50 Things You Learn Binge-Watching Every WWE WrestleMania
Binging 40 stunning years of WrestleMania reveals a LOT about WWE history.
There's a magic to WrestleMania that's difficult to quantify.
It's the "Show Of Shows', "The Grandaddy Of Them All", "The Showcase Of The Immortals" and it's undoubtedly pro wrestling's showpiece card/weekend. People plan holidays around 'Mania. Hell, some plan their lives around the sprint from Royal Rumble to those epic stadium dates in March or April every year. That's how important WWE's top attraction is - it also draws lapsed fans back in even if they don't watch programming all year round.
WrestleMania binging would've been one of the first things many fans did when signing up for the soon-to-vanish (at time of writing) WWE Network upon launch. There's a seemingly endless amount of history waiting in earlier events. It throws up cherished memories, childhood nostalgia and the kind of warm, fuzzy feeling normally reserved for Christmas mornings as a kid.
That's powerful, but the magic doesn't die in adulthood. No, for many, 'Mania becomes an annual pilgrimage and celebration of fandom. That's true when sitting down to binge watch as many as 2-3 cards every other night. You can learn a lot from rushing through hundreds of hours of pageantry, hype and pyro in quick succession. Honestly, it comes highly recommended. You'll see things with fresh eyes, and maybe spot things you missed first time around.
Not every observation here is favourable or even particularly positive, but there's a lot of love and affection in these pages for wrestling's tentpole event. Watching WWE develop from 1985's potentially perilous first steps to 2024's economy-boosting stadium monster is a fascinating experience.
Here's everything learned from all 40 'Mania specials.
50. The First One Sucked
When pressed to recommend one starting point for newbie fans, The Rock says he'd point to that original WrestleMania from 1985 as a must-watch. Honestly, that's a terrible recommendation, because there's next to no chance a younger generation would enjoy Vince McMahon's first big financial risk when going in cold. It's literally one of the worst 'Mania shows to watch back. Sorry, but it's true.
WrestleMania's debut hasn't aged well in the slightest. It's a gruelling watch today - there's no getting away from that. So many of the matches are plain dull, and the links between them with Lord Alfred Hayes are akin to pulling teeth. None of the slickness associated with WWE's product is on display, and even the pageantry and vibrant 'wrestling meets mainstream entertainment' vibe is absent outside Mr. T's appearance.
Sure, 'Mania I is a fascinating case study on just how far the company's presentation would go within a few short years, but it'd be a lie to suggest the actual show was fun to watch. Historically significant? Yes. Financially successful? Absolutely. Satisfying from beginning to end? Absolutely not. Bouts like Tito Santana vs. The Executioner and Brutus Beefcake vs. David Sammartino don't exactly scream essential.
Clearly, Rocky has some nostalgia for the original and that's fine. It's a surprise he didn't point to WrestleMania X-Seven or even one of the more modern examples. This would be like asking the dude which movie young teenagers should watch and him answering, 'Gone With The Wind, obviously'.
Apologies to start off on a low note, but there's no hiding 'Mania I's shortcomings. It's one of the worst supercards ever.
49. That Old Blue Cage Visibly Hurts
Buoyed by the fact WrestleMania I didn't kill his family's financials after all, Vince decided to go even bigger for the second event. 'Mania II was spread across three cities: New York, Chicago and LA. Credit where it's due. This was incredibly ballsy back in 1986 when technology was still playing catch up with McMahon's ambitions. He clearly didn't like the results, because WWE never tried this again.
They'd inflict the old steel cage on hundreds of wrestlers for another decade plus though. Internally, the roster called this "the Hogan and Bundy cage" well into the late-90s. Hulk and King Kong Bundy worked a fun enough main event in '86. They were locked inside the blue bars of steel, and honestly? Well it looked like a bloody nightmare to work with. The old WWF ring also appeared to be made of concrete.
