10 Absurdly Contrived Bad Guy Schemes
10. Oliver & Cheryl Lang - Arlington Road
For the majority of its runtime, Arlington Road is a perfectly fine, paranoia-filled thriller about a college professor, Michael Faraday (Jeff Bridges), who becomes suspicious that his neighbours, Oliver Lang (Tim Robbins) and his wife Cheryl (Joan Cusack) might be terrorists. It seems like the film is going to be a commentary on the reactionary nature of trigger-happy Americans, but in fact, takes a far less predictable, and far more insidiously loopy turn in act three. It turns out that Oliver and Cheryl are terrorists, and they've got a bomb primed to explode, so Michael drives to a federal building to try and warn the authorities, before realising that he has been tricked; he opens the trunk of his car, revealing a bomb, which explodes. Michael is framed as a terrorist, while Oliver and Cheryl get away scot-free, and Michael's young son goes away to live with relatives, never finding out the truth about his father being framed. It's a depressing but hilariously contrived ending that's certainly thrilling, but also extremely contrived in order to arrive at its "gotcha!" ending.
9. Lee Woo-jin - Oldboy
The baddie of modern revenge classic Oldboy, Lee Woo-jin, pays to have Oh Dae-su kidnapped and locked away in a building for fifteen years, while we remain largely unaware of why this is until the film's cruel, savage and extremely contrived reveal. At the film's climax, it turns out that Oh Dae-su has been locked away because of a prior sin; when at high school, he spread the rumour that classmate Lee Woo-jin was having sex with his own sister - which was true - and eventually caused her suicide. Lee Woo-jin, distraught ever since, concocted one of the most contrived and demented revenge plans possible. Not only does he hold him captive for 15 years, but upon releasing him, allows hypnotic suggestion to lead him to become attracted to Mi-do, a young sushi chef. The two end up embarking on a relationship, and at the film's climax, Oh Dae-su ends up realising that he has been having sex with his own daughter. He cuts out his own tongue as penance, demanding that she never know anything of this, and Lee Woo-jin, feeling his plan is complete, summarily commits suicide. This is one of those great pulpy yarns that manages to overcome how much convolution it relies on because it's just so much damn fun.8. Lex Luthor - Superman
This early comic book classic has a wonderfully loopy plot to form Lex Luthor's evil plan; he intercepts two nuclear missiles which are being tested, and aims for their destinations to be altered. This happens, but one of his hapless, idiotic cronies enters the wrong location, causing one of the two missiles to head right to the hometown of Luthor's girlfriend, Eve Teschmacher, in Hackensack, New Jersey. Thus, after Luthor overpowers Superman with Kryptonite and explains to him the location of the missiles, Supes manages to negotiate his release with Eve, on the condition that he save her family in Hackensack. And so we see, not only is the scheme itself immensely contrived, but so too is the manner in which it is resolved; if only Luthor's goon hadn't redirected the missile so conveniently to Hackensack, then Supes wouldn't have had a single thing to bargain with Eve about. It's ridiculous.
7. Auric Goldfinger - Goldfinger
Given how cartoony and ridiculous so many of the Bond villain plans are, Auric Goldfinger's is comparatively simple, if also immensely contrived in a far more pared-down way. The first step of his plan is having cohort Pussy Galore disperse a nerve gas over Fort Knox that will incapacitate every single guard on the island, and this will allow him to then creep on, plant a nuclear device that will irradiate all of the gold on the island, and then profit as the value of his own gold stock skyrockets. It's contrived because Goldfinger basically entrusts the entire crux of his plan with one person, a woman no less, who is promptly seduced by Bond's genitals and persuaded to replace the nerve gas with an altogether more harmless substance, preventing Goldfinger from carrying out his otherwise simple plan. Plus, there's the overwhelming feeling that Goldfinger should have just killed Bond when he had the chance, which he really, really did.6. Voldemort - Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire
Voldemort was a thoroughly menacing foe throughout the Harry Potter series, though there's still the nagging feeling that had he been a bit more savvy during the fourth film, The Goblet of Fire, he might have been able to actually defeat Harry, and do it a lot quicker, too. Instead, he opts for a ridiculously ham-fisted plot, all stemming from the Triwizard Cup, which we discover is actually a hexed, secret means to capture Harry and steal some of his blood, such that Voldy can be reborn. It's so, so, so convoluted; everything that leads to this scene of Harry touching the Cup has been seemingly telegraphed by Voldemort to happen, his powers of pre-cognisance being just that strong indeed. Why not simply transport him through simpler means? Does it need to be a cup? Why? Furthermore, surely there are less nefarious ways to get Harry's blood? Take it while he's asleep, for instance, and arouse no suspicion whatsoever; then you can come back to life and have the element of surprise against Harry. Granted, it's fantasy, and sometimes with fantasy you just have to roll with it, but this one just seems so freaking obvious!
