12 WWE Nightmares That Could Come True In 2026
Will WWE's latest boom period fade? Featuring The Rock, Cody Rhodes, Sami Zayn and more.
If someone was writing about 2025's worst nightmares at the tail end of 2024, then they'd have perhaps opined that WWE fudging John Cena's retirement tour would've been right up there as a 'please don't' possibility. Cena's entire tour has been a mish mash of nostalgic fun and downright awful. Matches against CM Punk, Randy Orton and AJ Styles have been welcomed by fans, but his heel turn shook out as a complete disaster and should be considered a stain on his legacy once he hangs up the jorts for good.
WWE Unreal wanted fans to believe that every single beat of the story was meticulously planned out in advance, but that isn't true. The actual turn itself was, but then creative, Triple H and John himself didn't really know where to go with things. It didn't help that The Rock was only there for the opening chapter then vanished into thin air like he'd thumbed his nose and said: 'See you later, losers!'.
Does 2026 have anything as unfortunate as Cena's wonky heel run in mind? Only time will tell.
There's certainly a lot to fret about. We're not too far away from entering the most thrilling time to be a fan. WrestleMania season is nigh, but all of those fireworks, nostalgic tears and the lure of mega-matches won't be the only things keeping hardcore WWE fans awake at night. What if the bloom is just coming off the rose in the Triple H era, and what if WrestleMania's iconic status is about to be scuffed due to sheer corporate greed?!
Here are your worst fears manifested for the year ahead. Fingers crossed none of this happens, but...
12. Another Draft Comes And Erm…Goes!
Cards on the table. This writer has always loved the idea of a WWE Draft. Seeing wrestlers locked to each major show and unable to flit between them sounds like a challenge the creative team should relish. After all, they're the ones penning this stuff to begin with, so plenty of pre-planning would ensure that Raw and SmackDown's top champions are furnished with loads of juicy challengers for at least the next 12 months.
Sadly, WWE's frankly dull and counterproductive approach has ruined the whole experience. The 2024 Draft proved to be another complete waste of time. The same could be said for 2025’s Transfer Window shenanigans that acted as this gen's 'Superstar Shakeup'. For reasons best know to themselves, the company hasn’t honoured anything it ‘set in stone’ by posting various wrestlers to each show.
Workers continue to show up as and when they like on so-called rival brands, and that'll probably continue to be the case even mid-hype for a 2026 Draft. It'd be nice to imagine that next year's version (assuming it's coming, because 2025's seems to have been scrapped) would act as a hard reset for the concept, but no - it's foolish to think that way given the last couple of examples.
Triple H will talk about "ironclad" rosters, various legends will show up to make token picks, then wrestlers will show up whenever it suits or when WWE feels it needs to front load an episode of TV. Various excuses will be made for this, GMs will get involved in that process, then everyone will forget they even need to justify cross-brand stuff at all.
Rinse and repeat. Will that stop this fan from getting excited by the potential? No, but it's difficult to see WWE sticking to their own rules.
11. Too Many PLEs Feel Skippable
Maybe skippable is a strong word, but far too many WWE PLEs feel supplementary and routine rather than must see at the moment. Yes, the bigger ones like Royal Rumble, WrestleMania and SummerSlam will always carry weight, but events such as Clash In Paris, Wrestlepalooza and even Money In The Bank have felt less than in 2025.
Add in various Saturday Night's Main Event specials and there’s a lot of content for the sake of content on the WWE schedule. Triple H must arrest that in 2026. Each event needs a hook, sure, but they can't stop there and put their feet up. That's particularly true when it comes to the build. Some of the final steps towards recent WWE shows have been tepid at best, and those 'go home' episodes of TV seriously need work.
Of course, this is the consequence of running so many international events as well. The company promotes some of these like house shows with cameras. That felt fresh and different a few years ago, but maybe not so much now - especially not when some of the matches have a strong whiff of exhibition over high stakes.
Sadly, at time of writing, the rumour mill suggests that Survivor Series and the titular WarGames set piece will be thrown together for the sake of it, so these problems look set to persist. Vince McMahon rightly received backlash for booking like: 'Oh, it's October, so we need Hell In A Cell matches' rather than putting bouts in the cage because it made sense.
Hunter shouldn't go down that route too often. If you don't have a story that suits WarGames, then don't bloody do it!
10. Entrance Music Gets Even Worse
Def Rebel manning WWE's entrance music wing just hasn't worked out. There was a lot of talk that their deal with WWE expired in late-2024, but the group's fingerprints are still all over the weekly product thanks to some truly God awful entrance themes. Now, reports are doing the rounds that some top stars are sick of weak entrance tracks and want their old tunes back.
Things aren't going well then.
