10 Acting One-Hit Wonders

Wow, they're the next big thin... Oh.

The film industry can be a harsh maiden of a business; one minute, talent will be treated like royalty, and the next, they'll be thrown away like last night's leftovers. It's an industry permanently fixated on what is hot and new, side-stepping anything remotely old and "uncool", meaning Andy Warhol's words can all too often wind up true. So it is that though many actors demonstrate versatility that keeps them relevant, or they're just so entertaining to watch doing the same thing over and over, many actors (for numerous different reasons - lack of necessity and lack of talent being the foremost) never managed to ascend past that one major hit that propelled them to fast fame. Here are 10 one-hit wonders in the world of acting. You might've seen them in a few other films, but never once have they even begun to approach the success of that big thing that made them a hit.

10. Alicia Silverstone

Alicia Silverstone shot to fame at the tender age of 19 when she took the lead in the surprisingly hilarious teen comedy Clueless, playing ditzy, popular girl Cher, who became a role model for young girls the world over, and the object of just about every man's affections, young and old. However, it's hard to say that she managed to follow it up with anything of actual merit, instead deferring to starring in Joel Schumacher's risible superhero film Batman and Robin, playing Batgirl. Since then, she's been mostly relegated to discreet TV appearances and brief roles in straight-to-video clunkers where she lazily recycles the very persona that made her famous. Granted, at 38 years old (we all thought she must be older, right?), she's definitely not too late for a comeback, but given her current career trajectory, it certainly seems doubtful.

9. Brandon Routh

Brandon Routh comes right from the Orson Welles school of peaking too early, being plucked out of obscurity to play one of the most coveted roles in all of pop culture; the mild-mannered-reported-turned-superhero Clark Kent. Though Routh received decent praise for managing to (mostly) live up to the immense stature of what was Christopher Reeve's signature role, the film itself didn't light the box office up, and both fans and critics were divided over the unconventional plot. As such, a sequel never materialised, and Routh hasn't had a good starring role since. He's been relegated to (admittedly hilarious) cameos in Zack And Miri Make A Porno and Scott Pilgrim vs. The World, and while a growing role in the DC TV Universe keeps the coffers filled up, Atom is hardly Superman.

8. Mark Hamill

Mark Hamill has to be one of the luckiest actors alive, given that until 1977 he was trapped in the seemingly inescapable world of TV movies. That was until George Lucas came a-knocking and cast him in the most successful and beloved sci-fi franchise of all time, giving him technically three hits playing the same character, Luke Skywalker in Star Wars. Hamill was hardly the high point of these flicks, but did a perfectly adequate job nonetheless. Still, it's no surprise that the offers didn't really come rolling in once he was done. Instead, Hamill has deferred to the less judgemental world of voiceover performance, though has earned consistent praise for his excellent vocal work on Batman: The Animated Series. Short of hilarious cameos in Jay And Silent Bob Strike Back and Kinsman, he very rarely makes screen appearances, and it's always referential to his one big hit. Even when Hamill returns to Luke for Star Wars: The Force Awakens, fronting 2015's biggest movie, it's not like he's truly expanded his horizons.

7. Shannon Elizabeth

Shannon Elizabeth made a name for herself as the foreign exchange student Nadia in the teen sex comedy American Pie, starring in the film's most famous scene, as she performs a sexy strip for Jim (Jason Biggs), only for him to, ahem, blow it and ruin the whole thing. Nudity is always an easy way to ingratiate yourself to the teen audience, and she certainly succeeded, though oddly for an industry as superficial as Hollywood, her career never really seemed to take off. After starring in the first American Pie sequel, as well as Scary Movie and Jay And Silent Bob Strike Back (we're seeing a pattern here), she pretty much faded into obscurity for a decade until re-appearing for a brief cameo in the fourth theatrical American Pie film, American Reunion. Simply, Elizabeth wowed us in one role and then quickly descended into nothing.

