15 Things We Learned From Dark Side Of The Ring: Muhammad Hassan
The rise, fall and rebirth of the man behind WWE's most controversial character.
Muhammad Hassan will always be viewed as one of the most controversial characters in WWE history. The timing of his arrival on the scene couldn't have been more knowingly inciteful (not insightful!); people in the United States were still picking up pieces from the harrowing events of terror attacks in New York on 11 September 2001 when Vince McMahon introduced his latest creation in 2004.
Aspiring hopeful Marc Copani was cast in the role, and it'd change his life forever, but...not everything was as it seemed with Hassan initially. VICE's series finale for this season of 'Dark Side Of The Ring' peeled back some of the layers to reveal what was really going through Copani's mind as he tackled such sensitive subjects as racial tension, immigration, outright xenophobia and more via top WWE shows like Raw or SmackDown.
Some of his answers might not be what fans expect. Also, unlike a lot of what VICE produces for 'Dark Side', this story has a happy ending. It's been a long, often arduous journey to get to this point for Copani though, and he examined the mental impact of watching a dream die through no fault of his own during the documentary.
Want to know how one episode of Sunday Night Heat nobody remembers changed everything? You got it. Wonder what Hassan's punishment was for questioning Eddie Guerrero backstage? That's here too. There are quite fascinating tales on everyone from Vince McMahon, his daughter Stephanie, The Undertaker, the bizarre "Wrestler's Court" and more.
Here's everything learned from a 'what might've been' look at the all too brief WWE career of Marc 'Muhammad Hassan' Copani.
15. Jim Cornette’s Reaction To WWE’s Repackage Job
Say what you will about Jim Cornette (and people do!), but he did a sparkling job of running old WWE developmental talent factory OVW. Whilst there, Jim helped nurture and produce the likes of Brock Lesnar, John Cena, Randy Orton, Batista and many, many more. Between 2002-2004, Marc Copani was one of his brightest prospects for attaining main roster success.
Cornette had booked Copani solidly for around two years as vain villain Mark Magnus. He became OVW Heavyweight Champion, and Jim knew it was only a matter of time before WWE called the guy up to their main roster. However, what Cornette didn't expect was that Vince McMahon would fancy a complete repackage job.
His reaction to that phone call coming in is priceless on the show: “All of a sudden I get a call from the WWE office…saying they wanted to make him an Arab. I said, but he’s an Italian from Syracuse!”. Copani had been an arrogant heel along the lines of ‘Ravishing’ Rick Rude in OVW, so this was a complete 180 turn to say the least. It clearly caught Jim totally by surprise, because he likely figured WWE bosses would want more of the self-obsessed heel stuff.
Not quite.
There's a brilliant moment during 'Dark Side' when Cornette's face drops and he stares right into the camera. The developmental booker knew he couldn't protect his OVW roster from anything that happened to them in the major leagues, but he had to be really worried for Copani if this was the sort of thing McMahon had in mind for him.
14. How Copani’s Family Reacted To The Change
Understandably, Marc himself was a bit taken aback when Cornette told him all about WWE's plan. He immediately went to his family to break the news, and they were "trepidatious" about the whole thing. Some of them rightly pointed out that tensions were still running high post-9/11, so they wanted Copani to be careful he didn't get into a whole heap of trouble away from the ring.
That was a reasonable response considering safety was a real issue.
Copani made one thing crystal clear to his concerned family though - there was zero chance of him saying no to WWE and knocking back the chance to appear on top programming like Raw or SmackDown. He'd worked too hard to reach this moment, and now things were about to pay off. Marc admitted to VICE that he didn't really stop to properly think about what he might be getting himself into with the Muhammad Hassan character.
He was just far too excited about finally going up a few rungs on the pro wrestling ladder. Ex-WWE peer Maven told the doc's producers that everyone could see that Copani had talent. However, there were a few sideways looks once the locker room learned what kind of gimmick he'd be playing.
Even that was up in the air, because WWE hadn't totally fleshed out what Hassan was supposed to represent. In retrospect, that sounds daft, but Copani himself viewed the persona differently to McMahon. He'd lose that battle eventually, but the aspiring star did think he could pull off something a little more intelligent than wrestling characters typically were.