The 2025 Royal Rumble exposed how weak some of their tracks are. Fans in attendance had zero clue who some entrants were before their name or graphic flashed up on screens, and that’s a problem. It’s unthinkable, but what if WWE moves on from Def Rebel towards another provider and things get even worse. The general quality of music has been dipping in wrestling across the board this generation, so hopefully not.
Fans and wrestlers alike deserve better than the generic trash we’re being fed. It honestly sucks that someone as celebrated and noteworthy as Finn Bálor had music nobody recognised during the Rumble. Why should that be considered acceptable? Def Rebel's over-reliance on catchphrases and other oddities isn't even done well or creatively either.
For example, the "Role Model" line that plays in Bayley's theme feels woefully out of place, and so does some random dude encouraging you to hail "The Queen" during Charlotte Flair's entrance.
For balance, some Rebel tracks are better than others, but we really need to get some bespoke identity back into some of these things. People should know who's coming through the curtain straight away rather than waiting for a graphic or the wrestler walking into view.
9. They Pick Duff Royal Rumble Winners
For whatever reason, it’s becoming increasingly difficult for WWE to choose satisfying Rumble winners. Everyone still loves the event, and it's considered a launching point for 'WrestleMania Season' as a whole, but the company has to be careful with how it's perceived. In 2025, neither the men's or women's Rumble winners actually headlined either night at 'Mania 41.
Footage shown in WWE Unreal put over the creative thinking that went into Jey Uso's victory too. He was chosen because it'd be a complete shock to fans, and that's fine, but there was a 'last minute' vibe to the whole process that's tough to shake. Maybe the most important thing is that WWE plumped for something new at all, because there was a time when they might not have done so.
Still, Uso and Charlotte Flair marked surprise and unwanted 2025 winners respectively, and that's food for thought heading into next year. Hunter will want 2026’s pushes to work out, and he might want a little longer atop the card than he got from 'Main Event' Jey. He's a popular star, no doubt, but on the level of a Roman Reigns or Cody Rhodes? Not quite.
Royal Rumble sets the tone for what WrestleMania will be like, or should be like. So, picking winners that both thrill the audience and serve major storylines going into the biggest weekender of 2026 will be super-important. This isn't a new problem. Batista was booed out of the building for winning in 2014, and folks have been so-so on winners like Ronda Rousey, Brock Lesnar and others in years since.
Let's hope they've got their thinking caps on. And not just Michael Hayes!
8. Charlotte Flair Reverts To Type
Not many could've predicted that Charlotte Flair would close out 2025 by being a genuinely likeable babyface. Groans could be heard when she won the Rumble in February. 'Aw, here we go again', some said. 'Why does she need another title reign anyway?!', came the cry from others. That title reign eluded her. Tiffany Stratton was the winner at WrestleMania 41, then everybody moved on.
Well, Charlotte moved on. Tiffany has actually been stuck in some bizarre creative limbo and is nowhere near as exciting an act as she was earlier in the year. It's nice to see Flair happy and clicking with fans though. Her tag-team alongside real-life pal Alexa Bliss is full of fun, chemistry and surely has a few tasty matches in waiting against all-comers now they're Women's Tag Champs.
However, things could shift yet again once the calendars flip to 2026. WWE may well revert to type with Charlotte by booking her to dominate the women’s division yet again. Nobody really wants to see it, because she's been done to death atop the pack as an elitist heel and that's pretty boring nowadays. Nah, it'd be far better if Flair was able to spin out of this tag stuff, sustain her babyface run and maybe enjoy a stint as Women's United States Champ (or something).
Putting her right back on top of the Women's Title scene would only hold others down, and there's no sense in doing that once the new year dawns. This is arguably WWE's best chance ever to make Charlotte legit likeable to the audience, so they should bend over backwards to keep that going for as long as possible.
No more benchmark chat. Let's move on.
7. Sami Zayn’s Main Event Push Bombs
Check out any given episode of SmackDown every week and you'll see Sami Zayn working some of the best matches going. His United States Title 'Open Challenge' is a hoot, and it's led to excellence against John Cena, Rey Fenix, Carmelo Hayes, Je'Von Evans, Aleister Black and Shinsuke Nakamura. To date. More might've happened by the time you read this piece.
It looks for all the world like Sami is carving out a slow burn push towards World or WWE Title status. He worked as a main event foe for Roman Reigns during the whole Bloodline saga, but it remains to be seen if Zayn would fly as a popular babyface champ. Honestly, it’d be a nightmare if somebody as talented and passionate as he is tanked in the role, but that isn’t out of the question.
The wrestling audience has a habit of yearning hard for something, then turning their backs on it once it happens. We've all done it at some point, and it's a pretty glaring flaw. Sami is showing how adaptable and trustworthy he is during his US Title reign. Triple H would've known that already, but now he knows for certain that Zayn pushing towards an even bigger belt is within reach.