6. Linda Blair

At the mere age of 14, Linda Blair became an Oscar nominee for her superb performance in William Friedkin's inimitable horror classic The Exorcist, playing Regan, the young girl who becomes possessed by a demon and causes a lot of trouble for her mother and two local clergymen. Aided by a cracking make-up department, Blair gives a truly terrifying performance well beyond her years, and has become an iconic staple of pop culture...despite the fact that this is the only major role she's ever taken up. Though she has had brief appearances in a number of popular films including Red Heat and Scream (she cameos as a reporter), Blair has shied away from an acting career and is mostly relegated to making brief cameos that tip the hat to her famed role.

5. Danny Lloyd

Another child actor we wish had kept at it, Danny Lloyd proved in Stanley Kubrick's sublime horror classic The Shining that he could play s**t scared better than just about anyone. The shots of him riding around the hotel are unforgettable, as are his creepy utterances of "Redrum", and the countless bizarre sights he takes in around the place, including ultimately his own father (Jack Nicholson) going into full-tilt psycho mode. It's all the more impressive given that Kubrick made sure to protect Lloyd from the horror-based elements of the narrative (that is, everything), and he apparently only found out the film's true genre once filming had wrapped. However, Lloyd decided acting wasn't for him, and after taking a brief part in a TV movie, quit the business. He eventually became a biology Professor and continues to teach today.

4. Paul Hogan

There is only one thing anyone would possibly know Paul Hogan for, and that's his iconic role as Michael 'Crocodile' Dundee in the Crocodile Dundee series, which propelled him to fame overnight and briefly initiated an infatuation between Australia and the rest of the world. The film was a monster commercial and critical hit, coasting on Hogan's natural, relaxed charm and killer sense of humour (not to mention his good looks and funny accent). This is the single role that Hogan has seemingly feasted on for the last two-and-a-half decades, working on a critically reviled (but financially successful) sequel, and then a third one that went straight-to-video. Without question, Hogan is a one-hit wonder.

3. Macaulay Culkin

Much like Hogan, Macaulay Culkin managed to establish himself with an immensely popular franchise, but has done practically nothing of merit ever since. He entertained a generation of kids and adults alike with his hilarious, cartoonish antics in the first two Home Alone films, both of which were massive financial successes, but ever since, he's been mostly a figure of obscurity. Aside from starring in a few indie flicks, he's become better known for his infractions with the law, his bizarre physical transformation, his friendship with Michael Jackson, and his lengthy relationship with Mila Kunis (I know, right?). He hasn't worked on a single feature since 2007's Sex And Breakfast, and doesn't appear to have anything on the slate anytime soon enough. Shame; he'd play a great serial killer.

2. Jaye Davidson

Jaye Davidson gave a mind-blowing, Oscar-nominated performance as Dil in Neil Jordan's superb crime drama The Crying Game, which was a major source of discussion at the time due to the nature of the film's narrative which SPOILER ALERT involved Davidson playing a transsexual man who spends most of the film dressed as a (scarily convincing) woman. Davidson even attended that year's Oscar ceremony in androgynous dress so as not to ruin the surprise for anyone who hadn't gotten around to seeing the film yet. Aside from a role in campy sci-fi Stargate two years later, Davidson has stayed out of the limelight, and it's a real shame, given the talent he demonstrated in this role. Whether he would have been able to escape the considerable shadow cast by starring in such a controversial and singular part is unknown, but we really wish he had tried.

1. Carrie Henn

Carrie Henn shot to immediate fame by starring in James Cameron's mammoth sequel to Ridley Scott's sci-fi masterpiece Alien, being billed right next to Sigourney Weaver, starring as her surrogate daughter Newt, a terrified survivor of the Hadley's Hope colony, which was largely laid waste to by the Xenomorphs. Henn gives a sublime performance - all the more impressive because she had no experience - and helped imbue the film with the heart it was sorely in need of. Perhaps realising that she'd captured something really special - or conversely, not wanting to put up with the long hours of acting - Aliens remains her single role, and one that places her in the annals of film history, playing one of sci-fi's most beloved characters. Being a good sport, though, she frequently appears at fan conventions to talk about her experiences on the set. Instead of pursuing acting, she decided to read Liberal Studies and Child Development at California State University in 2000, and now works as a teacher. Which one-hit wonders do you wish kept acting? Or which ones do you wish would escape from straight-to-DVD Hell? Let us know in the comments below.

Contributor
Contributor

Articles published under the WhatCulture name denote collective efforts of a number of our writers, both past and present.