13. How He Viewed Hassan Initially
Of course, Copani compared the Muhammad Hassan gimmick to older, more cartoony characters like The Bolsheviks or The Iron Sheik. So, he kept content in his earliest promos fairly tame. This new guise was more about gently nudging people towards a certain response rather than outright inciting a riot or offending anybody.
That all changed once WWE started pushing for more controversy, but things were in check at first. Former WWE writer and producer Michael Leonardi recalled seeing early vignettes and promos that portrayed Hassan as a frustrated Arab-American who was actually just irked by xenophobia and struggling to comprehend why his family was suffering because of heinous actions by others.
It had potential, especially because Copani was knocking it out of the park with his delivery. If he and WWE could successfully turn the scathing heat on punters for singling him out for the way he looked post-9/11 when he'd grown up in America without incident, then they'd be onto something. Hassan could've been a super-smart political and societal commentary, but this is wrestling.
The biz usually paints in broad strokes, not nuance, and thus Muhammad Hassan's more intelligent, level-headed pleading for equality was ignored in favour of ramping up the controversial aspects of his kayfabe'd background. To Marc, maintaining some respectability during early promos on OVW programming was important. He definitely didn't want to be linked to the 9/11 horror even in passing.
Going a more cerebral route appealed to him more. Then, Vince McMahon got his grubby mitts on things.
12. An Episode Of Sunday Night Heat Changed Everything
There might not be a human out there who vividly remembers the 12 December 2004 episode of old 'C' show Sunday Night Heat. Why would you? A match pitting Billy Kidman and Akio vs. Paul London and Chavo Guerrero has been lost to time, and it's hardly like the wrap-up show was an ongoing concern to WWE back then. Most have probably even forgotten that Ivory and Todd Grisham hosted the thing in late-2004.
During the episode, both hyped the coming debut of Muhammad Hassan on Raw. Then, in a moment which thankfully not many people would've seen, Ivory asked Todd how he'd be getting to Huntsville for the flagship. When Grisham said he'd be driving, she answered: “Good, because I don’t want you to be flying, if you get my drift”.
Eek!
Journalist John Pollock told VICE that he thinks this was a real shift in WWE’s way of thinking and their approach towards the Hassan character. “That sets the tone for what the audience can expect”, he added. Pollock wasn't wrong. Come Raw on the following Monday, people tuning in knew they were about to see an angry Arab-American wrestler who was based on the horrific Twin Towers tragedy several years prior.
Ivory pretty much spelled that out on Heat. Copani himself wasn't privy to any of this, because he was far too busy readying for a debut segment opposite company legend and fellow 'Dark Side Of The Ring' subject Mick Foley. He would've been horrified though, surely. WWE's own announcers were almost suggesting that anybody flying on a plane with Hassan was in immediate danger.
11. WWE Insisted He Stay In Character At All Times
Some people in the real world honestly felt like they were under threat.
Both Copani and on-screen manager Shawn Daivari had to stay true to their gimmicks when they were travelling, which clearly made things a little dicey at airports or out on the road generally. That edict was passed down by none other than Vince McMahon himself. In other words, Marc had no choice but to play Muhammad Hassan whenever he was out in public.
This proved problematic, which nobody will be shocked to hear. Copani literally saw people fear for their lives around him, especially when he was on planes. At one point in the doc, Marc recalled seeing and hearing people on the phone to family after spotting him. They wanted to say they loved them, and there were fears Copani (as Hassan) would do something to hijack the flight.
Wow. This part of the show was seriously intense.
Staying in character when in view of the public was certainly nothing new for pro wrestling or WWE, but other characters like Ted DiBiase's 'Million Dollar Man' or The Undertaker had been more cartoonish in nature. Ted was a rich braggart and 'Taker a largely-mute undead force, but it obvious to onlookers that they were merely playing a part to keep the pretence up.
Hassan felt different to folks due to what had happened in the real world mere years before. By insisting he stayed in gimmick at all times no matter where he was, McMahon was actually putting one of his own workers in danger more than anything else.
10. His Scary Experience On Tour In Australia
During 'Dark Side', Copani remembered being with WWE in Australia and drinking at a bar with Gene Snitksy, Chris Masters and others when a group of men approached he and Daivari. They were Muslim, and things got heated. The men were angry that these guys were portraying Muslim characters on TV rather than living faith for real. If he was being upfront, Copani hadn’t even thought about that!
