12 Exact Moments WWE Titles Became Worthless

Triple H, Steve Austin, Bret Hart and Vince McMahon have all ruined WWE belts.

By Jamie Kennedy /

WWE championships are supposed to signify excellence. They're rewards for a wrestler's hard work. No, not everyone can be World Champion, but they can be Intercontinental or United States titleholders without cracking the glass ceiling and reaching that elusive next level. There's no disgrace in that, but there sure is disgrace in trashing any title with unwanted champs or booking so vile one would think it's 2000-era WCW and Vince Russo is on a one man mission to create the worst product ever...again.

Advertisement

Of the 12 straps examined here, no less than 4 are still in circulation across Raw and SmackDown (well, technically 5 straps considering some tag belts are in there too!). One of them has regained some form after a frankly useless period of ill-advised nonsense, but the jury's still out on the others. Triple H has a job on his hands if he wants to make them credible again - if they were ever credible in the first place.

Some top stars are at least partly responsible for wrecking a title's value or momentum. Glittering names as lofty as Steve Austin, Bret Hart, Shawn Michaels and Triple H are involved. The latter duo worked a scenario so counterproductive it reeked almost as bad as the nWo's 'Finger Poke Of Doom' over on the other channel.

Exact moments are pinpointed for each championship too. Get ready to deep dive on title wins from specific episodes of WWF/WWE television, and prepare to recoil in horror when you see some of the creative lurking during beloved eras fondly remembered for being full of 'Attitude'.

Here's how to destroy a belt's purpose in literally seconds.

12. The Ringmaster Is Million Dollar Champ

Looking back, the Million Dollar Title was a mere prop created to make Ted DiBiase's cash obsessed character look like an even bigger tyrant. It was established in 1989 during some entertaining and memorable vignettes, then DiBiase waved the thing in everyone's faces during feuds opposite then-former bodyguard Virgil and whispering promo artiste Jake Roberts. Later, Ted stopped talking about his custom made belt after winning the tag straps with IRS, and that was that.

Advertisement

Until 1996 rolled around, at least.

On the 8 January '96 Raw, DiBiase reactivated the title and handed it to his new charge The Ringmaster. Steve Austin wasn’t quite one of the biggest stars in the industry (like these untouchable WWE peers) at that point, but that’s not why this bombed. Unlike when Teddy was warring with Virgil or Roberts, The Ringmaster had nothing going on creatively or really any character-based ties to such a token prize. In short, fans didn't care about him carrying around DiBiase's old luggage.

As if realising this, the WWF ditched any Million Dollar chat shortly after Ted stopped being Austin's manager in May. It was a distant memory by the time Steve won King Of The Ring the next month and cut an iconic speech coining his new "Austin 3:16" catchphrase. That made more money than some dollar sign prop ever could.

Being honest, the Million Dollar Title's worth died as soon as DiBiase willingly handed it off like a Christmas present. The WWF shouldn't have let that happen. Belts, even ones like this, should be won during matches rather than gifted during promos.

11. Maven Ends ‘Taker’s Brief Hardcore Respite

What's your fondest memory of the old Hardcore Title? Mankind clutching it like a newborn baby in 1998, perhaps. Or, maybe you're one for Crash Holly's slapstick 24/7 days. Seeing him defend his belt in a restaurant's children's play area against The Headbangers lives long in the memory. Meanwhile, somehow, Maven beating The Undertaker to grab the garbage match beacon doesn't.

Advertisement

It happened though. On the 7 February 2002 SmackDown, Tough Enough winner Maven beat 'Taker to become new Hardcore Champ. This brought back the 24/7 madness that had been cleverly paused during 'Big Evil's reign. On commentary, Jim Ross remarked that nobody on the roster was stupid enough to try ambush Undertaker without preparation. So, 24/7 was back, but the latest attempt was a case of diminishing returns for the WWF.

The belt felt out of place once the initials changed to WWE, and it was merged with the Intercontinental Title in August 2002. ‘Taker’s run with the thing was Hardcore’s last highlight. It was all downhill from there. To illustrate that, here's a list of several champions who won the thing before it was swallowed by a more important belt: Shawn Stasiak, Johnny Stamboli, Justin Credible and Christopher Nowinski.

Highs of 'Taker retaining against Rob Van Dam in a pay-per-view smash hit at Vengeance 2001 were distant when Planet f'n Stasiak was winning the belt on house shows like WWE's product was a video game. Still, at least the fine folks of Bethlehem, Pennsylvania got to see history made and Shawn's sixth then seventh mini-runs with the beaten up trophy.

Maven's vacant stare in February '02 summed it up. The hardcore division was scorched earth post-Undertaker relevancy.