5. The Plants - The Happening
Granted, this film is absurd and contrived from start to finish, what with the so-called "bad guys" actually being plants that emit a gas that convinces human beings to spontaneously commit suicide. Mark Wahlberg and a ridiculously miscast Zooey Deschanel try to outrun giant clouds and make it through the day as everyone around them turns suicidal, but from a plan perspective, and from an evolutionary, scientific perspective, doesn't this all seem a bit, well, theatrical? Plans emitting a gas that signals our brain to pick up a nearby weapon and do ourselves in feels a far stretch beyond a plant emitting a gas that just, you know, shuts our body down and kills us instantly. But then that's sort of the point, I guess; M. Night Shyamalan was looking for something that looked good in a trailer, and this silly gas allows for a lot of ridiculous, dramatic death scenes, whereas the more sensible "scheme" of the plants would have had everyone on planet Earth die of poison within a day or two. Still, things like this are probably the last thing we should be complaining about in this horrible, horrible film.4. Dr. Nichols - The Fugitive
Here's a bad guy scheme that's so over the top and ridiculous it borders on the hilariously inane. Dr. Charles Nichols is trying to develop a new drug, when colleague Dr. Richard Kimble (Harrison Ford) discovers that it causes severe liver damage. Nichols, wanting this swept under the rug, takes the rather drastic step of sending a man to kill Kimble, but the man ends up killing Kimble's wife instead. And why was this? Because Nichols hired a freaking one armed man to do the job. We're pretty sure when you decide to take up the job title of "ruthless assassin", it's probably a good idea that you have fully functioning - not to mention present - limbs, to account for any parts of your plan that might go awry. Plus, being one-armed is going to make you pretty damn easy to identify if the plan screws up. Nevertheless, Nichols hired him anyway, and it really couldn't have helped to contain the mess; maybe if he had fully-functioning limbs, the confrontation with the wife would have gone completely differently. Plus, Nichols basically allows Kimble to find out his complicity in the drug scheme uncontested, which is, well, both dumb and extremely funny.
3. Le Chiffre - Casino Royale
Le Chiffre has been a naughty boy; he's been playing fast and loose with his clients' investments, and after Bond screws up one of his deals, goes to the Casino Royale card game in Montenegro to try and win a purse big enough to pay off those he owes. However, Bond ends up foiling him again, taking $100m and stashing it in a Swiss bank account. As Bond leaves the Casino, though, La Chiffre hatches his insanely over-the-top - if extremely entertaining - plan to get the money back, by kidnapping Bond's little ragamuffin, Vesper, and leaving her in the middle of the road. Bond, of course, gives chase, and upon realising that Vesper is lying in the road, swerves to avoid her, promptly crashing his Aston Martin DBS in spectacular style, earning Bond the Guinness World Record for the most barrel rolls in cinematic history (really; you can look it up). Given that Le Chiffre needs Bond to give him the password to the Swiss bank account, this is a pretty bloody extreme and risky way of catching him, if we concede that most people in car accidents like that end up on a morgue slab. Considering this isn't just Le Chiffre's money at stake, but by proxy, his life, you think he'd be a little bit more thoughtful about the investment. Instead, he opts for a plan that is both over-thought and incredibly stupid, relying on way too many apparent guarantees to succeed. Still, he doesn't get the password out of a naked, sore Bond in time, and winds up on the business end of a bullet in the brain.2. Loki - The Avengers
Tom Hiddleston's Loki is an extremely fun villain to watch, and The Avengers was a totally wild ride, but that doesn't excuse how needlessly convoluted his plan was. Loki ends up getting caught by The Avengers, and they remark the considerable ease with which they managed to achieve this, instantly becoming suspicious that he might have a plan, and they're right to feel this way. From here, Loki's back-up arrives, firing at the Helicarrier, which in turn triggers Bruce Banner's transformation into The Hulk, and in turn the Helicarrier suffers catastrophic damage. Given what little agency Loki has in this fight, what was the point of him getting himself caught in the first place? Why not scramble attack jets remotely and have Banner Hulk out all on his own? That'd probably cause some pretty substantial damage without taking the risk of exposing himself so brazenly. Plus, given that we know Loki is just answering to an even greater power, it all seems a bit redundant in the end. Furthermore, Internet rumour has speculated that this is all just part of yet another aspect of Loki's plan, that he intends to return to Asgard to wreak havoc in some form or another. We'll have to wait and see how that pans out...