The penny suddenly dropped that Muslims would be offended by “a non-Muslim portraying that character”. This shows the other side of things. Copani and Daivari didn’t just have to look out for people in the United States who might've been tense post-9/11, but they had to think of the other side of the coin too. Some other Arab-Americans would be mad at what he was doing.
Deep down, Marc knew he’d be fine in Australia because he was surrounded by wrestlers (Snitsky told VICE he was prepared to fight if he had to), but it was one of the first times Copani had second thoughts about the Muhammad Hassan character. “That’s when the lines between wrestling and reality no longer existed”, he said.
It came as a real shock to him that Muslim people would even react this way at all. That's rather silly looking back, but he genuinely hadn't paused to think of the impact on a certain demographic of people other than those showering him with boos or telling him to "go home".
Somewhat ironically given the surroundings, this was a sobering wake-up call for Copani, but he was already in too deep.
9. Kurt Angle’s Part In An Eddie Guerrero Drama
Copani had to look out for political backbiting behind the curtain at WWE shows too. He'd been using the Camel Clutch as a finisher (lifting it from fellow anti-USA character The Iron Sheik from a generation or so prior), and it was getting a reaction from fans. One day, Kurt Angle walked up to Hassan and pointed out that Eddie Guerrero was using the move as a routine spot in his matches too.
Angle wondered if it'd be a good idea for Marc to protect his finish by having a word with Guerrero. Looking back, Copani definitely wishes he hadn't and thinks he should've kept his mouth shut, but he took the advice and approached Eddie backstage. That's when Guerrero said that his father had invented the workmanlike submission, so he'd always used it as a tribute.
Yikes.
This turned into "nuclear heat" for Copani from the rest of the WWE locker room. Many had already been upset that his Muhammad Hassan character was getting a big push so quickly, but now critics could point to unhappiness that Marc had apparently been disrespectful towards a cherished veteran like Eddie. Realising that the proverbial had just hit the fan, Copani told VICE: “I was mortified. I just really felt like I’d made a mistake that I’m not gonna come back from”.
He called his father and wanted to fly himself home to escape the heat, but ended up in the dreaded "Wrestler’s Court" instead. Suddenly, things had gone from a young worker trying to humbly protect his finish to the entire roster piling on. Yeah, let's just assume Copani didn't thank Kurt for that one.
8. The Consequence Of Wrestler’s Court
Onlookers outside the biz must laugh and shake their heads when they find out about "Wrestler's Court", but it was something young stars had to look out for during Hassan's era. He was tried in the nonsense court by The Undertaker and others. On VICE, Chris Masters hit the nail on the head by saying this is a way to "shame [someone] in front of everybody" and nothing more.
It was also a crafty, rather see-through way for veterans to snag themselves free booze on the road. Copani's fate was ridiculous. He had to buy "over a thousand dollars worth of drinks" for the roster. Gee, do you think that's enough? As if that wasn't bad enough, certain unnamed key members of the WWE upper card poured expensive beverages on the floor right in front of Marc right after he'd bought them.
How childish is that?!
Once this nightmare episode was over with, Guerrero came up to Copani, gave him a hug and said he knew he didn’t mean anything by the Camel Clutch query. It was a bit late for that, 'Latino Heat'! Where were you when this fresh-faced relative rookie was forced to shell out a substantial amount of money on booze that mean-spirited (no pun intended) workers would tip onto the floor anyway?
Copani didn't labour the point, but it's clear he viewed "Wrestler's Court" as a real con. In effect, he was punished for nothing at all. Eddie wasn't even that bothered by the initial question. It wasn't quite a million dollar one, but more of a $1,000 one.
7. Stephanie McMahon Trashed His “Pushback”
Anyone who has been tuning into her Stephanie's Places show on ESPN recently will know that Stephanie McMahon has a bubbly, fun-loving side. Poor Marc Copani didn't get to see that when Steph was in the pressure cooker of day to day WWE creative back in 2005. On 'Dark Side' he recalled pushing back against the company's decision to focus more on the idea that Muhammad Hassan was a terrorist rather than somebody sick of being called one.
McMahon was the head writer on SmackDown around that time, so Copani went to her and expressed his concerns with the creative direction. “She kinda put me in my place”, he said. Stephanie blasted Marc and said that this was a “huge opportunity” for him. So, he should ‘shut up - we know what we’re doing’. Afterwards, Copani wasn’t convinced at all.