Keep a close eye on things once he gets there. It'd be rather rubbish if Sami becoming World or WWE Champ (something he's worked hard for his entire career) bombed and he was pulled out of the firing line after just a few weeks/months in the hot seat. Not everybody can keep a top babyface run going, y'know.
6. The Rock Messes Them Around (Again!)
Sorry, but The Rock’s involvement in John Cena’s heel turn then subsequent absence from the rest of the story sucked. He wasn’t even at WrestleMania 41. Rapper and abandoned pet project Travis Scott ran in on the main event between Cody and Cena instead, and Rock was barely mentioned on TV after being there for Elimination Chamber.
Payoff for his part in the story has been seriously poor, and there’s no way WWE can let Rocky muck them around some more. Stop letting him meddle with creative plans, please. Sure, there might be more to the story behind the scenes than meets the eye from the outside looking in, but 2025 wasn't a great look for Dwayne Johnson and his role as a key figure in this bold WWE/TKO adventure post-Vince McMahon involvement.
If anything, this year kinda screamed right in fan faces that Rock doesn't care about the minor details the way he says he does. His work opposite Cody Rhodes between events at WrestleMania 40 and Cena's heel turn at Chamber 2025 was confusing, then he vanished into thin air when the biggest story beats needed fleshed out.
The fact that Rocky didn't even explain why he'd helped JC turn heel is staggering.
Triple H and the WWE creative squad would be well within their rights to seek assurances from Rock if he makes any pitches for 2026. They need to know that he's onboard and will actually show up when needed, not just when he feels like it. The company cannot afford too many botched cliffhangers, especially near the top of the card (which is where The Rock would always be).
5. Various Partnerships Dilute The Product
One of the most unpredictable aspects of this modern WWE era is how the organisation has forged links with other wrestling promotions. Under Vince, that seemed impossible, but it did happen historically. Go back to the 1990s and you'll find the then-WWF linking up with AAA and ECW in 1997, and then there were ties to Jim Cornette's Smoky Mountain outfit before that.
The extent of WWE's current partnerships with TNA and AAA are next level though. They're co-promoting cards with both promotions, and WWE owns a 51% controlling stake in the Mexican group too. Perhaps it's only a matter of time before TKO outright owns TNA as well, who knows?
Those links with TNA and AAA have been bleeding over onto WWE TV, and not just on NXT either. Dominik Mysterio flaunts his AAA Mega Championship on Raw, and announcers regularly mention both companies in practically every episode. That’s fine, but things should be kept to a minimum. A glance over at AEW should act as a warning to WWE that diluting your core product with other feds is a risky idea.
Things get too busy, they’re too hard for fans to keep track of, and it generally waters things down. WWE already demands a lot of fan attention to keep tabs on, so it'd be unwise to keep stacking names like AAA, TNA, Evolve and more on top of Raw, SmackDown and NXT. LFG? Less f'n generosity wouldn't go amiss.
To explain, that means focusing more on the core WWE product than doling it out to others. Working relationships are great, but it'd be smart to show some restraint. A little less Tony Khan, a little more selfishness.
4. Cody Rhodes Starts Getting ‘Roman Reigns Heat’
It’s easy to forget amidst the fanfare of his retirement tour that John Cena once played before regular jeers, or that Roman Reigns was once booed out of buildings weekly despite being babyface. Consistently maintaining a strong connection to the audience as a babyface is difficult, and that's why Cody Rhodes deserves immense credit; he's done a remarkable job of sustaining popularity as a face.
Surely that’ll change eventually.
WWE and Cody himself might need to leap before they're pushed on that, or face the consequences by looking reactionary rather than proactive once boos start raining down. On a recent episode of SmackDown, Rhodes addressed his Crown Jewel match with Seth Rollins and leaned into some comedy, but there was a subtle heel air to the way he carried himself (and not for the first time).
This was either pure coincidence or Cody spots danger lurking ahead. He's no fool. Rhodes is a student of the game (so to speak) who understands all too well that wrestling audiences are fickle. He used to be one of those yay-ing/nay-ing punters himself whilst watching his father and brother do their thing at shows, so he has valuable experience on both sides of the barriers.
A heel turn before that Cena/Reigns-style 'go away' heat becomes prevalent would be best. Sadly, wrestling rarely realises that things need to change before fans do. How long can Cody's babyface status survive before change is essential? That's the question, one that must've dominated countless WWE creative team meetings over the past 3 years or so.
No-one wants to see Rhodes get booed when he's supposed to be getting cheered. Not after this epic run.
