15 Best Wrestling Games Of All Time
WWE and WCW games aplenty here. There are some surprises you won't see coming too!
Spoiler Alert: Several of the games featured on that graphic were only there to keep you guessing!
That's a bit cheeky, sure, but there are just so many wrestling titles to pore over and pick from. Being objective rather than subjective was tough too, because everyone has their own favourites and nostalgia does play a powerful part here. The objectivity extended to choosing games from a number of companies; otherwise, it would've just been a WWF/WWE SmackDown vs. Raw and 2K super show, or a love letter to the AKI Corporation.
All of those get plenty of praise, don't worry, but only the absolute best from select series were considered. The ultimate versions, if you like. That was the criteria unless those from the same run of games had individual genius which helped them stand out from one another or still made them 100% playable today.
You might well be surprised by some of the choices. There are a few select oddities in there, and one doesn't actually feature any traditional gameplay to speak of. No, it isn't the woefully underbaked WCW Backstage Assault. That was murder on the eyeballs and murder on the thumbs as gamers literally wrestled with controllers to get workers onscreen to do anything.
This list isn't concerned with the worst though. It's about the best wrestling gaming has had to offer over the years. Arcade button bashers, text-heavy sims and some newer heavyweights are all in contention.
How's this for an opening shocker to kick things off...?
15. Legends Of Wrestling 2
There's no way Acclaim's sometimes-fantastic/sometimes-clunky surprise package could've been higher. It's the Marmite series of wrestling video games - the latter-day WCW Starrcade to WrestleMania. Some out there adore it despite obvious shortcomings (this writer fondly recalls his mum coming home with the original on PS2 right as he started exploring the old territory days via PowerSlam magazine and the wonders of the internet), whereas others think it tanked harder than a Mordecai push.
LOW II had some charms though. The career mode was based around the old territorial systems in places like Florida, Texas and Atlanta, and the developers even made sure to revolve storylines around the wrestlers you picked. For example, choose to be Jerry Lawler and you're practically guaranteed to run into that Andy Kaufman feud.
The gameplay was a slight hangover from the dreaded days of WWF Attitude, which was cherished for its presentation but eventually loathed for the complicated combos required to pull off even the simplest of moves. Legends Of Wrestling plumped for something more intuitive, and it's very much worth a play through today if you've still got an old PS2 knocking around or have a copy of the game and can work out emulation.
It's fun that Eddie Guerrero was included in the game even though he'd re-signed with WWE by the time it released as well. This is a gentle reminder that alternatives in the pro wrestling gaming market should be essential. It kinda sucks for hardcore fans that 2K's (admittedly excellent) series has cornered the market.
Give LOW II a try if you're a traditionalist and fancy something a little different.
14. WWE Day Of Reckoning 2
It's a crying shame that many haven't clapped eyes on Day Of Reckoning 2 before. THQ and Yuke's put it out as a Nintendo GameCube exclusive in 2005, and it launched during the peak of WWE games over on the PS2. Titles like Shut Your Mouth, Here Comes The Pain and the first SmackDown vs. Raw hogged the spotlight, and that meant DOR 2 was overlooked by most folks.
Rectify that as soon as humanly possible, because the game is a blast to experience.
The submission system had depth and the stamina system added a tactical layer to matches. Best of all, none of that detracted from the overall zip of matches. Yuke's struck a neat balance between the car crash no-sell style of older games like SmackDown 2: Know Your Role and a more measured approach from AKI's games over on the N64. That's worth seeing, people.
They got this juggling act spot on. Playing through bouts in the game is awesome fun, especially once you get to grips with the old "spirit"/momentum meters governing everything. That can take a bit of getting used to if you're more in tune with newer wrestling games, but it's worth persevering with - some of the matches turn out to be epic, because nobody can go full pelt from first bell to last.
Gameplay is the big lure here, but the Story Mode is nothing to sniff at either. Sure, it's a little less branching than gamers were getting over on the PS2. That's undeniable. It was still a hoot to plough through at least once though.
13. Saturday Night Slam Masters
Capcom struck gold by creating this wrestling gem for arcades in 1993. The developers went for a unique blend of side on fighting game visuals (Street Fighter II, Mortal Kombat etc style) with grappling mechanics. This wasn't to be a simple kick and punch fest. Nah, Saturday Night Slam Masters was gloriously over the top in terms of presentation and gameplay, but it had some good wrestling action underneath all the flash.