However, despite seeing that things were starting to get out of hand, he doesn’t think the gimmick was “intentionally distasteful up until the end”. As Hassan, the guy just didn’t have the necessary backstage power or sway to fight what was happening creatively. He simply had to do as he was told, which is the fact Stephanie McMahon rather curtly reminded him of.
There was a nagging sense that things were only going to get worse. That'd prove to be the case, sadly. WWE shifted Hassan from somebody speaking out about terrorism and being blamed for something abhorrent to a character who glorified "sacrifice". It was a key shift he was never on board with, hence the concerned chat that didn't go well with Steph.
6. The Original WWE Push Plan He Was Told
Copani was pulled aside and told WWE's grand plans for him. According to writers, he was set to defeat company icon The Undertaker in a number one contendership situation. Following that, he'd then move on to wrestle Batista for the World Heavyweight Title. Everyone said that Vince McMahon’s end game was to have Hassan beat Batista in Washington, D.C for the title and lord it over the United States.
“Kinda like the big F-U to America”.
Things obviously didn’t turn out that way, so WWE must’ve changed their minds en route. It seems rising backlash from external groups worried about the way their Arab-American character was heading played a major role in that, but Marc thought he was destined to win big gold eventually regardless. After all, he'd been pushed to the moon as a hated heel since debuting, so why wouldn't WWE put a title on him?
WWE had enough faith in Copani to program him in top-billed segments sharing the stage with everyone from Hulk Hogan and Mick Foley to Steve Austin and 'Taker, so they were surely all in on finishing his character arc. Hassan was due to beat Undertaker at the Great American Bash '05 (another slap in the face to patriotic punters), then win out vs. Batista at SummerSlam in the nation's capital.
Instead, Muhammad was slapped about by 'Taker at the Bash then JBL took his spot opposite Batista in Washington. One regrettable angle on a July episode of SmackDown forced McMahon and WWE to change course overnight. They couldn't palm off the negative feedback any longer.
Hassan's big title win over 'The Animal' was promptly deleted from prospective booking sheets.
5. UPN Banned Him From SmackDown
TV execs at UPN were appalled by an angle on the 7 July 2005 episode of SmackDown. In light of the London Bombings earlier that miserable day, WWE had Muhammad Hassan use Daivari as "a sacrifice", then five hooded men attacked The Undertaker after Hassan gave a beheading gesture. Knowing this would cause some backlash, the company ran a crawler warning fans about the segment, but they didn’t cut it from the broadcast.
Bruce Prichard has put blame at UPN's doorstep before via his 'Something To Wrestle With' podcast. According to him, there was also no way to quickly edit the tapes back then once they'd been sent to the station. Hmm, surely something could've been done, because this was catastrophic to WWE PR and to Copani's career as a whole.
UPN were horrified by the reaction, so they told WWE his Hassan character couldn’t appear on their channel afterwards. That's when writer Michael Leonardi popped back up on VICE to says he didn’t agree with what the promotion was doing creatively, and felt like they “needed to scale back”. He then claims he was “stripped of all [his] responsibilities and demoted” almost immediately for speaking out.
This was a dreadful day all round. People in London were terrified, then WWE aired footage that seemed to glorify their pain and misery later that same evening. Copani deeply regrets playing a part in all of that stuff. He'd pushed back against the creative direction, but was pretty much told to keep his mouth shut by higher ups.
Even so, he felt bad.
4. “Don’t Buy The House”
This story shows the rotten human impact playing such a controversial character had on Marc's real life.
He'd been making some decent money since jumping up from OVW to WWE's main roster in late-2004, and Copani was ready to buy a house. Before putting an offer down for the property, he needed some reassurance from his employer that the Hassan gimmick had a bright future on television. So, Marc outright asked management's John Laurinaitis what he should do.
The answer chilled him. "Don't buy the house", Laurinaitis replied. That told Copani everything he needed to know. He was doomed due to incoming pressure that had flooded in from all comers pushing back on the anti-American gimmick. Sadly, this meant he didn't feel like he was in the right position to commit to buying the house, and he had to limp on until WWE cut ties following the Great American Bash in July 2005.
Copani became clear collateral damage here as WWE warred to fend off criticism for their own deliberately-incendiary booking. Maybe if they'd steered clear of talk about "sacrifice" and kept Hassan as more of an anti-terror persona horrified by the way he was being treated then everything would've turned out just fine, but no - Vince McMahon couldn't stop himself from seeking more and more heat at the cost of good taste.