No wonder Hogan had hip and back problems years later. Their joints must've been screaming. Wrestlers would've been thrilled when the promotion eventually did away with this cage in 1999. A famous bout between Steve Austin and Mr. McMahon at St. Valentine's Day Massacre marked one of the final occasions when old faithful was put up then torn down.
A new mesh style, partly inspired by the flashy new Hell In A Cell variant, debuted after that. Watching Hogan vs. Bundy back reveals that the previous cage was nightmare fuel for workers planning to get a good night of sleep in. Let's hope the WWF had some ice packs on standby for these men once they came back through the curtain.
Ouch...brother!
48. It’s Sad To See Andre Struggle At ‘Mania III
By 1987, towering monster Andre The Giant was a physical shell of his former self. Ravaged by pain brought on by his immense size, Andre lived an agonising existence day to day. Travelling from show to show put too much strain on his body, so The Giant pretty much called time on his in-ring career. That's when Vince went to ask his old friend for a favour.
McMahon revealed on the Netflix docuseries about his life and career that he wanted Andre to put Hulk Hogan over in the main event of WrestleMania III because he realised that'd be one of the biggest attractions ever. At first, Andre said no, but he'd cave after some gentle prodding and the promise of a huge payoff. Seeking a way to minimise the pain, The Giant debuted a new black singlet so he could hide a back brace underneath and give himself some support.
Watching the match all these years on with that context is rather sad. It's clear that Andre could barely put one foot in front of the other without hurting himself. He soldiered on to help Vince and Hulk out, and for what might well be one final big pay day. That wouldn't prove to be the case (Andre wrestled a limited schedule until 1991, and then worked some bouts outside the WWF in '92), but he couldn't continue testing his massive frame much longer.
There isn't much joy to be had in anything beyond the opening staredown and Hulk dropping a leg to retain the WWF Title. Revisiting Andre's pained expressions and 'turtle on its back' selling will tug at your heart strings a little.
47. ‘Mania IV’s Tournament = Marathon Watch
Confession time: The guy writing this adored his WrestleMania IV VHS. It was a double tape behemoth, which is why he begged his mother to buy it. Four hours of wrestling action across two videos?! Sounds too good to miss. The truth is that 'Mania IV, when viewed through adult eyes, had a much better concept on paper than it did in execution. 16 matches (11 from a tournament for the vacant WWF Title) was a tad ambitious.
It's easy to imagine younger fans stumbling upon this and wondering why the company was going through a boom. Yeah, Rock - if they'd think that about 1988's biggest show, then just imagine what they'd have to say about 1985's version! The match to match quality wasn't on par with what people have come to expect every March/April, but star power does save the day in select spots.
There's a Hulk vs. Andre rematch to keep things interesting, and the tourney finale pitting Randy Savage vs. Ted DiBiase does up the ante somewhat near the end. Overall though, this was another federation experiment that couldn't live up to the hype going in. The shockingly drab surroundings of Donald Trump's Plaza (the show was actually held in Atlantic City's Convention Hall) didn't help either.
That venue would be used again the following year, and it's kinda weird to think that this budding friendship between Vince and Donald eventually led to one shaving the other's head on pay-per-view. There wasn't much of that excitement to be found when rewatching 'Mania IV, sadly.
Still wore the VHS tape out as a nipper, right enough.
46. V Featured The First Top Tier Main Event
Get this: 'Mania V marked the first time someone dethroned the WWF Champion to win the belt on the biggest night of the calendar year. Hulk Hogan beat Randy Savage (who had won the aforementioned tournament at IV) to emerge victorious. This was also the first headliner with any bell to bell value. Yep, Hulk vs. Bundy in the cage had merit, but it wasn't exactly racking up the stars.
Hogan vs. Andre was a blockbuster perfect for posters, and Savage vs. DiBiase had clicked in-ring, but 'Mania V's main event upped the quality significantly on previous pay-per-views. Randy's rejuvenated work as a heel can take some of the credit for that, and so can the hysteria still surrounding Hulkamania in 1989. There was also a lot of heartbreak surrounding the breakup of Hulk and Randy as the Mega-Powers, so people were eager to see them collide in a money match ASAP.