10. Titus O’Neil Picks Up The 24/7 Belt

Trust 2019 WWE to take something that had worked a generation before but turn it into one of the worst rehashes ever. On the 20 May 2019 edition of Raw, a beaming Mick Foley announced the new 24/7 Title (based on the old Hardcore Title's semi-permanent around the clock rule). Then, Mick invited a bunch of lower tier stars to the ring so they could literally fight to hold it.

Advertisement

Titus O'Neil was crowned the first 24/7 Champ because he managed to pick the thing up off the mat and hold it for longer than a split second. A jealous Robert Roode then pinned Titus immediately afterwards and hid backstage so nobody could find him. Not very glorious, and it was hardly thrilling television. Sure, everybody understood what the company was going for here, but it fell flatter than O'Neil during a Greatest Royal Rumble entrance.

Being fair, R-Truth did do everything in his power to make something of the comedy title after that. It was an uphill struggle he was never going to win. Nobody took the 24/7 belt seriously (how could they?!), and it's no shocker that Triple H couldn't wait to toss it aside after seizing control of the product in 2022. That title was DOA, man.

People were staring around in disbelief upon seeing the actual design, then things impossibly got worse as a bunch of midcarders scrapped over the biscuit tin lid like it was precious cargo. If it wasn't for Truth's efforts, then 24/7 would've been binned in three months, never mind nearly three years.

Next time, please don't bother.

9. Speed Titles Are Social Media Only

Quick! Name the male and female WWE Speed Champions. GO! It's hard, eh? Currently, at time of writing, Dragon Lee and Candice LeRae hold the straps, but that might've changed by the time you read this. OK, so this article could've claimed that Repo Man and Stephanie McMahon's old personal trainer Muffy were parading around with them on social media. Few would know without checking.

Advertisement

The men’s Speed Title was introduced in February 2024 and Ricochet became first champ in April. Following on, the women’s version was announced in August 2024 and LeRae won it that October. There's just one problem: Champions don’t carry the titles with them on main programming like Raw or SmackDown. Rico once defended this in the face of fan questions via X by saying the Speed Title is a social media exclusive, but why should fans care who’s champion if the titleholder can’t even be bothered to bring the thing with them to more important TV shows?

WWE might well have an exclusivity deal with X, but surely it’d be in everyone’s best interests to promote these things as meaningful? No?! They exist in a niche bubble, and that’s why nobody cares. Many fans barely even remember they're a thing week to week unless Michael Cole or another commentator brings it up.

The premise of quickfire matches in app is solid, but WWE hasn't really made the most of the platform. It's never good when one can skip every single match in a title's history ever and know they didn't miss anything important. It'd be a surprise if the Speed belts lasted beyond this ongoing deal with X.

8. Random Teams Blight Women’s Tag Hunt

It was a matter of when not if for the Women's Tag-Team Titles showing up here. Arguably, they haven't been of real importance since Bayley and Sasha Banks first won them back in 2019. That might be slightly unfair, but it wasn't long until WWE lost interest and started throwing any creative stragglers they could think of towards the titles in vague hopes they'd catch on and make something of them.

Advertisement

Random pairing Nia Jax and Shayna Bazler beat Bayley and Banks at Payback 2020, for example, but they’re just the tip of the iceberg. Yes, there have been some nice moments for the belts since; Natalya and Tamina winning in 2021 was sweet, and the union Bianca Belair and Jade Cargill formed had star power for days. However, the sheer number of thrown together duos to win the titles is borderline impressive from a 'creative has nothing else for you' standpoint. 

Rhea Ripley and Nikki A.S.H, Zelina Vega and Carmella, Asuka and Charlotte Flair, the aforementioned Jax and Baszler, Raquel Rodriguez and Aliyah. The list goes on. It’s been a struggle to care about the titles since Bayley and Sasha’s second reign ended in 2020, let's be real about it. Then, by the time Banks and Naomi had dumped the titles off before walking out in 2022, fans had made up their minds.

People want some sort of cohesion between teammates. Ripley and A.S.H, Asuka and Flair, and Raquel and Aliyah? Nah, none of them had that. They were only tied together by loose threads, and WWE didn't even bother to tell stories of developing friendships that hooked viewers.

Those Women's Tag belts are the lowest of the low in terms of audience interest.

7. Bret Hart Has A Senseless US Title Flirt

It's absurd that this actually happened.

Advertisement

Live on the 17 May 2010 Raw, a creaking and visibly uncoordinated Bret Hart pinned The Miz to become the new United States Champion. Initially, the live crowd popped, then people in Toronto started to realise that oh - a dude who can't bump just won one of the midcard belts. Hart was also fresh off having one of the worst WrestleMania matches ever vs. Vince McMahon at XXVI.

Somehow, Miz had to flop around like a fish and make Bret look as close to a million bucks as he possibly could before staring at the lights. It was mission impossible, but WWE must've been overjoyed with Miz's efforts because they crowned him top champ later the same year. What of Hart's US Title reign then? He vacated the title within a week after being announced as the new Raw GM.