Taking your chosen star from jobber to World Champion is the key aim here. Being honest, you can sprint through everything the game has to offer quickly, but it's important to remember that this was designed to be a coin muncher in arcades first and foremost. Ports to home consoles were largely faithful, although they did add in a few choice modes (Death Matches on Genesis/Mega Drive, for example) of their own to keep things interesting.
Seeing Hagger from the Final Fight series pop up as a playable character thrilled those who loved Capcom's beat 'em up franchise. Similarly, there were obvious parallels between chief antagonist Biff Slamkovich and characters like Guile and Alex from Street Fighter, or even Axel from Streets Of Rage. The lore and comparisons are shockingly deep for such a seemingly simple button masher.
It's a shame Capcom couldn't secure the WWF license for a full-on arcade thriller based on the real-life roster. They'd have done a bang up job with stars like Hulk Hogan, The Undertaker, Bret Hart, Yokozuna and more. Regardless, don't overlook Slam Masters just because it has made up gimmicks.
This is an essential must play for fighting and grappling fans alike.
12. WWF WrestleFest
That's not to say the WWF missed out on the hot arcade marketplace in the early-90s. WrestleFest actually preceded Slam Masters by releasing to rave reviews in 1991. It was another button masher with surprising depth. You could still have fun with the thing even if you only wanted to hammer the controls and hope for the best; therein lies the beauty of mixing arcade simplicity with deceptive mastery if one took the time to learn.
Presentation went through the roof for WrestleFest, so it reflected the larger than life product Vince McMahon's company was showcasing at the time. Yes, the game was released in the 90s, but this was as OTT 80s as you were gonna get. Fest was a total dream for those who had lived through the monotony of titles like WrestleMania on the NES or the rather out there MicroLeague Wrestling on systems like Amiga and Atari ST.
Not as "out there" or unhinged as some other WWE gaming moments, to be fair!
Impressive voice samples for the time on commentary and from announcers like Gene Okerlund and Mike McGuirk added so much to the game's aesthetics. Then, once gamers picked from a number of WWF favourites and stepped into the ring, they were bombarded by colourful visuals and a neat blend of kick/punch spots with some amazingly well-realised moves.
Look, WrestleFest is a basic brawler today, but it had a massive impact on the future of wrestling games when it launched. This was a step up from everything that had come before, and it richly deserves a place on any list looking at the best wrestling titles of all time.
11. EWR Revenge
From in-ring button mashing to text-based contemplation.
Those who fell in love with Adam Ryland's Extreme Warfare Revenge series in 2002 will understand. Those who have no earthly clue what the hell they're staring at above won't. If that's you, then do yourself a favour and look into the EWR series or the latter day TEW one. These simulation games are still going strong, but it's EWR that takes the mic to cut a Hall Of Fame promo here.
Everything about EWR's base game is unofficial. The promotions are made-up, wrestlers (whilst often based on real-life counterparts) are fictional etc etc. However, download various packs from editors online and you'd literally be able to play booker for modern-day WWE, AEW and more. In a beautiful turn of events, those editors also set about the task of recreating entire eras/years.
Want to be Eric Bischoff and turn WCW into a success in 1993? Go for it. Think you could do a better job with 'Attitude' than Vince McMahon in 1998? Give it a try. It was even possible to assume control of smaller promotions like ROH in 2002 and turn them into WWE-beaters over time. The fun was/is endless, and that's what makes EWR so great.
Backstage politics, TV ratings, pay-per-view buyrates, feud chemistry, match quality, hirings, firings, contract negotiations, real-world events affecting business - all of it was included. Yes, players have to use a bit of imagination and there's no visual match engine to speak of, but EWR remains a thrilling sim experience every hardcore fan should check out.
This one would even put it above the more modern TEW titles.
10. Virtual Pro Wrestling 2
Time for a Japanese exclusive.
It's the sort of game that'll make fans of Mitsuharu Misawa and Kenta Kobashi smile. Both legends were included in-game under the All Japan wing, but Virtual Pro Wrestling 2 also featured wrestlers from New Japan, FMW, Michinoku Pro, Pancrase, Pride and more. Legendary figures such as Andre The Giant, Terry Funk and even Mil Mascaras were also available as playable characters.
VPW 2 used the exact same engine as WWF WrestleMania 2000 on N64, but that's where the similarities stop. Being honest, there's more AKI love coming higher up on the list, but it'd be remiss to mention their work without talking about this cherished January 2000 release. The gameplay was everything, and it'll be instantly familiar to those who remember anything WWF or WCW on Nintendo's old hardware.