The knock on impact of this, unfortunately, was that poor Marc Copani couldn't get his real life in order and buy the house of his dreams 'cause he didn't know if he'd have a job good enough to keep up mortgage payments.
3. Great American Bash 2005 Was “Full Circle”
This match vs. The Undertaker was one that Muhammad Hassan was originally slated to win, but criticism of that aforementioned angle on SmackDown in early-July changed everything. Suddenly, WWE decided they'd rather wash their hands of the character they crafted, and the only one who'd lose out would be the guy playing it.
Hassan lost to ‘Taker in a number one contenders match at the Great American Bash 2005 pay-per-view. Internally, Copani knew this would be it for his run in WWE, but something else was playing in his mind that night: Marc’s family were in attendance for the show, because it was in Buffalo, New York. That’s where Copani had grown up and started dreaming of one day becoming a wrestler, so this was a weird full circle moment for him whilst also processing the death of that dream.
On 'Dark Side', Copani said he was honoured to stare at the lights for The Undertaker in spite of the crappy circumstances for him personally. He drove home after the show, and he “couldn’t even begin to tell you the thoughts [he] was feeling”. Marc was heartbroken by how things had turned out for his career, and he knew he wouldn't get another chance.
WWE chiefs had told him there was no way to repackage him into another character. That's plainly utter drivel. Wrestling can repackage anything, and it isn't often concerned with being clever or cute about that either. Copani could've denounced the Hassan gimmick and moved forward as an updated take on his old vain heel guise.
Vince McMahon wasn't interested.
2. He Had Dark Thoughts After WWE
Marc admits he was really depressed post-WWE. He felt like wrestling had turned its back on him, but readily admits he turned his back on the industry too. One day, after stumbling around with no direction for a few years, Copani came home low on energy and needing sleep. Then, a dangerous thought occurred to him.
“What if you don’t wake up? What difference would it make? What difference do you make? How many days have you wasted?”. That played over and over in his head, and things threatened to get out of control. This one moment was akin to a personal rallying cry for Marc. He realised he had to make serious changes to his life in order to regain happiness, because he couldn't keep thinking about what could've been in WWE.
Revealing this to the world on camera to VICE must've taken a lot of strength. It's likely something Copani has discussed during various interviews over the years since making peace with the end of his pro wrestling dreams, but still - he didn't need to let viewers in like this and could've easily palmed off the WWE departure as 'just one of those things'.
Instead, Marc decided to inspire anyone who's struggling with their own self-worth. What's more, he's been able to use a negative experience as fuel to help others in his day job. Working with young children and helping them achieve their own ambitions has become a form of therapy for Copani, and he's really grateful for that.
Good on him.
1. “I Don’t Waste Days Anymore”
After picking himself back up, Marc went to college and worked nights at UPS. He found the experience “very humbling”, and ended up getting a degree then becoming a teacher. Going further, he also became a school principal. Copani managed to turn his life back around and find the happiness that had eluded him since his WWE dream died. He didn’t realise just how much he was suppressing the pain and heartbreak of things.
According to the man himself, it wasn’t until a decade or so later that he “started to appreciate the journey and career [he’d] had regardless of how it ended”. Today, he doesn’t blame WWE, and says he made the decision to play the character. So, he doesn’t hold grudges about it. Jim Cornette appeared again to say Copani is probably better off in the long run for getting out of wrestling; “I’m happy for him”, Cornette closed.
It's somewhat poignant that VICE's latest 'Dark Side Of The Ring' season ended on such a happy note. Copani's story hasn't resulted in tragedy, death or suicide. There's no addiction issues to pore over or bounce back from. No, he just needed time to rationalise everything in his own mind and then move forwards.
Marc perhaps says it best when he adds: "I don't waste days anymore". He's been able to look back on some of the more positive things about his WWE run, like sharing the stage at WrestleMania 21 with childhood hero Hulk Hogan, or wrestling The Undertaker on pay-per-view in his last company match.
Roll on 'Dark Side' series seven!
What did you think of VICE's episode on controversial WWE gimmick Muhammad Hassan? For more 'Dark Side Of The Ring', check out 15 Things We Learned From Dark Side Of The Ring: Tony Atlas and 13 Things We Learned From Dark Side Of The Ring: Daffney!