Thankfully, some credibility has been restored to the US gold since, but it was totally worthless when Bret held it high above his head in Canada. Making The Miz look like a chump for Hart’s useless reign was unnecessary. He was always good enough to bounce back, but it was a bit risky from the writers at the time.

The title itself, which shared lineage with a WCW version, hadn't been this low since a guy named after boners held it on Nitro amidst Russo-led carnage in 2000. General Hugh G. Rection could take some bumps and work some proper matches, at least. 2010 Bret simply couldn't do anything workable.

Davey Boy Jr's face above really says it all.

6. Hornswoggle Kills First Cruiserweight's Lustre

Speaking of WCW lineage, it's the old Cruiserweight prize. WWE brought that onboard after acquiring the remnants of their own competition in 2001, and they agreed that Cruiserweight was a better name than Light-Heavyweight. Remember that for later, because you best believe the other belt won't escape without a roasting!

Advertisement

Hornswoggle was the final WWE Cruiserweight Champ until the title was brought back (without sharing the same history as this one) in 2016. He was an abomination of a choice. Not even Jacqueline’s head-scratcher of a reign in 2004 killed off interest in the Cruiserweight idea completely. That was ill-advised, but Chavo Guerrero and Rey Mysterio pulled the nose up afterwards with some stunning work.

By 2007, WWE had clearly lost interest in promoting the title seriously. So, they decided to put the thing on lil' Horny at the Great American Bash before Vickie Guerrero stripped him of the belt and deactivated it. Just. Like. That. Seeing Finlay's kayfabe son hold the same title the likes of Mysterio, Dean Malenko, Chris Jericho and Eddie Guerrero had made famous was awful.

Fair play, Swoggle was an improvement on some WCW aberrations like Oklahoma, but that was hardly going to be difficult. Ed Ferrara doing an offensive impression of JR with Bell's Palsy was next level bad, after all. Hornswoggle high fiving fans who didn't want to high five him back then being cut short by Vickie was a rotten way for the Cruiser strap to go out.

Ultimo Dragon would've been palming his forehead. Or falling over mid-entrance. One of the two.

5. Women’s Revolution Shatters Diva Tag

Nikki Bella wore the expression of somebody who knew the title dangling from her shoulder had just become rudderless on the 13 July 2015 episode of WWE flagship show Raw. Stephanie McMahon called for a "revolution" in the women's division that night, and she introduced NXT stars like Charlotte Flair, Becky Lynch and Sasha Banks to a wider audience.

Advertisement

Her promo pretty much nullified the Divas branding and meant the Divas Title Bella carried around had to go. It limped on until WrestleMania 32's fab three way pitting Charlotte vs. Becky vs. Sasha, but the belt's name was mud as soon as a women's revolution became WWE's latest crusade. Few were upset to see the Divas tag go though.

That reality TV-meets-sex appeal name was never going to fly in a world of serious female wrestling. If WWE wanted instant credibility, which they did, then they knew they had to stop referring to the women as Divas ASAP. They could still be "smart, sexy and powerful", but the eye candy aspects had to be downplayed whilst the pure quality of matches went the other way and became a priority.

That July 2015 edition of Raw slashed through the Diva premise like a hot knife through butter. Fan perceptions began to change overnight, a social media campaign gathered pace, then WWE brought back a Women's Championship in time for 'Mania. The toy-like Divas belt and all the cutesy branding surrounding it was wiped away in favour of tradition and an emphasis on better matches inside the ring.

It was a welcome change, and a necessary one considering the skills of emerging talent.

4. Mr. McMahon = ECW Champion?

Admittedly, WWE’s own version of the ECW Title was on shaky ground when Big Show beat Rob Van Dam to win it in July 2006. Still, fans were willing to stick in there because hopes were high that the McMahons would make something of extreme as a third brand and capitalise on hot One Night Stand pay-per-views in both 2005 and 2006. Then, Vince McMahon's version of extreme as a TV product rolled out properly and people were disheartened.

Advertisement

Vince went on to win the ECW strap from Bobby Lashley at Backlash 2007, and that ushered in the true end of any pretence that Extreme Championship Wrestling could be a standalone brand. Whilst true that McMahon was an urgent character on WWE TV and brought eyeballs no matter what he did, he didn't need to be ECW Champ. This was even crummier than his one week WWF Title reign in 1999, which is saying something.

McMahon (complete with baffling bandana) as champ was a nail in the coffin for Paul Heyman's once proud original vision. WWE ECW dwindled from that point on before being abolished in 2010. Final champion Ezekiel Jackson had one of the shortest reigns ever - Vince brought the hammer down on extreme before he'd even won it on the 16 February episode.