Well, apart from the dire Nitro and Thunder cash grabs ported over from PlayStation.
AKI downplayed the presentation of their WWF and WCW titles to focus on a cleaner real sports like production here. That fits the Japanese-centric roster, and it gives the game a real nostalgic feel for those who still trip over themselves to revisit anything All/New Japan from the 80s and 90s.
Being able to mix things up by controlling MMA fighters who have their own unique play style was a lovely touch. Hybrid matches (Misawa vs. Don Frye, for example) feel totally different to something standard between two puroresu greats. It isn't even a problem that the game omitted WrestleMania 2000's cage bouts. AKI wanted to stay true to the Japanese product they were mimicking, and cage matches weren't exactly commonplace.
9. WWE SmackDown vs. Raw 2007
Those who have played every single WWE game since the first SmackDown on PS1 might be slightly stunned to see SmackDown vs. Raw 2007 picked out from the litter of other titles in the series. THQ performed a soft reboot of sorts in 2004 with SD vs. Raw, and they started to slow the gameplay systems down with each passing release. Admittedly, to some who prefer their wrestling games to be zippy, that'll sound a bit crap.
2006's SmackDown vs. Raw '07 release was anything but crap. It introduced a brand new analog control mechanic for hitting moves and engaging opponents. Importantly, THQ and Yuke's let players pick between the new and old systems. That was a smart call, because it meant the game was more accessible to those who liked the previous way of doing things.
Bells and whistles brought to the dance for the series debut on Xbox 360 included better interactivity in certain match types and an overall glossier look to the graphics and presentation. That was to be expected, but there's really nothing wrong with the base PS2 experience either. You'll still have a good time if that's the version you'd like to go back and play now.
The Season Mode was another weird winner for Yuke's as well. Various storylines paid homage to the soap opera stylings of the era, but devs knew they could up the ante further because, well...this was a video game, not real life. It's a trip to play through some of it these days compared to the much more grounded MyRise in games like 2K24.
Generally, SD vs. Raw '07 was a sweet spot for the series before gameplay got too slow and contextual.
8. WWE 2K24
There could be cries of recency bias amongst readers who just flat out don't like 2K's more modern entries since the soft reboot post-2K20. Credit where it's due: 2K has worked really, really hard to make up for that disaster, and each subsequent entry since 2K22 has been an improvement. The upcoming 2K25 is predicted to be less of an overhaul and more of a perfection.
That'd sum up 2K24 too. Honestly, if you tired of WWE games and were scared off by 2K20, then you're in for a treat if 2K24 turns out to be your re-entry point. There's so much to see and do here. Modes like MyRise and Showcase serve up excellent story-led gameplay, MyGM isn't a return to the old GM Mode heyday but does scratch an itch, and Universe is still fun for those who like customisation and crafting their own WWE sandbox.
Speaking of which, the Community Creations hub. Oh, that hub. It's an endless stream of quality CAWs, Arenas, belts and more from people who clearly put a shift in and are proud of their work. This has been a stroke of genius from 2K. They've let passionate fans take the lead, and thus opened up your game to become a WCW/ECW/AEW/TNA/New Japan/retro WWF dreamland.
Choice, options and customisation are the three most vital aspects of 2K24. Splash pure gameplay that's actually fun again on top of that and you've got one of the best pro wrestling games ever made. The best ever? Not quite, but it's up there in the conversation and that's a triumph for 2K considering how disillusioned the fanbase was five years or so ago.
7. Fire Pro Wrestling Returns
The next two picks could be a sticking point for those who'd scream, 'WHERE'S FIRE PRO WRESTLING X PREMIUM ON SNES, YOU COWARDS?!' into the void. Fire Pro Wrestling Returns isn't perfect by any means (this writer doesn't think any Fire Pro game he's played actually is), but the gameplay is buttery smooth and a real joy to behold once you get stuck in properly.
Most of the entries in the series have that in common. Not the woefully ill-advised Xbox 360 avatar version launched in September 2012, right enough. Lord only knows what developers Spike Chunsoft were thinking with that one. By comparison, Returns lives up to the Fire Pro name established on consoles like SNES/Super Famicon, PlayStation, Game Boy Advance and more.