Throw in Miss Elizabeth as extra garnish on this delectable WWF meal and you had a recipe for cold hard cash rushing through company tills. Not much else of note bothered the main in terms of standards, although you might squeeze some thrills out of Demolition vs. Powers Of Pain with Mr. Fuji in tow and Rick Rude vs. The Ultimate Warrior on the undercard. This was largely a one match pay-per-view.
What a match it was, to be fair. Not even the familiar, washed-out look of the Convention Hall in Atlantic City ("Trump Plaza") could harsh the buzz. WWF mega-fans knew the promotion would have a job on its hands improving on this in coming years. Shockingly, they did, but that's up for debate too.
45. Ultimate Challenge Intro Is An All-Timer
In order to attain the gravelly tone needed for an old school WWF pay-per-view intro, one must put on a few Pantera albums and scream themselves hoarse. Then, follow that up by letting your mouth fill up with saliva. After that, press play on WrestleMania VI's cosmos-themed opening and have at it. By the time you reach: "...it's title for title, it's the ultimate challenge, it's WrestleManiaaaaaaaaaaargh", you'll be golden.
Or you'll need some cough sweeties. Worth it either way.
Vince McMahon laid down the soundtrack for 'Mania VI's open, and it's still one of the most nostalgic WWE moments of all time. It's goofy, over the top and silly, but the voiceover is also so much fun. All that chat about Hulk Hogan and The Ultimate Warrior being two of the most powerful forces in the galaxy as hangover Atari graphics from the 80s beam across the screen? Yes, yes and indeed...yes.
This is what people picture when they think of that early WWF boom, not the first WrestleMania. No, there isn't another rant about to be volleyed the way of Dwayne Johnson, but 1990's babyface vs. babyface match pitting Hulk vs. Warrior needed something this out there to help sell it. Fans were already excited, but this tipped everyone over the edge and gave WrestleMania VI its own aura.
Thankfully, the match met that hyperbole halfway. This was one of Warrior's finest showings. Not the finest, but it's definitely up there considering he was never known as some technical wizard between the ropes. Being honest, 'Mania VI would've been less than without the growling intro.
44. VII Had Warrior’s Best Match Ever
Warrior saved his best match for the year after that 'Ultimate Challenge' clash with Hogan. Surprise, surprise, it was the 'Macho Man' who brought the best out in someone else. The classic both worked at 'Mania VII is well worth your time even if you're the kind of fan who's more Bryan Danielson than Roman Reigns. It's a powerhouse of a bout regardless of individual taste, no question.
Arguably, this pair didn't even need the retirement story aspect, but that did admittedly add some weight to the reunion between Liz and Randy post-match. Fans were ready to see them come together again, and it's an emotional watch knowing the topsy turvy, often mysterious and tragic relationship between the pair in real life. Those were real tears around ringside, that's for sure.
If only federation fans had been able to see this sort of quality from Warrior on the regular. He and Savage stole the show that night, which is really saying something considering the strength of performances from The Rockers (in their opener vs. The Barbarian and Haku), The Hart Foundation (vs. The Nasty Boys) and the fairly obvious babyface love-in of Hulk beating Sgt. Slaughter in the main event.
None of those could touch Warrior vs. Savage. It stood alone at 'Mania VII, and how many times could people say that with a straight face during Warrior's peak run? Once? Twice? Three times at a push, perhaps? He might've flopped as a Hogan successor, but he didn't flop on 1991's biggest night.
Even Jim Ross, who'd need crates of his BBQ sauce to remove the bad taste from his mouth around Warrior generally, would've enjoyed calling this one.