3. The Recent Boom Bursts!
WWE has experienced a bit of a boom in business and overall popularity since Triple H assumed control of things from Vince McMahon, but nothing lasts forever. There’s some clear evidence that ‘The Game’ is running out of goodwill creatively with the audience. People are questioning his decisions more than they were before, and the quality of PLEs has also been debated due to the changing landscape of ESPN subscription prices.
On that front, 'The Game' is determined to hold onto his general belief that 'less is more'. Many WWE supercards only have a handful of matches (5 is his go to), and that flies in the face of a company approach that was once 'more is more'. Personally, the guy writing this article likes the relative bare bones layout of these PLEs because it makes each match easy to digest and enjoy fully, but they're clearly not for everybody and do clash with the stacked offerings in groups like AEW, TNA or New Japan.
Whilst it's doubtful that things will ever drop to 1995 levels of disinterest again, this current boom could fade somewhat back to pre-2022/2023 levels in 2026. In 2019, WWE earned scorn from all corners of the wrestling map for shoddy booking, boring TV and nonsensical ideas. McMahon's dotage would've been a terrible time to be a fan had AEW not raced into view and offered a vibrant alternative.
There's another elephant in the room which exists when people sit down to chat about why this financial boom is even a thing in the first place. Yes, TKO have steered WWE back towards headlines for the right reasons (largely), but that has come at a cost to paying fans.
Literally!
2. Fans Say ‘No More’ On Ticket Price Increases
It has never been more expensive to attend WWE shows across the board.
WWE/TKO seem to think they can charge whatever the hell they like and people will pay it. In a way, they’re right, because buildings are still selling out and big crowds are the norm even for episodes of Raw or SmackDown, but...surely this isn’t sustainable. Further increases will completely price many out of attending shows, and that's plain stupid from a basic business standpoint.
For most, it’s hard to justify the kind of cash they’re asking for tickets. Put it this way: Fans aren't only being charged premium rates for high-rolling PLEs like WrestleMania or SummerSlam, but also for weekly TV shows which previously offered a comforting, family-friendly price point provided you didn't mind where you were sitting. Those days are pretty much gone, at least for now.
The company looks real greedy these days. They’re in this to make money, obviously, but flagrantly fleecing fans isn’t a good look and won't be something WWE can do forever. Some of the reported ticket prices doing the rounds online for upcoming events are unbelievable, and not in a positive way. How on earth can your average punter shell out as much as $10,000 to attend one wrestling show, not least when they're sitting higher up in the arena/stadium rather than at ringside with extras and the cost of general living has skyrocketed?!
It's madness.
There's a twist to this entry. It's less of a nightmare for fans and more of a headache for WWE/TKO. In short, fans rebelling against this greed would maybe force bosses to change their strategy. Seeing dwindling attendances wouldn't please anybody though; not the money-grabbing corporate types or those who want wrestling to do well.
A middle ground must be struck. Some balance, please.
1. Money Makes WrestleMania In Saudi Permanent
This is a wild rumour, but the ever-churning conjecture mill suggests that money men in Saudi Arabia would love to make WrestleMania an annual supershow in their country. That’d clearly be a bit rubbish for the rest of the globe. WrestleMania shouldn’t exclusively belong to one place and one place only.
Hosting it most often in the United States is different, because that’s where WWE has always been based. Shifting it to Saudi permanently, or offering thinly veiled ‘WrestleMania World Tour’ imitations as side projects elsewhere hurts the brand’s legacy and would be a shocking show of corporate greed. Not to piggy back too much off the previous entry about soaring ticket prices, but it would.
This has been a worry ever since WWE promoted the so-called Greatest Royal Rumble mere months after the proper Rumble in 2018. The event held over in Jeddah failed to live up to the billing and was promoted in close proximity to a more traditional Rumble held in Philadelphia. That let to grumbles from fans that the McMahon family were selling the very soul of their operation.
As established, TKO aren't hiding how into making money they are. Yes, every business wants to rake in the cash, but brand protection is important. WrestleMania is a globally-renowned brand with a rich history and legacy, and it simply cannot be watered down with multiple variations on the same theme. That'd be a mistake long term.
'Mania 43 will take place in Riyadh come 2027, but some seem to believe there's a chance an announcement is coming in 2026 that WrestleMania belongs to Saudi Arabia from here on out. That'd likely destroy hopes of ever seeing one in the UK, Australia or elsewhere on the map, because any other 'Mania hangers-on WWE booked would presumably be held in the US.
Be very careful here. Yes, wrestling fans in Saudi definitely deserve the thrill of seeing WrestleMania come to town, but not every single year.
What other nightmares could come true for WWE in 2026? For more wrestling, check out 10 WWE Fates Worse Than Death and 10 Worst WWE Moments Of 2005!