Again, gameplay is the real draw, but customisation was another big selling point for those who knew how to implement various packs via PS2. That was tricky for beginners, but worthwhile, because it cracked open a vault of WWF/WWE, WCW, ECW, TNA etc content. Pre-Community Creations in 2K's series, this was unheard of. The closest gamers had been to that sort of cross-promotional fun was in the divisive Legends of Wrestling series, and that didn't boast the gameplay Fire Pro did.
Want another shock? Fire Pro Wrestling Returns isn't even the ultimate Fire Pro experience you can have. Another, less-critically lauded (at least upon release) entry into the franchise takes home the prize there. It really does need more love than it's been getting since 2018.
Say hi to a whole new...
6. Fire Pro Wrestling World
...World.
Fire Pro Wrestling World aimed to bring the best in class gameplay and unique retro flair of the series into the present day. Remarkably, those who loved the series overall didn't lead the charge to declare this the best wrestling game ever released. In fact, some seemed disappointed by the final product. That's baffling, because it's the most immediately accessible version of Fire Pro on the market.
An in-house quasi-2K Community Creations hub kept things fresh by acting as a workaround for those who wanted more WWE flavour. It's possible to hop onto the servers and download pretty much any wrestler you can think of from any era they worked in. That's also true for various logos, arena set-ups and more. The dedication this fanbase has is stunning to witness.
Yes, gameplay is World's best feature by a mile, but it isn't all the game has to offer. The isometric camera view and timing-based grappling system could leave some reaching for the headache pills, admittedly. Spend some time perfecting it and you've got one of the most compelling wrestling games going. Once you get Fire Pro, you get Fire Pro. There's no going back - it's like learning to ride a bike.
There's a bit of charm to the 'handheld warrior' Story Mode too. It's presented in more of a Nintendo DS than PS5 style, but that's OK. There's still fun to be had, not least if you're into Japanese wrestling.
Come for the match to match gameplay, stay for the customisation and the options.
5. WWE SmackDown: Shut Your Mouth
The less said about 2001's SmackDown: Just Bring It, the better. That game failed to launch the series on PS2 properly, meaning fans had to wait until 2002's Shut Your Mouth to get a proper next-gen WWF/WWE title. SYM was to JBI what 2K22 would be to 2K20 in the future. If anything, it was even better than that. THQ and Yuke's made amends big time back in '02.
Gameplay was still fast, but definitely less arcade-y than it had been before. Wrestlers actually sold moves for a little longer than 0.2 seconds, and the painfully short Season Mode from before was lengthened to two full years of meaty WWE storytelling. It's still one of the best story modes any wrestling game has ever had, and it's amazing to think the developers made it even better 12 months later.
More on that to come, which won't surprise anyone.
Remember that point about being fair to every kind of wrestling game and limiting the number of similar entries from a series? Yeah, that goes out the window when it comes to Shut Your Mouth. This game deserves a lot more praise than it gets next to its successor. It was the first one which felt like an accurate reflection of the weekly TV product fans were watching in real life.
Little touches, like the new Draft kicking off Seasons and lower-tier wrestlers starting on Sunday Night Heat rather than Raw or SmackDown, added loads to the immersive feel. Silliness was also still a part of the gameplay, and that made multiplayer matches even more of a laugh.
It's only right to give this game some flowers.
4. WCW/nWo Revenge
WCW's foray into the gaming market was topsy turvy. Titles on NES and SNES had only been so-so, but then WCW vs. nWo: World Tour changed things for the better in 1997/1998. Less than a full year later, AKI Corporation brought their beloved grappling engine back for another whirl with WCW/nWo Revenge. The rest, as they say, is history.
There's a reason this is the most loved World Championship Wrestling game ever. Nitro and Thunder sucked, Mayhem was underrated but undercooked, Backstage Assault was...awful, World Tour was solid and Revenge was lush. It's still fun to play now if you can look back the obviously blocky visuals on N64. There's so much attention to detail that hardcore WCW lovers will appreciate.
The nWo helped WCW become the coolest promotion in the biz, and that comes across in-game. By comparison, main rival WWF WarZone on PS1 still had a wee bit too much family friendly nyuk-nyuk-nyuk mid-90s Vince McMahon on commentary atmosphere to make it an 'Attitude Era' winner. Revenge was dripping with cool compared to that game.
At the time, it was like seeing favourites from Nitro come to life on N64. Then, best of all, the matches played out with a neat momentum-based system that made sense and was simple to get onboard with. WCW/nWo Revenge is a time capsule from the period when Eric Bischoff's company ruled the industry.
They were even dominating the gaming world too, but that'd change once AKI hitched their wagon to the WWF in years to come. No prizes for guessing what's next on the list!