43. Sid Wouldn’t Have Worked As “Hogan 2.0”
Months after outing himself as one of the least 'by the book' babyfaces ever (again), Hulk Hogan beat man mountain Sid Justice in the main event of 'Mania VIII. Their match wasn't for the title, but the old "Hogan must pose" decree meant Randy Savage vs. Ric Flair for the gold was stuffed in the midcard. That didn't wreck their match, but it did deserve to headline.
There was another subplot happening behind the scenes. Sid spurned Vince McMahon's pitch that he become Hogan's replacement once the red and yellow carthorse left (again!) post-show. According to Justice, becoming a babyface hero to the masses would turned him into everything he hated, so he said no and knocked back the keys to the kingdom. That was something few could wrap their heads around, but it made sense to Sid.
Something becomes crystal when rewatching 'Mania VIII now: Sid was right. He was always better as a heel or tweener right on the edge. For proof, look at how comfortable he was slotting in as a threatening heel monster next to Hulk. The truth is that Justice would've floundered in the 'next Hogan' role, because his heart just wasn't in it. No amount of McMahon pandering could change that.
It was bold to say no, admittedly. Sid signing on to become the next top babyface could've changed everything, and meant workhorses like Bret Hart and Shawn Michaels would've been ignored for a little while longer. Or, at least, until Sid said he liked working with them in big vs. little man epics.
Nah, big Sid was way more comfortable as a villainous sort who could occasionally play tweener.
42. ‘Mania IX Feels Like An End Point
Maybe it's the smaller scale venue, or maybe it’s the way they were desperately clinging to Hulkamania like it was the last hope for humanity, but the WWF’s boom period was definitely over by WrestleMania IX. Something feels...off when watching it back today. It's the first event that makes it abundantly clear the McMahon family no longer had a vice like grip on their own "sports entertainment" style after improving on 'Mania I's humble start.
The fed had been cartoony from the mid-80s onwards, but there were killer stories to back everything up. Now, all they really had was the inspired in-ring work of Bret Hart, a rising heel in Shawn Michaels, and an altogether wobbly need to get a little too hokey with the gimmicks. That'd become an even bigger issue during the 'occupational gimmick' era to come, but things started to sag in 1993.
Jim Ross on commentary also represented a shift in the overall style. He was more sports-centric, and wanted to wax lyrical about someone's collegiate accomplishments whilst calling out each move by name and giving things a more southern wrasslin' atmosphere. It's slightly jarring considering he was calling doppelgänger clowns, The Giant Gonzalez in a muscle suit and more whilst wearing a toga at 'Mania IX.
Hogan would end the night as WWF Champ even though he wasn't supposed to be involved in business between Yokozuna and Bret. The Hulkster politicked his way back into the mix, had another brief run, then faded away again. Rudderless would about sum it up. The WWF lacked direction, and that's so obvious looking back.
41. That Classic MSG Camera Angle Is Lush
You know the one.
The one showing the entrance in the background rather than a traditional hard cam view of the crowd. That angle always added a unique atmosphere to older Madison Square Garden shows before the setup changed in later years. It looked phenomenal when watching WrestleMania X again, and it helped that show stand out from the rest. Those who know will understand this: It just looks…right.
Huge trons showing flashy graphics were still years away, so the WWF had to go minimalist for 'Mania X and have the large roman numeral across doors right at the entrance. That, with the classic show logo above it, was more than enough. Big banners were unfurled around MSG to add more splashes of colour to the black and gold aesthetic. It's also very black and gold NXT before that was even a thing, in a way.
There's something so immediately pleasing on the eye about these non-traditional hard cam setups. Vince McMahon would move away from that where possible, because he much preferred shooting fan reactions in the background rather than piece of the set, but MSG's original layout still allowed for that. There were fans on either side of the entrance, and above it.
'Mania IX might've been the true death of Hulkamania as the company's main priority, but 1994's event might be the final one with that retro WWF feel. Things got a little lower rent and gritty heading into 1995 as budgets were slashed and fears the gravy train was over dominated conversation around the water coolers at Titan Towers; if they still had water coolers by that point!