "action" meandered along like everyone had collectively agreed behind the curtain that it'd be hilarious if they went through the motions and phoned it in. Maybe that's unfair, but there were periods of total boredom as Corporate Kane and Big Show dominated the field.
Fans there live weren't digging it, and they struggled to muster up much excitement for Roman's demolition job on The Authority's grand plans come the end. Post-match, one very confused Dwayne Johnson marched out to raise Roman's hand. The Rock's face was a picture as Philadelphia's finest rained boos down on the pair of them. Rocky had just lived roughly the same nightmare his fellow Hollywood star Batista had before him, and he didn't bloody well like it.
39. 2022 Women's
Hopes were high for the 2022 women's Rumble when Sasha Banks entered as #1. If nothing else, at least fans would be guaranteed some thrills and spills as the Legit Boss tried to wrestle her way to an unlikely win. Or not. Sasha was eliminated 10 minutes later by Queen Zelina. Goodbye, Banks, and goodbye hopes and dreams of a crowd wanting a killer match.
Those praying for someone to save the day would leave disappointed. Far too many of the entrants went less than two minutes; Melina lasted 53 seconds, Kelly Kelly went just over 60, Dana Brooke barely broke the two-minute mark, Cameron and Carmella were in for 50 secs apiece, Ivory was dumped out after 25 seconds, Molly Holly after 20, etc, etc.
It was a hellish mix of wasted moments.
WWE was building towards Ronda Rousey's company comeback and their latest attempt to convince everyone that she could be a team player. Rousey won the match by eliminating Charlotte Flair, then pointed at the big WrestleMania sign as critics circled like sharks waiting on Ronda's latest foray into wrestling to fall apart. It wouldn't be too long before it did.
38. 2012
The Royal Rumble goes from drama to full-comedy.
That's what happened in 2012. There was a hefty emphasis on laughs and silliness in this match. Mick Foley and Santino Marella held a kid-friendly war between Mr. Socko and the Cobra mid-match. Adding to the jovial feel of proceedings elsewhere, announcers like Michael Cole, Jerry Lawler, and Booker T all had short stabs in there too.
WWE peeled back on the 40-man idea by reverting to the standard 30, but then wasted some of the spots by cramming in too many commentators and duds like Ezekiel Jackson, Hunico, and even Ricardo Rodriguez. Star power was clearly not something the company's creative team felt this Rumble needed then. They were wrong about that.
Sheamus ended the night by doing some sign-pointing. He can't be considered the most unwanted Rumble winner ever (Batista in 2014 would like a word), but nobody seemed all that enthused about him either. There was a flat, almost lifeless feel the whole match that's only exacerbated when you watch it again for the first time since 2012.
This was not a banner era to be a WWE fan, put it that way.
37. 2011
WWE must've thought the Royal Rumble had grown stale by 2011. That'd explain why bosses decreed it was out with the firmly established 30-wrestler idea and in with 40. Announcers were instructed to hype this up as a game-changer on TV before the pay-per-view, but fans weren't fooled. They knew this meant that another 10 lower-tier names would litter the field and clog things up.
That proved to be the case.
Cameo comebacks for legends like Booker T and Diesel did offer some merriment, but that was fleeting. It was also evident that such fun would be few and far between. The main goal for 2011's match was to cement Alberto Del Rio as a headliner worth giving a toss about. Fair enough, but the supporting stories beneath that were far too weak.
Del Rio's triumph didn't have much help, and it wasn't what fans were excitedly yapping about afterward anyway. Nah, those folks preferred discussing Booker and Kevin Nash, or CM Punk's elimination at the hands of John Cena. Every truly great Rumble needs a top winner and excellent side quests. This bout barely had any of that, and that's why it's so far down the list.
Slightly better than the next year’s version, but not by much.
36. 1993
It almost feels dirty to put the 1993 Rumble so low, but even the highest of highs sprinkled throughout the mid-section can't paper over cracks elsewhere in the match. Mr. Perfect throwing Ric Flair out before their Loser Leaves Town clash on Raw is worth seeing, and so is Randy Savage nonsensically losing his bearings by trying to pin Yokozuna right at the end.
Some will squeeze value from Giant Gonzalez debuting to eliminate the Undertaker, but that's pushing it from a quality standpoint. Too much of this Rumble was just like Gonzalez - it lumbered along slowly, and seemed more obsessed with portraying Bob Backlund as a revived babyface hero for a new generation (ahem).
That'd come in handy later on, in fairness.
Flair, Savage, Yoko, Perfect, and 'Taker make up the star power hopefuls in this scrap, but they don't have much backup. Duff choices like Carlos Colón, Damien Demento, Skinner, Koko B. Ware, and Max Moon do little to inspire the match to rise above mediocrity.
Retro enthusiasts will cherish this show as a whole, but the Rumble itself? Hmm, it wasn't one of the best.