3. WWF No Mercy
WWF No Mercy took everything AKI had worked on in Virtual Pro Wrestling 2, WrestleMania 2000, the WCW games like World Tour or Revenge and perfected it. Released in late-2000, No Mercy coincided with the first two SmackDown titles on PlayStation. Those were fun, but the N64 reigned supreme as a wrestling game connoisseur's console of choice. If you missed out, you had to listen to Nintendo-loving pals at school bragging about No Mercy's excellence.
AKI nailed the WWF's atmosphere, but it was their gameplay engine that charmed people most of all. You will not be shocked to read that this deep into the 'best of' collection at hand. AKI knew how to mimic the ebb and flow of real world wrestling matches better than most, and they knew it was killer bell to bell action that'd keep people coming back time and time again for more.
Yeah, Stevie Richards muscling in on the 'Mania 2000 main event was a strange decision for the Championship (Story) Mode, but even that's become a curiously cute moment from WWE gaming history. Those who played No Mercy didn't care anyway - they were far too busy tearing it up in multiplayer with their mates then rushing home to battle the AI and hone their skills.
It's no wonder this became one of the best selling N64 games ever.
Finally, CPU controlled characters were smarter than they'd been in Revenge, which upped the difficulty factor somewhat. That challenge only made No Mercy stronger. Only two wrestling games stick out as 'No Mercy beaters', and even that's arguable depending who you speak to. Another almost joined them, but Backlash was scrapped before launch.
Dig dig diggity dig-diggity dog!
2. WWE 2K14
The last game that used WWE's 'scratch' logo is also one of the best ever put on disc.
2K14 was 2K's first real stab at things, but they had the know how of Yuke's as a tag-team partner after taking over from the financially ruined THQ. Starting hot, 2K14 hurled plenty of souped up features at fans. The '30 Years Of WrestleMania' mode was a centrepiece, The Undertaker's 'Streak' mode was a nice sideshow to that, and everything came together nicely under a slick gameplay engine that made matches fun to play.
One of the best things about 2K14 was that the game-changing Community Creations hub was easier to use. That made it less of a hassle to implement new characters into your experience - 2K expanded Create-A-Superstar slots to 100, which also helped. Naturally, the servers have long since been shut down, so if you're revisiting 2K14 today then keep that in mind. No WCW CAWs for you!
2K14 was the culmination of Yuke's work through the old SmackDown vs. Raw and WWE '12/'13 series. It wasn't a huge step forwards from the previous game ('13 was ace), but it did refine everything that fans expected and the 'Mania mode was top tier. Unfortunately, the same can't be said for 2K15. That wound up being a messy debut on PS4/Xbox One.
Back to the positives, because there are lots of them. 2K14 is considered by some to be the last truly great WWE game. This writer clearly disagrees with that (2K24 is on this list), but it does feel like a gem from a bygone era.
Speaking of which...
1. WWE SmackDown: Here Comes The Pain
Admit it, you knew this had a fair chance of snatching number one spot.
Shut Your Mouth was a class wrestling game, but SmackDown: Here Comes The Pain was an improvement in all areas. The new grappling system made it feel like there were more moves to choose from, and a body damage display made it easier to win by submission. If someone's arm is in the red, lock on an arm bar. If their leg is damaged, go for a Sharpshooter.
Some didn't like that the free roaming parts of SYM had been stripped back to menu screens, but that made the Season Mode play faster. Overall, the story mode was enhanced and felt like another step in the right direction following Just Bring It's half-baked restrictions and brevity. There are still fans who go back and play through Here Comes The Pain's career over more modern MyRise versions.
Body damage made things tactical, but over the top action remained a general rule of thumb for THQ and Yuke's. Some of the spots players could pull off in-game were insane. Who could ever forget hitting elbow drops from a helicopter? Or how about riding through backstage areas running over opponents in a forklift?
Legends were part of the roster for the first time in HCTP too. That might've been a response to the aforementioned Legends Of Wrestling series. If so, then it was a clever move on WWE's part. Newer match types like Elimination Chamber also made their debut in the series, and that was so much fun to play with friends.
The visual style of Here Comes The Pain still holds up, the gameplay is outstanding, and the variety of modes and matches on offer makes it the most must see wrestling game in existence.
What other wrestling games deserve to be on this list? For more like this, check out Every Change That Happened During WWE’s Transfer Window and WWE 2K25: 10 Biggest Reveals (So Far)!