By then, ECW was a pale shadow of its former self. There was next to nothing linking WWE's 'Sunday Night Heat by another name' product to Heyman's renegade offering, and that slide began once McMahon became a focal point on the spin off version. It was curtains for the original belt after that.

This is extreme...ly unwanted.

3. DX Makes A Mockery Of The European Title

A lot of people sling abuse WCW's way for the infamous 'Finger Poke Of Doom' nonsense between nWo members Kevin Nash and Hollywood Hogan in January 1999. That was undoubtedly one of WCW's worst moments ever, but did you know that the WWF sort of beat their competitors to the punch in late-1997? They even did it with nWo counterpoint D-Generation X.

Advertisement

It might seem odd to some fans now, but the European Title was serious business when it launched in early-1997. The British Bulldog won an excellent tournament final vs. Owen Hart in Germany on the 3 March Raw, and the belt was treated with distinction right up until Shawn Michaels won it at One Night Only in the UK later that year. Mere months later, then Commissioner Sgt. Slaughter order DX buddies Michaels and Triple H to wrestle on the 22 December flagship.

They’d ham it up before Shawn intentionally lost so Hunter had a belt to complement his own WWF Title. Post-match, Michaels went overboard with a trolling promo claiming he'd never had such a hard fought match in his life. On commentary, Jim Ross joked that HBK had "lost his smile". Entertaining as a TV spectacle, sure, but the damage done to the Euro Title was irreparable.

That midcard prize never recovered credibility despite decent work by D’Lo Brown, Kurt Angle and more. It was eventually unified with the Intercontinental Title in 2002 after at least two full years of outright mediocrity. One can trace the European Title's fall back to some degenerates lampooning it to pop themselves.

So much for the serious wrestling belt contested over in Germany.

2. Harvey Wippleman Destroys Old Women’s Title

As aforementioned, WWE treat women’s wrestling very seriously nowadays, but that wasn’t always the case. They tried to do it right in the mid-1990s when Alundra Blayze burst onto the scene for choice outings vs. Bull Nakano and Bertha Faye, but it was shortlived. Even so, champs like Sable and Ivory worked well for varying reasons after the belt returned later in the decade.

Advertisement

Then, Harvey Wippleman came along as “Hervina” and 'laughing stock' wouldn't begin to cover it.

Wipps won gold from The Kat on the 31 January 2000 Raw. Days later, this inside joke was wrapped up when Harvey dropped the title to Jacqueline on SmackDown. What a complete and utter waste of everybody’s time. The WWF didn't bother even trying to turn this into a fleshed out story that saw Wippleman hate on women's wrestling like some weedier version of Jeff Jarrett - the whole experiment was over too abruptly for that to sink in if they did.

It was clear as day that somebody (presumably Vince McMahon) behind the scenes just thought it'd be funny if Harvey donned a wig with some makeup and won the Women's Title. That likely got a belly laugh from the boss, but it was a sad commentary on where the title fell in the federation.

Post-Hervina, it took years before the belt was viewed as anything more than a sideshow. Trish Stratus, Lita and select others worked their butts off to try change things. They sowed seeds for the eventual women's revolution to come years later.

Seeing Wippleman hold that belt was something that should've stopped short as a giggle in creative meetings.

1. Gillberg Ruins The Light-Heavyweight Belt

WWE's one sided history would tell you that Eric Bischoff rarely played fair when trying to build WCW into a powerhouse. He gave away results from Raw, challenged Vince McMahon to a fight on pay-per-view and generally did everything he could to get under the market leader's skin or beat them at their own game. Bisch did a lot of controversial things, but at least he didn't have someone dressed as 'Stone Cold' win the Cruiserweight Title.

Advertisement

The then-WWF did something along those lines, and it totally mauled any chances of their Light-Heavyweight Title gaining traction with the audience. Taka Michinoku was a fine choice as first (revived) Light-Heavyweight Champ in late-1997. Christian was a slightly puzzling successor in 1998, but the title still had some potential. Then, someone said 'hold my beer' and Gillberg was introduced.

That Bill Goldberg knock off gimmick won the title on the 23 November 1998 episode of Raw, and literally nobody cared about the belt after that. It’s a real pity, because Dean Malenko and Scotty Too Hotty showed what could be done with it once the 400+ day nightmare was over at Backlash 2000, and X-Pac tried his able best to make something of the championship once he became main man in 2001.

Eventually, the old WCW Cruiserweight Title was changed to a WWF version after that. Light-Heavyweight was a goner, but it'd actually been skating on thin ice since Gillberg came out with his sparklers as a send up of WCW's main event star. What was that about inside jokes being left in creative meetings and never making it to TV?

What other exact moments torched WWE belts? For more wrestling, check out 10 Booking Steps For WWE's Road To WrestleMania 41 and 10 Untouchable WWE Stars Who Got Special Treatment! 

Advertisement